The Law Academy is a project designed to provide legal education for students studying law in the UK. Subscribe for more content.
Citations and Further Readings for each video found at the end.
Disclaimers:
At no point are these video lessons intended to provide any sort of legal advice. These are for educational purposes only!
These videos are intended to represent the law at the time of recording to the best of my ability. If there are any updates and/or mistakes, I endeavour to make sure these mistakes are corrected. Where you find a mistake, comment under the video and I will check and make the appropriate amendments.
The reality of law is that it is an ever changing and deeply complex subject. As such, mistakes and updates are inevitable. I feel that this it the best approach for this kind of educational content, given its static nature.
Image(s) Copyrights: This Photo by Unknown Author is licensed under CC BY-SA
AI Generated·May contain errors
Hello everybody and welcome to the first lesson in a series on the subject of international
humanitarian law. In this video specifically we're going to take an introduction to the subject,
we're going to think about what international humanitarian law is, what are some of the legal
sources associated with the study of international humanitarian law. We will think about what
really can trip a lot of students up thinking about really what is the scope of application
of international humanitarian law. When are we having conversations about IHL and then when are
we having conversations about another area of international law. And then we will finish by
thinking about the scope of this series of lessons looking at the kind of things that we're going to
be studying over the course of the next 40 or so videos on this particular topic. So this is
essentially what we're going to be doing. Like I said we're talking about international humanitarian
law, talking about its sources, talking about its basic principles. Even though this is only
an introduction lesson I will be providing with you some basic principles of international
humanitarian law that will be the framework and will be the guidance for us for thinking about
the next few videos on this topic. Things like the principle of humanity and distinction and
proportionality. All of these very core and foundational ideas within the subject of IHL.
I should make it very clear at the outset that instead of saying the mouthful which is international
humanitarian law every single time, I will often be abbreviating to IHL. If you see IHL or if you
see the phrase law of armed conflict or LOAC, I'm basically using those words interchangeably.
We're talking about IHL, we're talking about international humanitarian law. So as a basic
introduction then, international humanitarian law is a branch of public international law
that is designed to regulate the conduct of hostilities during an armed conflict. We're
talking about the laws of war but we're talking specifically about the laws in war.
More broadly what international humanitarian law can do, what IHL does, is it texts persons
not participating in hostilities. So people like civilians, those people who are not involved
in the direct participation of hostilities, they are unable to be targeted for example in IHL.
Same with medical personnel, people who may be working in medical ways
associated with the conflict. So people like Red Cross, people who work on the front lines
in sort of field hospitals and these different kinds of things that are treating people who
have been injured or who have sustained injuries as the result of armed conflict, as the result of war
that has taken place. Humanitarian workers as well are getting humanitarian supplies to conflict
zones, using humanitarian supply, humanitarian individuals and to provide aid to civilians,
to provide aid to medical personnel, to provide aid to various different parts of the world that
is affected by conflict in some way. And then those soldiers, people who maybe were participating
in armed conflict, who maybe are no longer able to participate in armed conflict. So if you are
wounded or sick for example, what rules apply to you? Or if you are a prisoner of war, if you have
surrendered and you are now therefore in the hands of the enemy combatants, what kind of things should
be expected of those enemy combatants with relation to how they treat you personally?
That is also important as a rule and as a way of protecting people who are not participating
in hostilities. IHL is also concerned in things like limiting the means and methods of warfare
to prevent unnecessary suffering. Essentially, when we think about IHL, if we just thought about
it from that first perspective, thinking about people not participating, that does not imply
that for all those who are participating in armed conflict, that it's fair game,
that you can basically do anything you want to that group of people and it doesn't matter
how sadistic, how horrific, how brutal the conflict gets. In fact, there are very strict
rules about the means and methods of warfare, the ways in which we can limit the types of weapons
that are used, the types of tactics that are used in order to prevent unnecessary suffering.
