11k years old "Göbekli Tepe stone seal" will send you on a wild ride

Ancient Civilizations
15 followers
7 Video Views·May 3, 2026
This was a wild ride, as we see how many things are connected to these three symbols of snake, human, bird, from Sumer to Egypt and Athens and the United States Capitol Building. Once you see it, it is everywhere, and quite profound.
Welcome to the video. There is this really fascinating theory that I was first made
aware of via Irving Finkel on Lex Friedman podcast. And so I did some hunting and I
found what seems to be the only peer-reviewed paper on it. And it is that this little green
rock may be the oldest evidence of writing, or proto-writing, and it comes from Gobekli Tepe
and is dated to around 11,000 years ago, or 9000 BC.
A round green stone like a scarab from Egypt, that's to say it has an arched back and a flat
bottom. There are hieroglyphic signs carved in the stone. No one said anything about it at all.
But it's clear to me that this was a stamp to ratify where the carvings of the signs
on clay or some other sealing material would leave an impression. It must be that.
So this is about 9000 BC.
Very crucially, he says that we can infer a lot from this single piece.
He compares it to if you understand the physics of a single raindrop,
you can infer the Niagara Falls.
He complains about this general air of timid academics that try to act like it's somehow
more noble to be cautious, but they end up just defaulting to a sort of religious dogmatic
reaction. They don't just look at things clearly. Sometimes a single artifact really is all you
need. Like if we found just one gold plate on the moon that has all kind of obvious writing
and diagrams, that tells you a whole lot. Our entire paradigm can be changed by single
artifacts. So if we're not disputing the dating, I'm with Finkel on this.
Nobody's arguing that these are accidental markings, and it seems to so clearly be a seal,
like we see in later Mesopotamian cylinder seals or just single pressed seals. This is
obviously some sort of proto-writing. Symbols put on a small portable thing used to convey
something to other people. And it's found in the same area with the earliest megalithic
architecture. And that's the same place where things like wheat and cattle were first domesticated.
And we see that all spread into Samaria and Egypt, and it just compounds over time.
It all supports Finkel's point that the simplest, most obvious interpretation of this is that it's
a little seal with symbols meant to be understood by people. And it all supports Finkel's point that
this single artifact is clearly implying symbolic expression intended for other people,
and so that implies a complex network of interactions. It serves the same purpose of
the countless other cylinder seals that would seem to pop up later and be used for thousands
of years in the Near East, and even up to the same idea of signet rings. It's a signature,
a way to verify that this was signed off of or approved of by a certain person.
And so that also implies hierarchy, and that you're doing something complex that
would require this. At the very least it's some sort of property rights.
Which is one of the simpler theories about the origins of writing. That it was just a
symbol that you could put on something, like a clay jar, so that you knew what was inside.
As you use a wet piece of clay to seal it, you're making sure bugs don't get in,
and it just preserves longer. And you can just have a pictograph, a simple drawing of a wheat
stalk on a jar, and that's to remind you, oh yeah, I put wheat in there.
Then you maybe develop numbers, how much of something is in that jar, and then ways to
claim it, to let other people know, hey, that's my jar. And what's so confusing to academics
about Gobekli Tepe, is that it seems to go against a narrative that you needed centralized
planning and agriculture before you had megalithic projects. If it is the case that these people
weren't fully sedentary at this point, but you're using this as some sort of big vault
of bank to store all kinds of products, you need some sort of personal identifier on your stuff.
Some symbol that either means you personally, or your clan. And since you're carrying this seal,
it's like a contract or an ID. You're saying, see, this is the seal, and that's my jar.
Symbols meant to express ideas to other people, that's writing.
But what we normally mean when we think of proper writing, the oldest evidence of writing
usually here is Sumerian cuneiform at 3400 BC, and then just a century or less, I like to think
of it as happening in the same century, kind of like the explosion of tech in the 21st century.
But you have Egyptian hieroglyphics dated at 3300 BC. If you want to go even deeper and get into
the Vinca tablets, this is in the Balkan area, and maybe as old as 5400 BC, but that is considered
proto-writing. I'm working on a whole video on that coming soon, so subscribe if you don't want
to miss that. But the point is, you see that these three symbols may be more than twice as old as
the previous record holder for proto-writing, going from 5400 BC. And so you see, these three
little symbols on this rock may push us back another 1600 years, as the new record holder for
proto-writing. A really cool detail I want to sneak in here about the Vinca symbols, but you'll see
how it relates to the overall conclusion of this paper and the video, that use of the Vinca symbols
seem to have died out around 3500 BC. Which is why I don't really care too much about who was
first when it comes to Sumerian or Egyptian. Every time I dive into it, I do end up agreeing that it
seems to be Sumerian that came first, but it's very reasonable to think that something was around
for at least around a hundred years earlier, or that they both were inspired by some other source
in this broader intersection of Africa, Asia, and Europe. It's almost certain that these proto-symbols
were all over the place long before writing emerged. And like I say in the language isolate
video, this great new tech gets adopted by neighboring people. They are pulled into this
more productive culture and technology. To where we get Cuneiform being used as the way to write
down non-Sumerian languages, like Akkadian and Elamite. The computer and internet system that
I'm using to talk to you right now was developed by certain people in a certain area, but the entire
world adopted it. Same thing with Cuneiform in Mesopotamia. New tech that is just so useful that
even very diverse people end up using it. But again, when you try and look up everything there
is on this little green stone with these three symbols, the only source I could find is a 2011
paper by Sarah Kiel Costello, published in Cambridge Archaeological Journal, and it's titled
Memory and Ritual, Reviewing the Antecedents of Writing. Seriously, this is all I could find.
