Is Celtic Mythology Behind This Iconic Folk Tale?

Medieval Legends
5 followers
In this video, I investigate Britain’s most attested headless horseman tradition, the brutal killing of yeoman John De Warton in 1379, and the strange links between local folklore and Sir Gawain and the Green Knight.
Could the famous headless rider of the moors be a surviving folk memory of a real event?
#History #Folklore #HeadlessHorseman #SirGawain #GreenKnight #BritishFolklore #CelticMythology #MedievalHistory #ArthurianLegend #Staffordshire #EnglishHistory #GhostStories #Mythology #Dullahan #FolkloreHistory
AI Generated·May contain errors
The Headless Horseman is a character from folklore whose roots can be traced back
hundreds of years. These are the Staffordshire moorlands, the setting for what might be the
oldest story we have featuring a headless horseman. But it's not a ghost story,
it's a medieval poem called Sir Gawain and the Green Knight. Now separately,
Victorian folklorists recorded stories on these moors of a headless horseman who terrorised the
locals and it's the most attested headless horseman in Britain. Could these two be linked
and what lies behind the headless horseman motif within British folklore? These stories don't just
appear out of nowhere. I did a little digging and I found a tragic, real event that took place here
nearly 700 years ago. So buckle up, this is a true story. The year is 1397. Thomas Litchfield
was the abbot in charge of Dulechris Abbey. There's nothing left of it now, but at one time
it was a Staffordshire powerhouse. England was in turmoil, the plague had ravaged the population.
Richard II was king and his reign was fragile. The country was bankrupt. Local barons and
abbots ruled like despots and Litchfield was no exception. He employed 21 knights who travelled
the country extorting money in exchange for protection. Medieval mafia style tactics.
Anyone who refused to pay would be beaten or put to the sword. John de Warton was a yeoman,
a farmer who owned his own land. He was sick of the abbot's men terrorising him and his neighbours.
De Warton had a good standing in the area and one day he decided that he would stand up to
Litchfield's mob. He gathered a group of armed men and attacked the unruly abbot's gang.
Now we don't have information on how this attack played out or whether there were any casualties,
but de Warton seems to have been quite successful. The abbot says in the court records that de
Warton and his men managed to disable the ability of his men to be of service for a good period of
time. It's important at this stage to point out that the abbot was not a warrior monk,
he wasn't fighting alongside these men, he employed them to do his dirty work.
Saturday 17th April 1379. The market fair was taking place in Leek. John de Warton always
visited the fair and today was no exception. After the market John began his journey home
on horseback across the moor alone. He clearly felt safe enough to travel solo. Perhaps he
thought his dealings with the abbot had come to an end. Nevertheless he was armed with a sword,
a bow and arrows. Hiding behind the rocks and heather lay the abbot's men. They knew de Warton
would come this way. Litchfield had given them explicit orders. The yeomen walked unknowingly
into their ambush. One of the concealed men let loose an arrow, striking de Warton in the body.
He fell from his horse. Surrender to the peace shouted one of his attackers. John had little
choice. He was completely outnumbered, unhorsed and badly wounded. He surrendered, throwing his
sword and his bow to the floor. The abbot's men took their chance and sprung at him. Taking his
sword and his bow, they beat him and slashed at him with their blades, before delivering a final,
fatal blow. They beheaded him up there on the quiet moor. They then took everything of value,
his horse, his saddle, his weapons and even his clothes. They then continued onto de Warton's
house, where they broke in and stole everything they could carry. Litchfield's men rode back to
the abbey. The abbot welcomed them with open arms. This crime shook the community so much
that there was a royal inquiry and the abbot was sent to jail. I wonder if the memory of such an
event lived on within the community for years to come. Fast forward to the 1800s when there was a
huge interest in local folk traditions where previously there'd been none. The Brothers Grimm
had shown the world the importance and the richness of folk tales. Folklore collecting became
popular in England. Now these stories were collected from the Staffordshire moors in the 1850s
by a man called Thomas Slay. He writes, ghostly legends and superstitions still retain their sway
over the minds of the inhabitants of those wild moors, more especially the Headless Rider,
who haunted the moors between Leek and Worslow. A man returning from Leek, from the market,
sees before him a neighbour on horseback whom he hails for a lift. No sooner, however,
has he mounted behind him, than to his horror he finds that his companion is the Goblin Horseman.
The discovery comes too late, for a wave springs the horse, covering it abound, fields, trees,
hedges and ditches. In the end he's found deposited at his own door, helpless and groaning,
and so maimed and bruised that in a few days he passes. That's one of several accounts that Slay
collects. Several other stories are reported by local papers and in 1933 a group went out onto
the moors on the day of the fair and went looking for the Horseman, but this time he didn't show.
Slay's accounts mention the Horseman, but there's no origin story for the apparition.
