InFocus featuring Dr. McDonough on Mass Healthcare

Western Massachusetts News, Weather & Sports
497 followers
May 4, 2026
22News InFocus with Patrick Berry featuring Dr. John McDonough on the 20th anniversary of Mass Healthcare.
From the 22 news plus studio,
this is 22 news in focus with Patrick Berry.
Hello everyone. And welcome to this edition of in focus.
I'm your host Pat Barry. As you can see, I'm on the road today.
I'm here in Boston. Uh, joining, joining me is Dr. John McDonough.
He is the department of health policy and management at the Harvard TH Chan
school of public, uh, public health. Uh, Dr. McDonough,
thank you so very much for joining me.
The reason I'm having this conversation with Dr. McDonough today is because,
um, not too long ago we celebrated the 20th anniversary of,
of in my terms, mass healthcare. Is that the right way to phrase it?
Massachusetts health access reform would be a little more precise. Perfect.
So your role,
and the reason I wanted to talk to you is because you were part of the planning
group, the policy group before this all happened in 2006.
Walk me up to 2006. What were the conversations that you were having?
With some of the key legislators,
both here in the state and nationally about creating health care for all?
Well, so just a little, my story, uh,
I've been in this role since 2011 between 1985 and the end of 1997,
I was a member of the Massachusetts house of representatives. Okay.
I represented Jamaica plain, Roxbury, Roslindale,
parts of Boston and fell into the joint committee on health care and massive
health policy. Generally,
Massachusetts health policy became the major focus of my 13 years in the
legislature.
I ended up as the chair of the joint committee on health care or the co-chair
of the house and the Senate co-chair. And so what's important to understand
about, um,
or one important thing to understand about chapter 58 in 2006 is that there's
at least a 20 year history before that,
that laid the key foundational elements that the Romney team was then able to
stand on. And without those foundational elements,
chapter 58 never would have happened.
So in the 20 years prior,
the work that took place over those multiple decades,
I guess my question is why,
why a, a simplified healthcare system was,
was it something that somebody saw back in the seventies or eighties that
somebody said, this is, this is screwed up.
We need to make this easier and simpler and more affordable.
So easier and more affordable for people who need to buy it.
I'm not sure I would say simpler. Okay.
A simpler was not necessarily the goal easier for consumers to be able to
find reasonable, affordable,
quality options for them. Um,
but there's a massive complications underneath it and around it that we don't
have to get into. But, you know, we have, you know,
a simpler way to do it is any country that has what's called some kind of a
single payer system where it's all financed through the government.
Government pays all the providers, you go, you get your services,
maybe you have a copay or something like that,
but the government then pays the provider. That's the simple way to do it.
In the United States,
we had that opportunity under president Truman and Congress would not agree to
do it. This is in the late 1940s.
And so instead we don't have one system. We have multiple systems.
If you're elderly or you meet the disability definition,
you can get on Medicare, all federal.
If you're low income and you qualify,
you can get on your state Medicaid program run by the state government's
finance, mostly by the feds.
If you work for an employer who offers health insurance to their workers,
then you can get on that.
If you work for a company that offers you something that you like and afford,
that's how most people get health insurance. But again,
it's thousands and thousands and thousands of individual employers making their
own decisions in their own separate little system.
Then you have what's done through the Massachusetts health connector,
which is individual coverage, sometimes referred to non group coverage,
which is available for people who don't qualify for Medicare,
Medicaid or employer coverage.
They can go to the connector and now they can find affordable options.
That was the missing piece until 2006 and seven under chapter 58.
That was the, the whole that got addressed in there.
But so we don't have one system. We have multiple systems.
I even mentioned veterans health, Indian health services,
all these other niche categories for how people get coverage.
It's a, it's a mess. It's terrible.
It's a people PhDs who don't know the system,
try to figure out their options. And they come in, they say, I have a PhD.
I have all these, I can't make any sense of this. Can you help me make sense?
And I can help them make sense. And then they go away.
You know, it's funny. I've heard the phrase multiple times.
And it's countries around planet earth.
Try and emulate the United States in a multitude of ways.
Not one of them is trying to mirror our healthcare health insurance system.
Actually South Korea attempted in the 1990s and they went down that path.
They actually mandated employers to provide coverage.
Everybody was so unhappy with it that in early in the century,
they switched to a single payer system and they're all much happier.
So of the countries that have that single payer system, are they,
is it better healthcare than the United States?
Is it simpler for the citizen to figure it out?
