Editor Charles Kesler hails the arrival of the Spring 2026 issue with Associate Editor Spencer Klavan. The issue, which went to press just after war broke out in Iran, features Charles's editor's note about Reagan's Cold War strategy and Trump's high-stakes new venture in the Middle East. Can he avoid recycling past mistakes? Elsewhere in the pages, the New Criterion’s Sam Schneider kicks off a new wine column, uncorking the favorite drinks of the founders. Plus, Harvey Mansfield and the realignment of the Ivies in Ralph Hancock's review; the rise of competing, renegade academies in Spencer's; Michael Anton on the Left’s misinterpretation of the Right—and more!
Chapters 00:00 Introductions 01:29 Iran War Predictions 10:02 The Founders on Wine 15:17 Harvey Mansfield and the Ivies 24:07 The Renegade Academy 31:02 Michael Anton and the Right 31:54 Closing Remarks
Hello and welcome once again to the Close Read, your official Claremont Review of Books podcast.
I'm your host, Spencer Clavin, Associate Editor of the Claremont Review of Books,
and we are introducing the Spring 2026 issue, which we've done a little previewing of on this
show, but now is our official rollout. I'm going to hold it up even for the camera,
and not just because I'm on the cover, but because we have cameras now, so we can
make these things visible. But I am joined, as ever, when we introduce a new issue
by the man himself, Editor Charles Kessler. Charles, it's nice to see you again.
Good to see you, Spencer, and to hear you simultaneously. It's almost like reality.
It's the wonder of the modern world. Yes,
eventually we'll get to a place where we can be in the same location, but that's far away. We'll
make our way back around to embodied presence.
We need to have a CRB event in Nashville, I think. That would be fun.
I'm all for it. Absolutely. I'll host.
That's a good idea and a nice offer. I appreciate that.
Although I think we should probably have it at a Honky Tonk bar if we really want to do...
Well, it will end up there. It doesn't have to begin there.
That's right.
Scott Yenor, with his piece on country music, will take us there over time.
Well, this is our first issue since the GALA double issue. It's got a number of things to
talk about, but I think maybe we can start with the war in Iran, which broke out just before we
went to press. So we thought a little bit that we might be up a creek because when we're going
to press, we already have all our pieces. But then you, Charles, came to the rescue with your
editor's note, we win, they lose, citing Ronald Reagan's objective in the Cold War and proposing,
I think, that Trump should adopt it as is in this war. But do you want to say a little bit
more about that and also how you think the war has been going since then?
Well, so the war had just begun, essentially, when we were ready to put this issue to bed.
So I didn't have much time to predict what the war was going to be since the war was
beginning and ending at the same time, according to the president.
And so we did the best we could. And Chris Caldwell, fortunately, had a book review
about tangential to the issues of war and touching on the issues of war. So we ended up, I think, with
two piquant approaches to the question of war in general and the Iran war in particular,
but not so much because it had just begun. And so there was not much you could really
say about it. What I said in my piece, which, as you say, takes off from Ronald Reagan's famous
remark to one of his advisors who had asked him what his goal in the Cold War was going to be
if he became president. And Reagan said, essentially, it's simple. We win, they lose.
Which was a very succinct and refreshing account of our national goals,
which recalled similar moments and sentiments in American history, but not so many lately,
not so many in the 20th century or the young 21st century. It needed to be said at the time,
even though it seems obvious it was not. Yes. I mean, Trump had run against the so-called
forever wars in both 2016 and 2020 and 2024, come to think of it. But that was clever politics,
but not useful geostrategically, I would say, because none of the wars,
none of our recent wars have been forever wars. I mean, Afghanistan was a frustrating
and a failed conflict from our point of view, but it was over in 20 years,
which, as wars go, is not that long. And Iraq, although also a very unsatisfying experience
historically for us, was over in eight years. Our involvement in it was over in about eight years.
So that's a very short forever. And the real problem with these recent wars has not been
that they lasted forever, but that there was a related issue, which is that they had no
clear idea of victory, of how to win in their minds. And so they tended to drift and just
continue and get no closer to an end, no closer to a victory that has a victorious end.