And so when we think about this, there's an interesting question. If this is the law of
armed conflict, why don't we call this series the law of armed conflict or the laws of war
or whatever like that? Why are we calling it international humanitarian law? Well,
like I said, it is sometimes called LOAC or the law of armed conflict, but IHL recognises as a
concept that war itself, that armed conflict, is cruel and it is inhuman. It is humanity at
its worst. If we think about some of the wars of the past, thinking about the Second World War,
thinking about the war in Vietnam, thinking about some of the conflicts that may be taking place
right now at the time at which we are recording, war is cruel, war is inhuman, war is horrific.
And so the underlying rationale for IHL is to instil, insofar as could possibly be instilled,
a sense of humanity in the fighting, trying to maintain a sense of humanity insofar as is
possible in a time period in which there is just such cruelty and inhumanity, trying to find this
kernel of humanity in there. And it's also important for post-war reconciliation. It's
also important to basically have this semblance of humanity that is present for when the fighting
actually stops, when the war actually ends, and people have to then go back to living with each
other and go back to a post-war settlement and a world in which that war has taken place,
the kind of trauma, the kind of post-war problems, the loss of life, the loss of economic
stability, the loss of maybe humanitarian resources that is necessary to survive.
So I guess you could say that that is a basic overview of what IHL fundamentally is. It's also
important to realize what IHL fundamentally is not. Notice here that within this rationale of
international humanitarian law that I've been speaking about, there is a fundamental assumption
that is sort of permeating all of our conversations, and it will permeate our entire
conversation about this subject for the rest of these lessons. And this is a very,
very important assumption. It is the assumption that war exists as a concept. Now IHL itself,
the body of law that is international humanitarian law, has nothing to say about whether or not a
particular war is itself lawful or unlawful. The war as a concept being lawful or unlawful.
For example, when Adolf Hitler on the 1st of September 1939 invades Poland and starts the
Second World War, on an account of the international law that exists today, that war would be unlawful.
There would be no lawful justification for that war. But IHL doesn't have anything to say about
that. IHL is concerned specifically with the conduct that is taking place within the parameters
of that war. So it almost views war as a state of being, as a state of either we exist in a war or
we don't exist in a war. If there is no war, then there is no application of IHL. If there is a war,
then IHL applies and it is concerning the specific contents of that conflict. We'll get to what the
difference between different types of armed conflict are and when an armed conflict is
triggered in future videos, but that's an important point to raise. It is the law which applies after
then it has been established that an armed conflict exists. And this is a very classic
distinction that exists. And it's a distinction between two areas of international law. The first
is what we call the Usad Bellum. The Usad Bellum is the law on the resort to war. The international
law on the use of armed force. This is primarily governed by the UN Charter and it is primarily
something that is not going to be focused on in this series of lessons. It's a completely different
area of law. This is not to say that there isn't some interactions. There might be some conceptual
interactions between the two. And of course, it is concerning the use of armed force. So there is
some kind of interconnections between these two areas, but they are still fundamentally different
areas of law. The second area is IHL or sometimes described as the Usad Bellum. The law in war.
The law regulating hostilities once the war has been established. And so you have a very
interesting paradigm. You can have lawful conduct in unlawful wars as well as unlawful conduct in
lawful wars. So, for example, the invasion of Iraq in 2003 by US and coalition forces is on
account of the Usad Bellum, on account of the international law on the use of force, most
scholars, the vast majority of scholars will conclude that that was an unlawful war. It was an
illegal war. But that doesn't mean that therefore every single piece of conduct that we could
identify in that war was unlawful from the perspective of IHL. Soldiers engaging in conflict
and following rules of engagement and following the sort of IHL practices, they were lawful acts,
even if it was done in an unlawful war. By contrast, you can have lawful wars. For example,
the Allies' defense of the European world in the Second World War, that would be on account of a
sort of modern conflict, that would be a lawful self-defense under the UN Charter. Of course,
none of that existed at the time, but let's just use that for a hypothetical. In that context,
there were war crimes that had been committed by Allied soldiers during that conflict.
