Appalachias greatest Mysteries

Mysteries Around Me
175 followers
20 Video Views·May 7, 2026
Coming up, we investigate some of the most baffling mysteries to ever take place in the
Appalachian Mountains. What could have caused them and will they ever be solved? This is Appalachia's
Greatest Mysteries. Our first story takes place in the mountains of Bath County, Kentucky,
where an event so bizarre and unthinkable took place that even now, 150 years later,
scientists can't explain it, while many others believe that's because it had supernatural origins.
One of the strangest mysteries to ever take place in the Appalachian Mountains
took place in the spring of 1876 in Bath County, Kentucky. It was your typical morning at the
Crouch Farm as the old mountaineer stepped out on his front porch and surveyed the skies for
any clues to the weather. Today was a big day. He would need to hitch the mule to the wagon
and make a run to town, two miles away for supplies. And although the sky was clear there
in the distance, the old man took note of a light swirling wind amongst the treetops on the mountain
ridge, where the morning sun was slowly rising. Looks like there'll be falling weather later on
today. The canny hillsman surmised, inside the small cabin, Mrs. Crouch had just finished cooking
the morning breakfast, where now her 11-year-old grandson, Allen, was the first to arrive at the
kitchen table. A few minutes later, Miss Sadie Robinson, a young schoolteacher who was boarding
with the Crouch family, also made her way to partake in the morning meal. And before long,
breakfast was over and old man Crouch disappeared down the dusty trail, bound for the nearest town
of Olympic Springs to do a little trading. As was her custom, the boarder, Miss Sadie Robinson,
quickly set about cleaning the morning dishes as Miss Crouch took to the shade and the comfort of
the front porch to begin making a batch of soap. The morning sun rose higher and higher in the sky
and soon it was 11 a.m. and all the shadows in the morning dew were both gone. And despite Mr.
Crouch's earlier prediction of falling weather, the skies, well they were clear with nary a cloud
in sight. Truth is, there'd been a long dry spell of nearly three weeks and by the looks of things,
it wasn't going to be ending anytime soon. Yet, all of this was about to change and what happens
next is still talked about and debated by scientists to this very day. You see, as Miss
Crouch was working on her soap, she noticed something fall out of the sky just out of the
corner of her eye. That was strange, it almost looked like a snowflake. Then, there in the
distance, there was another and then another. Astonished, she called out to her grandson,
Alan, come look at this, I think it's snowing. And in a flash, the curious young boy, too,
was standing on the porch when he heard the slapping sound of something landing on the
fence posts behind him. Then, the sound of a mysterious rain landing on the tin roof above
them also caught the attention of Sadie, who came to the porch to see what was going on.
And there, all three of them watched in astonishment for the next several minutes as
chunks of meat rained from the cloudless sky, covering nearly an acre of the family farm.
But what in the world was this? The pieces were nearly two square inches and were all over the
fence and the porch and left a dark stain on anything that it touched. A couple hours later,
Mr. Crouch returned home and quickly took note that his farm was covered in some mysterious
meat that now his hogs and dogs and even his rooster were eating. He picked up several pieces
and examined them. They seemed to have some sort of fiber running throughout the pieces.
It was certainly a baffling mystery. And within a few hours, even though there wasn't nary a
single telephone that existed in this part of the country, wagon tongues had spread the news
of the meat shower and now the Crouch farm was full of dozens of farmers, reporters,
and even a local professor who began jarring the meat in glass jars of alcohol to preserve them.
Speculation and theories ran wild. C.J. Craig had arrived on the scene less than two hours after it
happened. To him, the meat looked like pounded beefsteak, very soft and tender, and had a
peculiar smell. The Baptist preacher, Mr. Nichols, contended that it was mutton. But the wily old
bear hunter, Mr. Ellington, well, he proclaimed that it had a greasy feel and that he knew the
And by God, this was bear meat. It was then determined that what they really needed was
someone brave enough to eat a piece. That's when Jimmy Welsh, an Irish railroad laborer known for
being able to eat anything, whether it was skunk or fowl or even crows, he was bet a dollar that
he wouldn't eat the mystery meat. A whole dollar just to eat that? Well, you got yourself a deal.
