We saw many tracks of the white bear of enormous size along the river and shore
and the men as well as ourselves are anxious to meet one of these bear. The
Indians give a very formidable account of the strength and ferocity of this
animal which they never dared to attack but in parties of six, eight, or ten
and even then frequently defeated with the loss of one or more of their party.
One of the party running towards us and making signs of hollering as if in distress
had shot a brown bear which immediately turned on him and pursued him a considerable distance.
These bear being so hard to dive rather intimidates us all. These white or grizzly bear
have become so troublesome to us that I do not think it prudent to send out one man alone on an
errand of any kind particularly when he has to pass through the brush. The hand of providence
has been most wonderfully in favor of us with respect to these bear or some of us would have
long ago have fallen a sacrifice to their ferocity. So back in 1804 when Lewis and Clark crossed this
country in this area that we're in today they encountered dozens of grizzly bears across the
landscape. We believe that there may have been as many as 50,000 grizzly bears in the western
half of North America in the 1850s before Europeans really started to settle the west.
When the European Americans started to settle the west they brought with them livestock and
agriculture and mining and a lot of different activities that they just felt grizzly bears
were incompatible with and so there really was generally an attitude of trying to eradicate
them because they didn't think that they were compatible with the lifestyle that they wanted to
live. The main cause for grizzly bear decline during that time was that just like many other
large predators they were being targeted for removal. So by the early 1900s the grizzly bear
population had significantly decreased in the lower 48 states. At the turn of the century people's
attitudes towards wildlife really began to change. They started to appreciate having wildlife and
understanding the value of having biodiversity on the landscape is really important for having a
healthy intact ecosystem. They were realizing that bears and other wildlife weren't an infinite
resource and that they they could indeed eradicate species if they weren't protected.
There were many steps taken in the early 1900s to protect our wildlife resources and to bring up our
wildlife populations. It was the beginning of the Lacey Act. The Fish and Game Agencies started
so they started regulatory mechanisms to control how many animals could be or couldn't be hunted
and also started taking a close look at habitat and trying to protect that habitat. Your national
park system started coming online. A lot of independent groups started up. That combined
with federal and state agencies coming online was really the beginning of trying to reverse
the effects that happened during the early 1800s and mid-1800s. Yeah the Lacey Act was put in place
to control the trade of wildlife species so that wildlife couldn't be hunted to be sold in other
states. During the the late 1800s early 1900s and into modern day the North American model for
wildlife conservation was being developed and at the very core the principle is that the wildlife
is held in public trust instead of being owned by a monarch. So even early on when actions were taken
to protect fish and wildlife populations some populations were still struggling and even on
the brink of extinction. This led to the Endangered Species Act being adopted in 1973. The Endangered
Species Act works to protect plants and animals that are threatened or endangered by working to
conserve the species and also protect its habitat. The Endangered Species Act is meant to be a step
wise process. It is meant to take a hard look at a species determine if or when it needs additional
protections then provide that species those protections. During that process the Fish and
Wildlife Service works with partners state agencies to determine the recovery criteria
that must be met in order to declare recovery and remove that animal from the list and turn
it back over to state management. ESA also comes with a fail safe at the end of it. It's an agreement
between the Fish and Wildlife Service and the state agencies to monitor that population to ensure that
success remains into the future. So there there were two main reasons grizzly bears were listed
as threatened under the Endangered Species Act. One was having to do with them dying from interacting
with people so that could be in the form of getting into conflicts with people. These were
back in the days when we fed bears at garbage dumps and so there there were too many bears
dying and then there was a loss of habitat. Yellowstone was a place where people went to
view all sorts of wildlife including bears and they were fed constantly by people. There was no
prohibition towards that. The dumps in Yellowstone they were just open pit dumps and along with just
public feeding wildlife and bears they realized that was a bad thing and so they closed down the
dumps and all these bears then were that were used to this food resource they were both habituated
and food conditioned and they became serious threats. There were a lot of human injuries,
many human deaths, a lot of property damage and a lot of bears were killed as a result of that.
Well they killed so many bears they realized because all this human activity this population
is now threatened and so they were put on the Endangered Species List I believe in 1975 or 76.
