Chicago’s Oldest Mexican Restaurant vs the New School!

Chicago Cuisine
3 followers
Okay so in this video today we're doing Mexican food. I'm back in Chicago to take care of some
unfinished business. Last time I was here I was exploring some of the cities I kind of eat
including the very spot where deep dish pizza was invented. But here's the twist the same person who
gave Chicago deep dish also started the city's oldest Mexican restaurant and is still standing
strong since the 1960s. And you know me so when I heard that I couldn't just let it slide like
I had to circle back. So today I'm putting on my stretchy pants Nacho Libre style and
I'm diving into three Mexican spots to prove that Chicago's food scene isn't just about pizza.
First up Su Casa. Founded in 1963 basically the grandparent of Chicago's Mexican food scene
this spot is often credited as the oldest Mexican restaurant in the city.
Now some would say it leans more as tech specs but let's clear it up. Ike Sewell's vision for
Su Casa was to bring Chicago an authentic elevated Mexican dining experience. Now here's the crazy
part before Ike invented deep dish pizza in 1943 the very thing Chicago is world famous for he
actually wanted to open a Mexican restaurant first. Meaning if history had gone just a little
differently deep dish pizza might have never existed. That's right Su Casa nearly Thanos
snapped deep dish out of Chicago's food scene. In 1963 Ike finally circled back to his original dream
he took an old 1800s carriage house and gave it a second life and he turned it into Su Casa
which has since become a landmark of its own serving traditional Mexican plates for over six
decades. Walking into this place feels like stepping into a time capsule except this one
all right let's head into the kitchen and see what's cooking. So we're going to start off with
steak chimichurri tacos. First of all this is Cheque. Cheque is our main cook. Cheque how you
doing? The man behind all the magic back here. So we use flank marinated homemade um home marinated
flank. Throw that on the grill really quick. And stop eating steak well done. That smells really
good. Awesome that's delicious man. All right steak chimichurri tacos. Putting these jumbos.
Have you had any customers touch the pan anyway? Yeah by accident they realize it's hot really
quick. Yeah there we go. And here comes the main event and let me tell you this table just turned
into a fiesta. The steak chimichurri tacos you know I'm a sucker for chimichurri and the
combo fajitas with the street corn. The fajitas are sizzling louder than my neighbors on the 4th
of July. And if you don't end up making a little mess on your shirt you're doing it wrong. And then
the heavyweight champion of the night the mojete with the pork. This thing shows up in a stone bowl
the size of my baby's bathtub. Sewcastle really lives up to the name because after this spread
I don't know if I should grab a fork or apply for residency. One thing's for sure you're not
leaving here hungry or quiet because you'll be telling everybody you know about it. Now let's
head to the next stop. Next up we're in the south loop at La Catina. Holding it down since 2006.
And let's be clear yes they've got tacos but these aren't your basic three dollar Tuesday tacos.
These are the kind of tacos that make you stop mid-bite and look at the tortilla and whisper
where have you been all my life. But the real flex is their lineup of traditional Mexican cooking.
We're talking enchiladas, nachos, fajitas and then the menu hits you with the signature plates.
These plates were so elevated I had to do a double take just to make sure I wasn't sitting
inside of a five-star spot. Honestly half the menu I couldn't even pronounce. Oh wait I'm doing an
al pastor. I don't know now. It's easy to see why La Catina is a south loop favorite. It's not just
dinner here it's an experience. Now excuse me while I grab a seat and see what else the menu
has. You have like a uh a platter that has like all the tacos on it. All right then let's do the uh
the steak taco, fish taco. So I got a fish steak and what else did you hit you say uh pork
pineapple. Oh okay. Two hours later. Okay I want to do one of the pineapple. Definitely
I want to do a pineapple. That what is that four right now? I have three. Let's do two pineapple
and the fish and al pastor. Yeah that's what I'm gonna do. And uh is this hot spicy or just mild?
Like a medium? Okay for me that's a 10. Oh the green stuff salsa verde. All right well thank
you. I appreciate it. All right so here's how my taco journey went down. First up the steak taco.
Juicy. Favorable. Basically the taco equivalent of a good handshake. Firm. Confident. Gets your
attention right away. Then I went for not one but two al pastor with pineapple tacos. Because let's
be real. One is just a warm-up. That smoky pork sweet pineapple combo. It's like a salsa dance
party happening in my mouth. And finally I ended it with the fish taco. Light. Crispy. Refreshing.
Honestly if you eat them in that order you might question why you eat tacos in any other way.
And now our final stop La Calle. Tacos and tequila. This place is the new kid on the block.
But it's already strutting around like it owns the playground. The decor is all black and white.
Sleek. Modern. So sharp it looks like it was ripped straight out of a graphic novel.
I had to get a peep behind the curtain to see how they do it. This place is a family affair and you
can see it in action. The whole crew is in here moving with this incredible rhythm like a culinary
dance. You can literally smell the years of tradition and passion simmering in every pot.
It's not just a meal. It's a story told through fire and flames. But as far as this restaurant
specifically it's called La Calle meaning the street. So everything is going to originate from
the street food from Mexico City. Right. So from the vision of the outside we got the white walls,
black letters, old English. Right. Keeping it really traditional. Keeping it really modern.
So when we think about traditional Mexican food right we have the tacos, the tortas, the burritos,
the elotes, all that. Also when it comes to Chicago I mean we're a big drink in town. So we had to
offer the drinks. But not only do we have to offer the drinks we have to do it in an authentic way.
Andrew walked me through that vision revealing how every design choice was a deliberate step
toward bringing the authentic and electric energy of Mexico City to the heart of Chicago.
Also grassroots from Chicago and also Mexico City. Tuesday more like taco Tuesday.
It was finally time to dig in. Now I'm just hoping the tacos can live up to the expectations that I
set in my mind. Now to get things started it's time to get this lime and get them all dressed up.
Now it's time for the main event. I tried one of each taco. Steak, ground beef, and chicken.
Plus their famous elote corn in the cup. While all the fillings were fantastic it was the corn
tortillas that put these tacos over the top. They were some of the best I've ever had.
And for a pro tip try adding some of the delicious elote corn to your taco. It's a game changer.
This place just opened with the level of attention to detail you can truly taste the difference.
And that's a wrap for our taco tour. We started with the legend,
hit up a fan favorite, and ended with a place that's just getting started.
One thing's for sure whether it's a hundred year old recipe
or a brand new creation Chicago's taco game is strong. Now if you excuse me I think I need a nap
and maybe another taco. Now if you like the video click that like and subscribe button and also
share it. Until next time see you in the next video. I think so too. I'm videoing.
Yeah yeah.