And so you have a lawful response to war, you have a lawful self-defense,
but you can have unlawful actions in the sense that they violate IHL. So make sure you always
keep these two concepts distinct in your mind when thinking about this area of law.
International humanitarian law derives itself from a number of different sources, just like
basically any area of international law that we study. So for example, and just along the
kind of lines as ordinary public international law, one of the main areas of international
humanitarian law, one of the main sources, are treaties. The treaties that have been developed,
a lot of them developed after the end of the Second World War, after the horrors and the
destruction that was caused by the Second World War. There was this real impetus from the entire
international community, from the newly founded United Nations, to really start codifying more
strategically and more importantly some of the rules of IHL, especially also taking into account
some of the technological changes that existed as the result of the Second World War. There's a
lot of debate about aerial bombardment, for example, and there were sort of negotiations
and there were back and forths and sort of summits that took place prior to the Second World War,
but nothing was ever written down and formalized in a treaty before the Second World War.
When we think about IHL and we think about the treaties that are associated with IHL,
one of the first places that you will be thinking about would be the Geneva Convention,
before Geneva Conventions of 1949, as well as the protocols which were additional to the Geneva
Conventions that were established in 1977. That's where a lot of our treaty law is going to come
from when we think about some of these basic principles of international humanitarian law.
So make sure if you are studying this area of law, make sure you have these,
basically the Red Cross website, with access to these two groups of treaties.
But there are additional treaties. There are Hague Conventions that existed prior to the Second World
War. There are also conventions like the Convention of Weapons, Convention of the CCW.
You have things like the Saint Petersburg Declaration that's going to be very important
when we think about things like the Martins Clause. There's also a number of different
arms controls treaties on things like cluster munitions and things like white phosphorus.
You have our ICL treaties, so treaties that concern international criminal law,
and concern the areas in which there is an interconnection between international criminal
law and international humanitarian law, specifically with regards to things like
war crimes within the Rome Statute. That's a very important area that is identified by treaties.
And also, like I said, the Hague Conventions as well.
In terms of customary international law, one of the most important resources that you will find
very valuable as a student of IHL is the ICRC's study on customary rules of international
humanitarian law. Just search that and you'll find it on Google. It has a number of different
rules. And essentially what the ICRC was trying to do here is try to codify what the position
of customary international law was with regards to the rules of IHL at the time at which it was
created. It's updated some new rules as well. But of course, as we know from people who have studied
public international law already, if you've watched our lessons on public international law
already, you will know that customary international law is not as easy to identify as a treaty,
for example. It involves thinking about a consistent state practice as well as this
idea that the state practice is being conducted with the view that they are basically following
an obligation, this idea of opinio juris. And so identifying customary international law can be a
little bit difficult. And so the ICRC study on IHL and customary IHL is a very, very valuable resource.
You could also point to soft law and manuals. So the San Remo Manual is very, very important
for thinking about the law of blockade and laws related to naval warfare as well,
as well as the state law of war manuals. So for example, the UK's Ministry of Defence
Law of War Manual or the US Law of War Manual or any other manual that is basically handed out to
soldiers and then to military generals and commanders to basically set out what the domestic
legal position is on these particular areas of international humanitarian law in order to ensure
that there is compliance with these basic rules of the Geneva Conventions. Of course, there will
also be things like the interrelationship with other legal fields. So there is a huge debate
that has been going on for the past 10 or so years, probably even a bit longer, about the
interrelationship that exists between international humanitarian law and international human rights
law. To what extent do we say that international human rights law provides additional over the top,
if you will, or additional protections on the rights of people living in warfare than that of
IHL? A very interesting debate that is to be had is to what extent is international human rights
law engaged when people are living under belligerent occupation, when they are living in a state of
occupation? To what extent is it just IHL that is engaged or to what extent is it both IHL and
international human rights law? And if that is the case, what is the kind of mechanism and relationship
that exists between those two areas of law in that particular circumstance? Similarly, when thinking
about things like war crimes, and you could also apply things like the law of genocide to this as
well, international criminal law interacts with international humanitarian law in various different
ways too, we'll get to this in future lessons, as well as things like refugee law. The definition
of a refugee, thinking about the refugee convention, when populations are fleeing conflict zones,
this means that there is a direct interconnection between the law as it applies to
armed conflict, the IHL, and the refugees that are created as the result of the conflict that is
being regulated. But that also has to be thought of and understood as a very important part of this
area to study as well. Finally, before we look at the scope of this series of lessons, I just want to
very quickly go through the core legal principles that are researched in IHL. These are
essentially the principles that guide the interpretation and application of IHL, and it is
these basic principles that are fundamental to all areas of international humanitarian law,
and so if you just have these four principles drilled into your head and drilled into
your basic understanding, then you won't go far wrong when thinking about IHL.
