Our Freedoms Aren't Up for Debate: Ranking Member Raskin Opening Remarks

House Committee of the Judiciary
69 followers
May 13, 2026
TW: @HouseJudiciary | FB: HouseJudDems | IG: HouseJudDems | M: /HouseJudiciary
AI Generated·May contain errors
Video Summary
AI GeneratedA speaker criticizes a congressional hearing on Sharia law, arguing that it is a redundant and politically motivated distraction. The speaker asserts that the First Amendment already prohibits the imposition of any religious law, including Sharia or the Ten Commandments, and warns that targeting specific religions undermines constitutional principles and promotes social division.
Chairman, thank you.
Thanks to our witnesses.
Forgive me, but didn't we have this exact same hearing not that long ago?
I think it's the fourth or fifth in the line, and I can't believe that the cupboard of Republican
ideas is so barren now that in order to distract America from Donald Trump's illegal unconstitutional
ruinous war and his ruinous illegal unconstitutional tariffs and the spiraling price of gasoline
and the unlivable economy he's created, that we have to go back and have this exact same
hearing over and over again, couldn't we come up with something else instead?
It's not exactly working to reverse Donald Trump's precipitous slide into being the most
unpopular history, the most unpopular president in American history, because that's where
we are.
So if we're going to have another religious convocation, perhaps next time it could be
a debate between a Donald Trump dressed up perhaps like Jesus Christ and the Pope of
the Catholic Church, so the Pope can answer Trump's recent accusation that he's weak on
crime.
I never got that charge.
After all, Trump himself is a convicted felon who's pardoned more than 1,600 rioters, insurrectionists,
Proud Boys, Oath Keepers, domestic abusers, child molesters, white collar fraudsters and
international narco traffickers and drug dealers, and the Pope is certainly not weak on him.
The Pope has made his views on Donald Trump perfectly clear, so I don't understand why
Trump is saying that the Pope is weak on crime.
Anyway, I had this idea I wanted to float by my colleagues to perhaps create some legislative
progress in this field.
The Republicans are afraid that Muslims are going to impose Sharia law on the rest of
the population.
Now, I'm not so afraid of that because we have 535 members of Congress and only four
of them are Muslim, which makes it extremely unlikely.
How could less than 1% of Congress impose Sharia law on the other 99%?
And what's even more reassuring is I actually know some of these Muslim Americans who happen
to be in Congress, and they're all civil libertarians who stand up for the separation of church
and state.
But even if they changed their minds and convinced all the Christians, Jews, Hindus and freethinkers
in Congress who are 99% of the House to vote for Sharia law, I'm sure someone on the Senate
side where there are no Muslims at all would put a hold on it like everything else that
we send over there.
So I'm a pretty good vote counter, and I don't think that there would be a single vote to
establish Sharia law in the United States Congress or in any state of the union.
But anyway, I had this idea to take advantage of the fact that we all agree on this point.
Why don't we generalize the proposition of this anti-Sharia law movement to say that
any religion in America, whether it's Islam, Christianity, Judaism, Jews for Jesus, Seventh
Day Adventism, Jehovah's Witnesses, Mormonism, fundamental Mormonism, Unitarian Universalism,
Branch Davidianism, or Hare Krishna.
I was playing with some language and I came up with this rough cut, Mr. Chairman.
It goes like this, Congress shall make no law respecting an establishment of religion
or prohibiting the free exercise thereof.
What do you think about that?
Do you think that covers it?
We could call the first part the establishment clause.
We could call the second part the free exercise clause.
I know we could get that through the Democratic caucus.
You think we could get it through the Republican conference?
I'm not sure.
I hope so.
The problem is that we've got theocrats out there across the religious spectrum who want
to elevate their own religious creeds and dogmas above the Constitution and establish
them over the secular law.
Take for example what the Texas and Louisiana legislatures recently did.
They voted to endorse the Ten Commandments and post the Ten Commandments in every public
school classroom in their states.
I didn't even know that was necessary because I thought the Ten Commandments were doing
all right after millennia.
I didn't know they needed an endorsement from the Republican conference, but they went ahead
and did that.
Now they want to have votes in every state legislature to endorse the Ten Commandments
and to post the Ten Commandments.
I'm opposed to that because of the provision in the Constitution, Article 6, Clause 3,
which says there shall be no religious tests for public office.