And it's that disorder, that failure of strategy that made Mr. Trump and his movement
turn against them so comprehensively. And I certainly share that criticism. I mean,
neither the Afghanistan war nor the Iraq war were strategically thought through
or prosecuted by arraying all of our means towards that end of victory. And that, however,
is, I think, the way Trump has thought of this new war, the Iran war, that we need to win it,
and that we need to win it decisively and clearly. My complaint, I guess, going in is that
though he didn't want to do this, he ended up promising victory easily and quickly.
And whether it was four or five weeks, he said several times, is how long this war was going
to last. Occasionally he said, we want it in the first day, or we want it in the first 10 minutes.
I mean, he had some very peremptory formulations about this war, which I don't think is
strategically or morally really wise. It started to feel a little bit like four weeks to flatten
the crescent for a bit there, you know, like the COVID kind of. And you sort of answered the
question that I was going to ask, which is, do we perceive these wars as forever wars because we've
lost our threshold, our tolerance for war in the modern world? Or is it more about
the kind of amorphous dissipation, the weird way that these wars seem to drag on? And
you point out that Trump has taken great care not to make this war or to signal that this war will
have a decisive and swift end. I mean, I guess it's too soon to say whether that will be true or
not. Yeah. I mean, early on, if you recall, his goal was unconditional surrender.
And, you know, not ours, I mean, the Iranians, unconditional surrender. And, you know,
that too was very bold. I mean, a war which accepts no stopping point except the unconditional
surrender of the enemy is almost inherently going to be a tough war. And it may not be long,
but it could be quite bloody in order to get the enemy to the point of unconditional surrender.
I mean, not only losing, but admitting to themselves that they had lost.
And unfortunately, we haven't gotten there. We're, I don't think, much closer to an
unconditional surrender from Iran than we were, you know, two months ago when the war began.
Right. Well, it seems as if perhaps there was some hope, maybe not on Trump's part, but
surrounding the war that there would be a corresponding uprising from the people or
even the return of the Shah. And since that has not materialized, I would imagine,
I have no knowledge of this, that there's conversation going on behind the scenes in
the Trump administration about what would look more reasonable as an expectation,
opening the Strait of Hormuz, for instance, you know, you can sort of envision a number of them.
Yeah, you are channeling, I think, Angelo Cotevilla in this piece, and he's kind of
been our guiding light, even in absentia on matters of foreign policy. But we should turn,
I think, to some of the other pieces in this issue, because life goes on while the war proceeds,
and there's a bunch of other good stuff in here that people will be interested in.
We've got Chris Flannery on his long-awaited, long-promised banner essay on John Quincy
Adams, his various speeches for the 4th of July. We've got a few things coming up for
the 250th anniversary down the road, but this is sort of, I think, a taster of that and actually
related to what we've been discussing, because Adams is a great guiding light as well for
foreign policy, although with a longer historical view. No, that's right. And by the way,
I didn't realize until Christopher Caldwell, our beloved colleague, told us in one of our
editorial meetings last month, I guess, that John Quincy Adams is pronounced with a Z,
Quin-zee. Quin-zee, yes. I learned that from Chris's piece. Yeah, I don't know about the
piece. I heard it from him in this meeting. But the family seat of the Adamses is in Quin-zee,
Massachusetts, which I didn't realize was pronounced that way. But now I do,
and I feel so much better. Yes, I know. It's a real enlightenment. Most importantly,
with knowledge like this, one can feel superior to others who don't know it.
Yes, exactly. That's right. For very little effort. But an embarrassment of riches,
I think we should make special mention of our new regular, Sam Schneider, who writes for us about
the copious amounts of alcohol that the founders drank during the revolution and even after.
This is going to be a regular feature, no? Am I right in thinking that we're confirmed?