And with that, the meat was placed on the table and Jimmy was duly informed that his supper
was ready. He sat down and took a long look at the meat before he remarked that he had never
ate meat alone. So an order of pickles and crackers were placed alongside the main dish.
Then Jimmy took the meat up on his fork and after two or three unsuccessful efforts to get that
stuff in his mouth, he laid it back down. Well, I at least need a glass of whiskey to wash it down
with, he proclaimed. A few moments later, a glass of whiskey was produced and placed on the table.
Yet once again, Jimmy hesitated and finally proclaimed that he wasn't hungry. So they raised
the bet to three dollars if he would simply gulp the meat down. And that's when Jimmy remembered
it was the season of Lent. And so he backed out on moral principles before he promptly guzzled down
the whiskey to keep it from going to waste. As Jimmy shamefully exited the dinner table,
a local butcher, L.C. Frisbee, finally manned up. After all, he dealt with every sort of meat there
was on a daily basis. If anyone would know what this was, surely he would. So the butcher began
examining a piece. It sure got a milky feel about it, don't it? It's kind of like veal or lamb.
And then, to the astonishment of all those in attendance, without any hesitation, the butcher
put a piece of it in his mouth and chewed on it for a few seconds before spitting it out and
proclaiming. Fellas, I've handled all sorts of meat, but I ain't never tasted nothing like that.
That's right. To the astonishment of everyone in this small Kentucky community, it had in fact
rained meat. And soon, the news of the event was spread all across America,
in what newspapers were calling the Kentucky Meat Shower. Samples of the meat were sent to
universities all across the nation, where experts began examining the meat under microscopes,
and all sorts of theories emerged. One professor contended that it was frog spawn that had blown
into the air and then fell. Another swore that it was lung tissue from a human infant or even a
horse. But perhaps the wildest of them all was that a flock of buzzards had flown over the farm
and just all happened to vomit at the same time. Still, the question remained, how did this happen?
Well, it turns out that another mysterious shower had occurred just seven years prior in 1869,
less than 200 miles away, when the Knoxville and Kentucky Railroad tracks were first being laid
through a pristine virgin Appalachian forest, as workers were working in an area known to be an old
date of American burial ground. Locals had long called this area Indian Grave Gap, and for years,
it was known as Forbidden Ground. Well, when those railroad tycoons came through,
they were unconcerned with superstitions of mountaineers, or with preserving or respecting
any burial ground, and they simply saw Indian Grave Gap as the quickest way to build their
railroad. The workers had been in the area for days, clearing out the forest, when suddenly,
a powerful storm sprang up out of nowhere, and the skies darkened as black as night,
with thunder rolling and lightning popping. Suddenly, dead snakes began raining from the sky
by the thousands for nearly ten minutes, and when the storm finally passed, there was an estimated
million ringed snakes from five inches to two feet in length, covering the entire forest.
The event was witnessed by over 200 workers and hundreds of locals who flocked to the scene after
the storm. Is it possible that these two events were connected, and if so, how can they be explained?
Some have suggested that it's possible that the Crouch Farm was also an old Native American
burial ground, and that both of these mysterious rainstorms might have been some sort of warning
or message from beyond. Still, more than 150 years later, both of these bizarre rainstorms
remain unsolved. Coming up, Appalachia's greatest mysteries continue with a mysterious race of
who have baffled historians and scientists to this very day.
