2024 Mazda CX-5 Review | Better Than a CX-50?

POP Cars
24 followers
3 Video Views·May 3, 2026
We're driving a 2024 Mazda CX-5. It's a compact SUV. Coming up, is this thing better than the
similarly sized and much, much newer Mazda CX-50? Also, a new solution to one of our greatest CX-5
complaints. Let's begin with interior. Much like the CX-50 we drove not too long ago, this is a
very simple and clean aesthetic. For some people, it may be too plain. I like it because it makes
the bold touches really stand out like this metallic bit and the red stitching. I don't
really care for this shiny black plastic. It really shows off the dust and fingerprints.
What I do like is how nice most of this vehicle feels. It's nice and squishy and soft. The volume
knob here or even like the window switches and everything has a premium feel. Moving to practical
concerns, I wish there were power ports up here so you could set a phone in an obvious spot.
However, we do have wireless phone connectivity and we're going to talk more about that in a
second. You could have a phone wirelessly connected here and then charge it on the
wireless phone charger. If you have a second phone, you can put it in here. You've got a USB-C port
and then there's these little slots dug out so you can run a wire out in case you need access
to your phone. There is good door storage. There's a sock pocket up top. Down below,
you have room for a bottle and various other crap. The seats are comfortable but definitely
on the firm side. I also wish there was a little more lateral support given how quickly you're
likely to drive this. In the upper shoulder region, it doesn't hold me in place quite as well
as I might prefer. Seated behind my ideal front seat position, I've got just enough knee clearance.
Headroom is actually pretty good. I'm five foot ten with a long torso. That middle position with
that center hump could be a little bit difficult for an adult but it's perfectly sized for our
child. Kiddo, how did you like sitting in that middle spot? Very comfortable except the front
room with the big hump is kind of... Thank you for weighing in and now back to snacking.
One thing we have in the CX-5 that we do not have in the CX-50 is a recline function. Now,
it's not an elaborate recline function. It's two position but I do like the fact that you can get
a little extra lean if you are so inclined and I'm normally so inclined. For cargo space, there
are 30.8 cubic feet. There are much roomier options. CR-V and RAV4 both come to mind but for
our family, it's actually plenty of space and I really like how it's organized in that 40-20-40
split gives you a lot of flexibility for expanding that space. They've got those little remote
releases in the back including for that middle 20 position. It's a two height load floor and the
difference between the low height and the high height is so minuscule as to kind of negate the
function. Just like make it one height, save yourself the engineering Mazda. I really like
the lower height because it helps keep things from sliding out the back after you've been
driving around with, say, a trunk full of groceries. There is just a little bit of underfloor
cargo space, some cargo nooks on the side, and then also we have an actual spare tire back there
which seems to be increasingly rare in new vehicles. What about getting our booster seat
installed? The latch points don't have covers but they are slightly inset so it's a little
tricky to get it installed. I also wonder if it might be a little narrow for a rear-facing car
seat. Child, how do you find climbing in and out of the Mazda CX-5? Easy because it's super low
and the door opens pretty pretty wide. I also like the fact that the doors cover the sills so
if you drive up here in the mountains and you get a bunch of like mud and dirt and like snow and
stuff on the outside of the vehicle, when you get in the vehicle you probably won't get that stuff
on your leg. As for safety, the CX-5 rates strongly a five-star overall from the NHTSA
and it is a top safety pick from the IIHS. It also includes a full suite of active driver assist and
six airbags. Family, what do we think? Is the CX-5 family friendly? Small family friendly. Rear window
test. Almost all the way down. Armrest test. Driving in a comfortable eight and four, I can't
touch either of the armrests with my inboard or outboard elbows. But they're so squishy. Well,
they're pretty squishy but if you push a little bit you can feel that there's some real hardness
hiding underneath. Same deal on the outside. This edge here, if you get underneath that cushioning,
pretty firm. Because of reach issues and hidden imposter hardness, I'm gonna go 44% inboard.
I never do 44, that's weird. No, I'm gonna go with it. 44% inboard and let's say 57% outboard.
Hey, would you like to see more videos like this where we review cars as a family plus the
occasional helicopter adventure? If so, you are welcome to subscribe. Style! I really like the
style of the CX-5. I think there is a cohesive look to it, like the way this curve in the front
mimics this curve in the rear. They did a very good job when they designed this thing eons ago
for the 2017 model year. This is the eighth year the second generation CX-5 has been on the market.
They did an update in 2022 just to kind of refresh things but this is a very old design.
Want to know a secret? What's that? I like this better than the newer Mazda designs.
