How Parliament Makes Law - English Legal System.

History of Law
11 followers
#education #law #learning
The Law Academy is a project designed to provide legal education for students studying law in the UK. Subscribe for more content.
A. Gillespie & S. Weare, The English Legal System (Oxford University Press, 2021).
E. Allbon & S. Kaur-Dua, English Legal System (Pearson 2020).
Disclaimer:
At no point are these video lessons intended to provide any sort of legal advice. These are for educational purposes only!
Image(s) Copyright: This Photo by Unknown Author is licensed under CC BY-SA
In this lesson what we're going to do is explain the parliamentary process for passing legislation.
This is going to be relatively short because it is something of an easy concept to understand
within the English legal system, so we're not going to spend too much time on it. Ultimately
this is just the various stages that a bill will go through before it receives royal assent and
becomes a piece of legislation. We looked in the previous lesson at the ways in which the
legislation will actually begin its life as a bill. The types of bills that are introduced,
things like private members bills, public versus private bills and also hybrid bills.
This lesson we're going to talk about how those bills then go through the various stages of the
parliamentary process to become law, to become legislation and receive royal assent from the
monarch. So let's begin then with the first of these issues. Let's just think about the various
stages of parliamentary lawmaking in their generality. Let's just think about them in their
sort of general form. So the parliamentary lawmaking process takes place in a number of stages
as you would probably imagine. There is a first reading, there is a second reading, the legislation
then goes to what is known as a committee stage which is then taken to the report stage, a third
reading and then it goes to the next chamber. Remember we have a bicameral legislature in
Westminster in the United Kingdom and this means that there are two chambers and so we go from the
House of Commons to the House of Lords and then finally once it goes through the same stages in
the House of Lords then we see that it receives royal assent. So let's think about what each of
these stages means one at a time. Let's look at what each of the things that are required at each
stage, the relative amount of debate and formalities that take place at each stage etc etc.
So the first reading of the bill is simply a very formal procedure of reading out the bill to the
House of Commons. There is no room for debate, there is no room for deliberation on the bill at this
stage nor is there even a vote which takes place. So every single bill that is introduced
that is that is going to go through the process will receive a first reading and there will be
no vote on whether or not to take the bill any further and that takes place in further readings.
What does happen at the first reading stage however is there will be a declaration of
compatibility made. So not only will the bill be read but it will also be made clear that the
seen to be compatible with the Human Rights Act. This is part of the legislation of the Human
Rights Act and it is a requirement for legislation to essentially adhere to the Human Rights Act.
We then go to the second reading. This is where there is a lot more debate and discussion on the
bill where this takes place. The aim of the second reading is not to necessarily get bogged down
within the specific details of potential legislation rather and instead it is to focus on
the intent of the bill itself. So talking about more the broader overarching themes of the
legislation, the passing of the legislation rather than necessarily focusing on the detailed
specificities of the bill itself. That's what the second reading exists to do. At the end of the
second reading there will also be a vote on whether or not to take the bill to the next stage.
So this is the first part where we start to see the various different votes being taken place on
the bill itself. This will either be done verbally by the Speaker. If there is no objection then at
which point the bill will go to the next stage. If it is not clear that there is an indication
of support for the bill then the Speaker will declare division and a formal vote will take
place. This is where there will be two lobbies. The MPs will walk either through one lobby or the
other lobby depending on whether or not they support or oppose the bill and then we get the
vote on it. If the bill passes the second reading, if it passes this vote stage, then it
will go to the committee stage which is the third element of the legislative process. This is where
the finer details of the bill are discussed and debated. A committee will consist of a selection
of Members of Parliament. Now this is supposed to roughly match the composition of the House of
Commons. So if for example, as we have today, we have a Conservative government and we have quite a
sizable Labour opposition with some other smaller parties involved as well. Given that this is the
case, a committee will consist mostly of Conservative MPs with a percentage of Labour, Liberal Democrat,
SNP etc. So to be fair, the way in which the percentage of MPs, depending on which party,
sits in the House of Commons will depend on the consistency of the committee itself.
Here, this is where a number of various amendments will be made to the legislation
and then they will be voted on in the committee in question. So the committee stages are far more
detailed and nuanced stage of the process. This is where some more of the finer details are
discussed and proposed and reformed and amended and ultimately we get a more refined version of
the bill following the committee stage. Stage four then is the report stage. If there is a number of
amendments or any amendment that is made to the bill in the committee stage, then it will go back
to the House of Commons and be reported back to the House of Commons as part of the report stage.
The House of Commons will then be able to debate those amendments and vote on whether or
not they ought to be accepted or rejected. If there are no amendments during the committee stage,
if no changes are made during the committee stage, then there will be no need for a report stage.
So there wouldn't be a report stage if there are no amendments or changes that are made to
the committee at the committee stage. Finally then we have the third reading of the bill.
This is also simply a formality process. This is just where we see the final vote on the bill.
It is unlikely that you will ever see a bill fail at this stage because if it has gone through the
second reading and the committee stage and it has gone through the report stage and it has
garnered the support of the majority of Members of Parliament, then at this point the bill is
unlikely going to fail. There's unlikely going to be a change of heart from a number of MPs at
this point, but sometimes this can happen. When this takes place and we go through the third
reading and the piece of legislation, or the bill should I say, passes through the third reading,
it then gets sent to the House of Lords. Once passed through the Commons it goes to the House
of Lords where it will go through the same process. It will go through a number of reading
processes, it will go through a committee process, a report stage and a third reading.
Where the Lords has made amendments to the bill it will get sent back to the House of Commons for
approval. So the House of Lords cannot make amendments to the bill and then push it through
to Royal Assent. Any amendments or changes that are made in the House of Lords has to go back to
the House of Commons to be voted on by the democratically elected Members of Parliament.
Sometimes there will be a back and forth that takes place where there are various amendments
that are made by the Lords that goes back to the Commons, that goes back to the Lords again,
and this is a process known as ping-ponging. But assuming that it passes through all of these
stages, it goes back to the Commons, the Commons approves of the amendments or overrules the House
of Lords if they don't approve of the amendments, and it goes all the way through to the final stage
we get the point of Royal Assent. This is again another formal process, a formality, where the
monarch will give Royal Assent to create the legislation, to turn the bill into law. Now
ever since the Royal Assent Act of 1967, the monarch doesn't even get to read the legislation,
they get the title of the legislation and they get told to sign it or to give their
assent. So this goes to show just how much of a formality this process is, they don't even read
or consider the legislation itself. The last time a monarch refused Royal Assent was Queen Anne in
1707, so this is just again a relatively useless formal process, and so at which point the
legislation becomes law. Now if there is no specific time in which the legislation is set to
enter into force, so for example the Human Rights Act was passed in 1998 but it was set to enter
into force in 2000, if that doesn't exist then it will be said to enter into force at midnight
on the day of receiving Royal Assent, so essentially the day after receiving Royal Assent.
That is the process by which a bill goes through Parliament and is created into law.
