This obscure myth shaped the Western mind (Myth of Etana Complete Breakdown)).mp4

Ancient Civilizations
15 followers
5 Video Views·May 2, 2026
his is the complete breakdown of the Myth of Etana, part of a three video series at this point starting with the green Gobekli Tepe stone that might be the earliest form of writing, to the earliest ascent into heaven myth, riding on an eagle, something that would influence the rest of Western mythos.
Welcome to the channel.
In the last video we covered this little green stone which might be the earliest example
of proto-writing, it's 11,000 years old, comes from Gobekli Tepe, and has these three
symbols on it.
Maybe they're just decorative, or maybe they're trying to express something.
It's believed that this is a snake on the left, a person with extended arms in the middle,
and a bird on the right.
And if that is what this is, then it could be the oldest example of what comes to be
the Master of Animals motif, and goes all the way through 11,000 years of history, with
depictions of Athena flanked by a snake and an owl, up to the US Capitol building having
Liberty flanked by the snake and the eagle.
This bird being an eagle seems to be the most common, and in that last video I mentioned
the myth of Etana, and how this was tied to this timeless force of consolidation.
That as one group develops something that gives them some tech boost, in this case it's
the Sumerians with their writing.
Some other neighboring groups will willingly adopt it, but others resist these new systems
because they feel like they lose their culture, they're being swallowed up by this monoculture.
People today complain about the effects of the English language and the Anglosphere creating
a global monoculture.
Well for these people, from 9 to 2000 BC, there is this increasing snowballing of tech
advantages from the major empires.
If you just want life to be easier and to enjoy these material gains, just adopt the
Sumerian writing system, it's the easiest way to plug into a more productive system
coming from the southern end of the Fertile Crescent, but this quickly meant that local
traditions down to the myths and gods get swallowed up by the Sumerian pantheon and
temple complex.
The myth of Etana is from around 2100 BC, and we'll compare Etana's flight with other
ascents in myth, from the biblical Enoch and Elijah, to the Hindu Garuda, and even
Alexander the Great's legendary Skyward Journey, and I'll make sure you guys understand
how scholars have even reconstructed this myth, what remains debated, and how its imagery
of a man riding an eagle was immortalized on cylinder seals, and would pop up in later
art.
But one of the big takeaways here is that while this myth predates other things that
This was a very late consolidation or syncretism of many other Mesopotamian traditions.
If we just zoom out that timescale a bit more, it's 4,000 years before us today, but it
is 7,000 years after the creation of the Gobekli Tepe stone from last week's video.
The imagery on that stone, just like this story, will focus on a man's place between
the forces of the snake and the eagle.
Now don't take this comparison too far, it's not exactly the same of course, but roughly
think of it how like Christianity spread through Europe, incorporating or retelling the local
stories and putting their worldview in the context of this larger, all-encompassing thing,
backed by a more hierarchical and industrious center, Rome in that case, and the Sumerian
city-states in the case of the myth of Etana.
Because one of the points of this myth is to establish why the Sumerian kings have the
divine right to rule.
And of course, this myth did not influence every case of birds carrying someone into
the sky.
Nor is every similar example of this connected to the same meaning, it doesn't mean everyone
shares the same metaphysical worldview.
In ancient Egypt, the Ba, one of the many aspects of the soul, was often depicted as
a human-headed bird that could fly from the tomb and rejoin the body.
In Norse mythology, Odin's ravens, Huginn and Muninn, which mean thought and memory,
they fly across the world gathering knowledge, but it also evokes the idea of consciousness
traveling independent from the body.
The Yakut of Siberia describe shamans transforming into birds and riding bird spirits during
ecstatic journeys to the spirit realm.
In indigenous North American traditions, especially among the Plains and Pueblo peoples, birds
and again, specifically eagles, play crucial roles in death rituals, with feathers seen
as soul conductors.
Which could bring us right back to Egypt, with a similar association with feathers.
But this wide recurrence suggests that these myths are not simply copies of each other,
there's no reason to think that the myth of Atana is affecting Pueblo people traditions,
but rather these are independent responses to a shared human phenomenon.