In the heart of Appalachian folklore lies a mysterious tale that has captivated the
imaginations of generations of researchers, historians, and the curious alike. Unexplained
ancient remains scattered across Appalachia suggest a prehistoric race once inhabited them
long before the Native Americans ever set foot here. But how and when did they get here,
and where did they go? Just who were the Moon-Eyed People? Most folks today don't even realize it,
but the evidence is actually hiding in plain sight right underneath the canopy of forest,
covering the vast regions of Appalachia. There is a dim but persistent tradition of a strange
white race preceding the Cherokees. Some of the stories even go so far as to locate their former
settlements and to identify them as authors of ancient stone ruins found all over these mountains.
The earliest reference appears to be from John Sevier, who was a frontiersman and one of the
founding fathers of the state of Tennessee. Sevier was involved in several treaties that
led to the removal of the Cherokee Indians. This role required him to travel great distances
through the still remote and virgous forests of Appalachia. On one such expedition in 1782,
he discovered what appeared to him to be a vast military complex sitting atop a mountain in
Georgia and built with architectural engineering that was foreign to the natives. And strangest of
all, it bore a striking resemblance to European constructed battlements. The fort consisted of
that was two to eight feet high and the widths suggested that it had once been much taller.
It encircled nearly 100 acres at the top of the mountain that consisted of monster ferns,
fed by a spring that floated over two million gallons a day. There was evidence of two towers,
large gates, and many fortified fighting pits. Many of the stones weighed tons. Mystified by
the ancient ruin, John Sevier consulted the great Cherokee chief Okatosa, who was over 90 years old,
being born in the late 1600s. The chief told Sevier that his forefathers knew the builder of
the fort and that it was built by white men from across the great water who were here long before
the natives. The Cherokees tell us that when they first arrived in the Appalachian area,
they found it inhabited by a certain moon-eyed type people who couldn't see in the daytime.
The tradition was rather ghostly. Chief Okatosa claimed that when they first arrived in the
Chickamauga country, the moon-eyed people were already here. They were a race of fair-skinned,
light-haired, blue-eyed people who looked like nothing they'd ever seen before.
The natives considered them an albino race. The houses of this strange race of people were
made of upright logs, and the dirt that was removed from the interior of the house
was thrown up on top to serve as a roof, and they were said to have occupied the country in North
Carolina from the head of the Little Tennessee River to the Chickamauga Creek near Chattanooga,
with forts established all along the way. The Cherokees waged war against them, and according
to tradition, the last stand taken by these moon-eyed people was near the mouth of the Chickamauga,
where they surrendered and agreed to move out if they were permitted to go in peace.
About the same time that John Sevier discovered the ruins in Georgia, a researcher named Benjamin
Barton published a book that described an ancient people who were also moon-eyed,
and they were first discovered in Panama by Welch explorers in the 1700s. These explorers
actually lived with them for a short while and described them as an albino race who could see
better at night than in the day. But the question remains, who were these moon-eyed people,
and how and when did they get here? When the Spanish explorer Hernando de Soto's banner
waved proudly over Georgia's Fort Mountain in the early days of the 16th century,
the mystery of the moon-eyed people was already old, but the fortress they built in defense of
Cherokee Indians still stood, and once again it protected a white people against the natives.
It's still standing today, and the flaming banners of sunrise and sunset
vault a mystery still unsolved. The semicircular wall encloses approximately 100 acres on the top
of Fort Mountain. The steepness of the cliffs on three sides of the mountain form a natural defense
on the east, the south, and the north. The wall contains 29 pits located at intervals of 50 or 60
feet, which a man might stand waist-deep and wield a battle axe or any other weapons he might have
handy. But what if the moon-eyed people built this structure as something more than a fort?
It turns out that there's actually a significant amount of science behind the positioning of the
stones. The wall is in line with the sun's east-west axis. Perhaps the stone structure
was a calendar or a means to keep up with the growing season. The northeast position of the wall
even aligns perfectly with the summer solstice. This was important because it's possible that the
moon-eyed people used this wall as more than protection. In fact, it's likely that they used
it to predict the positions of the sun and the moon in the future, and using this knowledge to
know when to plant their crops or when harvest might be late was powerful magic. Still, how and
when did the moon-eyed people first arrive? One clue can be found on this historical marker
located on the shores of one of America's busiest port cities, Mobile, Alabama.
