In the US, a letter from an attorney can cost a small business tens of thousands of dollars before a single judge sees the case. California alone receives more Americans with Disabilities Act lawsuits than any other state in the country. Who is the law actually protecting?
In this episode, Siyamak speaks with Taha Saleh, Owner and Operator of T.A. Saleh, on what a single lawsuit threat cost him to resolve; Victor Gomez, Executive Director for California Citizens Against Lawsuit Abuse (CALA), on who is being targeted and whether the current system is actually serving people with disabilities; and Roger Niello, Senator, on the reform bill that passed the Senate with nearly no opposition and what it would take to change it.
00:00 - Intro 01:11 - ADA Lawsuit Notice and Implications 04:48 - Settlement and Financial Impact 12:26 - Challenges and Long-term Effects 14:16 - Advocacy and Legislative Efforts 20:36 - Legislative Proposals and Industry Reactions 27:11 - Community and Industry Support
<html>
<head><title>404 Not Found</title></head>
<body>
<center><h1>404 Not Found</h1></center>
<hr><center>nginx</center>
</body>
</html>
Small businesses in California are getting letters from lawyers that they're not compliant with ADA
requirements and sometimes these letters could be devastating to these small businesses because
they don't have the legal knowledge and it could threaten losing their business. Today we sit down
with small business owners, advocates and lawmakers who are trying to make an impact by changing the
laws in California. It's a good law, it's a law that's made to protect people, to protect some
most vulnerable members of our society. I think what we've gone wrong is when we take something
that's meant to do good and we find actors that want to exploit it and take money that could be
meant for my employees, that could be meant for new equipment, that can be meant to grow my business,
to add more employees. Now I've got to pay for something else that's frivolous. I'm Siamak,
welcome to California Insider. Taha, it's great to have you on, welcome. Thanks for having me again.
You own a multiple number of gas stations in California and you have faced something that's
common in California called ADA lawsuits or threatened by a lawyer to get sued. Can you
tell us what happened to you? About 2021, I got a letter through my landlord, he said
we're getting sued and that came as a surprise. I heard about ADA but being in a small town
and having a newer store, I thought I was in compliance. So it was a bit of a surprise.
Take us back to that moment. What happened next?
Oh man, I was worried. I didn't know what was going to happen. I didn't know what my exposure
was. What the letter ended up saying was they made a list of a few things that were out of
compliance and we have an ADA ramp out in front of my store and it was not the right slope. It
was off by like 1%. We have this wide aisle. I'm thinking, man, I love my store. We're ADA
compliant. We have this area where you can come up. We have two parking spots where we're supposed
to have one but it was off. The request was to create a new slope that was within the scope
and to do a few other things. Did you know what that's going to cost you when you saw the letter?
No, I had no idea. The other thing about it was with ADA, we thought we were in compliance
but things change. Code changes. So when you're in compliance at one point,
sometimes something changes and you're out of compliance and there's no way for you to know
when that changes unless you're practically looking for it. When the letter came, they
threatened to sue you. You don't know how much it's going to cost you. What did you do next?
We got an attorney. We responded. Their letter was very hyperbolic. Here's what you've done
wrong and here's the possibility of what you can get. They always list the highest amount.
It's like millions. Each violation can get up to this much and daily fines and all this. So
it's stressful. Did you think you could lose your gas station in a sense? I didn't think I could
lose my gas station. I was just really worried about how I would operate moving forward. Just
a lot of unknowns. You start thinking of all what you have to do. Yeah, it's stressful. From
what I gather, there was a financial pressure on you, the money part of it, but there was another
part which was stressful. Can you tell us about that part? Because most people may have not
experienced this kind of loss. So you get this legal letter. What was going through your mind
at that time? Anybody that's gotten a legal letter, you think of all the possibilities and
unfortunately, you think of all the worst possibilities. And so what does that cost?