In modern recorded near-death experiences, people across cultures have described sensations
of floating above their body, of soaring upward, or being guided through the sky.
And we get into a sort of chicken-and-the-egg problem here when some of these people described
winged beings.
Of course they're aware of depictions of angels in our culture, but why were winged
creatures associated with this to begin with?
Why did the ancient people depict them like that in the first place?
And when you're having this feeling of floating up into the air, that's something that you're
naturally going to associate with birds more than any other creature.
And so to be clear, I'm not saying that every instance of the soul going up into the air
via birds across the world, that's not all connected to the myth of Atana.
It's almost certainly much older than Gobekli Tepe.
But it's all to that point that I made in the last video, that we see these spiritual
experiences occurring on an individual, personal level, and then they become standardized in
larger religious practices.
And in the era of writing, that means standardized myths.
That means these individual experiences, and unique symbolic expressions across different
people groups, come to be boiled down or consolidated into these state myths.
Just as everyone is getting on this standardized system of writing, even if there's not just
one version of this myth, it's at least getting closer to some sort of standardization or
canon.
But with that, let's just get into the actual story.
Our story begins at the dawn of cities.
The gods have just founded Kish, the first city after the flood.
But kingship was still in heaven.
No human ruler yet sat on an earthly throne.
The great gods deliberate and decide to send down the institution of kingship to mankind.
They choose Atana, a humble servant, as Kish's first king.
He is to unify the people and legitimize human rule under divine sanction.
But as time goes on, this king encounters a personal crisis.
Without an heir, Atana fears his line and the newly founded kingship will die out.
In desperation, he turns to the gods for help.
Day after day, Atana prays at dawn to Shamash, the sun god and divine judge, pleading for
the plant of birth, a mythical remedy to cure infertility, desperately pleaing to grant
him an heir.
Oh lord, let the word go forth from your mouth and give me the plant of birth, show me the
plant of birth, remove my shame and provide me with a son.
His prayers are earnest and unceasing, echoing upward toward the heavens.
Unknown to Atana, the answer to his plea will arrive in a most unexpected form.
Born from a drama unfolding in the wilds outside his city.
And so the stage is set for the intertwining of two tales.
One of a man seeking the gift of life, and another of a prideful eagle and a faithful
snake whose fate will guide the king's destiny.
In the hills near Kish stands a tall poplar tree, Sarvatu, sacred to the sky storm god
Adad.
In its high branches lives a great eagle, and at its roots dwells a serpent.
Despite the natural enmity between bird and snake, these two make an unusual pact.
They swear before Shamash to live in friendship and share the tree's territory and bounty.
Each day, both creatures hunt for food.
The eagle soars to catch wild game, and the serpent prowls on the ground.
Each brings meat back to the tree, feeding themselves first, then generously allowing
their young to eat.
Their oath is to not overstep the limit set by Shamash.
It's a promise of mutual respect and restraint.
And for a time, peace prevails.
The tree is a miniature world of harmony, where opposite forces like the eagle and the
snake are able to live in harmony, through the respect of this limit enforced by the
god of justice.
But the eagle's heart harbors ambition and treachery.
Despite an abundance of prey, the eagle plotted evil in its heart, to eat its friend's
young ones.
One day, while the serpent is away hunting, the eagle swoops down and devours the serpent's
defenseless babies.
In some versions, one especially wise fledgling of the eagle even begs its father not to do
this evil.
Father, don't eat, the net of Shamash will ensnare you.
But the eagle ignores the warning.
It made up its mind and committed the vile act, confident that it could evade punishment.
Upon returning, the serpent finds its empty nest, its children are gone, and the bereaved
snake is overcome with grief and rage.
It lays down and weeps, crying out in a bitter appeal to Shamash.
My own nest is not there, while its nest is safe.
My young ones are scattered, and its young ones are safe.
It came down and ate my young ones.
You know the wrong which it has done me, Shamash.
Truly, oh Shamash, your net is as wide as the earth.
Your snare is as broad as the sky.
The eagle should not escape your net.
Shamash, as the divine arbiter of oaths and justice, hears the serpent's plea, and the
sun god formulates a cunning plan to punish this treacherous eagle.