But I promise you it is thoroughly fascinating and worth it. So let's jump in and actually break
this down. Just from the intro, we get the setup of the claim, quote, I posit that A, there are
recurring motifs in the visual culture of the Neolithic Near East, and B, the subject matter
of these motifs relates to religious beliefs and practices. I argue that to fully understand early
seal use, we must proceed historically rather than ahistorically. First, considering the primary
association between these objects and cosmological concerns, and then broaden interpretations of
later seal use, archive systems, and ultimately writing to consider how the content or meaning
of the glyptic imagery may relate to those contexts. The author calls these symbols memory
tools because like all writing, like if you write on your hand to cheat on a test in school, it's a
way to get around the effects of time. You don't have to remember the symbols, this writing is
doing the remembering for you. Famously, it's the complaint the Greeks made about writing to begin
with, that you would lose the oral traditions of the time of Homer, these bards that could remember
these enormously long epics. Now in the opening, I mentioned how you use wet clay to seal a clay
jar. It's true for most of the story here, but you have these time periods called Pre-Pottery
Neolithic A, or PPNA and PPNB, B just is a later period, but it means no clay jars like we think
of them around the time of Gobekli Tepe that had stone vessels and what are described as plaster
lined pits, these sort of proto-containers which could be aligned with lime plaster and used for
communal storage of foods and especially grain. And so I'm just warning you if you're annoyed by
this, I'm sorry, but I might slip into calling it clay, but just think I could also be meaning
plaster. These Tepe sites around Turkey are so old that they're before pottery, and so it might be
confusing as to why we're saying that this little seal can be used in clay. It's just that it's so
similar to the other later cylinder seals that you would like roll into clay, or the simple ones that
you just press in, just like this green one. And I get it's not literally clay pots, but it's being
used the same way. You're whipping up a dirt and water, you're making a plaster in this case, and
then you could press into that and have the same relief effect as you would with clay. I hope that
makes sense. I realized while recording this, I'm going to throw some people off because I keep
saying clay, but I mean the same idea. Squishy thing that you push a thing into and it makes your
shape. Let's continue. And you see this paper taking a really interesting turn. One of the
deeper points here is the very cool concept of this shared culture all throughout the Fertile
Crescent. The author is trying to see if there is some shared understanding of symbols across
diverse people and areas. And I have a whole video on what I describe as this bull cult mound
building culture in this area. Where of course I say at one level the people of modern day Turkey,
Egypt, and Iraq is spanning thousands of years from 10,000 years ago to 4,000 years ago. At one
level yes of course they're distinct people, but the core elements of their cultures are all related
at a fundamental level. There is at least a base or some substrate of one culture that also does
flourish into unique cultures in different areas. But just like how Japanese and English people can
be seen as very different on a genetic level, or looking into their history and thinking of them
as people groups, their cultures can be very different in a ton of ways, but at the very
core ways of how they think and what they do on a daily basis it's all very similar due to this
global monoculture that has emerged. Again connected to our technology, and back then it was this
shared connection to this new tech of domestication. Domesticating plants and animals and these forces
that allow for megalithic construction. It all seems to emerge across these Tepes, the southern
Turkey region, and then wheat, beer, bowls, and megaliths become core to the entire Fertile
Crescent culture. While crucially remembering that there was never some clear start date and that
there was no pure just line go up progression. Quote, by contextualizing seal use and the
development of writing within the history of religious belief and practice in the Near East,
I emphasize the social context of information technology, the struggles and choices of
societies in flux. Instead of a monolithic milestone, dividing prehistory from history,
the development of writing was part of a dynamic process through which cosmologies shifted,
power hierarchies were rearranged, and society reorganized itself in a new urban setting.
I don't know if you've ever seen this great cuneiform Microsoft excel sheet meme,
before man was, excel waited for him, the ultimate art awaiting its ultimate practitioners,
and they show these example of cuneiform spreadsheets essentially. They really are
tracking the most mundane things like amounts of wheat, who's trading wheat with who, and so to
translate this meme in a more academic language, quote, the fact that early writing was so closely
linked to numerical notation and record keeping has helped shaped research on the subject,
drawing attention to the administrative and accounting needs that presumably drove the
invention of writing. With domestication we have so much more stuff, and people do not feel that
it is random or based on luck anymore, like some very small tight knit tribe that hopes to find
some game to hunt. People feel like their material success was due to choices made when it came to
their crops or their cattle. Think of all the most simple but timeless wisdom literature,
from Sumerian to Aesop's fables, which basically eventually becomes almost all cultures,
they have children's stories meant to warn against excess or laziness,
the generalizable idea that you need to work through the summer to have a surplus in the winter,
that you reap what you sow. I hate to be a gardening elitist, actual farmers would laugh
at me here, but I really do think anyone can feel this even just trying to keep a single plant alive
and productive. Anyone who's never done this cannot appreciate how much connection you can
have with your plants, how protective you'll be of them. Scale that up and if you've been working
hard every single day for your wheat harvest, you will definitely want a way to make sure people
knew that that was yours personally. A harvest is not like a hunt, it's not a random luck based or
communal event. I can hear the comment section trying to pick that apart, but I think you know
what I mean. And time becomes incredibly important. Without even getting into the insanity
of ancients tracking the stars with incredible accuracy, just sticking to the point that once
you start having forms of legal agreements, loans or credit based on some future income,
that you have goats or cows right now, and I have a ton of growing wheat, you can see it looks good,
you know I'm a good farmer, I promise to give you wheat for meat. But shout out to the swindlers and
liars all throughout history that created these evolutionary pressures for writing,
because you gotta imagine that as you got disputes over what was actually agreed to,
you needed a mediator and then to have records. So I take my little portable green stone,
I press it into this plaster or clay, and then maybe we put a symbol for wheat, and this other
symbol that means five, maybe a simple line or just some symbol for trade, and you put your
palette, the term for this little stone, and you have your symbol that means one cow. Now me,
you, and at least one mediator all have to agree on what these five different symbols mean.