That costs attention to the rest of your business operations. Creates stress. We all know what
stress does to the body. And it just takes your eye off the ball. You get distracted. You start
worrying. So then you pull back. In a business sense, you pull back. Anything that you want to
spend money on, you got to wait. You got to be careful. You got to be timid. Stop. I mean, it
goes down as low as stress at the home too. It just goes everywhere. And then when you got that
attorney, what did they tell you? First thing is make the repairs. We had to call somebody out
to come do our own inspection and to find anything and anywhere we were not ADA compliant and make
those repairs. It's funny. There's all these requirements are usually from something that
happens. Like there was one requirement where if we had hot water in our bathroom and if the
sink was open, those pipes, those hot pipes have to be insulated. Because I guess somebody at some
point who was either didn't have something in their legs, got burned washing their hands. So we
quickly identified the areas that we weren't compliant and became compliant right away.
Did the attorneys that reach out to, did they have an intention to make money from you? Absolutely.
So I know stories of other stores who in the settlement, because you go into a settlement,
they usually tell you, okay, this is how much we want for each one. They start with the
hyperbolic number. It's millions or whatever, if you don't settle, because they want you to settle.
They wanted me to settle. And I think it was like four or $5,000 per infraction. I think it was four
infractions or five infractions. And the stipulation is you have to have it done within a year. I know
stores who paid the fine and didn't get it done for a couple of years. And nobody said nothing
because they had their money and they were gone. So that to me proves that there wasn't about being
in compliance. It's about how can I make my quick dollar and move on? Do you think these people that
send you the letter, do you think they came to your property and take a look at your infrastructure?
Or do you think they may not have even seen it and used it? Because some people are using Google to
systematically sue or send these letters out to a lot of people. I thought that same thing.
I think my understanding is they might start online, but at some point somebody has to visit.
Now, whether it's the people themselves or they hire a third party to come do these visits,
I don't know the answer to that. But my understanding is from my lawyers, they said that
somebody at some point has to be on site. And how much did it cost you to settle this?
I think $20,000 range or something like that. But the cost to do all the work was beyond that.
I think at the end it was like $35,000 or $40,000 to do all the work. So $30,000 to $40,000 to do
the work and the settlement was just to pay so that you don't get into a lawsuit? Yeah, that's all
they want. They don't want to go to a lawsuit. Again, they're like, we can give you for
this much, but we'll take this much. It's so convenient. We can get you for this much and
every day you're not in compliance, but you can also just give us this little bit and we'll move
on. So your thought is they don't really care? No, they don't care. They don't care. No, absolutely.
Because in my business, we're heavily regulated. So some people might say, you should have known
that. But things change. And when you're behind a counter, you have so many things to deal with.
You're not able to have the resources to hire somebody to go out there and make
sure you're in compliance and everything. So when it comes to fuel, food, we have inspectors and
they come in and they don't come in to penalize you. They come in to get you into compliance
and educate you. This was not an educating moment. This was not, hey, we found something,
do better. It was, we found something and we're going to exploit it. Are you worried now about
this type of ADA, potential more of them coming to you? The good part is we're in compliance.
We're aware of it. So if and when there's some different changes in the law, I'll be aware of it.
And additionally, being a part of an association really goes a long ways as well. So I can't do
this on my own. So I am with the, if you're aware, I'm with the California Fuel and Convenience
Alliance. That association allows me to come together with other members and we're able to
keep track of what changes in the laws and implement that before we have another situation
where we get sued again. Based on what you're seeing in the laws, what do you think should be
the right way of dealing with the ADA compliance? It should go back to how the fuel compliance is,
the food service compliance is, and that is, it's an education, it's a public service. I think
there's organizations already within the state that can probably handle this, some type of
inspection, but it should be education and awareness. Now there's, you know, when there's
situations like the person I told you about, it took two years to make the repair, they should
totally get a fine, right? If you're given a year to do something, you don't do it, then you're
negligent. But for the rest of us, just give us an opportunity to be in compliance. If you were told
ahead of the time that you have to fix this, would you have fixed them? Yes, plain and simple,
absolutely. And what about going to court? Did you think about going through the lawsuit? It would
have cost way too much. That's the thing I think that's intentional. There's settlements not too
egregious to where it makes sense to go to court. If you think about that, it's kind of strategy.
They probably do some type of math, like, okay, if you take me to court, it's going to cost you
$20,000, $30,000 in litigation. I'm going to ask you for $20,000. It's a business proposition.
