Eleanor Janega- Why Did The Church Control Everything In The Middle Ages.

Museum Mysteries
14 followers
21 Video Views·May 13, 2026
In the Middle Ages, your life wasn't just governed by the King—it was owned by the Church. While peasants toiled in the fields, a massive network of priests, monks, and "princes of the church" controlled everything from your education to the fate of your eternal soul. …
AI Generated·May contain errors
Life in the medieval period looked like lots of different things to lots of different people.
Your place in society could dictate everything, from what food you ate, where you could go,
how educated you were, and even how long you were likely to live for.
Across this series, we'll discover what life was like for those that worked,
those that earned, those that learned, and those that played in medieval England.
When we talk about medieval Europe, it's almost impossible to talk about one of the most
important subsections of medieval society, those who pray. And by that, I mean the clergy.
There's a lot of different ways to be a clergy member. In general,
it means that you've dedicated your life to religion and the church more specifically.
We have to remember that in medieval Europe, when we're talking about Christianity,
we're actually talking about Catholicism. And in many ways, the story of medieval Europe is
about the Catholic Church coming to primacy. Probably the most common form of clergy member
is just parish priests. Parish priests are responsible for giving sermons to their
community in the vernacular language to explain what it is they just heard.
The other thing that parish priests do is give sacraments. Sacraments are particularly important
because partaking in them is, by definition, what makes one a Christian. These are things like
baptism, reconciliation or confession, marriage, Eucharist, and last rites, which is what is
performed right before somebody dies. Parish priests are responsible, therefore, for all these
incredibly important Christian things. And parish priests are very common as a result.
You need to make sure that there are enough parish priests that they can actually administer
to everyone in their area. So in the countryside, in peasant communities, you'll have one church
that will see to, oh, maybe 50 people or so, and they'll be dotted around in the countryside as a whole.
We are here standing on top of Castle Heddingham in Essex. This is a great example of how parishes
work in the countryside. As you can see here, immediately, there's one parish church in the
town surrounding Heddingham Castle. Beyond there, you can see another on the horizon. If you live
three miles away, every Sunday, you're not going to want to have to walk or take a horse
all the way over to another parish. It can be a really long way on a Sunday morning.
This means that it takes out all of the travel and you have a dedicated priest in your community
who knows what's going on with you. So parishes work differently in different places. In cities,
there will be many more parishes in a much smaller space. That's because there's simply a larger
population to see to. The guild members in London are going to want to make sure they're getting
top-notch pastoral care. And so there may be one church every few blocks to make sure that
every single person in that area is getting everything that they need.
We are here on top of the initial early medieval tower of St. Michael's in the North Gate. What
you can see from up here is how dense a city Oxford actually is. Obviously, it's larger now
than it would have been in the medieval period, but still, this is an outstandingly large place.
This is because all of the colleges and all the various clergy members who have set up shop here
attract more and more people to cater to them and cater to the community as a whole.
What you can also see up here are the various steeples that dot the skyline. These are all
individual parish churches, so they're seeing to the needs of the general community within
Oxford itself. They want to have Eucharist given to them, they want to have their children
baptized, they have to be buried somewhere. And it's the parish churches that see to that.
John, thank you so much for meeting me and bringing us here to St. Michael's at the North
Gate. It's a fantastic church. It's the earliest church in Oxford, and I'd be glad to show you
what it's like inside. I think that it's probably one of the most unique churches in England,
certainly. But I was wondering if you could tell us a little bit about its functions as a parish
church in the medieval period. This is one of those towns characteristic of high medieval England,
where you have a very great number of churches crowded into a very small space.
In Doomsday Oxford, that's at the time of the Doomsday Book in 1086, there were five named
churches in Oxford, and St. Michael's was one of them. By 1200, there are 20 churches. Nothing
like Norwich, which has 61 churches, and London, which has 200. But given that Oxford is much
smaller than any of those places, 20 within a small area is quite a lot. The parishes are all
small and very often have fairly low incomes. St. Michael's had a parish which ran inside the
north side of the wall and didn't take in a great deal of commercial property.
And of course, it's commercial property from which the church derives a large part of their income.
One of the problems about medieval churches is knowing how they were founded,
and that's something we're very ignorant about. But there are various suggestions
of which the most likely, probably, in a town like Oxford, is that they were founded by groups
of neighbors. We can't prove that, but it seems to be the case in continental towns that that's
often the case. An alternative explanation is they may have been founded by local lords.
Lords in the countryside very often had town property and would found town churches,
probably with the object, amongst other things, perhaps primarily, of making a profit.
Above the regular parish clergy, there's a next level, the bishops or the princes of the church.