And so you see how simple it is that just wanting to mark something as yours,
the idea of property, ownership, and then the dynamic interaction of trade with others
forces you to develop a shared language system. But my favorite part here is that the author
stresses that it is not to imply that ancient life was reduced to spreadsheets. As Michalowski
observes, even the administrative use of writing involves complex psychological, ideological,
and social issues that cannot be accounted for by purely utilitarian explanations.
Those psychological, ideological, and social factors require more attention.
Like I touch on on many of my videos, you'll see this recurring theme of the modern materialist,
the kind of atheist, they don't believe in spirits or anything supernatural. That worldview,
I think, makes it really hard to truly understand what's going on in the ancient mind,
a reality that we share with them. I'll get into that later. And the author gives some history on
the competing ideas in this field, that most just downplay the symbols used on the stamps.
Quote like Hole and Pittman, I find that the images on early seals carry meaning and significance
that is in many cases religious, which adds a very particular dimension to our interpretation
of these objects. I hope to broaden our understanding of the social context of early
writing, so that in addition to recognizing its bureaucratic function, we can see it as part of
a long visual and symbolic tradition rooted in religious belief and practice. Over several
thousand years, similar iconography is found on these objects. This iconography includes a raptor,
quadruped, and snake, sometimes shown as a set, and sometimes with plants and humans included.
I offer explanations of this imagery, followed by an interpretation, in which I argue that the
imagery refers to widespread and long-held religious beliefs and practices. From the very
earliest settlements in the Near East, pre-pottery Neolithic A, circa 10,000 to 8,700 BC, were found
examples of glyptic imagery. Pallets of baked clay with symbols carved on them were found at Morabeth
and Jephalamar, along with a few carved grooved stones. The carved designs include a scorpion,
serpent, quadruped, and abstract markings such as cross-hatched and wavy lines. A recent find places
the Jephalamar and Morabeth palettes in a wider context. A similar palette was found at the 10th
century BC site of Göbekli Tepe in southeastern Turkey. Like the example from Jephalamar discussed
above, it has figural imagery, including a bird on the right and a snake left. The central image is
too schematic to interpret with certainty, but given the T-shaped anthropomorphizing sculpture
at the site, it is tempting to see the mark as a human with outstretched arms, what I discussed
below as an orant gesture. Orant comes from the Latin orns, which means praying. It is the hands
raised to the side look. Quote, it should be emphasized that there is no evidence that the
pallets were used as seals, that is, to impress a design on plaster or clay. Nevertheless, the
similarity in both concept, an intaglio image on a small portable object, and motifs to later stamp
seals suggest the stamp seal tradition may have developed not only from earlier uncarved pendants,
as had been suggested, but also from these incised stone and clay pallets.
So again, it's lines like, it should be emphasized that there is no evidence that the pallets were
used as seals, that's that kind of overly cautious mentality I think Finkel is warning against,
complaining about, that everything else would point to this being used to express an individual,
that if it makes so much more sense to just view it that way, why don't we? Of course,
we can never know for sure that it was used that way, but that's not an interesting point,
everything works like that. A murder trial can be circumstantial. When you find the guy's blood
on the victim, and you have him claiming on camera that he's gonna kill this person,
you can come in and be a philosopher and go, technically, that does not mean that he did it.
Finkel is saying this happens a lot in his field, that all the arrows are pointing to this
conclusion. It makes so much more sense to see this piece as some sort of seal. And again to
the point of this being tied to some sort of ownership claims and legal issues, you're the
one that's signed off on this sealed thing. It's your symbol that matches that stone in your hand,
there's no way that somebody opened it up, took stuff out, and sealed it again.
