Great Art Ep.4: The School of Athens (Raphael) | NTD Arts & Culture

Explore art
12 followers
The Renaissance was a revival of the ancient world through the spirit of the modern Christian world,
and no work better represents this epoch than Raphael's The School of Athens. Plato and
Aristotle, the giants of ancient Western philosophy and heroes of Raphael, walk toward us, flanked by
a monumental gathering of Greek philosophers in the midst of discussion and the exchange of
knowledge. But their faces would have been recognizable to Raphael's contemporaries,
perhaps as their own. Now opposite this is the representation of philosophy,
a painting that's come to be known as The School of Athens, and it's fascinating
for all sorts of reasons, not least of them being the presence of the pagan gods
in this Christian pope's study. That is, the two big statues in the background,
one of them is Apollo, shown there nude with his lyre because he's the god of poetry,
and on the other side is the statue of Athena, or as the Romans would have it, Minerva,
a kind of warrior goddess of justice and wisdom, and above all wisdom.
What Raphael has done here is to create a monumental gathering of Greek philosophers,
and he set them into a monumental architecture that was inspired by ancient Roman architecture
that is indeed, one might say, a model of the new church of Saint Peter's that's being designed by
his friend Bramante. In fact the ground plan that can be worked out for this painting corresponds
exactly to the ground plan of the Saint Peter's designed by Bramante, and we'll see that Bramante
enters into this. This is a painting then that celebrates philosophy. Like the Disputa across
the room, it is geometrically articulated. Down below we have that pavement pattern,
a simple rectangular pavement pattern. Here we come up a flight of steps to the monumental
architecture, to the great arches that are coffered in the way of the ancient Roman baths,
and we have a series of concentric arches, circles, so that the circle itself again
dominates up here, but in a very different way. It is not the absolute circle of heaven that we
see across the room. We have a set of steps that distinguishes a lower zone from a higher zone,
and we then have all of these figures, but only two are isolated. Only two are set against
the sky, framed by that background arch, and these, I think there's a detail there that we
can look at. Those two are what the Renaissance would refer to as the princes of philosophy,
of Western philosophy. That is Plato and Aristotle, and these are the heroes of this.
Everything else radiates from them, and that radiation, as we'll see, is extremely important,
because this is, as I said, it's a painting about philosophy, but it also extends that
philosophical reach right down to the artists, as we'll see. What we have are two groups at the
very bottom, and they are very low, so that the relationship of these two figures to these
figures on either side will become something of importance. Again, it's a perspective.
We can work out the perspective. It's a very rational space, and perspective, as you'll see,
is very important here. However, it's the figures themselves that articulate values.
Raphael, for example, takes Plato and Aristotle. How does a painter differentiate two philosophies?
One points up, and one points out. Eventually, when we can get to their books, Plato holds
one of his books, the Timaeus, and Aristotle holds his Ethics, but it's exactly that kind of thing.
Plato points up, Aristotle points out. No, he doesn't point, he reaches out. Plato points to
that realm of higher ideas. Aristotle reaches out to this realm of human behavior, and so what we
have is exactly that kind of differentiation, but the two are also known in other ways. Plato is,
after all, a pure philosopher. Plato is shown as an older man. He is without decoration.
He stands on bare feet and stands on his toes, so he's already rising off the earth. His hand
that reaches up and from that finger springs the background arch, so that they're totally
contained within that group. Aristotle, on the other hand, was the philosopher. I mean,
after all, he was a philosophical mentor to Alexander the Great. He's the philosopher of
the court. He has, in many ways, he has entered into the world, and he is very much a man of the
world. Plato's beard is long and unkempt. Aristotle has just seen the barber. He's very well trimmed.
Aristotle's robe is, first of all, it's a much more expensive blue than the red of Plato, but
it's trimmed in gold. He wears gold-trimmed sandals, and he stands flat on the ground,
so he's very much a figure of this world. The fundamental difference is Plato's verticality
and Aristotle's horizontality, and these will continue. Once again, this is a painter thinking,
one might say even thinking geometrically, just in terms of vertical and horizontal,
but this then continues down below. I mean, not all of these figures can be identified,
although lots of effort has been taken. One in particular can. That's Socrates. I mean,
his portrait is known, and here he is arguing. I mean, and this is, again, this is,
he's really making his points. This is the logic of Socrates, and he's arguing with a young,
foppish figure in armor, and that, of course, can only be his favorite Alcibiades.
Down below, however, it becomes even more interesting. The division is between a
Platonic side and an Aristotelian side. The Platonic side is to the, what we could call
the dexter side of the painting, that is, looking out from the painting, so this would be the
privilege. This is the side that is privileged in the case of Christ. Opposite in the central axis
is where the meaning of the painting is carried. In the school of Athens, there is no central axis.