When the bears were listed in in 1975 under the Endangered Species Act as a threatened species
the population size was maybe 800 bears in the whole lower 48 and their range had been reduced
to about two percent of what the range was back in historic times and the places that they still
existed were places that were protected because they were either national parks or they were very
large remote areas that bears could still exist in. The Endangered Species Act essentially creates
a plan for recovery of a species that is threatened or endangered. The U.S. Fish and
Wildlife Service is in charge of the recovery program but within that there are many different
people and agencies that are working towards recovery so that could be the Forest Service,
Montana Fish, Wildlife and Parks in our case, tribal governments and others as well so it's
a network of agencies that are working together to recover the species. The parameters put in place
to recover the grizzly bear population under the ESA said okay we need to identify a population
in this case the Yellowstone grizzly bear population and we need to put committees and
people in place which in our case is Interagency Grizzly Bear Study Team and the Yellowstone
Ecosystem Subcommittee basically incorporates all the states including Yellowstone National Park,
Grand Teton National Park, Idaho, Montana, Wyoming to all get together and they outlined
a recovery plan that was written for the grizzly bear and it outlined population parameters,
monitoring requirements to ensure that the population is one recovered past this
brink of extinction and secondly that any threats that cause that population to become
in peril in the first place no longer exist. The Fish and Wildlife Service has ultimate
jurisdiction over the management of the grizzly bear in the Yellowstone Ecosystem but every
individual landowner, producer, anybody that has a garbage can that lives in grizzly bear country
runs livestock, the Forest Service, BLM, all the land management agencies involved but in the
Yellowstone Ecosystem the Wyoming Game and Fish Department has been the major player in the
recovery of grizzly bears in the Yellowstone Ecosystem. Everybody is responsible for the
recovery of the grizzly bear and that includes not only agencies but the public because in order
for grizzly bears to exist on the landscape long term everybody has to play a role in that and that
comes with tolerance and tolerance is everything when it comes to recovering any species specifically
animals that are big and cover ground and so yeah I'd say everybody is responsible for it.
In order for grizzly bears to be recovered in each of the ecosystems where they are listed
there are different recovery goals so the goals differ from one ecosystem to another but they have
to do with the size of the population reproduction and the presence of the animals on the landscape.
There are six grizzly bear recovery zones in the lower 48 states. They are the Yellowstone,
Northern Continental Divide, Bitterroot, North Cascades, Selkirk and Cabinet Yak ecosystems.
Of those ecosystems grizzly bears have fully recovered in the Yellowstone and Northern
Continental Divide ecosystems. They are still working towards recovery in the Selkirk and Cabinet
Yak ecosystems and there are currently no grizzly bear populations in the North Cascades or Bitterroot
ecosystems. The recovery plan set aside certain criteria to recover grizzly bears.
The easy way to describe it is a minimum population of bears reproducing females across
the entire recovery zone and then reducing human cause mortality. That's the basic criteria for the
recovery plan. I think in many ways the primary factor that we had to overcome to recover grizzly
bear populations is to limit the amount of human cause mortality and the ways that we went about
trying to do that included both habitat protection and population protection. We protected habitat by
reducing human access into some of the areas because where we have high road densities you
tend to see lower bear survival and that can reduce their chances for long-term persistence.
We put in food storage orders on public lands all over to make sure that people were keeping
their attractants away from bears and reducing that kind of conflict and then of course more
recently as the bears have expanded into more human areas we're really doing conflict prevention
and conflict response to try to reduce human cause mortality from that as well.
So it has been said that wildlife managers spend a lot more time managing human wildlife conflicts
than actually managing the populations of the animals and that is so true. Whether it's elk,
urban deer or grizzly bears you work so hard at minimizing conflict. Instead of being proactive
and trying to actually manage the long-term coexistence of people and bears we're so
reactive to managing conflicts and we spend an inordinate amount of time doing that.
