The Hidden Costs of Sustainable Investing

Workplace Wavelengths
31 followers
Individuals and large institutions alike are allocating more of their dollars to investment strategies that meet some level of environmental, social, and governance criteria. This is commonly referred to as responsible, sustainable, or green investing.
#investing #mondaymotivation
AI Generated·May contain errors
Individuals and large institutions alike are allocating more of their dollars to
investment strategies that meet some level of environmental, social, and governance criteria.
This is commonly referred to as responsible, sustainable, or green investing. I'll use
sustainable to describe it in this video. According to the 2018 Global Sustainable
Investment Review, as of the start of 2018, more than 25% of U.S. domiciled assets under
In Canada, it is just over 50%, at $2.1 trillion in Canadian dollar terms.
That's up 42% since 2016. BlackRock, one of the world's largest asset managers,
recently committed to making sustainability a key part of their investment process.
This growth in sustainable investing is good news, to the extent that sustainable investing
leads to positive social impact. But it also has some important implications for
investment outcomes. I'm Ben Felix, Portfolio Manager at PWL Capital. In this episode of
Common Sense Investing, I'm going to tell you how you can align your investments with
your views and values. But it's probably going to cost you.
The two most common types of sustainable investment strategies are negative screening
and ESG integration. Negative screening eliminates certain sectors, companies,
or practices from a portfolio. ESG integration is more of a reweighting. Instead of completely
eliminating industries, an integration strategy will underweight companies with lower ESG scores
and increase the weight of companies with higher ESG scores. There are index funds that employ
both of these strategies, often in combination with each other.
Having a sustainable portfolio sounds like a really good idea. And it might feel even
better than it sounds. However, I think that you need to consider two equally important
factors in deciding to implement a sustainable investment strategy.
The first factor is the impact on your expected returns. And the second is the extent to which
the investment actually reflects your views and values. These two considerations need to
be assessed jointly. If a sustainable portfolio has slightly lower expected returns, but is a
perfect reflection of your views and values, you may be willing to accept the trade-off.
But accepting the lower expected returns of a sustainable portfolio that does not reflect
your specific set of views and values might not be a trade-off that most investors should consider.
Let's start with the impact of socially responsible investing on expected returns.
The effect of ESG scores on stock returns was examined in a 2019 paper by Rocco Cicceretti,
Ambrogio Dallo, and Lemarchand Dham. They controlled four common risk factors and looked
at a global sample of 5,972 firms for the period 2004 through 2018. They found that companies with
higher ESG scores tended to deliver lower average returns than companies with lower ESG scores.
They found a statistically significant negative premium for the ESG characteristic in a traditional
Fama-French five-factor regression, a six-factor regression including momentum, and a seven-factor
regression including an ESG risk factor. They found that a one standard deviation decrease in
the ESG score is associated with a 0.13% increase in monthly expected returns. Put simply, controlling
for exposure to known drivers of returns, companies with higher ESG scores tend to do worse
than companies with lower ESG scores. The authors considered two possible
explanations for this observation, both grounded in economic theory. ESG characteristics reflect
investor preferences or ESG characteristics are captured by some underlying ESG risk factor.
Based on the previously mentioned factor regressions, they found it much more likely
that it is an investor preference that drives the negative ESG premium. Investors may be willing to
accept lower expected returns simply because they do not want to invest in certain types of firms.
This is not a risk premium, but an effective investor tastes. That word, tastes, is important.
In their 2007 paper, Disagreements, Tastes, and Asset Prices, Eugene Fama and Ken French
explained that investors may hold an asset partially as a consumption good, regardless
of its expected return profile, if they have a taste for that asset. If enough wealth is controlled
by investors with specific tastes, such as the case of sustainable investors, the effect on
prices could be meaningful. Another way to think about this is that investors with a taste for
sustainable investments require higher expected returns to be convinced to invest in an unsustainable
company. This drives up the expected returns of unsustainable companies. They are also willing
to accept lower expected returns to invest in sustainable companies. This drives down the
expected return of sustainable companies. In a 2019 study, Olivier David Zerbib developed an
asset pricing model including premiums for ESG exclusion and investor tastes. The premiums for
exclusion are related to the increased risk of stocks that are neglected by sustainable investors.
The premium for investor tastes is related to the cost of externalities that sustainable investors
internalize to maximize their welfare instead of the market value of their investments. Using this
model, Zerbib analyzed US stock data between 2000 and 2018. He found an exclusion effect of 2.5%
per year and a taste effect of 1.5% per year. These effects show the approximate magnitude of
underperformance driven by, respectively, a negative screen and an integrated approach to a sustainable
portfolio over the time period examined. As ESG preferences grow stronger, the expectation is that
these pricing effects will become more pronounced. In a 2019 paper, Lubos Pastor, Robert Stambaugh,
and Lucienne Taylor constructed a theoretical model to examine the implications of ESG investing on
expected returns. They again found that firms with higher ESG scores have lower expected returns.
And those expected returns get lower when risk aversion is low and ESG sensitivity is high.
They also found that the size of the ESG investment industry increases as the dispersion
of ESG preferences increases. I know that was a lot to take in, so think about it this way.
