🔹 Online Training: Access our comprehensive training programs anytime with Shield K9 Online. Our structured courses are designed for all skill levels, ensuring effective training from the comfort of your home.
🔹 Exclusive Content: See unedited training sessions and behind-the-scenes content by joining us on Patreon. Support us and get insider access to our training methods!
🔹 No Nonsense Training Book: Prefer a hands-on approach? Our No Nonsense Dog Training Book is packed with practical tips and techniques to help you train your dog effectively.
🔹 High-Quality Training Gear: Equip yourself with the best training gear from our Shop. Our products are designed for quality and durability to enhance your training experience. Subscribe to our channel for the latest tips, techniques, and updates. Hit the notification bell so you never miss a new video!
Alright guys, I can only pick one of these dogs.
I'm going to drop the one that I'm not going to pick.
Malabars always land on their feet, right?
Yeah, yeah, yeah.
Whoa!
I know a lot of people are going to see this thing,
and they're going to say,
I want one, this is going to be a fantastic family pet.
Don't do that, okay?
This is a working dog,
and I know she looks sweet as pie right now,
but she will make your life
a living hell
if you don't know what you're doing.
So if you get one of these dogs,
you better have a job in mind,
and you better have training
lined up for the dog from someone
that actually knows
what they're doing.
Hey guys, Paz here at Shield Canine,
and a lot of you have been asking me
why I prefer the German Shepherd.
And today, I'm going to tell you.
So number one, I like the German Shepherd
because I'm not gay.
And if you are, there's nothing wrong with that.
But my preference is the German Shepherd.
But in all seriousness, there's a lot of debate out there.
German Shepherd or Belgian Malabar.
Now, both breeds have a lot of similarities,
but they also have a lot of differences.
So I'm going to tell you guys today
why my preference, after having both,
is, to this day,
the German Shepherd.
There's a number of reasons why I see
a lot of people jumping into the Belgian Malabar.
So number one,
they can make you look good
in relatively short order.
There's a number of traits that the Belgian Malabar has
that makes them really,
really easy to train.
They can become very, very flashy
without you maybe being an expert trainer.
So that's why you see a lot of young trainers
getting themselves a Belgian Malabar right away.
I know I'm going to hurt a few feelings.
I know I'm going to ruffle some feathers with this one.
But at the end of the day, I'm going to call it the way it is.
It's the same when I see trainers
getting themselves like a Border Collie.
Generally, the reason that they're doing that is because,
you know, it's easy to make the dog look good with training
and then imply that you're able
to train every dog like that.
So there's a couple of things about the Belgian Malabar
that make them like that. Number one,
they tend to be really intense, right?
They tend to be very, very intense dogs,
very, very high-energy dogs, you know,
and very, very willing to work.
They are neurotic. They love,
and I mean that in the best sense,
they're neurotic in that they love patterns.
They love doing the same thing over and over and over again.
And they're very obsessive.
So their love of patterns actually makes it
very easy to get them addicted
to behavior, especially when you give them
drive satisfaction within that behavior.
And then the dog really will
perform those behaviors with high levels of
enthusiasm, and it's not particularly
difficult to do that with the Malinois just because
of the way that they're wired. And the other reason
why people love the Belgian Malinois
is because they are sensitive.
So they're intense, they're addicted to patterns,
and they're also sensitive, which means
it doesn't take a lot of pressure
to get the dog to stop doing
something or to change the way a dog
is doing something. So let's say they're doing something
maybe slightly incorrect, it's easy
to apply the pressure in such a way that it makes
the dog more correct, and it's not
difficult at all. So the other thing that you'll see
with Belgian Malinois is the drive comes in
early, and the neurotic behavior
comes in early, as in they start showing
that as early as six to eight weeks
of age. So you're able to start training a lot
sooner, and they're able to absorb information
seemingly, especially when compared
to maybe a working line German Shepherd, a lot
faster. So again, they speak to that instant
gratification side of human nature,
right, where we want as much
as possible, as soon as possible, and
we don't want to wait. Whereas with German Shepherds, sometimes,
in fact, most of the time, you have to
let them mature to some degree, right?
Your typical eight-week-old German
Shepherd is not hanging off of
everything, they're not maybe showing all the
drive that a comparable eight-week-old
Belgian Malinois would be showing. And it has nothing
to do with the overall quality of the dog, it's just that
they develop a little bit more slowly.
So people that kind of want that instant gratification,
they get the Belgian Malinois. The other thing
is the Belgian Malinois is super sensitive, right?
It doesn't take a lot of pressure to get them
to stop doing the wrong thing, and it doesn't take
a lot of pressure to get them doing something
that they're already doing in a better
way. All that being said, now I know
you guys are going to be like, well, Haz, you're really
describing an awesome dog. Like, why
wouldn't you get a Belgian Malinois? Well,
there's a couple of reasons for me why
I choose not to get a Belgian Malinois. Number one, at this
point in my career, I don't need a Belgian Malinois
to make me look good. I think, to be honest
guys, like, I don't know any other
dog YouTuber that really does the
working line German Shepherds the way I do that
actually competes with them, that actually, you know, performs
at a high level with these dogs, and I understand
why. I mean, at the end of the day,
these dogs, they don't think the same way
as a Malinois. They are not as sensitive
as a Belgian Malinois. So, a lot of people
think, oh, you know, German Shepherds, they're more
forgiving. Yes, they're more forgiving, right?