Shamash instructs the serpent to prepare a trap.
Hide yourself inside the carcass of a wild bull.
Soon, all kinds of birds gather to scavenge the carrion.
Sure enough, the great eagle, smelling this feast, descends from the sky.
Before approaching, the eagle's youngest chick again chirps out a warning.
Perhaps the serpent is lying in wait inside that bull.
But the eagle is emboldened by seeing smaller birds safely eating, and dismisses this caution.
If the birds felt any fear, how would they be eating the flesh so peacefully?
The eagle dives down and begins to gorge on the bull's flesh.
With grim patience, the hidden snake waits until the eagle has crawled inside the carcass.
Then in a flash, the serpent strikes.
It seizes the eagle's wings and its jaws, confronting the astonished predator with its
crime.
Now trapped and smeared with blood, the eagle frantically offers reparations.
It promises to give the snake whatever it desires if it was spared.
But the serpent's divine mandate is clear.
No bribe can annul divine justice.
The snake mercilessly clips the eagle's wings, tearing out feathers, and drags the
mighty bird to a remote pit in the mountains.
There it throws the eagle down to die of hunger and thirst.
A slow, agonizing punishment befitting this horrible crime.
Having delivered justice, the serpent leaves the crippled eagle in the dark pit.
The proud creature that once ruled the skies has literally fallen.
It was literally cast down from the heavens, unable to ever soar in those lofty heights
or to return to its home at the top of the tree.
As later commentators would note, the very word for mountain or kur in Sumerian, which
is used for where the eagle is trapped now, this word can also mean netherworld.
Symbolically, the eagle has been consigned to a living death in an underworld-like mountain
pit.
Don't think of a mountain as being tall and up in the sky.
The point is that there are these craggy pits and caves.
And the eagle that was once the master of the skies is now trapped in this gloomy darkness.
Thus, the oathbreaker meets poetic justice.
Alone and wounded, the eagle languishes, unable to escape its earthen prison.
And it does the only thing it can.
It prays.
Humbled and starving, the eagle cries out to Shamash, confessing its wickedness.
But Shamash replies sternly to the eagle,
You are wicked and have grieved my heart.
You did an unforgivable deed, an abomination to the gods.
The sun god refuses to personally rescue this sinner due to its oath-breaking act.
But in his mercy, Shamash decides the eagle's fate will serve a greater purpose.
I will not approach you, but I will send another to help you.
And so the stage is now set for Etana's path to cross the eagles.
Intertwining these two quests, the eagle's desire for deliverance
and the king's need for the plant of birth.
During Etana's daily prayers, Shamash finally sends an omen,
telling the king to seek out a pit in the mountains where a great eagle is trapped.
Obeying the god's words, Etana sets out on the journey,
hopeful that this is the path to the elusive Shamu Sha'aladi,
the plant of birth that can cure his wife and secure his dynasty.
Following Shamash's guidance, Etana ventures into the wilderness
and indeed finds this pit-bound eagle, injured and near death.
Etana places juniper branches over the pit's opening,
shading the creature from the harsh sun.
The sight evokes pity in him, the eagle's wings are shorn,
it cannot fly, and it is withering away and starving to death.
When Etana peers into the hole, the eagle looks up at him,
and king and predator meet eye to eye in mutual need, and Etana strikes a bargain.
He will nurse the eagle back to health,
and in return the eagle must help him find the plant of birth.
With no other option, the eagle agrees,
and thus begins this unlikely partnership, forged by Shamash's divine will.
The man will save the eagle, and the eagle will carry the man to heaven.
Etana tends to the eagle with care and patience,
and the tablets say he spent seven or eight months feeding the bird,
cleaning its wounds, and waiting for its feathers to regrow.
That time period is close to the nine months of a human pregnancy,
and so maybe it's playing with the idea of him giving birth to this new thing.
Over time, the eagle recovers its strength,
and you can imagine Etana's mix of hope and anxiety during this period.
Each new feather on the eagle's wing is one step closer to his own goal of reaching the sky.
Finally, the day arrives when the eagle's wings are restored and it's ready to fly again,
and true to its word, the grateful eagle offers to carry Etana into the heavens.