The first principle is the principle of distinction. This is the principle that we have to
distinguish at all times in armed conflict the delineation between what are legitimate
military objects and objectives, and what are not military objectives. This is often a distinction
between the combatant and the non-combatant. This includes not only people, i.e. combatants, people
who are actually actively engaged in hostilities and non-combatants, but also objects, civilian
objects, medical objects. These are all things that can never, in any regards, be targeted in
international humanitarian law. There are methods and ways in which a civilian will lose their
status as being a non-combatant in IHL, if they start to directly engage in hostilities, for
example, or a civilian object like a building, for example, might be ordinarily a civilian building,
but if it then is starting to be engaged with by a combatant military in order to be used for
military purposes, then it can also have the effect of losing its status. There is also the
tricky area of the law concerning what we call dual-use objects, objects that have both military
and civilian applications, to what extent does the law apply there, but even though there are
some grey areas and even though there are some tricky little areas that the law doesn't apply
as neatly, the fundamental principle of distinction is always applied and is always applicable in IHL.
The next major principle is this idea of proportionality. Even when attacks against
military objectives are sought out, so let's assume we've dealt with the distinction issue,
we've distinguished between a legitimate target and an illegitimate target, it doesn't mean that
you can just attack that military target straight away without any kind of additional considerations,
because what this principle tells us is that even attacks against military objectives must not
cause excessive civilian harm relative to the military advantage that is anticipated. So there
is a very clear rule here that says that, that recognizes that there might be circumstances in
which civilians might be injured or civilian objects might be destroyed or might be or might
be damaged in the process of conducting armed conflict, especially in these kind of modern
armed conflicts where there is an increasing amount of urban warfare that is taking place
and that is a sort of relatively new phenomenon in the sort of history of warfare compared to
wars of centuries ago, there is likely that civilians will get injured in a strike that
is issued, even if that strike is directly targeting a legitimate military target. And so
in IHL that is acceptable so long as it is proportionate, as long as there is no excessive
civilian harm relative to the military advantage anticipated. There is an additional targeting
consideration that needs to be made as well when thinking about this, this is the idea of
precautions, making sure that you have taken all feasible precautions to reduce insofar as possible
incidental loss of harm to a civilian or civilian objects as well, we'll get to that in future
lessons and when we look at targeting and the rules of targeting. There is also the principle
of necessity, force must be limited to what is necessary to achieve a lawful military aim,
there cannot be and there must not be the use of unnecessary suffering, there must be the avoidance
unnecessary suffering. This is to try and limit the hostilities of armed conflict, to try and
limit it insofar as possible so it only achieves the lawful military aim and doesn't go over the
top. If there is a for example a building that is a legitimate target and it could by all
circumstances be destroyed with a single strike, then the principle of necessity will basically
dictate that you would not use excessive force to try and destroy that building and in the in
the process you end up killing a lot of civilians and all this different kind of things as well.
Obviously that engages the other principles of proportionality and precautions but
essentially the point here is that we are not trying to cause unnecessary suffering.