We'll never be completely rid of human bear conflicts because the place where humans and
wildlife intersect has grown so there's just more need than ever to provide education and
information about living with wildlife and about bears and tools we are using to reduce conflict
are definitely information, education and outreach, helping distribute tools and resources like bear
spray, teaching people how to use bear spray, showing people how to use electric fencing and
providing technical support there. Also bear resistant containers are a huge part of conflict
reduction work so all of those things together contribute greatly to the reduction of human bear
conflicts. But we don't carry that burden alone we also rely on the public and other non-profit
organizations. It's up to all of us collectively and it's something that can't be forced it has
to come from the individuals it has to come from the communities for it to be successful so we're
all in it together. The Tribal Wildlife Management Program fills the role of mediator between people
and grizzly bears. They were here before us on the landscape and so we as tribal people act as
stewards for wildlife and we do live in a very different world today working with the people
that live on the landscape the residents of the Mission Valley of the Flathead Indian Reservation.
We really work to get ahead of conflict and try to kill the conflict and not the carnivores.
We also consult with landowners that have attractants such as chickens, goats, small
livestock, pigs, llamas or orchards. I mean I understand both perspectives the the conflict
issue you know I understand why a landowner may not want to have an electric fence in their backyard
where their children are running around but I also know through research that you know you're
essentially flipping a coin every night in the Mission Valley as to whether or not your chicken
coop or your small livestock gets attacked by a grizzly bear and so I understand the importance of
using these preventative tools but I also understand that there are real world reasons
to not want to have some of these mitigation measures on your property. So there's some basic
tenets about living in bear country and reducing conflicts has to do with assuming first that bears
could be anywhere so some ways we can reduce conflicts with bears out recreating are to
make a lot of noise when you're on the trail yelling to let them know you're coming so that
they don't get surprised. Being in groups of other people will also help reduce conflict because the
bears will hear you coming and avoid conflict typically. So those two things are huge just by
themselves avoid carcasses of large animals avoid dawn and dusk and for hunters proper game storage
so getting your animal out of the woods as quickly as possible having a plan and then no matter who
you are it's really important to carry bear spray and know how to use it so that if you do have a
bear encounter you you can stop it or you can change the bear's behavior. It's very effective
about 92 percent effective at changing behavior 98 percent of people who use it are not harmed
by the bear. I was working as a grizzly bear technician up in Libby Montana and I was by
myself I was up in the Cabinet Mountains and it was the middle of May I was collecting hair off
of barbed wires and bears do a lot of rubbing so they'll come along and they'll rub on the corral
and that collects the hair or DNA just like people try to build that you know family tree and see
who's connected. I was making a ton of noise I was clapping my hands I had a pack on and I had bear
spray right here on my chest and I got into this semi-open avalanche chute and all of a sudden I
heard a and I turned to my left and they measured it he was about 11 or 12 feet for me literally on
my left side. I immediately knew he was a grizzly bear I just turned to the right I dropped down to
the ground I was in that fetal position so legs to the side on my butt he had already got on me he
was on my back he had clawed up my arm and clawed up my back his entire body was on top of me and I
was just hunched over just slowly trying to work out that bear spray and I got it out I took off
the cap and he reached down he bit down on my skull and I reached over and sprayed him with
the bear spray and he took off. It was very much a defensive mechanism so he did not know what I was
he was very focused so it turns out that he was digging up glacier lily bulbs he was flipping
over rocks he was very focused and bears do that when they're hungry they get focused and they're
just zoning in so they're not always listening that's why it's so important to make a lot of
noise and so his encounter with me was very much defensive he just he was defending his area
typically all bears will run away but if you get close enough you surprise them like I did with
the bear that I encountered or you have a female with cubs or if they're guarding a food source
that's when those defensive mechanisms really kick in folks have been bluff charged too right
that's another defensive mechanism so that's giving you another warning that says hey you got
to back off so we really try to get folks to focus on behavior and to read that bear and what that
bear's doing because not every situation is going to be like mine either you could surprise a bear
from 100 yards away you could surprise them from right there I mean they could see you and just
bolt off and not do any warning right so we really try to educate and and focus like I said on that
behavior and having us read their behavior and where they're at there's definitely things that
I encourage folks to do right and that's practicing with bear spray and definitely knowing how to use