That sounds like a religious test when you round up all the politicians and you ask them
to vote on the Ten Commandments.
And by the way, if we are going to vote on the Ten Commandments, Mr. Chairman, I do not
support that omnibus Republican package.
I think we should have to vote on each commandment separately.
And I don't think that you should be able to vote for any commandment you yourself have
ever violated, because then we'll be taking the name of the Lord in vain.
So one politician I spoke to on the floor about this, he said that you know that the
Ten Commandments are the basis for the Bill of Rights.
He kind of confused me there for a second.
I said, well, I do know that there are 10 in each one.
That's true.
But let's test the proposition.
The First Commandment says thou shall have no other God before me.
The First Amendment says Congress shall make no law respecting an establishment of religion.
It's hard to see how the First Commandment dictates the First Amendment.
So is Sharia law incompatible with the Constitution, as the title of the hearing is?
Sure.
And so is legislating any other religious text, the Ten Commandments, the Torah or the
Analects of Confucius or whatever, any religious scripture or body.
The whole point of our First Amendment is that people can go believe whatever they want.
The government's not going to dictate to you what your religious worship and practice are
going to be.
The government is out of it.
So I did not write that language, to be clear.
James Madison wrote that language.
He took care of your whole anti-Sharia law centuries ago.
This is a complete waste of time.
And he had the right idea.
Madison would be appalled that the Fifth Circuit Court of Appeals just voted 9 to 8 to uphold
the compulsory Ten Commandments display in every school classroom in Texas or Louisiana.
Louisiana can do that.
It can compel display of the five pillars of Islam.
Think about that.
You really want to head down that road?
The states could force display of the ten precepts of Buddhism, the Analects of Confucius
or the five principles of Hinduism, if you can put up the Ten Commandments.
And by the way, the Ten Commandments doesn't exist as one commonly agreed upon body of
law.
If you go online, you'll find like 10 or 15 different versions of the Ten Commandments.
There's a Catholic version.
There's a Lutheran version.
There's a Jewish version, a Baptist version, Mennonite, and so on.
If you can compel display of ten of them, you can compel display of all of them.
There could be 100 commandments.
There could be 150 commandments.
So look, my friends, we don't need an anti-Sharia law or an anti-Christian law or an anti-Jewish
law or an anti-Hindu law.
We've already got one forbidding the imposition of any religious orthodoxy, forbidding the
endorsement of any religious orthodoxy.
It's called the First Amendment.
And everybody should familiarize themselves with it because this is a complete waste of
time we're doing here.
The government cannot establish, prefer, legislate, coerce, impose, or endorse any religious doctrine.
And we don't need a special law or a special caucus to do that.
And if my friends understand that, then I think they will reverse course on this movement,
unless the purpose of the movement is just to demonize and vilify not a religion, but
adherence of the religion.
But then I would have to believe that my colleagues are actually out just attacking Muslims, attacking
Muslim Americans, criticizing and vilifying them for their beliefs or their way of life.
And I don't want to, I don't want to believe that.
But I do challenge my friends to state one thing that an anti-Sharia law would do that
the First Amendment doesn't already do.
Tell me one thing that we would need to legislate that's not already taken care of by the Establishment
Clause or the Free Exercise Clause.
The real threat to our Constitution comes not from adherence of a particular religion,
but from turning our backs on the Constitution and the First Amendment.
Our freedoms are not under siege by a religious minority trying to build a community center,
but they are undermined by lawmakers who would want to turn Americans against each other
on a religious basis.
And is it true that religious fanatics commit violent criminal acts?
Absolutely.
I mean, you talk to any secular free thinker and they will say that every religion has
produced religious fanatics who have committed violence.
Take, for example, Timothy McVeigh, who was part of the Christian Identity Church, the
Christian Identity Movement, trained on racism and anti-Semitism.
He blew up the Oklahoma Federal Building in 1995, 167 people killed, 684 wounded.
They blew up a nursery school.
He was a violent fundamentalist Christian fanatic, but you wouldn't blame all Christians
for what he did any more than you should blame all Muslims or all Jews or all members of
any religious faith because of what one person or one crazed fanatic group does in their
name.
So, Mr. Chairman, I trust you understand all of that.
I do hope we will return to constitutional principles and I yield back.