War itself, armed conflict itself is evil enough as it is, it is horrific enough as it is,
there is not this sort of desire or there should not be this desire on the part of states and on
the part of militaries to engage in unnecessary suffering. And then finally the principle of
humanity, this idea links quite closely with the principle of necessity, this idea that we
should be taking into consideration the basic principle of humanity, thinking quite
clearly that even in armed conflict when violence and force may itself be lawful,
human suffering must be minimized and also that human dignity must be respected. That's why we're
talking about international humanitarian law, it requires that all persons that are affected by war
be treated humanely in all circumstances and is protected from any kind of unnecessary harm.
This is one of those principles that is imbued and permeates every single aspect of the law of
international humanitarian law of IHL. So with all this in mind then let's think about what we're
going to be studying over the next 40 or so lessons. I can actually scroll down and tell
you exactly how many lessons it is, it's 46, exactly 46 lessons. Well I'm going to read out
everything on the screen here by the way because I do recognize that some of this is quite small
but that's just to try and fit this entire sort of spider diagram on the screen.
The first major topic is going to be concerning the foundations of international humanitarian law.
This involves looking at the basic introduction that we've done here but also thinking about the
ways in which international humanitarian law interacts with other fields. So what are the
interactions between this area of law and human rights law or this area of law and the USADBELM
or this area of law and international criminal law. You could add other ones, there could be
others like for example the interaction between IHL and environmental law, international environmental
law, because of course when you destroy an environment in war that obviously has a climate
catastrophe issues associated with it. We will then spend a bit more time thinking about the
sources of IHL, we've touched on that here but we'll go into it in more detail as its own specific
and an important foundational lesson before thinking about the history of IHL, looking at
how it's developed, looking at how some of these treaties have developed over time and then thinking
about those core principles. The principle of distinction, the principle of proportionality,
the principle of precautions that we haven't touched on here but we will do in future lessons
as well as the principle of military necessity and humanity. That's the first section on this
series. The next section will be concerning ourselves with the issue of the classification
of conflict. So we're going to be thinking about the distinction that is made between
the international armed conflict and something that we call a non-international armed conflict
or a NIAC. Within the framework of international armed conflicts there are subjects such as the
issue of belligerent occupation and sort of the law associated with occupation, occupation law
more broadly. Within the context of non-international armed conflicts there are concerns
about and questions about the scope of hostilities in terms of the sort of the severity of force that
is necessary to trigger the instigation of a non-international armed conflict. To what extent
does civil unrest that is internal and domestic to a particular state go from simple civil unrest or
riots to a civil war to an armed conflict and we will think about that. We'll think about the
Tadic case that establishes that and we'll think about some of the rules associated therein
and we will also think about the scope of application. When does IHL apply? We've
answered that question that it applies when there's an armed conflict but when does an armed
conflict begin? That has a different question depending on whether or not we're talking about
an international armed conflict or a non-international armed conflict but also when does an armed
conflict end? To what extent and for how long do there have to be a secession of hostilities for
there to be no more armed conflict and we can sort of identify some case studies where you have sort
of spurious examples of countries that have sort of two or three days of fighting each other
then they stop for a couple of months and they have another few days of fighting each other. To what
extent did that represent two separate international armed conflicts or one continuous international
armed conflict with a sort of period of relative cessation of hostilities in between? To what
extent can we think about that in that kind of framework? We'll also think about the interaction
with the USADBELM because of course the USADBELM is heavily engaged when we think about
the scope of application of IHL because we're essentially asking the question of when a war
begins and when a war ends which does concern itself a little bit with USADBELM kind of questions.
Topic number three will be concerning the issue of the protections of persons. The protections of
persons concerns the protections of civilians against indiscriminate attack. We'll be looking
at things like the law of siege and siege operations which of course naturally and
necessarily engages with civilians and the support for civilians. There's some very
interesting law on this particular topic and there's some let's be honest unresolved issues
associated with this topic. We will think about the law relating also to civilian displacement when
civilians are moved out of a particular area and what the law should apply to them.