The CRB used to have a kind of lifestyle feature, which we called cum dignitate otium,
a phrase that Cicero used, leisure with dignity. But we gave up on that feature
at some point along the way when we ran out of leisure, I guess. But we're bringing it back,
at least temporarily, under that title for Sam Schneider, who works at the New Criterion
and at Encounter Books, I guess, and is a swell editor there, who is going to be our wine
writer, our wine columnist. I'm not sure we've decided on the name of the series
that he's going to be pursuing, but there will be more after this first one. But this inaugural
essay was quite fun. It was terrific. And Sam knows a lot about wine. But what impressed me
was that he was able to combine that knowledge of wine with an article about the founders,
the American founders, and what wines they drank and enjoyed, and how they got them,
and where they got them from. And it was quite a charming and even edifying performance,
I thought. So I'm looking forward to many more. Absolutely. He gives us a list at the end of
wines that we can get that are, if not identical, then at least analogous to
the Madeiras that they drank. Or Descendants, at least, some of them, yeah. Right, right,
exactly. There's the problem, I guess, of, is it Noble Rot? No, it's Phylloxera Vastatrix that has
kind of ruined a lot of the European crop. Makes it hard to get the exact images. They saved their
American roots, I believe, is what happened. And if so, it's sort of like the idea of NATO,
I guess. Or maybe NATO was about grafting our tops onto their roots. I'm not sure. But anyway,
yes, yes. And St. Paul has a whole metaphor about how the Christian church is, I think, a stalk.
It's a tree grafted onto the tree of Jesse. So this goes way back. So that's a great piece.
For me, it was the sheer quantity that just really made me feel better about myself. Speaking of
reassuring oneself about one's dignity, I thought, well, if the founders of our country were
knocking back whole casks of Madeira, then I can't be doing too badly. But let us talk for a bit
about this new book by Harvey Mansfield, because we've got a review by Ralph Hancock of Harvey
Mansfield's book on rational control. And this, of course, the great Harvey Mansfield of Harvard,
their kind of last remaining conservative, now that Jim Hankins has left. He's the last man
standing. And Hancock recounts how he himself was sort of led down the garden path, the primrose
path, to conservatism by some of Mansfield's lectures. He's been there for a long, long time.
And this is a summary, I think, or a write up, I guess, of the class that he teaches,
the kind of introductory class that he teaches on political philosophy, which you took,
Charles, am I right? Yes, Ralph and I were
graduate students together at Harvard. We overlapped. I think he's one year ahead of me.
And we, Harvard has two introductory courses in the history of political philosophy,
ancients and medievals on the one hand, moderns on the other. And Harvey would teach both of them
in alternating years with Judith Sklar, who in the in-between year would handle the assignment
alongside Michael Walzer. So they were more on the left, although they certainly weren't identical
in their politics, but similar. And Harvey would, every other year, run the whole show.
In the fall, he would teach ancients and medievals, in the spring, moderns.
And so this course, which was, it used to be numbered Gov 106B. I don't know why,
because, well, 106, I don't know why B, because it's the sequel to A. Somehow along the way,
Harvard changed its numerology. And instead of 106B, it became 1060,
1060. Or as I said to Mansfield, it must have gotten, you know, 10 times better
than it was when it was just 106. Now it's 1060. But it was a great course. For many people,
it was almost a life-changing course. Ralph Hancock, in his review, talks about coming back
from the very first, the opening lecture in the course, and saying to his wife, like, wow,
I've never heard anything like that before. And, you know, I'm looking forward now. My life is
going to be different and richer and so forth from here on out. And so he was just the right
one to do this review, because he remembered with gratitude and clarity what Harvey was capable of
and what he had done, you know, many years, many times over the 60 years he taught at Harvard.
You know, that in itself is remarkable. Harvey is 94 today, but he retired at 91.
I think the idea of retiring at 91 is so attractive to me as I get older. I don't know.
It's enviable. Absolutely. I always think of Jacques Barzun, who wrote his wonderful
book, From Dawn to Decadence, a history of modernity in the West. And I think he was in
his 90s when he, I think it was in his early 90s when he wrote that book. And it's a triumphant,
I mean, it's very, very appealing. And I think it makes one feel warmly about
the intellectual professions that don't wear out the body, you know, at age 30, like we're not
star athletes. We can hope to be working in our dotage. But there's a great line in this piece
by Hancock from Mark Blitz, another student of Harvey Mansfield, that the pace of his jokes
in lectures was like having a hundred Sandy Koufax fastballs aimed directly at your head.
