Delegated Legislation - English Legal System.

History of Law
11 followers
#education #law #learning
The Law Academy is a project designed to provide legal education for students studying law in the UK. Subscribe for more content.
A. Gillespie & S. Weare, The English Legal System (Oxford University Press, 2021).
E. Allbon & S. Kaur-Dua, English Legal System (Pearson 2020).
Disclaimer:
At no point are these video lessons intended to provide any sort of legal advice. These are for educational purposes only!
Image(s) Copyright: This Photo by Unknown Author is licensed under CC BY-SA
Welcome back everybody to our study of the English legal system. In this lesson we are moving away
from talking about primary legislation, which is the way in which law is made within Westminster,
and now moving on to talking about delegated legislation, which is slightly different
and exists in a number of different forms. We're not going to spend too much time focusing on
delegated legislation because I want to get to looking at the idea of judicial precedent and
the way the courts operate in England and Wales instead. So ultimately, the previous lesson,
as I mentioned, examined the process of passing what we describe as primary legislation. This is
law that is passed by Parliament. So a bill goes through Parliament, it goes through the various
stages, the first reading, second reading, committee stage, report stage, third reading,
goes to the House of Lords, then it goes to Royal Assent, and then it becomes law,
it becomes primary legislation. This lesson is talking about the making of, and the different
types of, what is described as delegated legislation. Now the first question you should
be asking, if you don't know what delegated legislation is, is what is delegated legislation?
Ultimately, a piece of delegated legislation is the process by which law is made, not by Parliament,
but by a particular individual or organisation on the basis of authority which is granted to them
by Parliament, by a piece of primary legislation. So sometimes Parliament can pass law that is
going to, that allows for the institution or organisation which it regulates to make legislation,
to make law, to make rules relating to that particular issue in that area. Within this
relationship, you see that primary legislation is sometimes referred to as the enabling legislation,
because what it does is it enables the delegated legislation to exist, it also enables those who
are in the process of creating primary, sorry, secondary legislation, to be able to create said
secondary legislation, secondary delegated legislation. Now ultimately, we can identify
three main types of delegated legislation when we think about how lawmaking works in England and
Wales. We can talk about orders in council, we can talk about statutory instruments, and we can
talk about what are things known as bylaws. Okay, let's do them one at a time. So the first question
is what is an order in council, or what are orders in council? Orders in council are made by the
Privy Council. The Privy Council is made up of the Prime Minister and other higher authorities
within government, so other members of the Cabinet, usually very high senior civil servants, and given
the fact that the Privy Council forms part of the government, what happens here is we see the use
of orders in council for the government to be able to pass laws without the express consent of
Parliament. So it is almost like a something of a workaround when it comes to the passing of policy
and the passing of legislation. It is not expressed because there is still influence on Parliament
here with the passing of what is known as enabling legislation. So an order in council
is the ability for the Privy Council to make the law in certain circumstances, and these certain
circumstances are limited and regulated by Parliament by the enabling legislation. So you
might be thinking straight away, well isn't this surely a violation of Parliamentary sovereignty,
or maybe a workaround of a democratic mandate that Parliament has to hold the government to
account if the government can just pass law, delegated legislation, through the Privy Council?
Well the answer to that question is of course no, because even though it goes through the Privy
Council and under the authorities of government, it is still regulated by a number of pieces of
legislation that is passed by Parliament, so the enabling legislation. So for example we have the
Civil Contingencies Act of 2004, that is the enabling legislation, that is the primary legislation
that is passed by Parliament that allows for the Privy Council to make law in a state of emergency.
So this is an order in council for the Privy Council to make a make law in a state of emergency.
You might think well surely that violates and goes around Parliament. No, because it is regulated by
the Civil Contingencies Act of 2004. Statutory instruments are laws and rules which are created
by specific government ministers under a particular policy field. So they are authorised to do this
under the remit of a particular piece of primary legislation. So again this is delegated in the
sense that it is enabled by the primary legislation that is given, but it is giving
government ministers the ability to create secondary legislation.
Now some of the reasons why this is so useful is because there's lots of regulation that may take
place that may require reform or lawmaking be done in a quite quick and simple manner,
and that doesn't necessarily require the full process of passing a piece of primary legislation
through Parliament and getting Royal Assent, because that is a long and lengthy costly
and and quite heavily time intensive process. A good example of a statutory instrument is the
Ministry for Justice making changes to the Police Codes of Practice under the Police and Criminal
Evidence Act. So under PACE there is the allowance for the Ministry of Justice to be able to create
and make changes to what is known as the Police Codes of Practice. There are quite a few Police
Codes of Practice actually, and for those of you who want to have a bit more information about
police powers and the Police and Criminal Evidence Act, we're going to get on to that when we look
at public law in more detail in the future. But you can see here that the Police Codes of Practice
can be changed and they can be reformed, and new Police Codes of Practice can be introduced
under a specific government ministry, under the Ministry of Justice, and this is all enabled by
the primary legislation, the legislation which is PACE, the Police and Criminal Evidence Act.
So essentially what these codes of practice do is form part of the particular policy
of policing guidelines ultimately. Finally then we have bylaws. A bylaw is simply a type of
law that can be made by local authorities and local councils. So often there's lots of regulation and
different things that can be done at a very, very local level by local councils that would
make sense to be made by Parliament at the central government level. So for example,
given the localised nature of bylaws, you can see the kinds of relatively menial interests that they
protect and that they regulate. So things like parking restrictions or cycle lanes, these are
going to be obviously regulated by the council. You don't expect a cycle lane to be introduced
in a leafy green village by Parliament itself, and that's why bylaws are so important. And again,
they are still also regulated, councils are regulated by Parliament and they are subjected
to and subordinate to Parliament, and so the legislation that allows for bylaws to be created
by local councils is the enabling legislation which creates the secondary legislation which
are bylaws themselves.