Be glad, my friend, let me bear thee to the highest heaven.
Lay thy breast on mine, set thy arms around my wings, let my body be as thy body.
As he mounts the eagle, we enter the most famous sequence of the myth, the cosmic ascent.
With a powerful beat of its wings, the eagle rises from the earth,
carrying Etana on its back, and higher and higher they climb, breaking through the clouds,
and the cuneiform text poetically records how the world below diminishes in scope the further they
ascend. After the first league, or a few hundred miles in mythic terms, the eagle calls to Etana.
Look down, my friend, what do you see? Etana peers at his kingdom below and is astonished.
The sprawling land of Sumer now looks as small as a simple garden,
and the vast sea as small as a bucket. As they climb further, the eagle asks again.
By the second measure of distance, the earth had become a mere hill, the ocean but a ditch.
And by the third, Etana could no longer discern land from sea.
The world of mortals has vanished into a tiny blur. Etana is experiencing a God's eye point
of view of creation, and the scale of the journey conveys the immense gulf between earth and heaven.
But with wonder comes terror. The higher they go, the more Etana's courage falters.
Eventually overwhelmed by the height and the sight of nothingness below, Etana panics.
He cries out to the eagle. My friend, I cannot go any further towards heaven.
Retrace the way. Let me go back to my city. In one fragment version, Etana's nerve fails
him completely. He begs the eagle to descend, and the eagle complies, returning the trembling
king to Kish. This could have been the end. Etana's first attempt to reach heaven ends in
retreat. Back on earth, Etana remains childless and plagued by ominous dreams.
In those dreams, preserved in some fragments, the message is clear. Without an heir, his city and
legacy are in peril. And in one dream, Etana finds himself at the gates of heaven, in the presence of
the goddess Ishtar on her throne guarded by lions. Only for those lions to leap at him, jolting him
awake in terror. The eagle interprets these dreams. They are omens that Etana must try again.
He cannot risk dying without an heir. Summoning his resolve, Etana agrees to make a second
ascent with the eagle. This time, the text suggests, they succeed in reaching the highest
heaven of the supreme god Anu. One Assyrian fragment even notes that Etana reached heaven
and prostrated himself before the gods. Together, man and eagle pass through multiple heavenly
gates, seven gates according to later interpretations, and arrive at the celestial
house of Ishtar, the queen of heaven. As Etana bows humbly in the courts of heaven, the tablet
breaks off. The climax of the epic is actually lost to time, leaving scholars to speculate on
its ending. But the absence of an explicit ending does not leave us in doubt. Mesopotamian tradition
and external clues all fill in the blanks. The Sumerian king list, which was compiled centuries
later, does record that Etana obtained the plant of birth, and succeeded in fathering a son named
Bala, who became the next king. In fact, there's a very short entry in the king list. Etana,
the one who to heaven ascended, ruled and had a son, Bala. And so we can reason that the myth
ends with Etana returning from heaven victorious, carrying the boon of fertility back to earth,
likely getting the plant of birth from Ishtar, administering it to his wife,
and thus the dynasty continues. This would fulfill the myth's purpose of legitimizing
dynastic succession. Etana's heavenly journey ensures the god's blessing on Kish's royal line.
In this worldview, if royal blood means anything, it's that they have a unique connection to the
gods. The gods want humans to be under the rule of a king who himself gets power from the gods.
But another version of the story appears to have a darker turn. A fragment suggests that at some
point, down and down, eagle and man fell together until they strike the earth, and the eagle's body
is shattered. This has led to debate over whether Etana, or perhaps just the eagle, met disaster.
One interpretation is that after reaching a certain point, possibly the heaven of Anu,
hubris or just an accident cause a fall, and only after a harrowing descent,
or even a temporary death of the eagle, the journey somehow resumes toward Ishtar's realm.
