After the battle of Edessa in 260, Emperor Gallienus confornted an impossible situation: his father captured by the Persians, rival generals declaring themselves emperors, and entire provinces breaking away from Roman control. The rebellions and disorder of this period were the climax of The Crisis of the Third Century and a low point in Roman imperial prestige.
But the emperor at the helm for these dark days has been misunderstood by history and painted as a failure due to his inability to stop systemic collapse. But upon further reflection, Gallienus emerges as a reformer confronting the crisis at its roots, introducing military innovations and reshaping imperial power in ways that would define the later Roman Empire.
This was the Crisis of the Third Century, one of the most dangerous periods in Roman history.
In this period of chaos and strife Rome split into competing rump states, including the so-called Gallic Empire under Postumus and it saw the rising power of Odaenathus in the East. This sudden fracture can be understood as a consequence of the complete collapse of Romanitas, the shared identity that had unified the Mediterranean world for centuries.
Drawing on political theory and historical analysis, this episode frames the crisis through deeper structural forces to look beyond individual actors as we explain why Roman emperors kept being overthrown, how military loyalty replaced civic identity and the role of ideology in holding empires together.
For more than 2,500 years, the Homeric Epics, the Iliad, and the Odyssey have occupied a unique
place in Western culture, as a fount of allusions and images, but also as a well for witty bon
mots that can be peppered into conversation whenever one wishes to illustrate their erudition.
In China, the Romance of the Three Kingdoms occupies a similar place in the popular mind
Though much more recent than the works attributed to Homer, it recounts events of the warring
states that fought to unify China during that civilization's own chaotic third century.
The novel's setting, scope, and themes of cyclical history have earned it a place at the apex of the
Chinese literary canon, and, like its Western counterparts, it has informed the worldview of
billions while making up a key pillar of the ambient cultural background that resonates
and exercises a subtle pull on thought and action, even for those who have never read it.
Like the Iliad and the Odyssey, the Romance of the Three Kingdoms, too, is full of quotable lines
that have entered popular parlance, and even some that have provoked profound reflection.
One of these selections is the novel's famous opening.
The empire, long divided, must unite. Long united, must divide. Thus it has ever been.
In these words, we grasp the theme of the novel, and the author's perspective on all of history,
that change is constant, and that no human effort can achieve a truly lasting impact.
All accomplishments will fade away, to be replaced by the deeds of those who follow us.
It's a provocative sentiment that draws a fine line between a harsh realist vision of history
and a pessimistic, even existentialist perspective. But a belief in the inevitability of decay,
change, and rebirth is of course not unique to Chinese culture, and it was one shared by
the Roman emperor Gallienus, who, in the wake of his father's shameful capture at the hands of the
Persians in 260, was immediately confronted with the necessity of reform and reinvention, as he
dealt with the potential breakup of his empire when generals and warlords rose in rebellion against
the weakened dynasty. Gallienus had reacted to the devastating news of Valerian's defeat and
capture with stoic resolve. When he learned that his father Valerian was captured,
just as that best of philosophers, it is said, exclaimed on the loss of his son,
I knew that I had begotten a mortal. So he exclaimed, I knew that my father was mortal.
But his generals did not share Gallienus's capacity for reflection, and the emperor would
watch helplessly as those he had trusted to safeguard the empire turned their backs on Rome,
and struck out to carve up personal fiefdoms. Gallienus's elevation to the position of
Sol Augustus in 260 thus coincided with the low ebb of imperial prestige,
and resulted in a self-perpetuating cycle of foreign invasion and internal usurpation
that would plague the remainder of his reign. This irresolvable dynamic not only eroded
centralized authority by trifurcating the Roman world, but it also threatened the very territorial,
institutional, and even intellectual coherence of the empire, as the tribal forces that Rome
had once so effortlessly brushed aside reaped the rewards of a divided Roman polity.