Back to the paper, quote,
The motifs on the impressed sealings vary considerably, including caprines,
humans, zigzags, chevrons, stylized bucrania, and cowrie shell impressions. The grouping of
quadruped, raptor, snake seen on the early Neolithic palettes is not, strictly speaking,
found on the Sabiabite impressions. However, the caprine is the most common motif found on level 6,
17% of total impressed sealings. S-shaped motifs are the second most common,
10% of total. And zigzags are the third most common, 5% of total. While these last two may
be interpreted as abstract designs, the zigzag resembles the form of the raptor,
and the S-shaped motif resembles the snake. Thus, taken together, these three most common
motifs echo the grouping from the early Neolithic palette. Many of the rest of the motifs are
vegetal. One important motif introduced at Sabiabite Glyptic is the human figure,
a motif representing 3% of the total impressed sealings. This is no ordinary person, but rather
one with unnaturally large eyes, and in cases where the full body is shown, a distorted head
or large headdress. I'll get into that more towards the end, but the point is we're seeing
these shared symbols. This quadruped looks like it has the horns of a sheep, and sheep were the
oldest known livestock in this area, domesticated before cattle, and this little guy is clearly an
alien of the type documented all over the world. Back to the paper, this composition, so like that
of Jerf Al-Amar, though chronologically very distant, suggests that these motifs carried
powerful associations. While their associations may have shifted over time, their repeated
appearance on Glyptic art over these thousands of years in the same region suggests some continuity
in traditions. Just look at the symbolism on figure 7 here, it's fascinating. This one reminds
me of Enki, Sumerian god of wisdom and water, he's always shown overflowing with water and fish,
and he's the Sumerian god of writing, he brought writing to people. Let me know what you think in
the comments, but that's what popped out to me, and I can see how you might think this is a bird
head, but the hands seem so odd, and maybe like it's water flowing out from the upraised praying
hands, a version of how we see the water flowing out on each side of Enki. And then this one is
the Goatman, which I know from everything from the Greek Pan, to the Christian fear of a kind
of Devil Goatman. You have in culture a vague kind of throughline of the Goatman as a force
of natural chaos, living in the woods away from society, it's lawless. But this might be the
opposite connotation that people of this time thousands of years ago might have had. In this
context that sees goats as the product of those people who took wild animals and domesticated
them. The goat might evoke the idea of promoters of civilization, or as the symbol of human will,
and goats were domesticated around 11,000 years ago, 9000 BC. You see how that all lines up.
And a really cool side note that needs to be included here, it's a point about Gobekli Tepe
that always stuck with me, is that in the oldest megalithic site we have, right around the time of
domestication, it seems like there is a progression where the older sites have no hierarchy between
animals and people, but over time we get humans literally on top of everything. And even these
seals, this oldest example of a sort of proto-writing, may have a human in the middle.
While later depictions with humans in the middle will be much more clear and obvious, it's more
prominent, it eventually becomes the master of animals theme that spreads all over this area,
which shows a human having two animals in their grasp, hands raised out on each side,
grasping these animals, the animals are utterly under the control of the human.
So how cool is it that from the small, handheld stone to the giant megalithic projects,
we're carving this idea into stone that matches up perfectly with the rise of human domination.
As we became something fundamentally different from animals, we are above the animals and able
to reshape our surroundings, carving the rocks into our image, and changing entire species,
breeding the traits we want to change the whole course of a species, whether it be wheat,
to goats, or cows. Again, I love that the writer sees that even with these ancient,
ancient people over 10,000 years ago, they have a more holistic and just plainly more interesting
view of humanity. It's not just literal bean counters trying to make sure they have enough
food so that they can live another day to fill another spreadsheet, it's understanding that the
core of human existence is to transform reality. Whether you think it just is what it is, or some
divine mandate, or some interesting concept to both of those ideas, whether it's the Egyptian
concept of dominating chaos and perpetuating ma'at or divine order throughout the cosmos,
Zoroastrian ideas that emerge around Iran, where Ahura Mazda gives us these divine mandates,
which sees humanity as the co-creator with Ahura Mazda, the wise lord, the benevolent
lord, we are supposed to take this formless, unproductive chaos of noon in Egypt, or just the
randomness of our material existence, through our will, we can improve our condition. From the paper,
quote, the time span discussed here is long, and the geographical extent of greater Mesopotamia
is wide. We should assume, therefore, that the meanings of particular images shift from case to
case. However, certain broader meanings of this visual tradition seem to have been consistent.
Recurring elements suggest that the imagery is religious in nature. Considering the broader
context of the Neolithic, it is argued that the beliefs and practices reflected in, and possibly
structured by, the images are linked to the process of domestication and sedentism that
characterized the Neolithic. Thus, I employ cognitive universals to interpret meaning to a
point. I argue that these objects had religious significance, and refer to the human position
within the cosmos, in particular, the struggle for increased human control over natural resources.
In the imagery described above, several religious elements can be recognized,
including the importance of a three-tiered cosmos. The tiered cosmos is seen in the repeated set of
bird-animal-snake imagery, each element of which corresponds to one level of the tiered cosmos.
The ritual specialist is the human figure, portrayed with an orant gesture, i.e. an
active agent, and or a distorted head, suggesting costume or transformation.
