Indexed Universal Life Insurance (IUL) vs Whole Life Insurance Which Is BETTER?

Finance Shield
6 followers
7 Video Views·May 2, 2026
Hey everyone, it's Caleb Williams here, the author of The And Asset. I am here in Arizona
in the Life 180 studio with my good friend, Chris Kirkpatrick.
Hey guys.
And what we're going to do is we're going to break down a common question. It's IUL
versus whole life. I wrote a book on a strategy on how you can overfund whole life, use it as
the best place to save your money, have that money grow the rest of your life, be able to utilize it
to buy the things, invest in the things that you care about, have it show up powerfully in
retirement, protect the most important asset, which is yourself. And what I've found is a lot
of people are actually using my book to promote their product. And a lot of it is indexed universal
life. It's definitely the most popular thing being sold on the market right now. And there's a lot of
things that you need to know about this. I will openly say, I don't want you using this strategy,
using IUL. And the hope is that we can just have a conversation as it relates to how that works,
the difference. And the reason why Chris is here is, and you can kind of share your story.
Yeah, absolutely.
But you used to sell a lot of this and you recruit for index universal life. And I think
we need to be fair. It's not for us to just say, it's all bad. It's all garbage. We'll be very
ignorant. And I already know that this video is going to get a lot of hateful comments. And so
I want to be open-minded as well. But I also want us to take a step back and really think through
not just what the illustrations look like, but what is actually going to happen in 20 years.
Yeah. I mean, you just hit the nail on the head. So for everybody who doesn't know my background,
I used to be licensed. I used to sell insurance. I was the head of recruiting and development for
a Fortune 1000 life insurance company, broker dealer. Their focus was IUL. They were one of
the top IUL manufacturers, producers, sellers in the world, in the country, I guess, because we're
pretty much the only country that really focuses on these. So we could say the world. But the
bottom line with this is there's a lot of people out there that are selling this as an investment.
And I want to say right out of the gate, that's just thinking about it wrong. If you've watched
any of our content, if you ever think you're going to buy an insurance product to be a pure
investment, and that's how you're buying it or you're buying it for that purpose, I would say
you're going about it the wrong way. And if any insurance agent is trying to sell you
that this should be an investment, then I would look to talk to somebody else,
because they don't understand all the moving parts to this. So there's a couple things here.
So what I'm passionate about, while I used to go around and I used to sell this before I understood
what I understood, and when I used to recruit people and train people and teach people how
to structure IULs to be kind of across the map, all the different structures that you can do,
and they are very flexible. You can do a lot of crazy things. And what I would say is this,
what I love, if you've watched our How to Structure a Whole Life Policy, we got a couple
different versions out there now, you look at the illustration and you see the guaranteed column and
you see the non-guaranteed column, and they're pretty close. But the difference with a whole
life policy, when you look at the non-guaranteed column, I could make an argument that the
non-guaranteed column is gonna actually be less than actually performs in the future. It may not
be, but there could be arguments made either way. The good news is that the guaranteed column,
you could get that contract, you could get a whole life policy utilizing the guaranteed column,
and you're never gonna be hurt, right? You're gonna be in a better situation. And so for me,
one of the things that made my shift in my life away from being an IUL advocate and turning into
a whole life advocate was I never wanna have to look at my clients in the eyes 10 years from now
when they're hitting retirement and feel like I got them into a product that actually had any
chance of hurting them. Yeah, and this is what I would say, two things. Number one is when I
was running the bank's investment department, I actually helped bail out another agency,
and guess what? Everyone was being sold these UL policies, and they were all getting letters in the
mail saying, if you don't put X amount of money, you're gonna lose. They saw it as their retirement
account, but they're gonna lose their whole thing. Well, let's talk about why. But then the second
thing is I get sick and tired of people saying, oh, I do whole life and universal life, and for
those people that are super conservative, they don't wanna lose anything, I put their money in
life, and everyone else who has a little bit of risk tolerance, Chris, you and I have pretty high
risk tolerance. I have maybe the highest risk tolerance of anybody I know. I have a company,
we work with people all around the country, I'm investing in things, we're putting hundreds of
thousands of dollars in marketing. I have a pretty high risk tolerance. If someone tells you that,
they have no clue what they're talking about because they're seeing life insurance as the end
result, and you will lose if you think a product is going to help you long term,
and that's gonna be the end thing. So sorry. No, dude, you just hit the nail on the head.