At the core of this instability lay the endemic factors of the third century crisis that had
stretched Rome to the breaking point over the past four decades. The emperor's physical absence
from contested frontiers created conditions in which regional commanders, acclaimed by their
troops in moments of military triumph or emergency, were transformed into rival claimants
to imperial power. The rise of these newly elevated figures necessarily diverted military
resources towards their suppression through another civil war, thereby dividing military
strength and exposing the frontiers to renewed incursions which only perpetuated the cycle of
crisis. So while Rome had lost many battles in recent years and had seen emperors come and go
with alarming regularity, the defeat of Valerian at Edessa represented something new. In many ways,
it was the death knell for the lingering sense of Romanitas, the unified civic, cultural, and
religious outlook that had united the Mediterranean world for hundreds of years, flowering during the
Pax Romana and reaching its zenith with the Antonine constitution of Caracalla in 212.
This ideology of Romanitas shaped the society's culture, beliefs, and values to the point that
the status quo appeared natural and inevitable. For centuries, there had really been no alternative
mode of thought possible to the mass of Roman society. As a dominant cultural form, Romanitas
in this world was comparable to our own hegemonic culture, pervading everything yet difficult to
and even more difficult to articulate by those raised within it. This sense of shared Roman-ness,
tied as it was to the Principate, traditional religious institutions, and social conventions,
formed Rome's ideological superstructure and had been the final thread by which Roman
civilization was held together after decades of crisis. When affairs were in this desperate
condition and the Roman Empire almost ruined, Postumus, a man of very obscure birth, assumed
the purple in Gaul and held the government with such ability for ten years that he recruited the
provinces, which had been almost ruined, by his great energy and judgment. But while these
transactions were passing in Gaul, the Persians in the east were overthrown by Odonathus, who,
having defended Syria and recovered Mesopotamia, penetrated into the country as far as Ctesiphon.
Thus, while Gallienus abandoned the government, the Roman Empire was saved in the west by Postumus
and in the east by Odonathus. The collapse of a system as all-encompassing as Romanitas
could result in nothing but the dissolution of this outmoded form of Roman identity.
In the words of Gramsci, the crisis consists precisely in the fact that the old is dying
and the new cannot be born. In this interregnum, a great variety of morbid symptoms appear.
The fundamentals of the unifying Roman political project, structured around the princeps and the
military monarchy, had always been flawed, and its universalism had never really been universal
by any modern standard. But the rising tide of Roman fortunes had quieted doubts and encouraged
loyalty to this dominating vision. Now, however, the spell had been broken and the morbid symptoms
manifested, as the very idea of Romanitas was revealed as the ideological fiction that it was.
The removal of this critical support mechanism that undergirded Roman order was the death of
shared identity, and we should not be surprised that it caused the scattered generals to become
lawless warlords and to act with their own interests in mind. Our poor sources for this
era make a timeline of these events impossible to recreate with any certainty, but it seems that all
these pretenders in Gaul, along the Danube, and in the east arose in quick succession, each doubtlessly
encouraged by the revolts of others to make their own plays for greater power against an emperor
who seemed fatally weakened by setback after setback. The Roman state, which traced its lineage
over a thousand years back to the city's foundation by Romulus, was dividing after centuries of unity,
pushed to the limit by decades of military defeat, climate disruptions, and the ever-present specter
of plague. If you're enjoying this video, please do us a favor by liking, commenting, and subscribing.
We're a small channel, and this is the only way to get the almighty YouTube algorithm to notice us.
Furthermore, you can help Tribunet become more sustainable by becoming a member for as little
as 99 cents a month. Thank you for all of your support. It must be stressed that these rebellions
were not just mere dents to Gallienus's pride, or even simple threats to his prestige. Instead,
they came at tragic personal cost for the man already reeling from the humiliating subjugation
of his father by Shapur. Gallienus and Valerian had long known the dangers posed by the delegation
of too much power to ambitious generals, and had stationed Gallienus's teenage sons Valerian the
Younger and Solaninus on the frontiers in nominal command of the troops, though real authority,
of course, rested with more seasoned commanders. On the Danube, Ingenis's path to revolt had already
been cleared by the mysterious death of Valerian the Younger, who held the rank of Caesar, which
marked him out as the heir apparent. We do not know if Gallienus's eldest son was murdered by a
scheming Ingenis, or if he died of natural causes, and Ingenis thus felt that the glare of imperial
suspicion left him with no choice but to revolt. But at the end of the day, it doesn't change the
equation. Gallienus had lost a son, and the Danube legions were rallying behind a rival claimant.