Want to know a secret? Yes. I disagree. I know. But I mean that does speak to the enduring quality
of the current CX-5's design. A couple paint thoughts. We got that red sole metallic on our
tester and I think that is the most beautiful red in the automotive industry. Dude! Oh, you're just
jealous. Yeah, you wish you were sole red metallic. Oh, and then for 2024 they have added a couple of
colors. You can now get your CX-5 in platinum quartz metallic and then also zircon sand,
previously only available on the CX-50, is available on the CX-5 but only if you go with
the carbon turbo trim. That carbon turbo trim is also new for 2024. Despite its incredible age,
we really like the look of the CX-5, although her more than me. But what do you think? Do you like
the CX-5? If so, if no, tell us in the comments section in motion. Driving the CX-5, I think it
rides pretty darn well, especially for a vehicle that's incredibly old. It has a more sophisticated
suspension. It's got a multi-link rear, unlike the CX-50 which has a torsion beam rear and yet
I prefer how the CX-50 drives. To me it feels a little more connected with the road. So even though
they're working with maybe less sophisticated parts, the tuning I think and probably the chassis
overall is more developed. Which is not to say this is uncomfortable to drive. I just prefer the CX-50.
Now when we get into these corners here, things get a little bit more nuanced. Notice
I can move the steering wheel and not much happens. It's not because it's a slow steering
ratio. It's a 15.5 to 1 ratio. That's only slightly slower than we experienced in the CX-50.
I think what we're experiencing there is like some looseness. To be clear, my expectation is not that
this drives like a sports car, because I don't expect that from SUVs and I don't expect that from
Mazda certainly anymore. But when you offer an input to the vehicle, what you want as the driver
is to get a response. Because when you know the vehicle is listening to you and responding as you
expect in the time you expect, that breeds confidence. All that said, we're going around
the corner just fine and most people won't care about all those nuances. And to Mazda's credit,
they do some really great stuff with electronics. A feature called G-Vectoring Control, which
imperceptibly reduces torque to put a little bit of weight on the front tires as you're entering a
corner when you're steering. And it's all imperceptible. But you feel like the car is just
sort of going around the corner in a predictable fashion. Bonus points to Mazda for getting all
that data and making it work. You somehow make that sound naughty. Oh, so many zeros and ones.
The last time we drove a CX-5, it had the naturally aspirated engine. And to us, that revealed some of
the lack in the transmission. With only six ratios, when you go between those gear changes,
you could really feel like it would have to kind of build its steam again. Here, because you've
got that turbocharged engine and a lot more power to work with, when you get those gear changes,
you just kind of keep rolling. In day-to-day operation, the six-speed automatic works fine,
reasonably quick reactions, fairly smooth gear shifts. But for best operation, it is really
ideally paired with that turbocharged engine. On the S Premium trims and above, you have three
different drive modes to choose. That off-road setting is an interesting one. It's really to
make it feel more like it does on-road when you're off-road, which is enhancing stability.
Ground clearance for a compact SUV is reasonable, but I would be concerned about underbody protection
if I were driving this thing in real off-roading. So, you know, keep it on mellow trails. Or don't,
actually. A buddy of mine, Dave Coleman, who works at Mazda, before they introduced the CX-50,
actually did some pretty bad off-roading in a CX-5. It was really impressive. I took that
more as a triumph of the human spirit than as a notch in the CX-5's belt. Maybe a little of both.
And I have grown tired of hearing myself speak. Let's see what Ebi thinks. Ebi's at the wheel.
Does the vehicle fit you okay? It does. I do feel like I could maybe be higher.
Well, you do have a little bit of an adjustment there. And you have actually raised something
that I think is really interesting. You keep talking about the... The seat?
Yes. Sorry. So interesting. You can, like, put a butt in it and everything.
No, we were talking about seat height between the CX-50 and the CX-5. The seat here is 5.7 inches
higher, which is a substantial amount, than the CX-50. So you may experience a more commanding
view than you might in the CX-50. Do you feel like you got enough power?
I do. And it sounds very powerful. The last time we drove it, you thought that the Mazda CX-5 had
merely adequate power. And that was the base engine that did not have a turbocharger. You
thought it just kind of sounded noisy. Noise without acceleration is just noise.
But when you couple it with real thrust, it can be exciting.
Yes. Why are you doing that?
For no reason. Sweetie, what's happening over here?
Let's move this along. How do you feel about the steering?
There's a little bit of a dead space on centers. So it's not turning right away,
which I don't really care for. Do you feel like it's a manageable amount of effort?
It is a bit on the heavy side, but luckily I'm very strong.
I'm laughing because of an unrelated joke.
How do you feel about visibility? The windows are on the small side,
but the view out is still good. The pillars are physically smaller.
It's one of the tells that you're in a car that's been on the market for a while.