We will think about combatants and the treatment of prisoners of war. We will think about
the detention, the concept of detention, detaining an individual within the
confines of a non-international armed conflict. That's a relatively interesting area that is
also quite new. Thinking about the wounded, the sick and the shipwrecked before thinking about the
protection of medical services, of hospitals, medical transports as well as humanitarian relief
operations and the use of protective emblems in war as well. Topic number five I've written here on
my notes that this is weapons law but we could describe this as the sort of means and methods
of warfare. Weapons law itself concerns the type of weapons that are allowed and the type of
weapons that aren't allowed. So we will spend some time thinking about biological and chemical
weapons, we will spend some time talking about anti-personnel landmines, cluster munitions,
blinding laser weapons, incendiary weapons before thinking about the law of targeting. The law of
targeting concerning the rules associated with when a lawful strike is conducted and when it is
not conducted. So these are the kinds of things we'll talk about with regards to targeting rules,
precautions in attack and in defence, the proportionality assessments, the idea of
the ways in which this actually practically works from the context and the confines of an actual
military operation. Thinking about things like kill chains and thinking about the kind of ways
in which decisions are made with regards to launching and operating strikes and the kind
of IHL considerations that need to be taken into account with regards to that. And then we will
think about implementation and enforcement in the next topic, in topic number five. This concerns
state responsibility for compliance with IHL, the law relating to individual criminal responsibility,
the idea of the law of war crimes, what is a war crime and how a war crime is defined in IHL,
as well as compliance mechanisms, the role of the international red cross for example, the role of
UN mechanisms in compliance as well as domestic implementation of IHL as well. And then finally
we will think about some of the modern contemporary challenges. We will think about for example
the impact of the law as it concerns non-state armed groups, what kind of tricky international
legal considerations can be used there, the ways in which there is the interaction between
international humanitarian law and counter-terrorism. We will think about the law of cyber operations,
a very new area of law that is very very important and even more new area of law is probably the
use of drones and autonomous weapon systems. Within this context I'm probably going to actually
add an additional video or at least an additional context and compliance which is the use of AI and
use of generative AI in making targeting decisions, which if you've been watching the news in the last
few weeks, has raised another interesting question about the diffusion of responsibility
for making targeting decisions and using artificial intelligence in that particular regard.
But it's not too dissimilar to autonomous weapon systems or drones in that regard either. We will
think about information operations as well as urban warfare and the challenges that are
faced by the idea of urban warfare and things like human shielding, the co-location with
civilian objects or all those different kinds of things as well. So this is the scope of this
series of lessons and it will be done in about 46 videos. In terms of citations and further reading
and all these different kinds of things, basically any of the textbooks that you see here are very
very important guides on international humanitarian law. My favourite is Marco Sassouli's
International Humanitarian Law textbook and there's actually a new edition from 2021 or 2022
I believe on that that you could get and pick up anywhere useful. We will also be engaging with
online blog posts that discuss IHL and articles as well and I'll sort of cite them on the screen
as and when they are used and when they are engaged in the video. We'll also try and engage
as much as humanly possible in actual real world examples. There are plenty of real world examples
that we can identify so I'm not going to shy away from real world examples, even very very
recent examples when discussing the legal implications. I'll try and do so with as much
sort of neutrality and a lack of bias as much as humanly possible. Of course there'll be some
instances and some examples where the correct answer of maybe the lawfulness of a particular
decision is obvious but it's important that we don't just understand and teach and think about
IHL from a quite distant approach just thinking about it as a bunch of laws and rules and things
that are written down. These are things that actually affect people in day-to-day life and so
it's important that we actually think about those people and think about the application to actual
case studies as well. So bear that in mind when we think about this area of law. I hope everybody's
enjoyed this introductory video and I'll see everybody in the next lesson when it next comes
out. Like I said we'll talk about the foundations of international humanitarian law in the next few
videos and think about some other basic principles and some other basic foundational stuff there.
So see everybody in the next video.