Soul flight might be alluded to in the bird imagery, and in particular, the composite
bird-human figures as seen, for example, in the Dagirmantepe glyptic. Recognition of these
particular religious elements in the imagery does not affect a definition of Neolithic religion as
a whole, but rather identifies one set of beliefs and practices, among many, that seem to have been
broadly shared throughout the Neolithic period. So if I had to translate this 11,000 year old seal,
or series of symbols, like how individual letters make a word, or string of words convey an idea,
the orant, or active agent, someone doing something, implying what I always describe as a more healthy
view the ancients had of our human will, this praising or just upright human hands figure in
the middle, flanked by the snake energy of the underworld, the chthonic, the below, and the
other side, the raptor, the heavenly energy of the above, mediated by a human who has to do something,
man as the bridge, or negotiator, or master of these two forces. Again, at the exact same time
we are seeing megalithic projects, in other words changing the environment, the rocks themselves,
how you see fit, and domestication, changing plants and animals to suit you. And the author
of this paper is going against a normal materialistic model that just looks at the rise
of civilization as a pure economic event. Quote, down in villages before they began to farm,
in some cases at least, for spiritual reasons, the process of settling down in one place,
of learning to live together, acts to differentiate the village and the house as a home,
as something distinct from the wild. Furthermore, as people did learn to domesticate plants and
animals, that structuralist division of home or domestic in contrast to wild took on a broader
implication, dividing both plants and animals into domestic or wild categories. Humans had taken
these wild forces, the life and death of the earth's wild resources, and learned to control them.
The fact that the human figure so often seen in these images has a distorted head and or an
orant pose, reminds us that the human control over this life cycle has a place within the realm of
religion and ritual. I want to interject here, it's something I get into at the end of this video,
the author goes further than most materialists, but does not seem to entertain the possibility
that non-human intelligences are real, what are just plainly described as spirits or aliens.
If you immediately laugh that off, I don't know what to tell you, I don't think you're looking
into the literature on this, I don't think you're even talking to your own friends and family.
Almost every person I know has some sort of weird ghost or supernatural story or would see
something that would fall in the UFO or alien category. People get triggered when you say you're
open to these ideas because they assume that means you're accepting a whole list of other
things that are connected to spirits or aliens. All I'm saying is that the ancient people say
that that's the reality, that's the dynamic, we're interacting with other non-human forces,
and I have seen stuff myself, I'll get into this at the end of the video.
But back to the paper, as for the geometric patterns, the standard academic answer is,
quote, such imagery is often associated with the first stage of the state of intensified
consciousness, of the type a person would experience in a meditation, a trance, sensory
deprivation, or under the influence of a hallucinogenic drug, formed by the brain into
known experiences. A wavy line could become a snake, for example. Images also transform into
each other, humans into animals and vice versa, for example. This part of the experience in
particular is culturally determined, the known experiences that shape the transformations vary.
In the third stage, a person often has the experience of going through a tunnel,
water, or some other enclosed space, followed by more intense hallucinations.
Rossano asserts that conscious altering experiences trigger part of the brain
associated with memory. Perhaps it is for this reason that such experiences and seals came to
be associated. Stein argues that the associations between seal designs and altered states of
consciousness demonstrate that the seals functioned as personal amulets. The idea,
kind of like I said earlier, that the specific combo of symbols would be like your signature,
your personal symbol to mark things with, like the idea of your personal animal totem,
your spirit animal. Somehow you have a mystical experience and the imagery in there just sticks
with you, it's so stuck in your memory that you just see it as your symbol.
We are left with the question of what happens to the glyptic and related imagery in the late
4th millennium BC when writing is first documented. The focal point of the new
cities were large temple complexes, the priests of which seemed to have held religious and political
power, and also controlled a redistributive economy. This was no longer the religion of
Neolithic villages, but one of a more complex order. The power of the local ritual specialists
and the power of the domestic over the wild was co-opted by the temple. At the same time,
they co-opted the process of storing memory, developing a writing system with techniques
controlled by the temple scribes. In other words, you had something that was very personal. People
were having their own mystical experiences, but also so many of them were similar in core ways
that you could have this shared culture throughout the area. And you might be using these symbols
that were special to you to mark things with them, and this all evolved very organically
and at a smaller local level, even with personal meaning evoked at the individual level.
But as things get more complex, like she says, they are co-opted by the temple.
We need to standardize this whole symbol-communicating thing, and that becomes
writing. Not only does seal use continue alongside writing, but the imagery found
on the Neolithic glyptic likewise continues. The archetypal subject of a powerful human
controlling dangerous forces of nature is seen most obviously in Southern Mesopotamia
in the 3rd millennium as the nude hero motif on cylinder seals. The nude hero, however,
is more closely linked to an increasingly secular kingship than to the religious specialist of the
Neolithic period. The changing social, political, and religious context is reflected in the altered
motif. A theme that will just be with us forever is that once you start domesticating some things,
you gotta worry that you'll be domesticated. And so once people start shaping the terrain,
the rocks themselves, the plants and animals, making them all in their image, having them
serve them, well eventually the priests come along and impose a system on you,
and then the kings come along and impose a system at another level. But these mystical experiences
were so important to the people that they maintained throughout all these different
cultural changes. Quote the archetypal elements from the Neolithic imagery are preserved in
Babylonian myth, as well in particular in the story of Atana, a legendary Sumerian king.
This story, like my interpretation of the Neolithic imagery, revolves around life and
fertility. The Sumerian king Atana desires a child, but must find the plant of birth in order
for his wife to conceive. He is aided by an eagle, whom Atana saves after a conflict with a snake,
the eagle's former friend. The eagle carries Atana on a journey, and the journey is akin
to a soul flight. Atana communicates with animals, he flies through the air, and in the legend,
it is following this flight that he has a visionary dream, in which he and the eagle fly to
the heavens to meet the gods. Soul flight and communication with spirits on behalf of the
community is the most important role of a shaman. This is not to say that Atana is meant to represent
a shaman, but rather that elements of earlier religious belief may be retained in later myth.