The Mesopotamian concept that the highest god is just unapproachable, and that Ishtar as a
fertility goddess would be the one that you could go to for help here, since we know he does have
air. This fall could have been just to show how great and distant Anu is, and act as a sort of
dramatic obstacle, heightening the tension when telling this story, and making the final success
and gift from Ishtar more dramatic. So in summary, this is in the context of the gods having already
sent a flood. Kish is the first city after the flood, so it's as if they hated that old system,
had to kill off everyone associated with it, that first king is Etana, but even though divinely
chosen, he can't produce an heir with his wife, and there's no stigma on him or the wife, it's
framed as just diseases causing this. It's not a punishment from the gods, they're the ones that
chose Etana, but he will be tested for his kindness and ability to nurture the eagle,
and see if he is brave enough to venture into the heavens. Can he, even if for just a short time,
bear this god's eye point of view of earth? Something that maybe the gods felt was necessary
and beneficial for a human king. But now I really want to break down the symbolism here,
you'll notice that in a lot of ways the eagle and serpent symbolism is kind of inverted.
How cool is it that again, literally the oldest example we have of what could be proto-writing
of snake, man, eagle, it's not just that those same three characters are in this story,
it's the same connotation of man as mediator or master of these two very distinct forces.
But also very interesting that in the oldest written version of this story,
which predates many of the more prominent religious stories around today, some of the
common symbolic motifs are either changed or the opposite of their later sources.
The eagle in Etana's myth serves a dual symbolic role, on one hand it is the vehicle of Etana's
ascent, literally carrying a mortal to the realm of the divine, and so you can see him as this
boon-giver to mankind, it gives us this freedom and ability to enter into the cosmos, to traverse
the boundary between earth and heaven. But also the eagle is introduced as the villain, he is the
arrogant, evil, oath-breaker. By betraying its sworn pact, the eagle shows a lack of self-control
at least, or just pure hatred and malice at worst. Again it's said that there was plenty of food to
eat, there was no real reason to eat the snake's kids, it's just a type of greed, he doesn't want
to be restricted in any way. Maybe the very thought of sharing the tree with this snake was appalling.
And the fall into the pit shows that God's rule will punish even the lofty eagle. The Neo-Assyrian
versions of the text call the eagle Anzu, linking it to the legendary Anzu bird, a monstrous divine
eagle known from other myths. Anzu is infamous for stealing the tablet of destinies in another epic,
so evoking Anzu here casts Etana's eagle as the mythic rebel against divine order.
You can see how biblical themes are similar with the high angel cast out of heaven.
The whole point, like the Gobekli Tepe stone, may be to stress an interdependence here,
that victims like the snake need a more powerful god to intervene to deliver justice,
even the great eagle is not above that justice, and it can be stripped of all of its power and
utterly at the mercy of a human. A human who can also not achieve what it needs on its own,
but needs the help of the god and the powers of the eagle. I do find it really interesting here
that the biblical stories of the fallen angel, which is of course heavily influenced by Sumerian
traditions, even the later Christians who are supposed to pray for their enemies, the one unique
core thing that it's offering here is forgiveness and universal salvation. There is the famous story
of Abba Macarius, one of the so-called desert fathers, one of the early Christian ascetics who
withdrew into the Egyptian desert in the 4th century CE. He has this great quote that if you
have not learned to forgive, you have not yet learned to pray. And he extended that to demons
and even Satan. It's said that at one point in the desert he had a vision where Satan was just
laughing at him, mocking this monk who is trying to offer this olive branch or have compassion for
Satan. But this would later be seen as heretical. I don't think you'll find any of the major
Christian faiths that think that you could pray for Satan's salvation. But here in the myth of
Atonah, the eagle is absolutely the evil one, and yet he is not utterly destroyed for all time.
Man's job is to nurse him back to health and almost domesticate or channel his energy to
serve mankind's purpose, the betterment of humanity through the divine rule of Atonah.
And again you get this inversion, this serpent doesn't equal evil, it's actually the agent of
divine justice and oath keeping. It honors its pact and rightfully seeks retribution when wronged,
appealing to Shamash's sense of cosmic order. And the snake is also connected to this loss
of family. It's avenging its murdered offspring. In a way it mirrors Atonah. Both are concerned
with their family line. Atonah doesn't have a male heir, and the serpent had his heirs taken
from him. Though like many traditions he would be connected to the earthly and chthonic realm.
Living at the base of the tree, it's part of this sky and earth, eagle and snake dichotomy.