I think it's key to understand. So going back to the ultimate flexibility, you can design an IUL
to look similar to a whole life policy. But the thing when you can take a whole life illustration
to the bank, you can never trust an IUL illustration. And I will say, you can make
IUL illustration look like almost anything you want it to look like. And they can be conservative.
I can tell you one of the practices with the company that I was with, the people would go in
and be like, okay, let's be really conservative. Let's illustrate this thing at 6%. And that's
their idea of conservative is 6%. And so that doesn't account for the fees and everything that
goes into the IUL contract. Now, the part about this that's crazy is when you get a whole life
contract with a mutually held whole life company, I should add, those guarantees are ironclad. You
are like a stockholder in that mutual company. You're part of it. That's what that
contract is. With an IUL, unlike with a whole life, the insurance company takes the risk.
They're offsetting that risk to you, to the policyholder. So if you look really close at the
details, yeah, the fees or the return of 6%, if that's what you're illustrating it at, and they'll
tell you, well, the average rate of return over the past 80 years or 30 years or whatever it is,
is over 8%. So I'm going to be really conservative and I'm going to show you 6%. Some of me will go
crazy and go like 5.5%. But that still doesn't tell the whole story because the fees, if you
really look at the fine print, they're not guaranteed. The fees are never guaranteed in
those. There always is an option. First of all, with an IUL, every single year, you're getting
like yearly renewable term. That's what you're doing. So every single year, your cost of insurance
goes up, period. They go up, but they can even go even higher. Well, the cost of insurance
goes up, but then there are internal administration fees that they never tell you about, that they
have complete ability to jack up the rates on those for you. The bottom line is, we don't have
enough time to get into all the moving parts. Let's go back to the philosophy. You said this,
but I want to highlight it again. Whole Life, and we have a lot of videos, there's a lot of
Whole Life that's not being sold, right? So I'm not making a blanket statement here, but Whole
Life, the insurance company, keeps the risk. The insurance company that is in the business of risk
management. Index Universal Life, or Universal Life, is what they're saying is, they're shifting
the risk over to you, and that is the big difference. Yes, there's levers and fees on
the UL that can go up, and yes, the index may not... That's not even the big point. Long-term,
life insurance is not an investment. It's a place to store capital. It's a place to protect your
money. It's a place to... There's a lot of other... It's the ultimate and asset, and on one side,
you can have a company that's been in business over 100 years managing that risk, taking key
things off the table for you, or you could roll the dice and put your money in something that's
not an investment, but at this point, you could just call it an investment. For sure, and so with
IULs, I'll say this is another thing that agents do, and what you just said sparked this in my
brain is they'll say, okay, the whole concept is you get a range, and I don't know exactly at this
very moment what companies are doing, but it's usually you have a floor of zero, so they sell
you on the fact that you can never lose money. If the market goes down, it's in an indexed fund, so
if the market goes negative 20%, you're capped at zero. On the upside, maybe the market does 25%,
but you're going to be capped at 12% or 13% or whatever that would be, so the pitch is would
you be okay guaranteeing that you're never going to have a negative year? You're not going to have
those massive 25%, 30% years, but is that worth it to you if you can get maybe an average
eight and never have a negative year? That's the pitch, right? Right, and it's valid. If we just
look at the index, it's a valid argument. Absolutely, but that doesn't look at the fees.
The thing is a zero year for you if you buy that policy is not zero because there are still fees,
and if you have multiple zero years in a row, which quite frankly, if you have a policy for
30, 40 years, you're going to have that happen from time to time, maybe a couple times during
your policy. If you have a couple zero years in a row, they have the ability to up the fees,
up the administration costs. Those fees will eat into your insurance costs, all the while,
every year, your insurance costs are going up, so that compounds the loss. It's really not
a zero-sum kind of situation, and it's really ... The idea that you never want to interrupt
compounding, there is zero capability for an IUL to guarantee that you will never interrupt
compounding, even though they sell you on the fact that it will. Another big issue that I see with
IUL is, number one, a lot of people are selling it as a banking strategy. You could do this,
my strategy or the strategy that we teach with IUL. By the way, if anyone's sharing with you
that you can bank with it, there's added risk there because now you're usually dealing with
a loan arbitrage. It's really kind of shady stuff. Even Nelson Nash, the founder of the
infinite banking concept, was very anti-universal life for that reason. Then if you take a step
back and say, okay, I'm going to do universal life as an investment alternative, then how do these
things perform in retirement? Because let's just say you have a million dollars. Let's just say
you have a million dollars of cash value. How are we illustrating that in retirement, and what are
the risks that you could face when you hit retirement? The risks are huge. When you talk
about ... There's this whole idea of order of returns that are important. When you retire,
if the market goes negative and you're using an IUL as an income-based strategy, which is quite
frankly why everybody buys them. It's how everybody's selling them is based on income, tax-free
income at retirement. There's all sorts of content out there on that. I would just caution you
against that. What happens is, and I've seen it. Trust me, I've seen this so many times.