Atana and the eagle discover that the plant of birth is not on earth, but in the heavens. Armed
with that knowledge, Atana and the eagle travel to the heavens to retrieve it. In this story,
we have the eagle, the snake, a plant signifying life, soul flight, a tiered cosmos, and dangerous
brushes with death, culminating in, if we understand the fragmented text to end happily,
the renewal of life. The elements of the story may be very old, it may even give us a sense of
an earlier myth that the neolithic images refer to. However, in the Babylonian myth, it is the
gods of the official pantheon who hold the plant that brings life, not the shaman, and it is the
king to whom the gift of life is offered. Similar motifs are found in the Gilgamesh epic, in which
Gilgamesh attains a plant offering eternal life, only to have it stolen by a snake. There we see
the persistent connection between snakes and the renewal of life. I'd add here, if you watch my
video on the strange connection between Sumerian and Chinese myths, the takeaway from them is
exactly the same, that you common people, they use the exact same term, the black headed ones,
the commoners cannot be in control. You guys can't figure this out, you can't be entrusted
with this power. There are gods in heaven who chose one person to be the leader. And so again,
that's what the author here means by this co-opting effect. How do we go from simple,
personal experiences with the mystical, likely your average people just started taking care of
or capturing baby goats, and then slowly they become domesticated, that they notice that the
plants emerge from seeds, they start planting them, even though it takes many, many generations
for it to start changing, and they were all having their own unique mystical experiences,
the spirits seem to be talking to them, and worship was just done on your own,
just talking directly to the spirits, or in your home with your family. How do we go from
that to these enormous temple complexes and priestly class, and this one absolute ruler
over everybody? They need to hijack the existing worldview and all the symbols,
and reframe it so that it supports their rule. You can't not have snake and eagle symbolism,
but now that human in the middle isn't you, that isn't you personally on that seal,
that's your king. The paper continues, quote,
Lamberg-Karlofsky has argued that societies contemporary to the late Uruk actively resisted
the adoption of writing in order to resist the attendant social control of the Mesopotamian
city. They may have also been resisting the co-optation and replacement of their religious
belief systems with that of the centralized temple. Rather than viewing the development
of writing as an evolutionary response to an increasingly complex bureaucracy,
I propose that this milestone was the locus of a struggle for power, both power over information
and memory, and power over religious belief and practice. The author is arguing that writing
didn't just appear because society became more complex, it didn't happen naturally. It's because
certain groups, especially urban temple elites, used it as a tool to control information,
to control memory and religion.
Language codes, information codes, beamed all around us, genetic codes, spanning history.
By controlling the codes, cipher zero intends to unite sans lingua franca.
The world will be torn aside, and then it shall be free.
Older Neolithic societies already had visual and symbolic systems, like seals,
to store meaning and authority, and many of their beliefs and symbols continue into later
urban periods. But as cities formed, religion became centralized in large temples,
fundamentally changing who controlled belief and ritual. Those who couldn't stomach the idea of
being subordinate to one king, or to needing these priestly mediators, would resist this
new system, which at its most basic level was pushing this new idea of writing.
Writing was not an inevitable progress, but a technology developed by one group,
and imposed on another. Simple symbolic representation in proto-writing,
the idea that you have your own little meaningful symbols, that allowed you to still feel like an
individual. But there seemed to be groups that were resistant to taking up foreign writing systems.
As almost all of human history plays out, it's just one group asserting its will over another,
and as much as we hate the chaos, it is very productive, and often leads to ways of life
that we enjoy much later. People in the future, who did not experience the struggle,
will take the thing being fought over as obvious, as the normal and correct way to live.
In the Tepes, all throughout the Turkey region, although we have major sites like Göbekli Tepe,
it's often described as a culture with shrines in the home. Like Göbekli Tepe itself, of course
there were major religious centers, but there was still a very rich, if not more dominant,
domestic religious system, where ancestors were buried under your floor. It was your own father's
skull that was plastered over, sitting in your room, in which you and your direct descendants
made offerings to. You fast forward 10,000 years into the future, and a Christian in this area
may be praying to the father in heaven, at a communal place of worship for the whole town,
and his relatives are buried in one church graveyard, not everyone's ancestors under
their own floorboards. And of course, all this is more neat and organized, and more conducive
to orderly, modern, specialized society. In all this time, between the Tepes and now,
we have the rise of increasingly centralized authorities and religions, from Sumer to Egypt,
to Rome and Mecca. And if you are the type that is critical of these larger,
imposing, more organized religions, you need to be honest with the fact that there is a very good
argument that this civilizing force is often connected with evangelizing. It's the spear
in the clay tablet, the holy book in the sword, the religion and tech advances of the more urban
societies. Whether it be Sumerians getting everybody to write with cuneiform, in this
connection to this whole temple complex and system with kings, or thousands of years later
with the British Empire, militarily expanding, but also in the best case, genuinely well-meaning
Christians that think they're doing good by getting people to speak English and have a
writing system. You see these themes throughout history of a monoculture emerging, swallowing up
tons of local cultures, including their symbols and spiritual beliefs. But to this paper specifically,
the author ends on the note that these three symbols are in a timeless dynamic tension here.