Headless Horseman stories from Oxfordshire and from Epping Forest both tell of a soldier from
the English Civil War who was fleeing battle and slain by the angry villagers. But no such story
exists for the Staffordshire Horseman. One tantalising link seems to be the connection
between the Horseman and the fair. Sightings of the Horseman and the infamous hunt for him
occur on the fair days, which is when Dewarton met his end. Now, do I dare suggest that this
is a folk memory of the events that took place in 1379? It could well be, but this is an exploration
of Headless Horseman's generally and I don't want to go too Da Vinci Code on you guys,
but I'll leave that one for you to think about. Washington Irving, who wrote The Legend of Sleepy
Hollow, which was later made into a film by Tim Burton, was American, but he loved visiting
England and he spent time in the North West Midlands. No doubt he was inspired by English
folklore, but we can't say which Headless Horseman he came across during his time here,
since there are quite a few. There is an earlier Headless Horseman from the English tradition
and that brings us to Sir Gawain and the Green Knight. That's right folks, story time is not over.
Our story begins, as a great deal of medieval stories do, in the mythical court of King Arthur
in Camelot. It was New Year's Eve. King Arthur sat feasting at the round table alongside his
favourite knights, celebrating Christmas time and the coming of the new year. Seated next to
Gwynevere was the good Sir Gawain. Trumpets and pipes played as they tucked into sweet meats and
dainties. The doors to the hall suddenly flew open and the music abruptly stopped. The knights all
turned to look. In rode an awesome being, an impossibly tall man with long limbs and wide
shoulders. His back was broad, but his waist was slim. Those present thought that he might have
been half giant. He was handsomely built, apart from the fact that he was entirely green. His skin
was green, his clothes were green, but they were made of the finest cloths. His reins were bejewelled
with emeralds and so was his belt. His horse was, you guessed it, green. He wore no armour or no helmet.
In one hand he held a holly twig, in the other an axe. The weapon was merciless beyond description.
A green steel blade as sharp as a razor's edge and a wooden staff that housed it beautifully.
Who is the governor of this company? His voice boomed as he rode up and down the hall, fiercely
eyeing all of the knights at the table. They were all afraid, except for the king who said,
I am. I am called Arthur. What is it you want? The green knight spoke again. I've heard great
things about this kingdom and its men. Your deeds are famous. You have the strongest steel and the
fastest horses. That has enticed me here. And if you are as brave as they say, then you won't object
to my little game. If there is one of you who considers himself bold, then accept this challenge.
You may strike me with one blow from my axe and I will return the favour in a year's time.
Arthur stands, accepting the offer, realising that the request is foolhardy. How could the green man
return a blow if the blow that Arthur dealt was lethal? Gawain stood up and said to Arthur,
My lord, your wife is present. This is your hall. This game is beneath you. Let me take the game
from you. And Arthur agreed. Sir Gawain approached the green knight, gripping the axe in his hand.
The green knight dismounted and knelt, exposing his neck. And Sir Gawain struck hard and true,
cleanly severing the giant's neck. Blood poured out. Without a moment's hesitation, the green knight
stood, walked over to the head, picked it up and tucked it under his arm. He then mounted his horse.
The head then spoke. Well, Sir Gawain, you have dealt a lethal blow and next year I
shall deal mine. You must meet me at the green chapel. Then he charged out of the hall,
spurring on his horse with sparks flying from its hooves. Arthur and his knights laughed in shock.
None of the knights had ever heard of the green chapel before. Sir Gawain knew he had to keep his
word, because if he did not, then he would lose his honour. And that is a fate worse than any.
He waited until spring before setting out to find the green chapel. He travelled a great distance,
peasants and noblemen alike helping him find his way. Every day he got a little closer. Months
passed until it was New Year's Day and a peasant told him exactly where to find the green chapel.
He rides high up onto the snow-covered moors, the bare trees chattered in the wind. He crossed a
ford into a wood and begins an ascent. He's very close now. He reaches the top of the hill,
expecting to see some kind of dwelling, but instead he finds the entrance to an old crag,
overgrown and green with moss. Could this be the green chapel, he thought. He rode inside.
As he entered, he heard the sound of a metal blade being sharpened on a whetstone. The sound
ricocheted off the hard granite walls, making his teeth shake in their sockets. Gawain called out,
and the grinding came to a halt. From a hole stepped out the green man, wielding a Danish axe.
I will repay you handsomely for the blow you dealt me last year, he said, striding towards Gawain.
Now kneel. Gawain did as he was told, revealing his neck. The knight swung the axe,
but Sir Gawain flinched, ducking out of the way, causing the knight to miss. You are a coward and
an oath-breaker, and I will pay you what I owe. Now stay still, he said. Sir Gawain knelt once
again, determined to face his end with honour. This time he did not flinch. The green knight
swung his axe, but he cleverly stopped mid-swing, just before Sir Gawain's neck. So now you're
brave enough to take a hit. Well, I'll go through with it this time, he said, pulling the axe back,
ready to swing again. As he lifted it, Sir Gawain realised that the blade had nicked his neck,
causing a small cut and blood to trickle down onto the snow. He stood up and grabbed his spear.