it your goal is to hit that bear in the face hit him at the feet it builds up a cloud and then
lastly is to carry two cans of bear spray I hiked myself out so I had an in reach with me I hit the
sos button but I didn't know how long it was going to be and I had nothing I barely had anything in
my can and so just having that extra can would have been super super nice I mean I made it back
the biggest takeaway would be that bear spray works bear spray is it's a great tool to use
it really saved my life and while it doesn't sound like it you know he cracked open three
quarters of my skull and I mean the minute I sprayed him he was gone and that whole interaction
was done you know I lost all my hearing in my left ear so when he bit down on my skull and
it was immediately was ringing and was gone when I came out of the hospital yeah I was mad because
I was six months I had to be I couldn't work they had to shave my head you know I lost all my hair
which was super upsetting and of course after I you know I went from hiking like crazy to doing
nothing I could barely make it up my own driveway and so that was very tough for me I mean numbers
wise grizzly bears killing cattle in the state of Wyoming that's our biggest conflict it's more
than just grizzly bear killing a cow up on public land there's a lot more to it well ranching in
today's world is tough anyways on any level and when you add in an apex predator like the grizzly
bear it makes it even more tough a big grizzly bear in this country you know is four to five
pounds a 600 pound bear is huge and they can take down a 12 1500 pound cow
they're nothing to be messed with or taken lightly they're a formidable force
when I do lose cows and calves to bears we have our range riders that are up there they get a call
into the game and fish predator guy and then he comes up and looks at it and and if he does confirm
it as a bear kill we are in the state of Wyoming where it states statute that the Wyoming game and
fish does pay us back for any losses due to trophy game animals yeah verified losses the
grizzly bears this year was up it was kind of a record year not necessarily a record we want to
go for but we had 91 confirmed grizzly bear kills in our allotment alone and three wolf kills
confirmed in a typical year we end the season with around 80 confirmed bear kills by grazing
up there I'm going to come home at least 10 percent of my calf crop gone so the losses are
way beyond just financial and physical losses it's a financially unstable situation I've seen a change
in the grizzly bear numbers just in the 15 years I've been here I used to see one bear a year and
then it's gradually gotten to where I was up there this summer every other week or so or if not every
week and we always either found a kill or saw a bear except for three trips grizzly bears been
listed since 1975 the grizzly bear generationally has lost all fear of man whatsoever and respect
of man because of that we have sows with cubs that are on their third fourth generation fifth
generation that have been raising beef eaters we've had sheep herders get attacked by bears
grizzly bears and so you don't ever go up there completely calm you literally are just bear aware
every time you're up there and all the time you're up there and you either have your bear spring or
your pistol on you at all times we just need to get the bear down to manageable numbers by example
when the when the wolf got unlisted and the state of Wyoming took over management of the wolf we saw
our wolf depredation numbers drop drastically and the wolves are still there we're ranching
with the wolves up there but we've got them at a manageable level I think if the state of Wyoming
can take over management of the bear and get the numbers where they belong we can all live more
successfully with the bear the conservation of a species is completely different than the
preservation of a species you know it's kind of cool still to see the grizzly bear in its natural
system me personally and most of us within the association don't want the bear gone
we just want the bear managed there is no better lifestyle in my mind than ranching
but on the same token you feel a little bit of despair and distrust because uh yeah it's not a
easy situation to be up there feeding them to the bears you know livestock producers that I deal with
in Wyoming are fantastic they're just good hard-working folks and making a living and they
take good care of the land because they rely on it you know for their future these folks also own a
huge chunk of land and it produces and sustains all kinds of wildlife everything from trumpeter
swans to bald eagles to Wyoming toads and other endangered species and other harvestable renewable
resources like antelope deer and elk and the fisheries resource and they provide a lot of
public access whether it's fishing hunting other sorts of recreation on their private land that's
mostly what we're paying for that the public gets to enjoy what is that worth I don't know if you
can put a price tag on that so you're not just paying for their loss of their calf to a grizzly
bear you're paying for them to continue to run their business and own this land to sustain all
that wildlife into perpetuity for wildlife in general a good compensation program is is necessary
it's it's a good thing to do it's good it's good for everybody not just the producers
in conjunction with that you know a few bears when they become a chronic depredator to livestock we
remove them from the population is the removal of a few select individuals worth of preservation
and the long-term tolerance of grizzly bears and all wildlife