Even if we become a multi-planetary, space-faring people, you will hear people complaining about the
same thing. I mentioned this in the language isolate video too, but the people at the time
saw writing as some new culture-destroying evil. This fear that these people would be losing their
soul, giving up their traditions to be a part of this what, a more convenient system? That leads
to material production perhaps, but at what cost? We might sympathize with these complaints, but also
we can't imagine life without writing. Try and think of how your mind would really work if our
entire society had no writing. We have a hard time understanding how complex societies could even run
without having writing. And I bet most of us would see it as some great moral evil if some private
school said that they wanted their kids to be illiterate, thinking we need some sort of reset,
that this whole economic-driven system really has destroyed the soul, and writing really is just a
You could see people short-circuiting trying to debate them because that's just such a unique
take, and it pulls out some of our own inconsistencies. A lot of us have this vague
opposition to centralized power, but then we're really proud of the progress that these systems
produce. It's all very complicated and often not even examined. Like the so-called pagan influences
that get brought into Christianity or Islam, even with all the power of all these kings and empires
over history, some cultural aspects are so deep that even if 99% of their way of life changes,
you still get some aspects to remain. You got fairies in Catholic Ireland,
djinn in Muslim Saudi Arabia, and so too going 10,000 years back, concepts like the immortal
snake, this person using their will either to reach out their hands and grab the wild beast
and shape them, or to raise them to the heavens for intercession, either way it's a person doing
something, and the divine bird spirit journey tide motif. These symbols are still at the core
of cultures all over the world today. From American symbolism, on the Mexican flag, and tons of other
areas, we see humanity in this position between the force of the snake and the force of the eagle,
and how incredible is it that those are the three images on the oldest example we have
of symbolic character expression? That is the main point of the paper and the takeaway from
this little stone. If you are interested in my personal take on the whole spirits or aliens
aspect of this, I guess a very useful way to think about it, especially in the age of the rise of AI,
is that no matter what you believe, it will be useful to keep in mind the question,
who's domesticating who here? We come to the issue of if we humans domesticated first,
where did this idea come from? Did it come by our own elites in the form of kings or shamans or
or from some non-human intelligence? At the very least, it seems to have come from some
non-conscious intelligence. Maybe it's us, maybe it's our own brains, but I think it's still plenty
fascinating that people feel motivated by forces that they do not fully understand. We've all had
the experience that you get hit by an idea that doesn't seem to come from your fully awake,
conscious, rational mind. Not from you. And so like I said, the author of this paper is going
against the norm in her field that they all just reduce it to economics, that culture changes for
people just on practical concerns. She said they definitely had religious beliefs and maybe were
driven more by these beliefs, but funny enough, doesn't seem to think that they're representing a
real reality, not actual non-human intelligences out there. Quote, the ritual specialist appears
in an altered form, often with a distorted head and exaggerated eyes. The distorted head may
indicate costume, cranial deformation, as seen in some late neolithic burials, or bodily
transformation. The emphasis on the eyes calls to mind the eye idols of Tell Brack, as well as the
third millennium Sumerian votive figures with wide open eyes. The significance of the open eyes is
difficult to assess. Lewis Williams and Peirce assert that an intensified form of vision is a
likely universal experience in an altered state of consciousness experienced during trance. For
example, the eyes of a shaman may be said to appear differently than ordinary eyes, and receive special
treatment after death. So basically they're tripping, they're doing drugs, and their eyes go all
hypno-toed and get all big, big eyes. This is the kind of academic stuff to me that just sounds
interesting at first, but I'm not really impressed that you could come up with some theory. Why is
it that Occam's razor is applied in so many other areas? When it cuts in favor of the standard
academic model, it's seen as obviously true. But when these people are being unscientific, they are
assuming a conclusion before the start. They say obviously spirits aren't real, the gods aren't real,
aliens aren't real. Obviously that's the case, so we can't consider that as an option, even if it
would be the simplest. The tripping on drugs big eye thing does not explain the head binding,
it does not explain examples of things having the wrong amount of fingers, be it six or three or
other numbers, or the very odd proportions, and literally doesn't explain any other part of the
phenomenon except for people's retinas kind of get bigger when they're on drugs. It's like guys,
their eyeballs don't get bigger. You get the point. And so a real takeaway from this video too
is just talk to people, talk to your parents, your friends, ask them if they've ever had a
supernatural experience, a mystical experience, something really weird, ghosts, aliens, UFOs,
whatever it is. I'm sure you're gonna find more people that have had something than haven't had
anything. And like the author mentioned, these mystical experiences are so tied to memory, we
remember them so clearly. Of other events in life that maybe even should be more memorable,
some reason these kind of things stick with us. I'm not sure how to pursue this in a more
scientific way. I've been picking on the academics here, but I totally agree with them that this
whole field of the alien stuff, the spirit stuff, it's just so full of nonsense that I get
the point of not wanting to, I don't know, get into it really, or not taking any of it seriously.
I just don't get the point in dismissing it when, like I said, almost everyone I've met
has had something happen, and then we have it recorded everywhere, all over the world,
all throughout human history. If it was anything else, you would just say it happened, it's real.
That's why I say it's dogmatic. It goes against the bedrock of their worldview.