Gallienus's decisive suppression of this revolt, notably through the deployment of his newly
constituted Mobile Cavalry Force at the Battle of Mursa, shows that Gallienus was anything but a
passive observer of the chaos unfolding around him. He was just as aware as any of his contemporaries
of the need for innovation, and his creation of the Mobile Cavalry Corps, as well as his momentous
decision to bar senators from military command, were significant breaks with tradition. For this,
he earned the undying enmity of the senators. But Gallienus did not want men from prestigious
backgrounds in command of armies that could be turned against him. Instead, he chose to promote
on merit. This severed senators from the most powerful positions, but he hoped that the humble
backgrounds of the men who now commanded his armies would encourage them to be personally
loyal to the emperor who had raised them so high. Ingenis's death, however, brought little relief,
as the same Danubian legions opted to continue their rebellion, and now elevated Regalianus.
There was no respite for Gallienus, as each crisis simply opened the door to another.
These woes were compounded by events in Gaul, where Gallienus had left his young son Saloninus
to oversee the Rhine, though real power rested with several handpicked generals, including the
highly respected and trusted Posthumus, said to be an exemplar of virtue even in these dark days.
If anyone indeed desires to know the merits of Posthumus, he may learn Valerian's opinion
concerning him from the following letter which he wrote to the Gauls. As general in charge of the
frontier and governor of Gaul we have named Posthumus, a man most worthy of the stern
discipline of the Gauls. He by his presence will safeguard the soldiers in the camp,
civil rights in the forum, lawsuits at the bar of judgment, and the dignity of the council chamber.
He will preserve for each one his own personal possessions. He is a man at whom I marvel above
all others and well deserving of the office of prince, and for him I hope you will render me
thanks. If however I have erred in my judgment concerning him, you may rest assured days that
nowhere in the world will a man be found who can win complete approval. But the cratering support
for the ruling dynasty revealed the true colors of every Roman, even those once held in the highest
esteem. This man, most valiant in war and most steadfast in peace, was so highly respected for
his whole manner of life that he was even entrusted by Gallienus with the care of his son
Saloninus, whom he had placed command of Gaul as the guardian of his life and conduct, and his
instructor in the duties of a ruler. A dispute over the distribution of war booty spilled over
into another rebellion, and Posthumus killed Saloninus before carving out a separatist state
in Gaul that soon grew to include Britain and Spain as well. In a matter of weeks Gallienus
had lost his father and two of his sons. We can only imagine the anguish and suffering he felt
as he reflected on the ruin that had been the price of his crown. Though called the Gallic
Empire today, we must remember that this breakaway regime styled itself as the legitimate Roman state,
even though Posthumus never made a play for Rome, being content to reign within his own sizable
sphere of influence. This marks him out as unique and gives insight into the shifting definitions of
what it meant to be authentically Roman in this time of disorder. It had long been recognized
that the city of Rome itself, even with all its history and prestige, was no longer the linchpin
of legitimacy. Instead, the capital of the empire was simply where the emperor and his court happened
Recognizing this, Posthumus felt no compulsion to engage in a risky campaign to seize the city of
Rome and instead devoted his resources to repelling any incursions into the regions that now swore
fealty to him. Unlike the other rebels, he seemed most aware that the universal Roman polity was a
thing of the past, a relic from a different age. Though culturally Roman, he did not mourn for the
end of a system that had failed so spectacularly. This Gallic empire thus maintained long-standing
administrative forms, institutionalizing regional autonomy without dismantling the idea of imperial
rule itself. Now responsible for a smaller share of Roman territory, Posthumus only had one front
to concern himself with, and was thus better equipped to safeguard his new empire from tribal
incursions. By projecting enough force to deter both tribal raiders and Gallienus's own efforts to
reunify the empire, Posthumus won over the local elite and increased the viability of his secession,
resulting in what could have been a permanent fracturing of the Roman world. As grim as
prospects were in the west, developments in the east were hardly any better. Though exact timelines
are incredibly difficult to discern, parallel developments in the eastern provinces further
attest to the fragmentation of imperial authority. In response to the devastation of the east by
Shapur, remnants of Rome's forces in the region rallied to the banner of the general Fulvius
Macrianus and the Praetorian prefect Ballista, who engaged the Persians and blunted their advance.