If we were in the market to buy a compact SUV, would you feel comfortable driving a Mazda CX-5?
I would. Sweetie's feeling comfortable.
I'm getting back in the driver's seat. In total, the CX-5, despite being very old,
is still a very pleasant day-to-day driver. Onward to remarks.
Infotainment. We have a standard 10.25 inch screen,
high mounted, close to driver's field of view, primarily operated through this knob down here.
But as teased in the beginning of the video, for 2024, Mazda has introduced a fix for the
thing that annoyed us the most about the CX-5. I really don't mind using the knob for this,
but for Apple CarPlay, which is an inherently touchable system, I would love to touch it.
And now you can. Yay!
And you've started an audio book. Very good. Apple CarPlay and Android Auto come standard
with this system, and there's also wireless functionality, which is super cool.
That touch functionality is only meant for your smartphone connectivity,
and by default, you can only use it when the vehicle is parked or driving at a very,
very slow speed. If you would like to use the touch screen functionality above just a creep
speed, like at normal driving speed, here's how you do it. Using the wheel settings, connectivity
settings, Bluetooth iPhone connectivity settings, then you have to select your specific device,
Micah's iPhone, and then scroll way down to the bottom, touch screen in motion for all devices,
select that. And now, after we accept that warning, when we go back to the main screen,
we're going to go to Apple CarPlay. I'm doing 10-ish. There we go. Still able to do it.
Although I'm going to stop because I'm going to run into this wall.
If you would appreciate added functionality like that, you might also appreciate
Flying Eyes Eyewear. Their unsurpassed flexibility, durability, and comfort are
one of the reasons why it's the only eyewear I'll wear in a helicopter.
If you'd like to learn more about Flying Eyes Eyewear, click the link in the description below.
What we learned in our last CX-5 video is that the CX-5 inspires a lot of knob-related passion.
Which is not what it sounds like, but if you still love the knob, that's totally fine,
but I love that Mazda listened and gave everybody else who prefers to touch their
CarPlay or Android Auto the option to do so. Well done, Mazda.
Also teased in the beginning of the video, we were going to talk about whether or not the CX-5,
despite its incredible age, is better than the CX-50, which is much, much newer and similarly
sized. The CX-50 has a much more contemporary exterior design. The interior is more modern
and offers just a little bit extra cargo space. It's also more capable off-road,
and I prefer the CX-50's off-road manners to the CX-5.
Countering all that in the CX-5's favor, it is similarly sized to the CX-50. It is $1,000
less on virtually every trim across the board. Unlike the CX-50, when you get in and you start
the engine, it doesn't automatically start beeping at you, and it's called a CX-5,
so it's got name recognition. If it were me, I would go with the CX-50 over the CX-5.
However, my opinion does not align with reality, because more people bought CX-5s in 2023 than
bought CX-50s. Literally three times as many people bought the CX-5. So no, the CX-5 is not
better than the CX-50, but it doesn't matter. All right, let's talk engine choices. The base
engine is a 2.5 liter inline 4-cylinder. There's a new feature for 2024 called I-STOP, which is
basically automatic engine start-stop. Fuel economy is somewhat better. Then there's that
turbocharged version of the 2.5 liter that we've got in our tester. That comes on the
carbon turbo trim and higher. With either engine, all-wheel drive and a six-speed automatic
transmission come standard, and if you want to tow with either engine, it maxes out at 2,000 pounds.
Sweetie. Yes? Will you share our trim recommendation? Oh, should I? Yes. Okay,
great, great, great, great. Our trim recommendation is which trim will give you the essential features
you would regret not getting, but at the lowest possible price. For 2024, Mazda has ditched their
former base S trim. Now, the 2.5 S Select is the entry trim, and that's our trim recommendation.
It includes dual-zone climate control, rear vents, leatherette seating, heated front seats,
a power driver's seat, and smart key access, though I wish you could just grab the door handle
to unlock the doors rather than having to push a button. If you're ready to buy a CX-5 of your very
own, click the Kelley Blue Book pricing link in the description below to see what your current
car is worth for trade-in and what you should pay for a CX-5. As for compact SUV competitors,
there's the Honda CR-V, Kia Sportage, Toyota RAV4, and the Mazda CX-50. Did we miss any remarks?
If so, tell us in the comments section. And now, it is our daughter's time to shine. Kiddo,
can you tell us what is your favorite feature of the Mazda CX-5? The rear seat heater buttons.
They're so much fun to push. Do you care about having your seat heated? No. You just like pushing
the button? Yeah, it's fun. And that was Kiddo's favorite feature. Family, I think we've done a
good job reviewing the CX-5. May I have a five? And a five. And you can get your high-five. Bam!