In the sense that you can put more pressure on them,
you can make mistakes with them that maybe
you couldn't make with a Malinois because they're less
sensitive, so it'll have maybe less of an adverse
impact, but on the other side, they're more
independent. They're generally less
addicted to patterns. So, getting
them to the point where they're performing with
heart and soul, as some people like
to say, in a trial, in the work,
that's what truly takes
talent and a true understanding of the
working drives of the dog. New puppy?
Don't know where to start?
Nipping, biting, peeing,
barking, doesn't listen? Fast
effective puppy training that actually works.
Think Shield
K9. Open.
You guys all know
Chico here. He's a beautiful dog, and that's
the other thing. I like substantial dogs,
and I know you can get big Belgian Malinois,
but, you know, I've always said, if you see a Belgian
Malinois walking on the side of the road,
the average person would probably assume it's
a stray dog, right? Because, let's face it,
they look very different, whereas if someone saw this guy
walking on the road, they're going to be like, man, somebody
lost their valuable dog because he's a beautiful dog.
Now, I know some people are going to say, has, you're biased.
That's not true. Malinois are
beautiful. Beauty's in the eye of the beholder,
but let's face it, the average person, when they see this
dog, and when they see your average Malinois,
there is no comparison. And,
at the end of the day, we're human beings,
right? We have perception of
aesthetics, and I personally
prefer the aesthetic look of the German Shepherd,
especially a beautiful one like Chico,
over your average Belgian Malinois.
The other thing that I really like about the
German Shepherd is they don't just give you
everything right away. You have to work
for it. You have to understand them. You have
to know how to bring that drive
out. You have to know how to get that dog
giving you 110%. You have
to intimately understand the drive
behavior of the dog, as well as how and
when to apply the pressure in order to get the
optimal performance from the dog. There
is the reason that the sport of IGP
was originally invented for this dog.
There is a reason that this dog is so
iconic, right? This is, for
me, the ultimate in working dog
because they have that combination
of mental clarity. They have
all the same level, especially in a high-quality
version, such as Chico. They have
all the same level of drive
and commitment that a Belgian Malinois has, but
they have a little more substance, a little
more power, right? Yep!
And there's just more there,
harder to get. It's a little more challenging,
and that's why I prefer
the German Shepherd, right? Now, as
someone that loves
drivy dogs, as someone that loves
dogs that are intense, I definitely
appreciate the Belgian Malinois. Don't get me wrong.
I've lived with Belgian Malinois for years.
You can see this little 10-week-old puppy, how
committed she is. She wants the toy
right at this early age, you know.
She's all in on biting
that tug, and that level of
drive and commitment is a beautiful thing to see.
But, there is more to
a dog than just drive and
commitment. There needs to be a brain.
There needs to be a brain, and
that brain is, for me,
the difference, fundamentally,
between the German Shepherd and the Belgian Malinois.
So, now, I know at this point, you guys are going to ask me,
Haz, I want a Belgian Malinois. Do you
recommend them for first-time dog owners?
No, I recommend Belgian Malinois
not for the first-time dog owner, but for the
aspiring dog trainer, or maybe the young
dog trainer that's starting out, because they can make
you look good, you know. You don't have to be
the best trainer. That Belgian Malinois is going to
be, if it's a half-decent dog, and your training
is, like, halfway decent, the dog
will look flashy. The dog, you know,
will make a nice picture. You'll be able to make
those cool Instagram reels with the dog.
So, you know, I totally understand why you see a lot
of aspiring trainers get themselves a Belgian Malinois,
but I think, one day, every
dog trainer out there grows up
and gets themselves a real dog, the
Working Line German Shepherd. Foose,
the
Working German Shepherd is full
power. There is absolutely
no comparison. When you have
one of these dogs that's firing on all
cylinders, it's a beautiful thing
to behold, it's a beautiful thing to experience,
and once you go Shepherd, you'll
never go back. You know, there's a lot of rumors
out there about the overall health of these
dogs. I'm going to tell you from my perspective
and from my experience, I have found
just as many health
problems with the Belgian Malinois, sometimes
they can be a little bit different, as with the
German Shepherd. Kia. Good.
Kia. Good.
Kia. Kia.
Good. Foose.
Good.
Absolutely no comparison.
And I had, for those of you that
want to go down the YouTube rabbit hole, I
actually had a really, really nice pair of
Malinois. I had a male and a female
that I lived with for years. The
male was named Bastion, the female was named
Nova, and there's videos of them maybe
eight, nine years ago on my YouTube channel,
so you can see that I really did this with
Belgian Malinois. I live with them, you know, I have
a lot of experience with them. Obviously,
lately, for the last few years, I've been living with German
Shepherds, and for me, the German Shepherd, hands down,
better family dog, better dog in
life, and more enjoyable for
me personally to work. That being said,
I still appreciate a good Malinois. It's just
at this time, not for me. As you
can see, guys, I mean, these puppies are three weeks apart.
This is a Malinois puppy, and this is a German Shepherd
puppy. I think the German Shepherd puppy just realized
there's another puppy here. I think the Malinois is still
looking at the toy on the ground and has no clue
as to what's going on. As you guys can see,
they are actually fairly similar
looking. One just looks like a stray dog,
and the other one looks like, you know, the
product of multiple generations
of intentional breeding. That's really
it. But other than that,
I think you guys should pick whichever dog
you like, and I'm happy to train it either way.
As long as the dog has drive, commitment,
and a strong heart, that's the most important thing.
Oh, let's not forget good health, but that goes
without saying. All that being said,
I hope you guys enjoyed the video.
I hope you guys took it in good fun
the way it was intended, and I'll see you guys
on the next one.
Whoop!