Did you find out how much it would cost from your attorneys? No, I didn't, but they told me,
yeah, don't do it. It's going to cost more. It's cheaper to settle. It's a common phrase we hear
a lot in litigation, it's cheaper to settle, unfortunately. Even though there's a principle,
I want to be on principle and see it to the end. So if you would have gone to court,
based on the fact that you did the report, they would not have a case? No, they have a case.
That's the idea. It's my understanding they have a case. That's why we're compelled to do the changes.
I think the issue is not that they don't have a case, it's the intention behind it. It's a good
law. It's a law that's made to protect people, to protect some of the most vulnerable members of
our society. It's awesome how far we've come in awareness and technology to allow other people
that maybe didn't have the access they had to have that access. People that were disabled,
sometimes were stuck at home. Now we're in a world where people can have technology where
they can get out and participate. We as members of society need to provide that space for them.
That's what I do. In my other store, I made sure my aisles were wider. People can get in and out.
There's plenty of space because I want those people in my store. I think what we've gone wrong
is when we take something that's meant to do good and we find actors that want to exploit it
and take money that could be meant for my employees, that could be meant for
new equipment, that could be meant to grow my business, to add more employees. Now I've got to pay
for something else that's frivolous. Do you think that's going to damage the purpose of the ADA rules
based on what's happening right now? Yes, it's going to give it a bad reputation. I'm excited
that we have these people that get to participate, that technology is working,
and we want to continue to grow with that. So when people think of ADA in a lawsuit, it's going to
leave a bad taste in your mouth. What do you want to tell to other Californians that may have no idea
about these lawsuits? Whenever lawsuits and payouts come out, it costs everybody. When businesses have
to pay, especially small businesses like myself, have to pay for things that are that are unaccounted
for, it comes from somewhere else. So yes, it's me that's paying. Yes, it's other businesses that
are paying these. But in general, as a society, we all bear the cost of all that. Do you have to mark
up your gas or other things to pay for these kind of things? It's not a direct thing. It's not
I got sued and I have to mark it up. It's more I got sued. There's money that wasn't
tagged for that. So then maybe it's a delay in an upgrade, a delay in equipment. Maybe it's not
hiring somebody else. So it's investment that could have went to the community somehow that's
no longer going to the community. What about the lawmakers? Right now, there's a couple of laws
in California state that want to deal with this. Would you have any thoughts for the lawmakers?
Get on it. Get on it fast. I don't pity their job. A lot of these laws end up
with good intentions. It's just some people are looking for the loophole. And I don't know if
there's any advice I can tell them to close loopholes. Or when they do find them, close them
sooner. Do you have any thoughts for the people that are doing this kind of lawsuit? Just understand
you're hurting people. These are real people. There's a better way to make money and to provide.
There's a more honest and ethical way. How long did it take for you to go through this process?
I think it was about a year. About a year? Yeah. Because then the other part about it was the
timing of this. This was during COVID or post COVID. So the fun part about it was there was a
real shortage in skilled labor to do the work, the concrete work. So there was a wait, right? I don't
know if you remember that time where inflation shot up to things that would cost $10,000, cost
$15,000. So you get the plan, you start doing the work, and now you got to wait for the contractor
to get time to come do the job. So it was a little over a year, if I recall correctly. To your question
of how do you ensure it doesn't happen or if you're worried it happens again, we had to hire our own
consultant to come out at $5,000 to go through our old property and give us a report of where
there could be some liabilities. And there was a few minor things that they found.
And we got that all taken care of. It was just the concrete that took a while because we had
to find the person to come do the concrete. And that was a disruption. We had to tear a lot out,
put it in, close the parking lot, half of the parking lot. So there's a real big disruption
to our business flow as well. It seems like you're doing well and you were able to pay this $15,000
on top of the $35,000. Some businesses we are hearing from, they're coffee shops, small mom
and pop taco shop, and they don't have this kind of funding. So what do you do? You don't have the
funding, you go to your credit card, you get a loan, and then that creates additional costs,
right? Now it's no longer just a $30,000 job. Now it's a $30,000 job plus 18% interest every year.