In 1170, Welsh explorer Prince Madoc and his 200 men discovered Mobile Bay over 300 years before
Columbus did. Madoc was so impressed by this new land that he returned to Wales for more ships
and colonists. Madoc was the illegitimate son of Owen Gwynedd, who was the Prince of North Wales,
and when Owen died, his sons fought amongst themselves for the throne,
and soon civil war broke out. Madoc apparently decided to seek other shores, and it's believed
that he made two and perhaps even three voyages to America. Madoc set sail again, intending to
return to Alabama in 1171 with 12 ships loaded with more colonists, but strangely, they were
never heard from again. Is it possible that this second expedition of Madoc actually landed in
Panama, resulting in the settlement of moon-eyed people in both Central America and Appalachia?
As noted by botanist and historian Benjamin Barron, many researchers speculate that these
Welsh explorers became the moon-eyed people, who, due to their total isolation, initially sought
shelter and hid in the cave systems of Appalachia, resulting in an albino race and would possibly
explain their poor eyesight. It would be hundreds of years later before the next known white people
would arrive in America. One such explorer was Morgan Jones, who traveled inland to South Carolina,
but he was captured and almost executed by a native tribe led by a light-skinned, blue-eyed chief
who adorned traditional native garments. As the explorer begged for his life, he was shocked when
the native chief who spared his life also spoke the Welsh language. Were these the mythical moon-eyed
people? Were these Welsh explorers the moon-eyed people who the Cherokees discovered living in
Appalachia when the natives first arrived? And was this mysterious stone ruin, which sat high atop
Fort Mountain in Georgia, their last stand in their war with the Cherokees? In 1803, when Thomas Jefferson
enacted the policy to remove all natives west of the Mississippi River, he called for the removal
of what he termed Welch Indians. And in 1804, Lewis and Clark wrote in their papers that they had met
a strange tribe of Welch Indians in southern Appalachia. Then, in 1841, a farmer in North Carolina
was plowing his field when he unearthed a mysterious statue of two strange-looking beings
that stood about three feet tall with large eyes. And many researchers claimed that they were solid
evidence that the moon-eyed people were indeed here hundreds of years before the Native Americans
ever reached Appalachia. But who exactly carved this statue and when? Was it made by the moon-eyed
people and did it have any connection with their study of the night sky? Some have even speculated
that this statue was made by the moon-eyed people, but not in a reflection of themselves, but of
aliens. Is this statue and the ancient ruins situated atop a 2,800 foot high mountain in
Georgia the only remaining evidence of a prehistoric white race known as the moon-eyed people?
What other secrets and clues are still hidden by the vast forest in the most remote areas of
the Appalachian Mountains? And finally, will we ever fully know what happened to the moon-eyed
people? Coming up, many people believe that the ancestors of the moon-eyed people actually still
exist in an exotic and mysterious race of people who are hidden in a small section of the remote
mountains on the Tennessee-Virginia state line known as the Melungeons. Give someone you love
the gift of old-fashioned storytelling. Four books for the young and old alike that will make your
heart smile. Click the link below to order your copy of the Appalachian Storyteller today. A
mysterious race of people known as the Lost Tribe of Appalachia that has baffled historians and
scientists for hundreds of years. Who were they? How did they get here? And more importantly,
where did they go? Coming up, the true untold story of the Melungeons, Appalachia's Lost Tribe.
They were Melungeons, oh Melungeons, Hancock County, Tennessee. One of the wildest and most
beautiful places in Appalachia. Even today, there aren't any railroads or interstates,
and there are only a handful of narrow, twisting two-lane state highways meandering through this
remote area. For centuries, only the heartiest of souls called these mountains home, and among them
were perhaps the most mysterious race of people in America, the Melungeons. For the most part,
their population was clustered atop Newman's Ridge in places like Snake Holler, Mulberry Gap,
Blackwater Creek, and other remote areas just across the state line in Virginia.