Ironically though, Gallienus would have been better served by their defeat,
since these victories emboldened the commanders and led them to declare Macrianus's sons as
co-emperors. Fortunately however, Gallienus still had loyalists in the region, and this rebellion
was put down by Odinathus of Palmyra, who emerged as the dominant player in the east.
Recognizing that he was now indispensable both as a bulwark against the real threat posed by Persia
and as one of the few generals who could be counted on to remain loyal, Odinathus leveraged
his position to win greater autonomy for the east and to set himself up as a regional potentate,
with possible designs to pass this nebulous authority to his heirs. Gallienus could not
have been comfortable with Odinathus amassing this much power, but from his weakened state,
there was little he could do. Besides, the self-styled lord of Tadmor still proclaimed his
loyalty, and even if these promises were beginning to ring hollow, he had proven himself to be an
effective counter to the Persians, leaving Gallienus with little choice but to formalize
his position. But the emergence of this semi-autonomous yet nominally loyal ally
highlights the increasingly ambiguous boundaries between treason and legitimacy. Indeed,
though Gallienus is perceived as the legitimate emperor during this period and his opponents as
rebels, these monikers simply reflect that it was Gallienus's successors which reunified the empire,
and the terms are thus a result of us retrojecting definitions onto developments at the time.
It's clear that to Romans living in 260, legitimacy was much more fluid in its application.
In a very real sense then, Rome as it had been was dead. There was no unifying force capable of
Our sources are eager to chalk up this fragmentation and loss of collective political
identity to alleged personal failings on the part of Gallienus. The emperor is cast in these
hostile traditions as an indolent drunk more concerned with pleasure and his German mistress
than the administration of his empire. Searching for a scapegoat, later writers would place the
Would that it had not to bear 600 pretenders. Had but those soldiers been saved who fell in
diverse battles, those legions saved which Gallienus destroyed, disastrously victorious.
How much strength would the state have gained? But the over-the-top criticisms seem to be attacking
a caricature more than a man, and modern scholars view them as more reflective of senatorial
prejudice against the emperor who had shorn the order of its ancestral privileges than actual
fact. Furthermore, the deeply held Roman belief that setbacks must be a reflection of divine
disapproval necessitated that Gallienus be condemned despite his efforts to reunify Rome
when dealt a deeply unfavorable hand by the circumstances. This facile, idealist interpretation
of history, which could not recognize systemic forces, had little choice but to paint anyone
who presided over disorder as a bad ruler. But Gallienus was not the man who is skewered in
senatorial sources. In reality, his refusal to be content with a rump state like Posthumus was the
glue that preserved Rome at this time of crisis. Whether because he still believed in Augustus's
vision or because he could not stomach any diminution of his own authority, Gallienus
responded to these trying times and personal tragedies with grit and determination. That Rome
managed to reunify in just over a decade was in no small part because of his forward-thinking
policies and simple refusal to let the candle be extinguished. But the Rome that eventually
coalesced under his successors would be radically distinct from the coyly exercised power of the
The writings of Plato form the intellectual backbone of Western thought in much the same
way that Homer's epics informed its cultural imagination. All his works would have been
read extensively and perhaps memorized by Gallienus, who was famed for his learning
and sophistication. There is no way of knowing which sections resonated with him most deeply,
but perhaps he found solace in Socrates's words in Book I of the Republic that a truly just man
does not seek recognition or praise for being a just man, that justice and goodness are to be
pursued regardless of the reputation they bring. If this is something that motivated him, then I
believe he would not mind the poor reputation he has today and would instead still see his quest
to reunify the empire as an expression of justice worth any sacrifice, including his own. Gallienus's
effort to not just reunify but to fundamentally rebuild Rome was just beginning, but many
tragedies awaited him yet, and he would not live to see it through.