Bishops are kind of like regional managers. They oversee all of the parish priests in their
vicinity, and they do so specifically within a cathedral. The thing about a cathedral is that
it doesn't just mean a large church. It's a name for the administration that happens underneath
the bishop. There has to be somewhere for the parish priests to go to learn. It's also a place
where the bishop might be overseeing local schools, where anyone local can go and receive
a tutelage in Latin. When I say anyone, I mean any boys. Women are usually excluded from this.
But every cathedral is also a functioning school. Cathedrals are also often sites of worship.
They'll have very specific relics of saints that people will go and pray to, and it might be
somewhere that people go on pilgrimage. For example, the Canterbury Tales, one of the most
widespread pieces of English medieval literature, is all about a group of pilgrims going from
London down to Canterbury to pray at the tomb of Thomas the Becket, a very, very important
medieval saint. We know a lot about what happens from the 13th century onwards, because it's in
the 13th century that we have a great deal of episcopal legislation, legislation drafted by
bishops. Bishops are very keen on seeing that local priests do their job in relation to the
congregation. And what that involves, for example, is seeing that parish priest teach the basic
Christian doctrines, see that everybody knows the Creed, the Pater Noster, the Our Father,
the Ten Commandments, in the vernacular, which is interesting. How far all this was carried through,
of course, we can't always be sure about. But it's in that period, rather than in the 12th century,
that pastoral care really takes off at a local level. 12th century, I think, much less so.
Over and above bishops, there are then what we call archbishops. As the name indicates,
they are more important bishops, and the most important archbishop in England is the Archbishop
of Canterbury. So they are the managers to the regional managers that are bishops, and oftentimes
they'll be in even more fancy cathedrals. Above archbishops are cardinals, and cardinals are
people who work directly in the Roman Curia underneath the pope. In order to become a cardinal,
the pope specifically has to select you to become one. Cardinals have a number of specific functions,
the most important of which is that they are responsible for electing the pope when the last
pope dies. Oftentimes, cardinals are also intermediaries with people back home. A local
cardinal, for example, who starts off as the Archbishop of Canterbury might be someone who's
particularly well-suited for translating messages from Rome back to England later. And then, of
course, at the top of all of these is the pope. The pope is God's representative on earth,
and he is elected by cardinals to oversee the church as a whole. A good way of thinking about
the pope is that he's sort of the king of the church. He is the person with whom all of the
power eventually stops, and he has ultimate say over most religious matters. The higher echelons
of the church, such as bishops and cardinals, and especially popes, don't come from common families.
While it's theoretically possible, for example, for someone from a peasant family to become a priest
and not uncommon, it's extraordinarily unlikely that they are going to rise so far through the
echelons of the church that they will one day be bishop. Instead, we tend to see that noble
or royal families feed to the higher parts of the church. It's not uncommon if you're a younger son
within a noble family that you will be sent to the cathedral school to be trained with the
understanding that it's possible that you may become someone like a bishop. In this way, powerful
noble families are able to exercise religious power as well as worldly power in their own households.
Outside of the hierarchy are what we call non-regular clergy members. The largest group
of non-regular clergy members are monks and nuns. We've come inside Denny Abbey because I want to
talk about the original settlers who were clergy members here, the Benedictines. We have all these
clues and hints about what was here before the initial huge abbey building. One of these clues
is right here in the wall, this pillar here, and it's from the original Benedictine church that was
founded here in the 12th century. The Benedictine monks are really interesting because they're the
ones who sort of came up with the initial idea of living in a community outside of the regular world.
Monks refer to this as ora et labore, or prayer and work, and the idea is if you take yourself
out of normal society completely, you can focus entirely on the Lord. Monks, therefore, will join
a monastery and they will pray multiple times a day and they will also involve themselves in work
that they see as serving God. A lot of the time for the medieval world this specifically means
copying out books, because remember this is a world without a printing press, so they're out there
making sure that books stay in circulation and can get to people in order to praise God. Later
in the medieval period, though, a new type of monk arises. These are called the mendicant orders.
They start with Saint Francis of Assisi in the 13th century and instead of deciding to leave the
world to work behind walls for the glory of God, they decide that they are going to go out into the
world to administer directly towards the people. Mendicant technically means beggar, and the idea
here is that the mendicant orders have devoted themselves to the concept of apostolic poverty.
They want to live like Jesus and the apostles did, and they want to be out in society asking for an
exchange of goods for their preaching. So they will say to you, I will give you a sermon on any number
of subjects, and in return please make sure that I eat for the night. So in the medieval world, when
mendicants came along, this was almost like a new form of entertainment. People wanted to hear new
and exciting religious views that didn't come from the parish priests that they've grown up under and
known their entire lives. These are people with different experiences who had new things to say
about something that was very important in the medieval world, which is religion. Parish priests
often see this as the mendicants intercepting tithes that would rightfully go to the local church.