They weren't black or white or Native American. Their unique physical appearance consisted of
dark, wavy hair with European features such as dark or gray eyes and thin noses and a unique
bump on the back of their head. To this very day, no one knows exactly where this exotic race of
people came from or how they got in these mountains. Historically, Melungeons kept to
themselves, living separate from both Native Americans and whites, and they never participated
in any of the wars that these two populations waged against one another. Because of their
isolation, their existence went largely unnoticed in Appalachia until the late 1800s. Yet, there
were clues of their existence much earlier. For example, in the late 1600s, French explorers
reported finding men who weren't Indian or white in the mountain pockets of modern-day Tennessee.
And during the formation of the lost state of Franklin, John Sevier was next to write about
them in the 1780s when he noted that there was a colony of dark-skinned, reddish-brown complexion
people, supposed to be of Moorish descent, living in the mountains of East Tennessee,
who called themselves Melungeons and claimed to be of Portuguese descent. And by 1795,
even the census listed 300 free, non-white persons living in the mountains of East Tennessee,
and since there had never been slaves or more than 50 blacks living in this area at the time,
these 300 free, non-white persons were apparently the first government acknowledgement of the
existence of Melungeons. And by the late 1800s, that number had increased to over 700 people.
And that's when the existence of this mysterious race began to appear in newspapers all across
America, attracting the curiosity of countless historians and scientists who descended on East
Tennessee and Virginia to investigate the Melungeons. Some speculated that they were
descendants of shipwrecked Portuguese sailors, while others claimed that they were lost colonists
from the Outer Banks. Other researchers claimed that they were a mixed race of Indian and African
and even Mediterranean. Wild theories emerged, stating that the origins of this race began when
Hernando de Soto traveled through these mountains in 1540, while others contended that they might be
the ancestors of Captain Juan Pardo, who brought an army of 125 Spanish men to the mountains in
1567, and that those men likely married with Native Americans. But perhaps the most spectacular
theory were that they were actually Phoenicians who fled the ancient city of Carthage after the
Romans conquered them in 146 BC. As fascinating as each theory was, the question still remained,
who were these people, and how did they get here? Coming up next, we explore each of these theories,
separating myth from reality, and examine new possibilities that may hold the key
to unlocking the mystery of the Melungeons.
Melungeons
Perhaps one of the most fascinating theories surrounding Melungeon ancestry takes place
in the ancient city of Carthage in 200 BC, on the banks of the Mediterranean Sea,
and was part of the Phoenician Empire. Carthage was one of the largest metropolises in the world
during this time, and with one of the most powerful armies and navies. However, the Roman
Empire was spreading, and soon, they set out to take control of Carthage, and this resulted in
the Punic Wars that raged for over 40 years and caused countless casualties. Before Rome finally
conquered Carthage, now under Roman rule, many people from Carthage fled to Morocco and immigrated
across the Straits of Gibraltar before settling in the coastal region of Portugal, where they
intermarried and were known as the Moors. Shakespeare himself made these refugees immortal
in his celebrated play, The Moor of Venice. These were the same people who had fought the Romans so
bravely and heroically. Eventually, a considerable number of these people crossed the Atlantic,
where their ship was marooned off the coast of South Carolina, near the North Carolina Line.
However, as soon as they arrived, they were rejected by the white people, who refused to
associate with them on equal terms or allow their children to go to school with them due to the
unusual color of their skin. Because of this, these newcomers to America migrated further
and further inland before crossing to the western side of the Appalachian Mountains,
settling in eastern Tennessee.
Another theory is that the Melungeons were actually survivors from the Lost Roanoke Colony.
In 1585, Sir Walter Raleigh made an attempt to establish the first permanent English settlement
in North America. It was a daring attempt to settle on Roanoke Island in the Outer Banks,
off the coast of North Carolina with 120 settlers. But you see, this new world was
fraught with dangers, and they quickly realized that they would need much more food and supplies.