It's a division between two sides, so they're, I mean, two very fundamentally different
structures, even though they have this similarity. I mean, even the two columns up here
are paired in the same way that the two philosophers here are paired, and then there
are the pairings on either corner. Down here is a group of figures around a bald man who leans down
with a pair of compasses and is demonstrating something on a slate, and that, of course, is Euclid,
the geometer, Euclid. On the other side, another bald man, again, surrounded by
disciples. I mean, the whole notion of pedagogy is very important in this culture, and in front
of him is held another slate which has the diagram of harmonic proportions that was
discovered by Pythagoras. So we have Pythagoras and Euclid. We have the order of forms and here
the order of numbers, which is higher than form because what these numbers represent
is the harmony of the universe, the harmony of the spheres, that is, that higher realm to which
Plato is pointing. So that, once again, what we have is a very interesting but subtle
contrast. If Plato holds his book vertically, the slate of Pythagoras is held up, but not quite
vertically, just at an angle, but it's held up off the ground. Aristotle holds his book horizontally.
The lowest object in the entire painting is the slate on the ground, flat on the ground, on which
Euclid performs his demonstration, and he's surrounded by figures here. I mean, the figures
that he's surrounded by are probably the astronomers and, like, well, clearly the one with
the crown is the royal astronomer, that is, the king astronomer Ptolemy, and the figure
holding the astrolabe is probably the Greek geographer Strabo, although other
other identifications have been put forth, but they both refer to astronomy and to the
geography of the earth. Then there are these two portraits here in the corner. One of them is a
self-portrait. Raphael puts himself into this. This figure looking out at us is Raphael, and this
takes us back, once again, to that long tradition of the 15th century in which
mathematics was the basis of painting. Raphael, of course, as a master of perspective, is a
mathematician in that way, and the entire perspective depends absolutely, ultimately,
for his mathematics on Euclid. On the collar of Euclid's dress, Raphael signs himself,
I mean, by his initials, Raphael Morbino. So he identifies with Euclid, and probably that
bald head belongs to Raphael's friend and mentor, the architect Bramante. So it becomes
very personalized. This is the artist, the painter rather, associating himself,
associating his art with philosophy through mathematics. On the other side, this world of
harmonic proportions and so forth. Originally, Raphael didn't have this figure, and he added it
later. He came back and added it. He filled it in. This figure is unlike all the others.
Raphael's figures are open. Raphael's figures discourse with one another. I mean, this is what
Vasari meant when he said that Raphael was sent to earth to instruct these uncouth artists in
social values. Raphael's figures are constantly dealing with one another. They're debating with
one another. They're talking. They're gesturing. And there's a lightness about them. I mean,
at this point in his career, I mean, Raphael is always young, in effect, but at this point in
his career, there's none of the heavy ponderation that one finds in Michelangelo, except for that
figure. This is a figure who can be recognized by his pose as a melancholic, as a melancholic
philosopher. That would make him Heraclitus, the ancient Greek philosopher. But he's also
pretty much the only figure who's wearing boots. He's also the only figure who is totally wrapped
up in himself, alone. He's holding a pen, waiting to write. He's leaning on a block of stone,
already cut stone. This is a figure who is inspired by a figure by Michelangelo up on
the Sistine ceiling, but it's also a portrait of Michelangelo. It is Raphael's tribute to
Michelangelo. Michelangelo was always jealous of Raphael. Raphael knew the master. He knew
that this was an artist of incredible magnitude, and one can say here that he basically paid
profound tribute to Michelangelo. He recognized Michelangelo's own personality. He also recognized
something else that comes out later in the biographies of Michelangelo, that is later
in the 16th century, that is he always wore his dogskin boots. All of this makes it clear,
but it's more important than just Raphael's own tribute to another artist, because he also defines
that artist, just as he defined himself here, in effect, as belonging, as it were, to an older
tradition of the rational basis of painting, painting as mathematics. Something is different
here. This is not where art comes from math. This is where art comes from something higher.
This is Michelangelo, who is also already known as a poet. This is Michelangelo sitting there,
brooding, holding his pen, waiting for inspiration, waiting to hear that higher voice.
This is something that everybody learned about. That is, among culture and society,
the whole idea of inspiration was fairly commonplace in the sense that all the prophets
of the Old Testament, they don't speak their own language, they don't speak their own words,
they speak the words of God. Or the Sybils in Greek and Roman literature, the Sybils don't
speak their own words. I mean, you go to the Sybil precisely because she
will give you the word of God, or one of the gods, Apollo, usually. So that there is this
whole sense in which there's a new value being brought into, as I mentioned before, being brought
into the very notion of artistic creativity. And that's inspiration. And this Michelangelo
had worked out on the Sistine Ceiling, absolutely. The alternating figures of the Sybils and the
prophets. You can enact inspiration there, where the figure that is probably most immediately
relevant here is Michelangelo's figure of Jeremiah, who sits brooding up on the Sistine Ceiling,
also with legs crossed so he can't move. And the next stage, as it were, of inspiration would be
the figure of Isaiah, who has moved from this kind of pose to this, so that his hand is still there,
but he has turned away, looking over his shoulder, and behind him are Genii. No, no,
this is Michelangelo looking to that higher source. All of this is something that is
encapsulated in this figure, a figure who is awaiting that kind of inspiration. This is the
tribute to Michelangelo, but it also takes what was the objectivity of painting as a liberal art,
in the sense of mathematics, it takes that and transforms it into some to the subjectivity
of poetry, for which there are no mathematical rules, and which you're waiting for inspiration,
that is to be filled with the word or the breath of God. And this is, as I said,
this is an even more profound aspect of Raphael's tribute to Michelangelo.