into the future so that's the bigger picture with livestock depredation
it seems like we used to call the mountains here the high country and a lot more people are now
calling it grizzly country anything that has to do with recreating in the back country
or even the front country nowadays you've got to be bear aware
grizzly bears have changed the way that we outfit and guide from when I first started
which is 1985 we really didn't worry about grizzlies we knew they were there but they
were not nearly as prevalent as they are today one of the things I wish folks would understand
about working and and living in grizzly bear habitat is every single bear you see is not
automatically dangerous I think that that has been a grave injustice to the bear is they've
gotten this this image of being immediately dangerous yes they can be but not every single
one is and I think there are probably some bears that have been killed because of the way people
think and that has come from this hype that every single bear the second they see is going to rip
your head off but when you'll have a serious encounter with a bear either you're going to
scare them or you're taking something away that they think is theirs the scaring part you just
pay attention make noise have a partner the taking away something they think is theirs is why
we try and get our animals off the mountain as soon as possible so we don't give them an opportunity
to claim it but as far as that goes I mean 99 of them don't want anything to do with you
hey bear hey bear hey bear get and if people would understand that I think you'd see a lot less
situations x escalate into a conflict situation one of the biggest detriments to the recovery of
the bear has been the misinformation that has been put out there by the wildlife activist groups
there are some of those groups I feel that have hijacked the endangered species act to their own
game they put out the word the grizzly bear is on the brink of extinction and if we allow one of
them to be killed we're going to be tipping it over and and they spread that word to the
misinformed majority and I don't think grizzly bears should be managed politically I don't think
they should be managed from the bench Wyoming Idaho Montana they all have super great wildlife managers
and we need to let them do their job the reason that we have the populations we have in these
states is because of state management we've got a population that is succeeding we've got a
population that's exceeding where they can live comfortably and so they're being pushed out into
places with where they really shouldn't be when my second child was just starting school they put a
bear fence around the playground should we have to worry when our kids walk to school should we have
to worry when we go out in the morning to feed the chickens when you start having to worry about
what you do in your own backyard something's got to change it's not the bear's fault there
in the situation they're in it's the mismanagement that has been going on for years but I think in
the in the back country where they belong they are a cool part of the ecosystem grizzly bear recovery
has been a conservation success because the populations of grizzly bears in the Yellowstone
and Northern Continental Divide populations are doing really well and the recovery goals have
been met for the greater Yellowstone ecosystem for quite some time once we've worked to reduce
threats to bears and help their population grow how do we know they are recovered there are specific
criteria like having an even distribution of females with cubs across the recovery zone but
real evidence is continued population growth continued expansion and evidence the population
growth has slowed and bears are competing more with one another as their density reaches the
upper limit simply put there is a limit to how many bears might fit in these core areas and
we are reaching it the grizzly bear recovery has been a conservation success story and I believe
that that story happened a decade ago I believe that the numbers have rebounded to the point
that you have a sustainable population that can be managed by state agencies into the future
and also the amount of range expansion that has occurred with the grizzly bears you know you see
bears now where 20 years ago they never thought they'd see bears with that amount of range
expansion the core population has to be doing well to provide these dispersing individuals that
move into these areas where truly I don't believe many people thought they would be seeing bears
my parents bought a small ranch a mile and a half two miles from the Glacier Park border
and to my knowledge up until 20 years ago I never ever saw a grizzly bear on that property
I don't ever see them going back the way they were when I was a kid where they were just back
in the mountains because my son was up there riding just west of there yesterday and saw three
grizzlies they're omnivores so they like grain they like alfalfa they like carcasses they like
everything and there's lots of it so one of the biggest reasons bears cause problems
around people is because there's food having a cattle operation is you're going to have some
natural death loss of your animals either from old age or sickness or pregnancies that didn't
go right there's always just going to be death loss in a cattle herd and so traditionally ranchers
just throw all those dead animals in a pit on a remote part of their ranch and but the problem
with grizzlies expanding back out is those bears are then attracted to those bone pits where all
these dead animals are and when they start concentrating on these dead animals then that