I'm not sure that sounds like a pleasant experience necessarily, but
yeah, it sounds really rich. And it has been making me realize, you know,
I'm doing some teaching now myself, and one of my fellow professors at the University of
Austin, Texas is a Straussian, and I really admire his teaching as well. And we talk a lot
about Straussianism at CRV. Of course, we are in some ways descended from Strauss via Jaffa.
And I think one of the questions I get asked probably more often than any other is what,
can you explain what Straussianism is to me? Because it's this very sort of like amorphous.
And now after reading this piece and after doing some teaching, I usually say what it
is first and foremost is it's a lineage of teaching. It's a way of passing down a kind of
devotion to texts in real time, which is cool to have kind of this tribute to that.
But Harvey has also gotten some great press recently for kind of taking Harvard to task,
which is interesting and very much of a piece with the moment, you know, the Ivies are undergoing.
I think it was Yale that recently had a soul-searching report about, you know,
bias among the professoriate. And do you have any, does this give you hope as yourself a member of
the academy that there's a kind of about-face going on, or do you think it's kind of too little,
too late? Well, we'll see. Harvard is a hard case. On the one hand, I never thought that
if Harvard ever had a black woman president, and it has, Claudine Gay,
but I never thought if they had such a president that they would ever discharge her, you know,
they would never fire her or accept her resignation. And they did. And that was to
me a very dramatic and unanticipated development because it really, she stepped down partly because
of the anti-Semitism crisis at Harvard, as at many other schools after the October 7th,
you know, Gaza attack into Israel. She didn't handle that well, or the questions about it
before the House committee. And, but then she was also accused of plagiarism in her dissertation,
which was, which was a dissertation that Harvey had not read. He was not on the committee,
but he was there in the Harvard government department when that dissertation was given
the best dissertation award for the year. I did not know that. That's a tidbit about that episode.
I had not realized. There's a little more egg on Harvard's face, I'm afraid, as a result of that.
But this is all just by way of saying that Harvard is a hard case. And Harvard has its
share of billionaires, you know, not as many, I'm sure as Stanford probably has, but some of them,
a few of them are conservative. So it's not hopeless that Harvard would get, you know,
some real money to fund a, you know, a viewpoint diversity or some kind of conservative program
in Cambridge. They have not done it yet. They've only talked about it and even
desultorily have they talked about it. So we'll see if anything comes of it, but I'm, you know,
I'm cautiously hopeful, maybe. Certainly Harvey was alone almost for a long time as, as the only
recognizable or the only out of the closet conservative at Harvard. I mean, Hankins was
there too, but he was not as, James Hankins was not as well-known as Harvey for being a
conservative, I think. Yes. Well, I don't think, yeah, he seems to have kind of made his views
more known as he realized how rare they were. In part, actually, I think it was through writing
for CRB. We started publishing James Hankins a while back before he was as prominent as he is
now. He wrote a piece for us on hyper-partisanship and began sort of stretching his legs in the more,
I guess, public facing journals rather than just the academic stuff. And so that's an interesting,
we can, I think, take some small credit for discovering Jim Hankins in that way. And
of course he was a major player in his field before that, but he's now, this is also a theme,
I guess, of this issue because my piece is a review of his joint venture with Alan Gelso,
formerly at Princeton, also a CRB contributor. And this is this big two-volume history of Western
civilization, the golden thread. And kind of the theme of the essay is that people like Hankins
and Gelso and even, you know, if there's a younger Harvey Mansfield out there, a successor to him,
they're kind of having to find their way outside the Ivies and outside the prestigious institutions.
And I can see, I guess, two different ways that that could go. Two different positive outcomes
from this renegade academy, as I'm calling it. One would be that the renegade academy itself
sort of acquires all this prestige and becomes a place that can rival these ancient institutions.