And of course it should have evoked the idea of the world tree in north mythology,
which just has an eagle at the top and a serpent at its base who are eternally opposed to each
other. It's likely that this all stems from some far older version of the myth which existed in
the modern day Turkey and Caucasus, upper Mesopotamia region, spreading down towards
Sumer and up through Europe. But again the snake was an equal part of this order, had a valid oath
with the eagle, overseen by Shamash, and ends up being the victim and the champion of justice.
And of course the pit that the eagle falls into is comparable to a hell and underworld.
In the earliest layers of the Hebrew bible, the afterlife is not imagined as heaven or hell as
we think of them in the modern sense, but just a descent into a pit. It's just the word bore,
alongside related terms like shield. There's the ancient greek concepts of the afterlife just being
a dusty dark kind of dwelling place. The dead are described as going down, it's within the earth,
cast into the pit, and it really just feels like a cosmic holding place. Nothing really good or bad
is happening there, it's just the absence of all the joys of life. It's only much later, during
times of exile in Babylon and under Persian rule, that you get these more differentiated ideas of
judgment, resurrection, or reward beginning to emerge. But it is all built on top of this older
pit-centered vision of the afterlife. But you're also seeing what's called the womb of the earth
motif. I agree with a lot of scholars that think the reason why we see ancient burials in the
fetal position is because you're putting them in as they came out. The grown man's dead body being
put in the womb is again a fetus to be reborn somewhere else. And then there's the shamu sha
aladi, which literally means plant of birth. I think in this aspect it's a very useful myth,
that it can be seen as a precursor to an early form of medicine. It isn't just an incantation,
a prayer, or blessing. Someone could believe in this story and be motivated to find out what that
plant is, some physical thing that can heal human issues. In other words, medicine. By obtaining the
plant, Atana ensures the continuation of his lineage. And so it is tied to dynastic succession,
blessed by divine grace, and can be compared to the idea of the tree of life,
found all throughout other Mesopotamian and Biblical stories. In the Epic of Gilgamesh,
which is anywhere from around the same time or maybe a hundred years later, I've seen estimates
that it comes 300 years after the myth of Atana, but the hero Gilgamesh is seeking a plant of life,
which in this case restores youth. It all taps into the broader idea of a cosmic life force.
If the gods are the ultimate life givers, they have built our reality with these other things
that have this life-giving essence in them. And Atana is the one who's bringing heaven's creative
power into the mortal realm. And so you could see a similar concept to Prometheus, though of course
he is going around the will of the supreme god. It's also playing with a very healthy idea that
immortality, in Atana's sense, means that his line continues on. Not selfish, personal immortality
like with Gilgamesh. And I really love the point that his cosmic ascent stresses a shift in scale
and perspective. The higher one goes, the closer we can get to the divine's mind, the more one sees
the big picture. We have a term called the overview effect for a similar feeling experienced
by astronauts. Edgar Mitchell might be the most famous for this, saying that he felt an ecstatic
sense of oneness where national borders vanished and the planet appeared as a single,
fragile system suspended in darkness. And the NASA program, of course, has a ton of eagle
imagery and names. It's pretty cool that we first set foot on the moon via an eagle. The Eagle Module.
But of course, the modern insights from science, driven mostly by an atheistic worldview,
could still be beneficial in driving home the point that it really is just us here.
We're floating in a cosmos that does not care about our existence. From solar flares to
meteorites and quasars, like the serpent and the eagle, Shamash and Atana, the conclusion is that
we still all have to work together, have some rule of law, but also an aspect of forgiveness
and rehabilitation. But in the Sumerian sense, of course, it was tied to the idea that the gods were
ones in charge, and that when Atana transcended human limits, he validated the institution of
kingship as divinely ordered. It's a way to have myth answer the question, who gave you the right
to rule? The answer is, don't you know, the gods chose him and he flew up to heaven and was granted
the boon that established this royal line in the first place. I have a whole video on how I think
the core idea here could have spread to China via the Proto-Silk Road, and it may be why both
cultures use the exact same term for the common people, referring to them as the black-headed
people. And it's not even just the exact same wording, it's that it's used in a framework of a
divinely chosen king to lead the commoners. It's supposed to remind the black-headed people that
they are beneath the king or emperor. If you want to check out that video, it should be up in the
cards or down in the description. But of course, all these ideas impacted later traditions, likely
those of Egypt, Greece, and over into India, but most directly the Abrahamic faiths. Abraham is
presented as having been born in Ur of the Chaldeans in Genesis 11-28. Ur is one of the largest
original Sumerian cities, and he was raised for years in Haran, Genesis 11-31 and 12 verse 1-4,
but these are two of the most intensely myth-saturated urban centers of the ancient world.