You were in the business.
It's mind-blowing. It's astounding to me that it's even legal to sell it in this way because
so many problems happen from it. Let's just say you had a million dollars in cash,
in accessible cash, in a policy, and you're 65 and you're looking to retire, and you want to use
that. They're going to be able to illustrate out of that. My numbers are going to be probably off,
but the ballpark would be close enough for a conversation. You might be able to pull out
$60,000 a year, $80,000 a year, which according to Monte Carlo simulations, seems really good
because if you look at all of Monte Carlo methodologies out there, if they say 4%
distribution on a million, that's a pretty conservative long-term gain. To be able to
illustrate 6% to 8%, once again, on paper, looks pretty amazing.
Yeah, tax-free.
Right? Tax-free, looks pretty amazing. The problem is you do that, you take that money out,
and now the market goes down. If you retire in 2008, what happens if that's you?
Then you're 65, the costs of insurance at that point in time are super high. I've seen policies
when people get into retirement that look really healthy, and then four years later, look like a
complete nightmare. Once again, it just comes back to the fact that it's just a dangerous game.
The reason it's dangerous is because IULs are so flexible, and you can make the illustrations
look like virtually whatever you want because there are so many moving parts.
That's why I like the simplicity of a whole life policy because I'm a big believer in you should
never invest in anything you don't understand. I don't think most people understand all the
moving parts of most mutual funds that they're invested in. Most people shouldn't buy individual
stocks because they really don't understand the companies that they're buying. I think it's so
easy to understand a whole life policy. Once again, you're not really investing in it. You're
just storing your money. I guess to sum this up, unless you have anything-
Yeah. I think in all fairness, there are people watching this that are in the business of
universal life. I want to challenge you to take a step back and say,
it's not just in theory, but what's actually going to happen? How are people actually going
to use this? That's number one. I also want to say, I have seen people in this space doing
special universal life with high net worth people that they understand the risk, and it's going to
serve them in some way. I'm just saying across the board, most people are being sold a bill of
goods that number one, that they don't understand. Number two, it's not going to give them the result
that they actually want. Number three, they're taking on a lot more risk than they should,
especially when there's better alternatives out there. That's my summary. I want to be fair,
and I also know that what YouTube can get really into a dark hole with people going back and forth.
I in no way want to say things or throw a punch at someone. Hopefully, this doesn't offend someone
that's dedicated their life to helping people, but I really want us to take a step back and
really think through what we're actually doing because even in the business that we're in,
there are practices. If I really take a step back and say, would I put my grandmother in this? Would
I put my mom in this? It helps you figure out what you should really be doing. I can double that up
and say that, listen, with the company that I worked with, there were so many good people that
were selling it, but with agents, I think it's key to understand this. If you're an agent watching
this, I would really encourage you to step outside the box that you're in, especially if you work
with a company like I work with or a captive company or you have a captive relationship or
you're really committed to hitting a leaderboard with a company or something of that nature.
The training that you get is very one-sided. The information that you're taking in is going to be
directed to achieve an agenda for that company that's trying to get you to sell their product.
That's exactly how it was for me for the first year and a half of my career. I was all about
that. It took me meeting with Don Blanton, quite frankly. That changed everything for me.
That's it. Once again, I don't mean to offend anybody, but at the same time, truth is truth.
If you disagree with anything I say, put it in the comments. We can have a conversation about it.
Anyway, I hope this serves you. I hope it helps. I hope it makes sense. If you have questions,
definitely feel free to type them out in the comments below. Also, if you're somebody who's
looking for help or if you're an agent, Caleb wants to give you a free copy of this thing.
I know it'll change your life. I know it'll help you. Definitely go to the link below. If you're
an agent, there's a special link for you. If you're somebody who's looking for help for your
personal finances, there's a special link for you. Go check it out. Until next video,
live abundantly, live efficiently, live like 180, and have fun.