As a result of this, sometimes parish priests will attempt to block mendicants from preaching in their
own town just to make sure that the money is going to the right place. They also might object to what
the mendicants have to say. If you're a very well-to-do parish priest, you might not want
someone coming in who's preaching apostolic poverty and the idea that everyone in the clergy
should be living in poverty. A lot of people were flocking to the priors churches to hear sermons,
who were, of course, very pastorally minded. Great preachers would preach in the vernacular.
The parish church had somehow to rival the friars and to provide the sort of services
which the friars could provide. You've got to remember, of course, in the Middle Ages that the
service is entirely in Latin, and the priest is facing the altar for most of the time, so facing
away from the congregation. So how much direct contact there was between priest and congregation
is difficult to say. Just behind me here we have some really great examples of the varying
kinds of arches you can get across medieval architecture. You'll notice here on the right
there's the really big rounded arch. We know that dates to the 12th century, and that's what we call
a Romanesque arch. It's called Romanesque specifically because they're trying to make
it look Roman. That's why you have the big pillars on either side, and the roundedness is supposed to
bring to mind and conjure images of Rome and the greatness of the empire. Medieval people loved Rome,
and they liked connecting themselves to that idea. On this side of the abbey we have some really new
and exciting architecture, and this is all established when the poor claires take over the
area. In the 14th century, this land is given to a local countess who uses it to establish one of her
favorite orders, the poor claires. As part of this, the poor claires build some wonderful new
gothic architecture. General rule of thumb, if it has a peak in the arch that means it's gothic.
Another great rule of thumb with arches like this is you can kind of tell when they were built based
on how many fingers you can fit in the arch more or less. This arch tells you that it's 14th century
because it more or less follows the peak of four fingers on a hand.
So here at St. Bart's in London, we can see an example of a 15th century arch. You can fit all
five fingers of your hand inside of it, but it's still got a tiny little bit of a gothic peak to
it. Another great little detail here are these floor tiles, which are still extant in the abbey.
And this is a nice reminder because a lot of the time when we see medieval abbeys, they're in states
of disrepair, and that can make us think that the people within them were walking around on dirt
floors because, well, we're walking around on dirt floors when we visit them. But that's not
always the case. Specifically within churches, we would often see really great ornate terracotta
tiles, and this is a reminder of exactly what was here before. The last kind of non-regular clergy
who you might not expect are actually scholars and students. Anyone who works at a university
is necessarily a member of clergy. And crucially, so were all university students. Just like now,
university students in the medieval period were notoriously rowdy. They would get in trouble with
local communities for things like running out on their bar tabs, not respecting the locals,
flirting too much with the girls. And being a member of the clergy meant that when they did so,
they wouldn't be seen in local courts. Instead, the clergy would look after other members of the
clergy. So if you don't pay your bar tab and you get in trouble with a local innkeeper, it's much
better for you to go in front of a clergy court who will give you a slap on the wrist and send
you back to class than it is for you to go in front of the city constabulary where you'll be
fined and possibly thrown in jail. The fact that students are clergy members is actually an origin
of an interesting phrase that we still use now to talk about relationships between universities
and the cities that they're in, and this is town-gown relations. Town, of course, means anybody
within the town, but gown refers to these students who are members of the clergy who are wearing
clergy gowns. With all these different types of clergy, it's really common for them to also be
overlapping in different ways. This is especially true of places like university towns. Here in
England, of course, the two university towns are Oxford and Cambridge, both of which were established
in the medieval period. This is because universities themselves were established during the medieval
period. More specifically, universities come into being in the high medieval period and in the 11th
century. The way that many universities work is that the individual colleges within them will be
connected to a particular order of monks. This is true, for example, of Canterbury College in Oxford,
which we want to talk about particularly today. Canterbury College started out specifically
connected to Benedictine monasteries, so Benedictines from all over England would send their brightest
pupils to Canterbury to study at the University of Oxford. One such Benedictine was a man called
Thomas Wycliffe, who will become very, very important within Oxford generally and Europe as a whole.
We're here on the Oxford streets to enjoy a beautiful spring day, but also to have a look
specifically at Merton College here, because it's here that Wycliffe starts his career.
In 1356, he writes a thesis that's called The Last Age of the Church, and it's particularly
interesting for a 14th century document because it talks about what he perceives to be the cause
of the Black Death. Now, there are a lot of sermons and plenty of pamphlets around in the 14th century
blaming specifically the average person for the plague. These preachers say the average person is
too lustful, the average person is too lazy and gluttonous, and for these reasons God has visited
the plague upon the earth. This isn't how Wycliffe sees it. Wycliffe sees the plague as a sort of
divine retribution and justice for sinful clergy members. As far as he's concerned, these people
are meant to be looking after their flocks, living a life of apostolic poverty, and in general
devoting themselves to God. One of Wycliffe's overarching concerns with religion in general
was what he saw as the undue wealth of the church writ large, but he also had specific objections
to parishes themselves. He thought that parishes were too interested in what he called pomp and
celebration. He thought they were spending too much money on festivals and they were bringing
in too much money from their parishioners. Of course, what Wycliffe says is very catchy,
and it definitely speaks to people who feel quite under the thumb. If you're tithing a large
percentage of your money every year to a church, you might not want to see your priests living
particularly wealthily. But it wasn't just parish churches that Wycliffe had a fundamental problem
with. Overall, most of his complaints were reserved for the mendicant orders or the friars.