If everyone has the same ESG preferences, the same willingness to invest in bad companies if
the expected return is high enough, and to invest in good companies despite a low expected return,
then everyone will hold the market portfolio and be happy. There will be no ESG investing
industry if everyone has the same preferences. If there are two groups, one group with no ESG
preferences and one group with strong ESG preferences, then there is an ESG investing
industry. As the dispersion in ESG preferences grows, the ESG investing industry gets bigger
and expected returns for sustainable portfolios get lower. Pastor, Stambaugh, and Taylor also found
that sustainable investing leads to positive social impact by encouraging sustainable firms to invest
more while discouraging unsustainable firms from investing due to the effects of investor
preferences on their cost of capital. Let's recap. Yes, you can encourage change in the world by
investing in companies that meet ESG criteria, but as long as there is dispersion in ESG preferences,
you are doing so at the expense of lower expected returns. This joint effect must be true. If
sustainable investing works the way that it is supposed to, by putting pressure on unsustainable
companies, then the firms excluded from sustainable portfolios must have higher expected
returns. Meaning sustainable investors must have lower expected returns than the preference-free
market. I think that we have established that investors should expect lower risk-adjusted
returns from a sustainable portfolio. A portfolio with a negative screen that entirely eliminates
industries will tend to be more impactful to expected returns than a portfolio with an
integration approach that reweights companies based on their ESG score. In either case,
lower expected returns are a consideration for investors with above-average ESG preferences
reflected in their portfolio. Lower expected returns are not the only cost that sustainable
investors endure. By definition, a sustainable portfolio must be less diversified than the market.
A reduction in diversification reduces the reliability of the investment outcome.
If companies with high ESG scores have higher expected returns, the increased concentration
and decreased reliability could be viewed as a reasonable trade-off. But companies with higher
ESG scores have lower expected returns. We are getting a less reliable portfolio with a lower
expected return, not an optimal trade-off. We also have to consider fees. A globally diversified
portfolio of Canadian listed iShares ESG ETFs comes with a cost of around 0.28% per year,
while a similar iShares ETF portfolio with no ESG consideration would cost 0.12% per year.
Lower expected returns, less diversification, and higher fees are the costs of a sustainable
portfolio. These costs exist on a continuum. The more sustainable that we want to get,
the higher the costs tend to get. If we start on one end of the spectrum, we might have XIC,
the iShares Core S&P TSX Capped Composite Index ETF. No ESG filter, market cap weighted,
235 holdings, and a 0.06% expense ratio. It will almost certainly deliver the market's return
after costs. XESG, the iShares ESG MSCI Canada Index ETF, favors companies with high ESG scores.
It has 129 holdings and an expense ratio of 0.22%. MSCI has designed the index to have an
expected 1% tracking error, so you expect to get the market return plus or minus some random error.
If we wanted more sustainability, we would need to increase the tracking error budget
and expect higher fees. For example, the Desjardins RI Canada Low CO2 Index ETF has 63 holdings,
more exclusions, and stricter ESG criteria. It has an expense ratio of 0.29%.
As we move along this continuum of trade-offs, the higher costs might be worthwhile if the result is
a portfolio that increasingly aligns with your views and values. But this is one of the biggest
problems that sustainable investors face. There is a huge difference between investing in a product
with ESG, green, or sustainable in its name, and investing in a way that aligns with your values.
Even the rating agencies that determine the ESG scores don't agree on the definitions.
This was explored in a 2019 paper by Florian Berg, Julian Colbell, and Roberto Rigobon.
They looked at ratings from five prominent ESG rating agencies and found that their ESG ratings
have an average correlation of 0.61, with a range between 0.42 and 0.73. The disagreement is driven
nearly equally by differences in ESG definitions and differences in how those definitions are
measured. For context, credit ratings from Moody's and Standard & Poor's are correlated at 0.99.
We can look at the MSCI Canada IMI Extended ESG Focus Index as an example.
This index takes an integration approach combined with total exclusions for tobacco,
controversial weapons, producers of or ties with civilian firearms,
and businesses involved in severe controversies. All good things to avoid for a socially conscious
investor. Now here's the issue. One of its largest holdings is Suncor, a Canadian energy company
specializing in synthetic crude production from oil sands. More than 16% of the index is made up
of energy companies. A different index provider, FTSE, creates ESG indexes that exclude oil, gas,
and coal companies. They don't exclude downstream companies like pipelines, but it's still a step
in the right direction. This difference in ESG index construction should not be a surprise.
From the Berg, Colbell, and Rigobon paper, we can see that energy specifically is a major point of
disagreement across ESG rating agencies, with an average rating correlation of only 0.29
at the energy category level. The inclusion or exclusion of oil and gas companies in an ESG
index is only one example of a larger problem. Name your social or environmental issue of choice,
and different index providers are likely to treat it differently.
Similarly, if an index provider treats one issue the way that you would hope,
they might not align with your views on other issues. This is a big problem from two perspectives.
Investors might end up enduring the higher costs of a sustainable portfolio while owning companies
that conflict with their values, and companies might be confused about which actions they need
to take to improve their ESG performance. Approaching the sustainable investing problem
successfully ends up requiring precise management of the trade-offs between implicit and explicit
costs, and your specific set of views and values. The perfect portfolio from the perspective of
views and values could end up being too under-diversified, too expensive, or otherwise
impractical. On the other hand, the simplest, cheapest, and most diversified portfolio is
likely to conflict, on some level, with the views and values of most sustainable-minded investors.
Step one for a sustainable investor is understanding that as long as there is
dispersion in ESG preferences, sustainable portfolios have lower risk-adjusted returns.
Step two is making a decision about the acceptable level of portfolio trade-offs in meeting the ESG
preferences that you have, where stronger ESG preferences will generally mean less diversification,
lower expected returns, and higher costs. Step three is probably the most important step.
It is verifying that the products that you have selected truly reflect the views and values that
have motivated you to be a sustainable investor. Thanks for watching. My name is Ben Felix of PWL
Capital, and this is Common Sense Investing. If you enjoyed this video, please share it with
someone who you think could benefit from the information. Don't forget, if you have run out
of Common Sense Investing videos to watch, you can tune in to weekly episodes of the
Rational Reminder podcast, wherever you get your podcasts.