Or you don't make it. I'm sure there are places that didn't make it. They're like,
I can't do this. I got to shut down. I'm sure there are. You are a business owner. You have
a couple of businesses and this happened to you in this state. How do you feel after this,
after something like this happened? I got involved. I'm sitting here today with you.
See, a lot of businesses don't have the privilege to be able to have the labor, to come and step
outside from the counter and start being a part of the change. I got tired of being victim to the
laws that are being written. So now I'm getting involved. I'm having conversations with you. I'm
educating the public. I'm talking to lawmakers. We're trying to find solutions. So after that
happened to me, I had a choice. Either just be angry and raise the prices, right? Or be something
for change and invest money into having the opportunity to come out here and speak to people
and speak to you. And how's that going? Oh, amazing. You learn so much when you get involved.
You learn so much and you become a better person when you get involved with the system. When you
go to your local council meetings, you go to your local planning commissions, you have conversations
with you. The knowledge and the fulfillment that yes, change can happen. Change can happen.
Like I'm running for city council in my city, literally, because I'm tired of the things that
are happening to my business. I'm tired of the development, the things that are happening.
I want to change stuff. Things need to change. You get involved. So you had two choices. One,
to raise the price. And what triggered you to get involved? I didn't like what was going on
on a federal level. I wasn't happy with the lack of action. In the past, we talked about Prop 47
and Prop 36 and those things not getting funded and things stopping. I got tired of just waiting.
I got tired of waiting. Now that you're involved, do you see things differently or is it the way
you saw it before? Yeah, I do see things differently. I see all the stakeholders.
It's not only about my position. It's not only about my store. It's about what works for everybody.
I always say there's a way forward for everybody. So you got to see that there's a lot more
stakeholders and you're paying more attention to the bigger picture. Yep. How do we solve problems
for everybody? How do we make sure that those people, those vulnerable people, they have more
freedoms now are able to go to stores like mine and not have to worry about getting hurt? We can
do that without the frivolous lawsuits. We can do that without the extra costs that can go towards
something else that we need in our community. You're running a small business, right? You're
spending your time. You don't have a lot of time or do you? Well, you're investing your time into
the community. When I'm here, when I'm in the community, that's two or three people that have to
put my store. So I'm choosing to make less money. A lot of people in my part, my father and
most people that are successful just dedicate themselves to behind the counter. That's why you
might not hear a lot of stories because people have to choose. Well, they have this choice in
their head where I have to be behind the counter. If I'm not behind the counter, I'm not making
money to feed my family. I'm in a privileged position where I can make that choice to make less
because for me, money's not everything. It's just not. But that's not everybody's position
in small business. Has there been a moment where you realized this is making an impact?
The most impact I see is in the individual people that I have conversations with and within myself.
I'll start with within myself. I have the courage to say what's right and not what needs to be heard
right now. So when I see a wrong, when I see somebody saying something that's not a part
of what's best for the collective, I no longer just go with the flow. I stop it right there and
I have that uncomfortable conversation. Now, what the tail end of that is, I don't know.
I'm not with them to see. I know it's working towards something bigger than me. But with
conversations I have with potential employers or other people in the community or lawmakers,
I can see the wheels turn. I can see them say there's a better way. But it's going to be a
hard push because when we've been doing things one way, it takes a lot of effort to get it to
go the other way, to be more of a collective. Why do you think that is? It takes courage. I think
there's courage to be the first or the first few to get through that, to go through that and show
people that there's another way, that there's a better way. You're spending a bunch of your time
on this activism that's coming out. Has it been worth it for you? Yes. You asked me a question
earlier, how do I see results? I see results in my kids. You reminded me because I have children,
have adult children. And it's this yin and yang where my courage has allowed my kids to have
courage. And when my kids do something that's courageous, I get courage. So it's been well
worth it. And some of the results are other people stepping up, other people seeing what's possible.
And trying and doing more and taking some risks. So I wouldn't trade it for the world.
I wouldn't trade it for the world. How do you see that in your kids? Oh, you want a specific story?
So my daughter, she was a high school senior last year and she's running for student body. She's
been in the student body. She was vice president. She says, dad, I have an option. I can run for
president, but there's these two very popular people. And I don't know if I'm going to win
or I can take the easy way and just go vice president because there's nobody running.