In 1380, he writes a pamphlet called Objections to the Friars. In it, Wycliffe refers to the
mendicant orders as the pests of society, the enemies of religion, and the patrons and promoters
of every crime. What he's interested in here is what he sees as the undue wealth of the mendicant
orders. He considers that the preaching orders were founded on a consideration of apostolic poverty.
That means they should be living in poverty. By the 14th century, however, they'd amassed great
fortunes, and so Wycliffe felt that they were living contrary to the very reasons that they
were founded. But why were they founded? Well, in parishes like this, we're not exactly sure whether
or not the parishioners would have been getting access to the sermons that they wanted to.
What friars offer is a sort of traveling sermon service. If you want to hear a religious speech,
and medieval people did, that was very interesting for them, you could get one while you were walking
to market. What Wycliffe and the Lollards do is they train their own preachers. So they're doing
the same thing that the mendicants would be doing out in society. They're giving sermons to the lay
people of Oxford and preaching about the things that they think are important. This is in one way
to counter the friars who they think shouldn't be bringing in as much money, but it's also to put out
their vision of religion to the world. It's actually a form of mass communication in the
medieval period and a really great way to argue your corner. So there can be huge clashes
theologically or about money within the church itself. There are also often clashes between the
clergy and the laity in general. A lot of these also have to do with money. As we've already seen
when we talked about peasants, clergy are often landlords. Primarily it's the local lord who
funds parish churches and this is part of a wholesale reorganization of the countryside
which happens in the 9th but more probably more particularly in the 10th century.
When villages are formed peasants are brought in to particular centers and part of that process of
nucleation is the foundation of a parish church for the new community. Partly for religious reasons
but as in towns also as a piece of property the lord would expect to take a share in the offering.
Oftentimes laity resent the clergy because of this. They feel that the clergy should devote
themselves to God and should not be accumulating so much wealth on earth. Some members of the laity
especially poorer laity also resent the clergy because of their direct links to people like the
nobility. If a noble family wants to make sure that there's someone praying for their souls after
death they can set up a community of monks and nuns on some of their own land. That creates a
new landlord where there wasn't one before and a new opportunity for resentment between peasants
and the clergy. If you are wondering why an organization called the Poor Clares is living
in a building like this which is you know obviously pretty fancy you wouldn't be the
only one. The answer in the specific instance of Denny Abbey is that the countess who endows the
abbey also lived here. The countess really likes the Poor Clares that's part of it. The other part
is that she like many other members of the nobility wanted to retire here and be a part of
the religious order. A countess is going to want to live in some style so she made sure that the
abbey here is well stylish enough. It's things like this that really get under the skin of
individuals like John Wycliffe. The Poor Clares are a member of the mendicant orders. They're
specifically the women's arm of the franciscan movement. So they're supposed to be living in
apostolic poverty technically. The hint is in the poor part. So for him taking money from a countess
setting yourself up as a fancy enough place for a countess to live is the exact opposite of what
religious orders should be doing. St. Michael's is an excellent example of the competing interests of
various religious institutions in the medieval period. It's overseen by the bishop in Lincoln
but it's connected to the college here in Oxford and it oversees and administers to the various
lay people within Oxford itself. This means its job is to see to the pastoral care of an average
person in Oxford but it takes their money and kicks it up to the college itself. There can also
be disputes between the clergy and local nobility about who owns what land where. Who exactly owns
which peasants? When you yourself are not working in the land that you depend on for your money
it very much matters who is doing the work in order to get food to your table.
The clergy are capable of creating entire cities like Oxford which initially exists specifically
to serve the religious people there. When you have a lot of students someone needs to cook for them
someone needs to clean for them. People move to the local area to service the clergy and then you
have a city. The complicated relationship with the clergy and the laity in the medieval period
can also lead to serious scrapes with major powers like the king. The fact that the clergy
control so much land and have so much money here is actually a huge part of their downfall
in the early modern period when Henry VIII is on the throne. Sure Henry VIII wants to be able to
get divorced without anyone telling him what to do but he doesn't mind taking all the land that
the monasteries own as well. One of the ways that you know we're talking about the medieval period
is that the clergy are still balancing on this knife's edge very successfully. They can be major
religious players and major landowners without it being called into question. You can tell that
something is modern when people like the nobility who we'll hear more about in the next episode
are able to counter the church and sometimes take some of that control back.