Is it more affordable? Yes. All of them. All of them. All of them.
All of those. And they all do it differently. They've all,
so you go to Netherlands, you go to Denmark, you go to Sweden,
you go to Norway. They all have unique homegrown versions,
but every one of them has some principles.
Number one is that everybody's covered. Everybody's part of it.
And it's basically one system that everybody fits into in different ways.
And as a result of that, they have better,
what we call population health outcomes. They have better life expectancy,
some of the blue zones, lower infant mortality, lower infant mortality,
less, less diabetes, less overweight. I mean,
they've got all kinds of advantages to us that we have not achieved here in the
US.
So do they not have the equivalent of a blue cross blue shield,
a stigma, a United healthcare? Some of them do. I'd say, for example,
the Netherlands, Germany,
and Switzerland would be the three leading examples of universal systems.
Everybody's covered, but they have private insurance plans,
but there's some key differences with them in the US.
One is that all those insurance plans under law in those countries have to be
nonprofit, but we have in the United States,
they're mostly for profit and they're answering to their stockholders and
shareholders and all of that stuff. So there's differences.
And then the other piece is that those in those systems where you have the
private insurance, it's much more tightly regulated,
much more tightly managed.
So government is in charge and there's no doubt about it.
And government managed the system are all,
when you try to reform the system here,
the first question is while you were forming Medicare or Medicaid or private
insurance,
because they're all different and they all go according to different drummers
and they follow different tunes.
And that's one of the reasons why it is so difficult to fix this system.
Because when you say to a senior citizen,
we're going to reform the system and make it better.
And then say, as long as you don't touch my Medicare, right. You know,
and there's a famous line, 1993,
94 when Bill and Hillary Clinton were trying to do national health reform,
where seniors would get up and say,
don't you let the federal government touch my Medicare?
Of course it's a federally run program.
Exactly. We are up on our first commercial break. Stay with us.
We've got plenty more to talk about.
This is 22 news in focus with Patrick Berry.
Welcome back to this edition of in focus. I'm your host, Patrick Berry,
sitting across the desk from me is Dr. John McDonough. Uh, he is a,
with the department of health policy and management at the Harvard TH Chan
school of public health. One of the integral parts of,
of creating better healthcare in Massachusetts and
really what ended up going through a number of States across,
across the country. So in the first part of this conversation,
we've talked a lot about the history. Let's fast forward to today.
So leading up to the 2006,
2007 implementation of, of, um,
redesigned healthcare here in Massachusetts, looking back,
is it what you expected 20 years later? Is it better? Is it worse?
Were there things that, that turned out better than you had planned things?
It turned out, man, not so good. We might want to fix that.
Where do we stand 20 years later?
Some things are a lot better. Okay. And some things I would say are worse,
not because of the system,
but because of other larger developments across the whole healthcare sector.
So some things that are better, uh,
we have about 300,000 people who get
health coverage through the Massachusetts health insurance connector
authority, which has been running now since 2006.
And those people have affordable coverage.
They have a choice of private health plans. Uh,
it depends on your income, how much financial help you get.
And it is there for everybody.
And these are quality products that cover all of the things that you would
expect. You need to have covered in health insurance.
So there's no skinny health insurance. There's no fake
plans. Uh, there's ghost plans. There's all kinds of things. This is,
this is, uh, um,
controlled and regulated by the connector authority,
which has a staff of people who pay close attention to everything going
on in the system. So the number of uninsured in Massachusetts,
before we started,
it was somewhere around 7% of everybody in Massachusetts didn't have health
insurance, which was below the national average at that point.
And we've gotten it down consistently since then to between two and 3%.
Oh, wow.
So there has been a serious benefit to the population of Massachusetts to have
health.
Well, and not only that, not only that, you know, look, people come and go.
Some people in between jobs or you're,
you end up in a job where you don't have health insurance.
Let's say you're starting a new business, right?
And you can't deal with paying for health insurance.
You can go to the connector and you can get coverage there.
And then if you start your business and you're of a size,
you can offer health insurance. Then you leave the connector,
or you can have your people, you know, use the connector as well. So it's,
so it's an option that's actually beneficial to people across.
So while there's like 250 to 300,000 on the connector now,
I think there's been like a million and a half people who've used it at some
point or another in the last 20 years and have
benefited from it until they didn't need it or they didn't qualify.
So in these ensuing 20 years from 2006 to 2026,
it just started here in Massachusetts. How,
how has that idea rolled out across the other 50 states?