gives them a chance to come around humans or homes or they start running into live animals which they
then can attack and kill and so we're heading out right now to clean up a bone pit and that
will help prevent bears from being drawn in close to people and livestock these bone pits where
people have been hauling carcasses for decades and decades and it hasn't been a problem because
there was no grizzly bears right but now that the grizzly bears are expanding out as an unintended
consequence of successful recovery then it's becoming an issue because bears are being drawn
near houses being drawn coming up from the river exactly and you can see some houses right there
it's got to cause them some problems sure does these folks here had uh 40 chickens killed by
a bear this year and that bear was probably just passing through to come to the dining buffet here
yeah success always comes with challenges and managing grizzly bears is no exception
when you have a tremendous abundance of grizzly bears for example when you have 12 grizzly bears
in one small cornfield 50 miles outside of the recovery zone for grizzly bears that's a problem
that's an issue that's it's obviously successful recovery but that is challenges that we have to
face on a daily basis now there's no doubt in my mind whatsoever that the grizzly bear is
biologically recovered we've met all the recovery goals set forth and exceeded those recovery goals
for over 20 years every scientist in the world knows without a doubt that the grizzly bear
population in the yellowstone ecosystem is recovered the only reason they're not recovered
is on paper because of lawsuits and it's contrary to what the purpose of the Endangered Species Act
was to help states and jurisdictions recover species to a healthy point where they can then
be managed by the states and we're there but unfortunately now some folks are using the
Endangered Species Act as a legal crux to fight delisting species that again are biologically
recovered if people would understand the reasoning behind our management decisions
become educated in why we're doing what we're doing then we'd all be better off we're the
experts but a lot of folks are resistant to hear from an expert so if you want to know about bears
and wildlife management there's a whole host of experts across the west that have been managing
these bears studying them for years and that's the information that we're trying to convey to folks
so education is the key to getting that information out so they better understand
why we're making the management decisions that we are so i wish people would understand how much
time and effort it takes to manage grizzly bears it is no easy thing and we have a lot of staff
dedicated to doing that it's not fortune and glory as much as people think but spend a lot
of time in the dirt dealing with day-to-day conflicts and doing preventative measures and
all that and it's 24 hours a day seven days a week every single year the reality of managing
grizzly bears is quite different than the than the movie version a lot of the common misconceptions
is that there's some vacuum that we operate in that we do everything and nobody knows what we're
doing everybody knows what we're doing we work with all agencies at the same time whether it's
fish and wildlife service the national park service the blm the forest service our own state
agencies other state agencies we are constantly in contact also the public and what we do in regards
to grizzly bear management not only from a preventative standpoint but also from a management
standpoint as well our jobs as grizzly bear managers we have to balance grizzly bear existence
on the landscape with human existence on the landscape our number one priority is human safety
while also maintaining for a viable population of grizzly bears the truth is is that you know
the grizzly bears were recovered in 2003 they've been delisted twice in the yellowstone ecosystem
bears are populating new areas bears are moving out into new areas that where folks aren't
necessarily used to having specifically grizzly bears and so here are some things you can do
to work towards coexisting with bears if they do show up in that area and that's everything from
securing attractants to livestock practices to how to recreate in bear country and the state's
worked really hard on promoting that information and education if we're not actively dealing with
a grizzly conflict the rest of our time is spent promoting how to be preventative and how to coexist
with grizzly bears and also what are the danger and lookout situations that people should be aware
of so that they do call us ahead of time instead of sometimes when it's too late so social tolerance
is just the number of animals that people find acceptable or tolerable in a particular area
social tolerance can vary wildly and in ways you might not expect depending on the community that
you're speaking about and their livelihoods there was a survey done in montana people's
attitudes about grizzly bears and almost everyone in the survey which was representative of the state
believed that grizzly bears were an important part of montana's natural heritage and so most people
believe grizzly bears belong here but their feelings vary depending on how close they live
to grizzly bears most people don't want them in their literal backyards but most people agree
on the value that grizzly bears should be allowed to live here so social tolerance of grizzly bears
based on the number of animals that they see in a given area is really unique it depends on your
perspective those folks that want to view and photograph and enjoy grizzly bears they want to
see them all the time and if they don't they believe that there's a failure in the system