I told her, go for it. Take the risk. Life is about taking risks. If you don't win,
you're going to learn something. She didn't win, unfortunately, but she learned something.
She learned don't give up and push yourself. And that experience has carried her into college
where she's a sophomore. She's a junior. She got reclassified as a junior.
And you want to see the full circle? I told you I was considering running for local office and I'm
going to run against them. It's very popular, very popular. And I told her, and I said,
I got to do this because I told my daughter, do the same thing. I can't tell my daughter,
do something I'm not going to do. So that's how, that's how, that's how it bounces off.
I funneled to them and they funneled back into me. It's a full circle. It's a full circle.
Life is a full circle. We're in this together. Now we go to Senator Nielsen. He has a proposal
to change the law and see what obstacles he's facing in California legislature.
We are hearing from a lot of business owners that they're getting sued
and they're getting fined by these lawyers. Can you tell us what you're seeing out there?
There's an article in the LA Times just today. The headline is one man has filed 1800 disability
lawsuits against Southern California shops. Store owners are fed up. That's just one example.
There are two or three, maybe four law firms in California that make essentially a cottage
industry, if you will, of suing businesses for alleged violations of disability access.
And I say alleged because many of them, they issue a threat to sue and the businesses will
settle that threat before the suit because for 10 or $15,000, they can avoid going to court,
especially smaller businesses in disadvantaged areas that are kind of intimidated by the
legal process. Whether the alleged defects even existed or whether they get fixed, I do not know.
But the fact of the matter is California, we like to say we're a leader on a lot of things. Well,
we are a leader in this. There are far more of these suits and settlements in California than any
other state in the country. And businesses are tired of it. And you're proposing a lot to fix
this. Can you tell us what's happening in the legislature right now? You have a law and then
there was Assemblymember Josh Lentol who had another one. Yes. Assemblymember Lowenthal's
originally was very much like mine. My bill is pretty simple. It just says that if a business
receives a letter threatening a lawsuit, that the business has 120 days to fix the alleged defect
and they can't be sued and there can't be a violation either. Assemblyman Lowenthal's bill
was originally much like that, but it was amended in the Judiciary Committee in the Assembly.
And that amendment, among a few other things, said that if a business receives an inspection by
what's called a CASP inspector, that that would inoculate them from any liability.
The problem is there's 900 CASP inspectors in the state of California and almost 4 million
businesses. It is unworkable. There's other clauses in that bill that make it problematic,
too. But his bill did pass out of the Assembly. My bill passed out of the Senate and it went to
that Assembly Judiciary Committee. And the chair wants me to take the same amendment,
and I won't. So we're at a standstill. The Lowenthal bill is in the Senate Judiciary Committee
and my bill is in the Assembly Judiciary Committee.
And the idea is that these businesses are getting the lawsuits. Seems like a shakedown, right?
Lawyers are coming in with lawsuits and then they have to pay the fine. And sometimes,
in some cases, we have heard that the people that are doing the suits, they don't even care
if the fix was done to the business. Well, you never know if the threatening
lawyer goes away when he or she receives the $5,000, $10,000, $15,000, $20,000,
as you said, shakedown fee. That's a term that has been used by others than you. It's
certainly not inaccurate. But I'm not aware that they come back and check to see if the defect
has been fixed. So it would be up to the business owner, first of all, to verify
that it indeed exists. And even if the business verified that it didn't exist
at the time of the threat, the threat still holds. And as I said, they end up settling
out of court. And maybe the defects are cured. Maybe they're not. We don't know.
When you introduced this bill, was there a lot of support among your colleagues?