Your blow has been dealt, the debt has been paid, and you will not deal me another, said Sir Gawain
as he stood, ready for a fight. The green knight laughed. Put your weapon down. You will not be
manhandled here. Our debt is settled. Ride back to Arthur, tell him what happened here, and you'll
be a hero. Now, that is an abridged version of the green knight. It runs at least a few hours
long, so I obviously can't tell the whole story here, but I might go back to it in another video
if you're interested. Let me know in the comments. But for now, let's take a closer look at this
story. The poem is written in a North Staffordshire dialect of medieval English. Now,
English during this period was highly regionalised, so the vocabulary is very distinct,
and it's distinct enough to pin it down to the North East Midlands. It was written roughly between
1370 and 1390. Now, the author never gives his name, so we don't know who it is to this day,
but we refer to him as the Pearl Poet. And what's uncanny about this story is that the writer,
who, as we know, was from the North West Midlands, almost certainly knew about Abbot
Litchfield and John de Warton. Since the Crown sent the Royal Commission to investigate,
it was a very big local story, if not a national story. Now, Ralph Elliot, a highly respected
expert on medieval literature, believed that the poem was composed by a monk from Julicrus Abbey,
because the site of the showdown has been identified as Ludd's church.
On the same bit of moorland where John de Warton had his final showdown, Ludd's church and the
surrounding land, guess what, belongs to Julicrus Abbey. And the level of literacy and the knowledge
of the local landscape, in Elliot's opinion, points to a monk at Julicrus. The colour of the
night is curious to me. Green is the colour of the yeoman. And de Warton, as we know, was a yeoman.
Green was the colour that Chaucer's yeoman wore. It was also the colour that the yeoman regiment
wore. Now, I wonder if the Pearl Poet was inspired by the story of de Warton, even just a little bit.
Perhaps the green just symbolises the wild man or the supernatural. These are just curious links.
There were certainly other influences on the Pearl Poet which were shaped by mythology,
not just local events. The beheading game is a common theme in medieval literature.
It first appears in the Irish epic in the Ulster Cycles, which was recorded in the 1100,
where a warrior is challenged by a giant to strike a blow. He picks up his own head, talks,
walks out with it, you know the rest. It's basically the exact same setup as the Green
Knight. In a sense, the hero wins the game simply by accepting it and keeping their word.
Now, what's curious is how similar the beheading game from Ireland is with our English story.
And it seems highly unlikely that someone in England would have had access to an Irish
manuscript. Now, remember, these were not mass produced works. There may have only ever been
one copy. Staffordshire is 30 miles to the Welsh border. And there's also a story from the Welsh
Mabinogion where Bran the Blessed is beheaded and continues to talk for another seven years.
There's clearly a recurring theme here. Exactly how they're linked is hard to say.
But there was clearly an oral tradition of the beheading game that was shared across Britain
and Ireland. How far back it goes is anyone's guess. Some believe that the headless horseman
can be traced to a character from Irish folklore known as the Dullahan, a rider who carries its
own head and holds a whip made from the human spine. Now, the Dullahan is first recorded by
Thomas Croker in 1835, and he tells us the story of a man hitching a ride with a mysterious stranger
who turns out to be a Dullahan. And when he arrives home, he's bruised and battered.
It sounds mysteriously like the account that Slay tells us from the Staffordshire horseman.
Slay may have been influenced by Croker's Dullahan, but he wasn't just inventing the
Horseman of the Moors, as it's attested for in other sources. Now, the Dullahan isn't an
ancient Irish spectre as far as we can tell, unlike the Banshee, which we can trace back to
the medieval period. We have no evidence that the Dullahan existed before the 19th century,
although it certainly feels ancient, we just can't say for sure.
Now, have you ever heard of the cult of the head? It's a theory that's caused some contention,
and the term was coined by Dr. Anne Ross, who speculated that the ancient Celts believed the
head was the seat of the soul, or that they worshipped the head in some way. Now, this was
based on artefacts found from the Celtic world, and Roman and Greek sources tell us that Celtic
groups in mainland Europe collected heads as their war trophies. Now, this has been confirmed
by archaeological findings. Ronald Hutton, on the other hand, says that the frequency with
which human heads appear in Celtic metalwork proves nothing more than they were a favourite
decorative motif, among several others, which were just as popular among non-Celtic peoples.
The use of the head as an icon is merely due to the practice of being favoured artistic image.
So, the jury is out. Hutton is being cautious and not wanting to make the assumption that because
they're depicted that they have some sort of meaning. In my opinion, ancient peoples didn't
simply make things because they liked the look of them. Now, Hutton isn't addressing the stories
from Ireland and Wales, and that's partly because he believes that the Mabinogion and the Irish
Annals are medieval inventions, not ancient stories which have later been recorded in text.
But that is a whole nother video in itself. Perhaps headless horsemen apparitions derive
from the beheading game, and the image of the headless green knight riding out of the hall.
If Celtic people really believed that the soul resided in the head, then this is certainly
echoed in the story of the headless horseman. They're often searching for their head,
and once they find it, they find peace, and their soul may finally rest. But more than anything else,
it's this landscape that links these stories. The headless horseman, the green knight,
and John de Warton all rode through here in one way or another. Now, thank you for watching. If
you enjoyed that, please remember to like, hype and subscribe, and let me know what you'd like
me to cover next.