and there's not enough grizzly bears but then there's folks that are out there recreating
they're out there fishing hiking hunting they don't want to be bumping into grizzly bears
all the time they don't and if they see more than one there's too many so it's a wide perspective
and the problem with grizzly bear management it's not just about grizzly bears no matter how they
feel about grizzly bears i think it's it's very safe to say people are unhappy with the government
one side or the other and so whether there's too many or not enough grizzly bears it's just another
reason to be angry with the government and criticize them so it's never just about grizzly
bears it there's a much bigger picture black bears grizzly bears they don't always work and
play well with others they can be a difficult species to coexist with people that's not to
say that they're not willing to live in and amongst us because bears are truly opportunistic
omnivores they will take advantage of any food source and it's the reason they can be so successful
even in human dominated landscapes but the opposite might not be true predators are subject
to a social caring capacity much more so than our ungulate species and that's certainly more true
with grizzly bears than than any other predator when the cost associated with them living up close
and personal in your neighborhood or community gets to be too high then they don't enjoy that
same social caring capacity that's a pretty big furball to try to shove down people's throats
there's only going to be the number of predators on the landscape that the locals are going to
tolerate that doesn't mean that every homeowner every tourist every photographer gets to see a
grizzly bear when they visit those three states because they're elusive predators you shouldn't
see them all the time that's one of the biggest challenges that we see today the reaching of the
balance between two diverse groups that want more more more the other wanting wait a minute
maybe we have enough and striking that balance has been really the challenge they're back on the
landscape to a certain extent due to regulatory measures but those regulatory measures can only
take it so far you know the recovery criteria for the grizzly bear changed over time which can make
it difficult to meet that recovery criteria the initial recovery criteria was met over a decade
ago the state agencies were ready to declare it a victory i think even the fish and wildlife service
was ready to declare a victory but due to several different lawsuits that came about in the past 10
years that goal post ended up changing and they removed them from the list and then they placed
them back on the list i think it's impossible to talk about the grizzly bears recovery process
and all of the things that happened without acknowledging the role that anti-hunters have
played in it meaning they just bring additional lawsuits to keep them listed under federal
protections but the real problem in my mind is is the vulnerability of the process and the ability
of outside forces to sue to get what they want out of the process and you have a situation like
you have now meaning litigation after litigation after litigation has moved that goal post and
moved it down the road to the point where i believe you create a situation where nobody
trusts the process anymore then the process breaks down and the endangered species act can then not
work the way it was intended the grizzly bears are doing just fine but it's managing the people
the people are putting up so many roadblocks towards progressive positive common sense
grizzly bear management that's really difficult to overcome so the biggest challenges with managing
grizzly bears right now is the false perceptions surrounding grizzly bears whether that be from
people on the ground all the way to big decision makers whether it be within the fish and wildlife
service or a federal judge the amount of misinformation and how the public is negatively
influencing the decision makers because of either fear-mongering on one way or the other either
kill them all or love them all neither of which is good for wildlife management that's the challenge
is again finding that middle ground there's no perfect system but the biggest challenge is
finding that middle ground where yeah that makes common logical sense it's a good way to move
forward that's gone anymore it's very difficult to find that in a mixed group of folks again we
have these huge differing opinions and perceptions on grizzly bears but i i think the overwhelming
common ground is that people love grizzly bears they're cool i mean even all the ranchers that i
speak with that are losing cattle and their livelihood to grizzly bears they don't hate
grizzly bears they see one and they're they're in awe it's cool they're a majestic beautiful
critter and we want to see them forever we want future generations to enjoy them so there's lots
of means to that end but i think that's the common ground it's just the fact that grizzly
bears are a beautiful magnificent creature and nobody wants to see them go away and i firmly
believe that the grizzly bear will be removed from the endangered species list in the not too
distant future and then the long-term survival of the grizzly bear will be square in the management
court of the different state agencies which is where it should be and i believe that they are
accomplished enough concerned enough and conservative enough that you will have grizzly
bears into the long-term and short-term future we all know that there is a place on this planet for
grizzly bears and and despite our different perspectives and how that might look depending