And so places like the Hamilton School in Florida, where Hankins and Gelso now teach, will
kind of rise up. UATX, where I teach. The alternative, though, would be, I guess, that
these places become so popular and attract such good students that the traditional academy has
to kind of take note and adjust to compete. In other words, if you want to get good students,
you have to stop just bashing the classics constantly. And as you say, we'll see. I mean,
neither one of those could happen. The whole thing could crash and burn and then we could
be left without any sort of viable academy. But those are all on my mind as possibilities.
So Spencer is referring to the cover story in the Spring Claremont Review, which is his piece
called The Renegade Academy, as he mentioned. It's a terrific piece. These two volumes that
he's referring to, one by James Hankins and the other by James Hankins' close friend and our close
friend, Mr. Gelso, Alan Gelso. This is a two-volume, and I understand, well-illustrated
history of the West, you know, which is, there aren't that many histories of the West these
days which are admiring. And this is admiring and, I mean, critical in some ways, of course,
but appreciative of the overall accomplishments and aspirations of the West. Anything you want
to tell us about these two volumes before people rush out and buy them and start reading them?
Oh, thanks for asking. Yes, they are very beautiful. I have them here next to me,
and I would hold them up for the camera, but they're so heavy that I think I would probably
pull a muscle or dislocate it, slip a disc. I remember back when I started writing at CRB,
I mentioned to Bill Voegeli, our wonderful colleague and senior editor, that I was writing
a piece on Shakespeare. And he said, in his wonderful Bill Voegeli way, pro or con?
You could say of histories of Western civilization, now you have to ask when somebody
says, yes, a two-volume history of the West, pro or con? And although, as you indicate,
this is not a hagiography, it doesn't sweep difficult moments under the rug. They're very,
very fine-grained treatments of slavery and a number of other atrocities. Nevertheless,
in the main, on balance, Gelso and Hankins are pro the West. And I think that makes this
distinctive in the current climate, which is odd to say. But because the Mainline Academy has become
so hostile to the idea of the West or the celebration of the West, I sort of suspect
that this poem will become a cornerstone of this alternative curriculum. In other words, I can
imagine this book being assigned in survey courses and serving as a kind of marker for
schools or courses that take a more traditional approach. And it really does deserve that,
because part of the problem is that our scholars are not in favor of the West. The other part is
that sometimes people are full of goodwill toward the West, but simply don't have the scholarly
chops to perform such a vast project. And Hankins and Gelso both, I think, are on side and also
extraordinarily skilled. So yeah, it was an honor to review the piece, or to review the books,
rather. And I hope, yeah, that people will not just read this essay, but go and acquire
these books, which are well, well worth the investment.
Yes. And both volumes are published by Encounter Books, the aforementioned
Encounter Books. So keep that in mind for your Christmas presents, your Hanukkah presents, your
end-of-the-year lists, all you readers out there.
This is a perfect present for a graduating high school senior.
Yes.
If you know somebody who's graduating in May, which is very soon, this is the thing to get them
as they go, wherever they go off afterward. I'm being told by our producer, Ryan Gannon,
who runs my life, that we need to wrap this up. We should once more, I think,
hold up the Spring 2026 CRB. There's lots more in it that we haven't mentioned. There's Mike
Antons.
We didn't get to all the highlights of this issue, but we direct your attention to them.
It's the kind of issue that John Quincy Adams would enjoy reading, I think, and we should
mention Michael Antons' piece defending the Claremont School and himself and me and others
against the attacks of Laura Field, who has written a book on the new right in America,
the Trump right, and it's a very curious screed and Anton has fun refuting it and
arguing against it. So I highly recommend that.
And other things, Dan Mahoney on Mark Blitz's new book on Aristotle. It's a rich, rich issue.
Yes. Vintage Mahoney on Blitz on Aristotle, I think, a really good introduction to
Aristotle himself, as well as a review of Blitz's book.
All right. Well, thank you, Spencer.
Yeah, my pleasure. Thanks, Charles. And I will just tell our listeners once more to
go to ClaremontReviewOfBooks.com to get this latest issue if they haven't
already got it in their inbox.
Or go to your neighborhood newsstand if you are lucky enough to have a neighborhood newsstand.
And we are proud still to be writing and printing in paper,
so you can go find us in three dimensions.
Oh, yes, very definitely.