Thus, the mothership returned to England to replenish with promises to return as soon as
possible. However, it wouldn't land on Roanoke Island again until five years later, when it found
the colony's fortified fort completely abandoned. The 120 people, they had all disappeared.
The only clue that remained was the word Croatia, carved into a tree.
Did the settlers assimilate with the Croatian Indians, who modern-day researchers claim were
already of mixed blood, containing both Spanish and Portuguese blood? Are these people the
ancestors to the Melungeons? Still, others claim that Melungeons are, in fact, descended from the
Spanish explorer Hernando de Soto, who brought an army of 600 men, along with 100 women servants.
In 1540, when they navigated the Nolchucky, the French Broad, and the Little Tennessee Rivers,
deep into East Tennessee, looking for gold, copper, silver, and freshwater pearls.
Now, de Soto drove his army deeper and deeper into East Tennessee, engaging in many battles
with the natives that cost the lives of nearly half of his men. De Soto himself would end up
dying from a fever he contracted in his foreign land, and it's theorized that many of his troops
defected in Appalachia and intermarried with natives, and were, in fact, the true ancestors
of the Melungeons. One final theory happened 20 years later, in the 1560s, when Spanish explorer
Juan Pardo led several expeditions with 120 men through modern-day South and North Carolina.
He built several forts along his route as he sought to establish trading relations
with the Native Americans. One of the forts that he built was on the French Broad River
in East Tennessee. Yet, most of his men were killed in a brutal attack from the natives in 1568,
and those who survived the attack were left behind as they fled into the mountains.
Many researchers claim that these people were the forerunners to the Melungeons. However,
they arrived. By the year 1900, the 700 Melungeons living on Newman's Ridge looked like no other
people living in America, and they had distinctly Mediterranean characteristics. They fiercely
contended that they were descended from Portuguese bloodlines, and some old-timers during the 1800s
claimed that they were here long before the whites arrived. Officially, the state of Tennessee
classified them as free persons of color, which limited their land rights and perhaps explains
why they were concentrated on Newman's Ridge where there was little fertile soil.
For the next few decades, sensational stories ran in newspapers all over America concerning
the Melungeons. Then, in the 1930s, something strange started happening. Their numbers
began decreasing. With new opportunities provided by public education, new generations began making
the steep climb down Newman's Ridge and intermarrying with other races, starting lives in faraway places.
Suddenly, by the 1960s, all of the Melungeons with Mediterranean characteristics were gone
and now were replaced with a melting pot of mixed races. Newspapers across America documented the
disappearance of Appalachia's lost tribe. The Melungeons' notoriety suddenly vanished and became
an obscure footnote in East Tennessee until the early 2000s when sites like Ancestry.com
and other DNA databases became popular. Suddenly, it became a badge of honor to claim Melungeon
heritage with tens of thousands of people claiming Melungeon blood, and by 2010, the first attempts
at large-scale DNA testing were carried out by genetic testing companies. There have been
several studies since 2011, and all of the results indicated a melting pot of genetic makeup, with
some Melungeons having African heritage and others having Native American and even more having
European ancestry. These results have led to more questions than answers. That alone brings into
question the accuracy of Ancestry DNA testing. And the question still remains, just who were the
Melungeons? Indeed, the Appalachian Mountains are one of the oldest mountain ranges on planet Earth,
so old that they even predate the age of Saturn's rings. The vast wilderness that stretches from
Alabama to Canada is home to countless mysteries, folklore, and legend that even science is still
trying to explain. From mysterious storms of fallen flesh and snakes to prehistoric legends
of the Moonite people, these mountains may forever hold stories that may never be solved.
What about you, my friend? What do you think could possibly explain these stories?
I look forward to your comments below. Thanks so much for watching,
and be sure to like and subscribe for more true stories from Appalachia's past.
