The Role of Judges _ English Legal System

History of Law
11 followers
#law #education #learning
The Law Academy is a project designed to provide legal education for students studying law in the UK. Subscribe for more content.
A. Gillespie & S. Weare, The English Legal System (Oxford University Press, 2021).
E. Allbon & S. Kaur-Dua, English Legal System (Pearson 2020).
Disclaimer:
At no point are these video lessons intended to provide any sort of legal advice. These are for educational purposes only!
Image(s) Copyright: This Photo by Unknown Author is licensed under CC BY-SA
AI Generated·May contain errors
In the previous lesson we took a general introductory look at the concepts of the
judiciary, looking at the structural components therein. In this lesson what I'm going to do is
talk about the role of judges in this process and start to explore the kinds of things that each of
the different judges at each of the different levels of governance actually does and we'll
explore this in more detail as we go on essentially. So like I said we took an introduction in the
previous lesson to the system of the judiciary in England and Wales. We outlined the process
by which judges are appointed. So we talked about for example the judicial appointments commission,
we talked about the role of the law chancellor in the appointment of judges and the changing
nature of this role owing to the 2005 constitutional reform act and then we also talked about the
various structures of appointment within the judicial process. This lesson is going to talk
about the role of judges. Now the type of judge that we're talking about in fact will depend on
the role that they play within the judicial system generally and we looked at the previous lesson
early on in the previous lesson at some of the different delineations of judicial structures.
So for example we took a look at the different lower inferior judges and then we also
talked about the superior judges and what we're going to do in this lesson is essentially do the
exact same thing but instead of talking about the general structure we will talk about the role that
each of these judges plays in the judicial process itself at each level of judicial appointment.
So let's begin with inferior courts. Most of the work the day-to-day work which is done by the
inferior courts will be essentially involving the hearing of various different cases. A county court
for example will hear civil cases, the crown court will hear indictable criminal cases.
Indictable criminal cases for those of you who don't know is just a delineation between
indictable and non-indictable or summary offences which essentially delineates between the crown
court and the magistrates. We looked at that when we took some introductory examinations of the
criminal justice system when we did criminal law. In criminal cases and in some civil cases there
will also be the presence of the jury in this process. A jury may exist it will always exist
in a criminal case at least when we talk about indictable offences and in some civil
cases there may also be juries attached as well. The delineation that is made here is between the
burdens of a case. When we look at the burdens of a case the judge will have a legal burden
as a result of which the judge represents the trier of law. The jury has what is known as an
evidential burden they will be the trier of fact. So what this essentially means is that the role
of the judge versus the jury are very very different. The judge will direct the jury on
the matters of law and will also essentially tell the jury and inform the jury or instruct the jury
should I say in essentially come to the conclusion that if this is the case that you are of the
opinion of this factual analysis for example if you believe this factual thing to be true or to
be false then you will find for the defendant or for the prosecution. Smaller claims will be dealt
with by county courts and in the case of civil proceedings in the case of civil proceedings but
then when we talk about non-indictable summary offences in the case of criminal law we have to
look at magistrates courts. Moving up slightly then let's look at the high courts. The high court will
often have a role as well in the hearing of cases. These are known as cases at first instance given
that this is often the first time the case is being tried in a judicial setting. In some cases
too however the high court will hear appeals from the lower inferior courts. So for example the
county courts or even the crown courts can then appeal to higher up but for the most part
the high court will also have a very similar role to these inferior judicial systems. They will hear
cases, they will be hearing cases at first instance but in some cases they may also hear appeals.
It is only when we get to the court of appeal that we start to see the lack of the hearing of
cases and instead looking at the adjudication of legal principles. As the name suggests the
court of appeal will deal with appeals which are made by lower courts. The appeals process is based
on disputes relating to points of law not relating to points of fact. So if there is a trial at a
lower court level whether it be criminal or civil and there are the jury make a decision but there
is some discrepancies in relation to how the law is applied in a particular issue, whether that be
a new area of the law, whether that be a disagreement about how a judge applied and
interpreted the law, this can then go to the court of appeal and the question that will be answered
is whether or not the lower courts were correct in their application of the law not their application
of facts. They will operate in both criminal and civil jurisdictions so you will see court of
appeal decisions made from both the civil and the criminal jurisdiction. The courts of appeal will
sit an odd number of Lord Justices of Appeal and the reason for this is to ensure that a clear
decision is made on a particular case so there is no 50-50 splits in terms of decisions that are made.
Often it is the case that it is three judges who will sit in the court of appeal and make
decisions but in some rare instances where we're talking about some quite significant pieces of
case law we may also see the sitting of five Lord Justices of Appeal. The final stop, if you will,
at least within the domestic system that a case can go is the last point of appeal which is the
Supreme Court. The Supreme Court again is a final point of appeal within the domestic legal system
and it is the point of again an appeals court so it doesn't hear
cases in the same way in the way that a trial jury and a trial court may do and it is the
final point of appeal within the domestic legal system and the reason why I've said that is
because there are obviously cases that can be taken to other courts outside the UK. You could
go to the European Court of Human Rights for example or the European Court of Justice in
certain cases depending on the jurisdiction and these may also have some kind of binding
authorities on to the United Kingdom's judicial system but that's a little bit iffy in some ways.
The Supreme Court just like the Court of Appeal will hear cases on appeal from both criminal
and civil jurisdiction. They will also be points and matters of law again not points and matters
of fact. Most often these cases will be civil in nature. It's quite rare that we see criminal
cases go all the way up to the Supreme Court however there are plenty of examples that we can
cite. In more high profile instances however the cases that are at the Supreme Court are often
matters of constitutional or administrative law judicial review. Arguably the most famous cases
were the two Miller cases which takes place in relation to Brexit and the decision made by the
government to prorogue Parliament at least in the second Miller case. This was arguably the most
important case in 2019 and was definitely the most highly publicized case one of the most highly
publicized cases in all of the history of the Supreme Court in fact. Now the decisions made by
the Supreme Court will actually create something known as binding precedent. We've talked about
precedent in previous lessons but essentially the precedent binds therefore onto all of the
previously discussed courts and creates precedent that the lower courts can't actually
they can't actually override in any kind of way.