Are California lawmakers open to passing this bill? What are you seeing out there in the
legislature? Oh, I think if it received a hearing in that Assembly Judiciary Committee,
I think it would pass out of the committee. And I think it would pass out of the Assembly floor,
just like it did in the Senate. I had only two no votes, I think, when it passed up the Assembly
floor. We have four joint authors on the bill who are Democrats. We have over half of the Democratic
Caucus, either as joint or co-authors, and obviously all my Republican colleagues. And
as I said, it passed off of the Senate floor with almost no, no votes. I have no reason to believe
the same thing wouldn't happen in the Assembly. So there is still time for this to come on the
floor, right? There is. There is. But if it dies this year, I am of the Winston Churchill School
of Important Legislation. And that is, I never, never, never give up. We'll bring it up again
next year. This is the second time I've offered this bill since I've been back in the Senate,
re-elected in 2022. So I don't give up. How did you pick up that philosophy? Where did you get
that from, not giving up? Well, if it's important to me, just because it dies one year doesn't mean
I can't bring it up another year. I have a few other bills that I continue to work on
in a similar vein. I worked on this issue back when I was in the Assembly, in the early 2000s.
I was singularly unsuccessful because at that time, I couldn't get Democrats to vote for it.
But since that time, a lot of Democrats have discovered these predatory law firms and businesses
have complained to them. And that's why I have so much support for it now. So I never gave up,
and I'm not going to. We're checking with Victor Gomez, who's been on the show in the past and has
been working on fixing the ADA laws in California. You have an organization that's been focusing on
lawsuit abuse in California. We talked to Taha Saleh, who has a gas station in California, and
he's been hit by this kind of lawsuit. Can you tell us what's happening with these lawsuits in
California? Yeah, definitely. Well, actually, just recently, I want to say over the weekend,
we had the LA Times even report out on these ADA lawsuit abuse cases, where you had an attorney
throughout the city of LA file over a thousand lawsuits all over the city related to ADA access.
So essentially, with the Americans with Disabilities Act and the lawsuits that come
from that, really, it's physical barriers that folks with disabilities are not able to
necessarily access a business. So as you folks know, or many of your viewers I'm sure know,
you'll see that parking stall in front of a restaurant or a retail establishment that's blue.
You have a ramp that's associated with it. You also have some hash lines where you could actually
be unloaded from a van or some type of vehicle. Those have specific requirements that have to
be met by federal law. And even if you're off a little bit, it triggers a lawsuit.
Perfect example is, let's just say a sink. You have a sink in the bathroom of your taco shop
or your coffee shop. If it's an inch too high, a half inch too low, whatever it may be,
even though it does qualify for accessibility, it doesn't fall within the law. And so,
in many cases, a lot of these businesses are being hit by these lawsuits. And they're not
unfortunately fixing the issue. Essentially, these lawsuits just create what we believe to be a
bigger issue in lawsuit abuse. Can you tell us more about these lawsuits? How many of them are
out there? Is this something that's happening to a lot of businesses? And then what's the impact of
them? How do they work? Well, here in California, it's very unique because California businesses
have to comply with the UNRWA Act, which is essentially a civil rights act where essentially
those with disabilities are protected under this California law as well. And unfortunately,
because of that, one third of all nationwide accessibility lawsuits are in California.
Because in California, unlike other states, they allow you the opportunity as an attorney
to essentially file lawsuits and try to get settlements or try to get claims awards essentially
out of these small businesses. And so, we here in California are actually seeing a majority of them
again, up and down the state. You do have some law firms that are very, very hyper-focused on this.