So it's changed a little bit. So after the idea started here.
Yeah. After, after the big signing ceremony in 2006 with governor
Romney and Daniel Hall, lots of States looked at it.
And you know,
because you remember I mentioned all the foundational work that had been done,
the States that looked at it for the most part said,
it's too complicated. We're not there. We can't do it.
This idea of an individual mandate requiring people to have health
insurance,
much more controversial in many other parts of the country.
California was the state that tried most seriously in 2008 and
nine to do it themselves.
I went out there to a public hearing to testify.
They couldn't get over a disagreement between people who wanted to go the
Massachusetts way or the single payer way.
And they deadlocked and nothing, nothing happened.
But in Massachusetts,
one of the people who was most centrally involved in this process was our
late Senator Ted Kennedy. And as we were doing this,
we were in constant communication with him all the time. At that point,
by the way, I was no longer a rep.
I was running the state's healthcare advocacy organization called healthcare
parole. I was the executive director. So I had the advocate's role,
not the legislator's role at that point in,
in around 2003 to 2008.
And Kennedy was looking at what we were doing because he saw
that there might be an opportunity in 2009 and 10 with a new
president, whoever it was after George W. Bush,
to take another approach on some kind of universal coverage
law that failed under Bill and Hillary Clinton.
And so he looked at our model, our model with the connector,
with expanding our Medicaid program with an individual mandate,
with all of these things to make it work and how it got implemented
in a bipartisan way with Republicans and Democrats and stood up.
The connector went into business later in 2006,
began enrolling people in 2007. And it's been,
it's been pretty successful over those 20 years. Um,
and, uh, and Kennedy said, you know,
I think this could be a model for the nation. Okay. And he began,
he was then chairing the Senate health and labor committee and he
started a process.
And he actually in 2008 hired me to go down,
work on his staff in DC to help translate what we did in Massachusetts
to the federal environment.
And that process led to in 2010,
the passage of the affordable care act.
Some people say the affordable care act is based on Massachusetts.
That's true.
Only as it pertains to title one of that law on individual coverage,
the rest of the law, very different stuff.
Was that something that former president Obama had on his
radar radar when he entered office,
a better healthcare system for all,
or was this something Senator Kennedy persuaded president Obama to
consider? So Kennedy said, and he said it to me, he said,
when he gave,
he gave Obama a crucial endorsement in his run for president
at the end of January, 2008, early in the process,
he had a big thing with Obama himself and Caroline Kennedy.
The three of them were up there before a huge audience. And he told me,
he said, you know, I only asked Obama for one thing.
And that was, you've got to make another stab at universal health.
And he, so he felt he had a commitment.
Other people say Obama's motivation came from watching his mother and
her illness, which she passed away. But, you know,
so there was this sense that after the failure of 1993,
94,
there might be another window of opportunity in 2009.
And indeed in the election where Obama got elected,
Democrats retained control of the house and the Senate.
So they had what we call the trifecta, the white house,
the Senate and the house and a good majority.
And so they decided, Hey, this is an opportunity and we can't let this go.
Fantastic. We are up on our next commercial break.
Plenty more to talk about. Stay with us. We're back in just a minute.
This is 22 news in focus with Patrick Berry.
Welcome back folks to this edition of in focus.
I'm your host very around the road today here in Boston.
Dr. John McDonough is with me. We are talking about, uh,
the Massachusetts healthcare for all act, you know, chapter 58,
chapter 58, which, which, uh, was launched in 2006.
So we're celebrating the 20th anniversary.
As an outsider looking in,
I think one of the most fascinating facts about passing
chapter 58 was the bipartisan agreement here in
Massachusetts. We had a Republican governor, Mitt Romney,
Massachusetts. We all know as a Democrat,
primarily democratically runs a house and Senate,
but everybody got together to say,
this is the right decision for the Commonwealth residents.
This is the way forward. What was that like? I mean, you had to,
the, the bipartisan buy-in for you must've been, wow, this is amazing.
There's a story behind it. Okay. Understand actually.
So you remember I mentioned the foundational stuff that happened.
So in 2006 and seven,
we did another major reform building a new foundation of the
system. And as part of that,
we had a new arrangement with the federal government around our Medicaid
program. We got a federal waiver. And as part of that waiver,
we got,
we put most of the Medicaid enrollees into managed care insurance
plan.
And we also from the feds got an extra pot of money to use
to sustain the safety net institutions, including say,
Boston Medical Center, Cambridge Health Alliance.