It's like if somebody's a Jehovah's Witness and they have this experience, it's insanely
profound, everything's supernatural about it, they really do think they experienced a true,
real entity, but that entity says it's Jesus and it tells them to go become a Catholic or
something, they're going to say that was a demon. If everything else in that experience was the
same and it just happened to agree with them, of course they would say this was a real experience,
but you get the point. I get why academics might see looking into all this stuff as a
waste of time, where do you go, where do you get good sources and all that, but I just think you're
never going to have an accurate picture of human history, of our human reality, if you don't
entertain this. If you have ideas for how to study this better or know who is, please comment
them down below. I try to keep a record of these kind of events and I have one here, you can see
this is an email I sent to myself so that it's dated, so that it can't be altered. I saw just
your stereotypical orb when laying asleep, there's no reason why I woke up, I didn't hear anything,
I don't know why, I just wake up, I see a little glowing golf ball sized, yellowish white kind of
orb, it just floats in, we're in the bed, the dog's sleeping right here on the floor and it comes in
and it just goes like this and floats right through the door. I saw it when it was past the
window and dog saw it as it came towards him, dog follows it, literally puts his nose up against the
wall where I saw it go through. Me and another species experienced the same phenomena and it's
the stereotypical orb that you have recorded all throughout human history. There's ancient Chinese
documenting this and there's Egyptians that have this that describe, I forget which part of the
soul, but this is like the fairy thing, they see little glowing orbs in the woods. I know I'm not
making it up, maybe everyone else all throughout human history is making this up, for some reason
that's not a silly conspiracy theory, for some reason it makes more sense in academia to act like
we're all just hallucinating the same thing or it's just anything else, but it can't be,
I don't know, it was an orb, it's a floating, seemingly intelligent acting thing. I always say
I think they just flipped the causal arrow. Of course, I grew up in a culture that knows about
orbs and you've got ghost adventures and all these different shows and you've got orbs and stuff,
I get it, maybe an ancient Egyptian is living in a culture that says that and an ancient Chinese
person and a Roman and an Irish, everybody all throughout history, they're just spoiled,
they couldn't have come up with this on their own, their culture already pushed this idea
of little glowing orb spirits. Why'd they all independently make up this thing? It's so silly,
the causal arrow is backward, it's a real phenomena that is then talked about in that culture.
So, if these people are saying they got the idea for domestication or the idea of writing from the
gods, what are you supposed to make of that? My dad, you could describe as anti-religious,
he thinks it's all very silly and it's a dumbing effect and yet he will tell you with the same
accuracy my whole life, super passionate, that he basically floated above his body and all the
details are the same from something that I've read, an account, an ancient Chinese account,
you would think my dad wrote that. He did not read this account, it's like some super obscure thing,
like I said, causal arrow has been inverted, all these cultures write about it because all these
different people over all this time have experienced it. He floated above the bed,
he said it felt really, really good, crazy pleasure, like just peaceful state, like he's
never had anything close to that, but also the sense that if he relaxed into that or if he just
wanted to be there, he couldn't get back to the body. He floated above it, he literally saw down
the whole room, just like people say out-of-body experiences. There is actually pretty interesting
scientific literature on that, so shout out to the standard academics, people are trying to
look into that more. But you get the quote from the paper, that bird-headed human figures and
Pleistocene imagery likely referred to shaman's soul flight, and she's saying because this concept
and all these different cultures that these shamans have, they're hallucinating that they're
out of their body. Of course, the academics are going to say they didn't really get out of their
body, there's no spirit that can get out of your body. So because they hallucinated going up into
the air, they were like a bird, they became like a bird or like a bird energy. So the way to express
that is to say, look, I was a human, but like I had wings, like it was my mind, I had in my human
mind, but also bird abilities. And so you express that by showing this human-bird mix. And similarly
with like the human-fish people, there's this idea that they're going underwater. If I want to convey
to you that it's a person, it's like a thinking, active being like us, but you know that lives
underwater, that goes underwater, I show it as a human and a fish, has the properties of a human
and a fish, which I would say is more tied to modern UFO stories. There's all kinds of accounts
of ships coming out of the water. And again, to my point that you need a larger conspiracy where
you're going against Occam's razor to say that all these people are making up the aliens with the
giant eyes kind of thing. So again, you've got wisdom, knowledge, writing, these gifts to humanity,
these benevolent, something's giving tech or advancements to people, whether that's Enki,
whether that's, you know, Athena with the owl imagery with the big eyes, right? It all just
maps on so well to this stuff that these academics are just absolutely allergic to.
They don't want to look into it at all. So ironically, you leave this to the domain
of kind of the more, how do I put this nicely, imaginative, less disciplined, less, uh,
less, insert a nice word for intelligent people here. They are the best people to
go to when it comes to aliens and spirits because they're the only people talking about it.
Hopefully if you share that frustration, uh, like and subscribe and all that,
because this channel will not be avoiding those interpretations of things.
I think it needs to be included. I don't want to, you know, make up anything or like over
exaggerate or dwell only in that. Like I said, I get annoyed by how that happens in different
communities too, but I also think maybe we can add and kind of help academia by making it more
holistic, more inclusive of all these different ideas. But also the main point of the video,
again, how incredible the oldest example we have of proto writing is snake, human,
Eagle, these three forces that are still so prominent in imagery today.
Thanks again. I'll see you in the next one.