They also tend to be focused on other issues we face in lawsuit abuse. Like,
you know, we've talked about in the past, PAGA, the Private Attorney General Act,
also Prop 65. Those also create lawsuit abuse type issues. But specific to ADA access,
California has created that perfect environment where you could actually sue that coffee shop
right down the street from you. You file a lawsuit. They're not going to want to run it
through court, but it's going to cost them tens of thousands of dollars just hiring an attorney,
taking their time out of their business to go run to your nearby courthouse. In many cases,
these lawyers will say, well, give me $10,000, give me $5,000 and I'll walk away. But unfortunately,
that doesn't fix anything. It takes money away from the small business, yet that issue in that
restaurant isn't fixed. That's really what we're trying to get at is we are working with disability
rights folks and saying, hey, how can we get to a point where you as somebody with a disability,
a physical disability, could still patronize that business and we could also not be hit with a
lawsuit, right? We love that idea. They love that idea. The only people that don't like that idea
are trial attorneys here in California. What percentage of businesses get sued in
California? Is there any data? Yeah, well, I don't know the exact
numbers that are out there every single year, because obviously they are filed
throughout the state, every business gets. It is kind of like they send you a letter,
so they send you a letter and you have to settle with them. If you don't settle with them,
then it becomes a lawsuit, right? Exactly. That's exactly the case and that's exactly
what's actually happening. Actually, just to be clear as well, it's a private action that is
taken. You are 100% correct, but in many cases, it's also public agencies that are being hit here,
so it's not just private business. In many cases, it could be a school, it could be a school
district, it could be a city that may not be in full compliance where their buildings aren't
perfectly accessible. These trial attorneys, these frivolous lawsuit attorneys, I call them
predatory attorneys. They are essentially preying over these small businesses. Number one, they're
not looking to fix the issue. They could care less if the accessibility is there for that person
or not. They just want to be able to file a lawsuit, get their money and walk away. So what
better way to do it for them than to target generally ethnically owned businesses? That's
why LA is being hit really hard and a lot of their ethnic communities. I happen to live in the San
Francisco Bay Area and I'll tell you the Vietnamese community in San Jose is being hit really hard
and Milpitas, the Filipino community in San Francisco, we've heard of thousands of cases
just in Chinatown alone where these frivolous lawsuits are being hit by these attorneys.
Again, not looking to fix the issue, but really to shake down businesses. And they do it again
because they know, hey, I have an opportunity. This person may not even know English. Well,
guess what? That's a little bit easier for me to get money from them because they don't understand
the law. They may have just gotten here. They started their business. We're going to go after
them. So yeah, unfortunately, in many cases here in California, the climate is perfect for them
and the California State Legislature, unfortunately, many are not really willing to do anything about
it. You're mentioning that when these lawsuits come in or the complaints come in, they don't
really care if the business fixes the problem or not. How come you say that? Do you have any
evidence of that? You'll see. And maybe there's even some establishments that you folks have
visited in Southern California where you have a business. Let's just say they get hit with a
lawsuit claiming that the accessibility ramp from their parking lot to the sidewalk is the wrong
incline. It does have to hit a specific incline where the person in the wheelchair could
access the sidewalk without obviously too much energy behind them to get up on the sidewalk.
Somebody files a lawsuit. One of these attorneys files a lawsuit. In a lot of these cases,
these folks that are filing these lawsuits, these attorneys, they know the laws
better than many other people. And they'll file the lawsuit. And let's just say, again,
I used to be a franchisee. I got sued, by the way, with an ADA lawsuit. And when I was
franchising, somebody would send me a demand letter saying, hey, fix the issue. But if you
don't want to fix it, just pay us $5,000 and we'll leave you alone. Well, guess what? You pay
that lawsuit $5,000. It's going to be another $10,000 to fix the issue. Why fix it? The best
thing to do is just hope that somebody doesn't see that again in the future. And it leaves you,
again, with a person with a disability that has gotten nothing out of it, except the only person
that really got anything out of it is a lawyer. So you're not actually required to fix it if you
settle out of court. And even if you get a fine, you're not obligated to fix it. What we're trying
to do, what California Citizens Against Lawsuit Abuse is trying to do is work with the state
legislature and say, hey, if you are hit with one of these lawsuits, how do we get to a point where
we actually fix the physical barrier issue and give the person with the disability the ability
to access that business? So again, we're not only championing the reduction of these frivolous
lawsuits, we're also championing the rights of disability advocates and those that are disabled
to make sure that they have access. Because candidly, at the end of the day, we want
everybody to have access to our businesses. We don't want it to just be some people or these
people or those people. We want to make sure that people with disabilities have access. They
could patronize our establishments. We'd welcome their money as just as green as everybody else's,
right? We're here as small business owners to sell a product or a service. And we want to make sure
that we are working with everybody, including those in the disability arena. Tell us what you
think about these threats and lawsuits on ADA compliance in California. Do you think it's fair
to small businesses? Or do you think this is a good way for small businesses to comply with the
ADA rules? Make sure to tell us in the comments or email us at siamak.californiainsider.com. We
read all of your emails and comments. I'm Siamak Khorrami. This is California Insider. We'll see
you next time.