And that money kept coming in year by year.
And in 2004, it was the George W. Bush administration.
And they told the state in early 2004,
that extra money you've been getting those supplemental payments.
We hope you've enjoyed them, but they're not coming back anymore.
At that point it was $385 million a year.
And so they were saying the next three year deal, it will be none of that.
So the state was looking at over a billion dollars less revenue.
And so that freaked out governor Romney freaked out
governor Senator Kennedy and the legislative leaders.
And that's when everybody came together. Okay. There was a, there was a,
and, and so as, as part of it, Kennedy and Romney went to president Bush,
George W. Bush and said, listen, don't take that money away from us.
But if you let us keep it,
we will switch it from money to institutions to buying
affordable insurance for people who don't have it.
And you president Bush can take credit for creating
universal healthcare in one state.
And the Bush administration bought into it.
But what impressed Bush most of all was seeing Romney and Kennedy together
come and make the sales pitch to them. They said, wow, this is really different.
There's something going on there. And they were right.
But so understand that it was kind of, there was a, I, I,
I say the state kind of, so we, we had the proverbial gun to their head.
We put a gun to our head and the federal government provided the bullets.
And so the notion was if we didn't have this set up ready to run
by July 1st, 2006,
we would lose the whole federal deal and all the money that they were going to
let us hold on.
So if president Bush saw this as an opportunity for him,
why didn't he look at Massachusetts and say, I've got 40,
49 other states I need to deal with. Why not roll it out,
begin to roll it out to other states?
Because by that point he was already lined up three quarters of the
way through his time in office. And so there's just, you know,
these are things you do early in your administration, not later on.
So that's where Obama took over. That's right. Right. And then,
and how long did it take the Obama administration to roll it out to more
states?
So, so he took office in January, 2009.
He signed the law 14 months later in March,
2010 and the whole law was fully
implemented in January, 2014.
So it took about three and a half years, but it was,
it was a massive change and it took,
you had to go through a whole Supreme court case where there were 20
Republican attorneys,
generals from state who were saying the whole law is unconstitutional,
got to throw it all out.
It took about two years to get that all the way to the Supreme court with their
decision and so forth. So all kinds, and, and, and the states had to set up,
you know, so we had already set up our connector,
but then 50 other states,
including DC had to do the same and it just, it took,
it took a lot of time.
So during the Obama administration, you pointed out, we had the trifecta,
we had the democratic president, democratic state for two, the first two years.
So, but were those, was that trifecta in those first few years?
Was that the ability to get this signed?
So now we fast forward to today where we have the Republican trifecta.
And it was, it was,
it was signed by Obama without a single Republican senator or house
member behind it.
Exactly. So now we fast forward to today where we have the opposite.
So what do you foresee happening with healthcare in the next five, 10 years?
Well, uh, so the, this,
the Trump administration made a big effort in 2017 to tear down the whole
law and repeal the whole thing. And they failed.
John McCain gave the famous thumbs down and that stopped that effort that,
you know, wasn't going well anyway. And, uh, so,
Trump started, you know, saying, I don't like the law. I think it's terrible,
but I'm making it work and stuff.
And when he was a candidate in 2024 revised healthcare,
he said, I'm not touching Medicare.
I'm not touching Medicaid and I'm not touching the ACA coverage.
That's what he said. He lied. He lied.
He's doing the most serious damage under his one big beautiful
bill act that he signed in the summer of 2025,
doing the most damage that's been done ever to Medicaid across the nation
and also to the affordable care act coverage.
He's taking away the subsidies that have really enabled it
to reach its full potential.
But he has promised a revised, better health plan.
He's where it falls in that usually when he does it, he says, yes,
and I'll have it out for you in two weeks. Whenever he says two weeks,
that's his mental tell that, you know, he's kidding.
He's not serious. He's never shown it.
He's got little bits and pieces,
but these bits and pieces basically try to give people what we call skinny
coverage where, yeah, you can buy coverage,
you can get insurance and maybe it'll be a little cheaper,
but then you've got these massive co-pays deductibles and
coinsurance,
this cost sharing that is financially devastating families
all over the country. And that's his answer. Unfortunately,
our time is up. Dr. McKenna a week.
You and I could talk about the insurance for the next four hours,
but I want to thank you so very much for the time we had today.
I really do appreciate having this discussion and congratulations on 20 years.
Great. Yes. Thank you. Absolutely.
This is 22 news in focus with Patrick Berry.