on where we live and where the bears are and our livelihoods the fact that we're there debating
this the fact that we have passionate discussions and we continue to discuss and and think about
what this future looks like is a healthy sign that people are engaged and care about the future of
grizzly bears and and that gives me hope in our future as a species and and for their species as
well so i think the future of grizzly bears from a grizzly bear perspective is great they're going
to do just fine they've proven how adaptable they are and they're recovered by all sense of the word
except for on paper the future of grizzly bear management is they're going to be around for a
long time for as many generations as we can count even if people screw it up again they're going to
do just fine because they're the critter that they are so one thing i wish people would understand
about grizzly bear management is we're not out to make everybody happy we're out to manage the
population long term and sometimes that means killing bears which people don't like and
sometimes it means not killing bears which sometimes people don't like so we try to do what's
best for the population as a whole taking into account of course human safety trumps things if
a bear needs removed for that but we're not going to remove them just at every drop of the hat either
there's that middle ground that makes common sense that fits the numbers meets recovery goals
long-term management of a bear population requires both of those things to occur and just because
it's not somebody's personal desire what the ultimate outcome of of a bear management strategy
is doesn't mean that the whole system's flawed how many bears are enough the reality is that it is
inappropriate to think that you can have bear range expansion occurring in perpetuity they don't belong
everywhere they can't thrive everywhere and it's unfair to the local populations of people to
expect that and it's unfair to the bear population to expect that you can't have bear range expansion
into what they were pre-settlement because it was pre-settlement humans didn't dominate the
landscape like they do now grizzly bears are just one of those species that are that are truly meant
to live remotely they're truly meant to live in wilderness areas and it's extremely difficult to
expect the bear population and the the locals to live in close proximity to each other bears are
always going to behave like bears humans are always going to behave like humans and to expect them to
100% coexist i think is setting a table for disaster suitable habitat or unsuitable habitat
from a grizzly bear perspective there's probably very few areas that are biologically unsuitable
because again they can adapt they can find food resources they can make it work is what makes an
area unsuitable habitat is the fact that a lot of those areas that they used to occupy are now
occupied by humans and they're used by humans for livestock production housing development
different things and where bears and people coexist they will come into conflict that's a fact
and so we have a tremendous abundant huge area where grizzly bears can live a wild free life
but trying to force them into areas and think there's going to be some
long-term peaceful coexistence between people and bears is completely unrealistic we have too
many people on this planet now that's what's going on and that's not going to change and so
that's what makes habitat unsuitable for bears is because it's currently filled with people
the future challenge for managing grizzly bears and maybe even bears as a whole is the personal
philosophy out there that they shouldn't be hunted management is part of taking care of
and being good stewards of wildlife hunting those populations so that they stay within
population goals and objectives is part of that management and so it really comes down to simply
being anti-hunters versus people who believe hunting is part of management and i don't know
how to get those two groups together i believe hunting to be a crucial component to wildlife
management including grizzly bears managing grizzly bears comes with a lot of challenges
and they come from the fact that this species evokes such passion from people
its physical presence sometimes as as a species they can be hard to live around though it's
possible but also the species evokes fear and reverence and passion and all of those things
make it hard to to manage them on the ground so it evokes a lot of emotion and understandably so
but i think knowledge is the antidote to fear and the more people can understand all of the
different parts of grizzly bear management the better we can make decisions about how we want
to see wildlife management done for generations to come i really think in managing grizzly bears
and and all wildlife species and natural resources i think an important factor is for us to understand
that we are part of the environment that we are not separate from it we oftentimes want to act
like we are not part of the natural environment but we really are and i think the more we embrace
the environment that we live in and act as a part of it the better chances we have of continuing
to maintain the biodiversity that we have education is the best thing we can do but it's
hardest to measure you know how many folks do we actually reach and how many listen and
it's it's really difficult but it's some of the greatest stuff we do and that's why we spend so
much time and effort on it there's a lot of uneducated folks out there when it comes to
grizzly bears i want folks to take the time learn from the experts do some research get the facts
before you form your solid opinion about grizzly bears