Both cities were embedded in temple economies, astral religion, and scribal culture that had
preserved and transmitted Mesopotamian myths, from the creation stories, flood traditions, divine
councils, and cosmic order. All of this had been recorded here for millennia. Even if Abraham
himself was not literate, daily life in these environments meant constant exposure to this
worldview through ritual, public oral recitations, festivals, and even in legal formulas, and
cosmological understanding. There's every reason to expect that Abraham's imagination, the very
language he used, and assumptions about gods, heaven, earth, and covenant were formed within
this conscious dialogue with centuries of Mesopotamian mythic tradition. And so let's take
a closer look at some specific examples of the myth of Atana's legacy. In Jewish and later Christian
traditions, there are two figures that stand out for their extraordinary departures from earth.
Enoch and Elijah. Enoch from the book of Genesis, and elaborated in the apocryphal First Enoch,
was a pre-flood patriarch who walked with God, then was no more, because God took him. This
cryptic line was interpreted to mean Enoch was taken alive into heaven. In the book of Enoch,
he indeed travels through multiple heavenly realms, learns cosmic secrets, and is transformed
into a heavenly being, all while still alive. Elijah, meanwhile, is a prophet in the Bible,
2 Kings 2.11, who did not die, but was taken up to heaven in a whirlwind, riding a chariot of fire
escorted by horses and fire. It shows divine favor and a transfer of prophetic authority.
Elijah receives a double portion of Elijah's spirit after this, and while Elijah doesn't
retrieve an object or secret, it shows him as a heaven-authorized figure. And in later tradition,
Elijah could return as an angelic herald. Both Enoch and Elijah show that the idea of bodily
ascent into heaven, they didn't die, they were in their normal, waking, conscious state in their
physical body, just like Atana. This idea became embedded in Near Eastern thought. In later Jewish
and Christian lore, these figures sometimes converse with or assist the living, but the idea
of Elijah coming back, or Enoch being Metatron in some mystical texts. But it all enshrines the
basic idea that there are special individuals who have a special connection to a divine power,
and that you can physically go up into these heavenly realms. And then moving eastward, we find
another parallel in Hindu mythology with the figure of Garuda. Garuda is a giant divine eagle,
often depicted as half-man, half-eagle, and serves as the vehicle, or vahana, of the god Vishnu.
Garuda's lore, recorded in texts like the Mahabharata, shares several motifs with Atana's
eagle. Garuda is an enemy of serpents. In fact, he is born to free his mother from servitude to the
Naga, or the serpent race. And in one of the most famous episodes, Garuda must obtain the amrita,
the nectar of immortality. It's very similar to this plant, it's something physical connected
to vitality. And he takes this from the gods and uses it as ransom to liberate his mother.
To do so, he flies to heaven, and after showing his cunning, and in many great battles,
he seizes the pot of amrita from the god's realm. We get an eagle performing a heavenly fetch quest
for a life-giving substance, all in conflict with the serpent. He devours snakes regularly,
and earns the enmity of the serpent gods. But we see that symbolic inversion. In Atana's story,
the eagle started as the villain to the snake, whereas Garuda is the heroic eagle, fighting the
good fight against the villainous snakes. But all versions are highlighting this war between the
and serpent. And Garuda is also Vishnu's mount. He's often shown with a human, which is usually
Vishnu or one of his avatars, riding on the eagle's back. It makes for a very easy comparison
with the Akkadian seal of Atana in Hindu reliefs of Vishnu on Garuda. And also in the Ramayana,
two eagle brothers, Jatayu and Sampati, are said to be sons of Garuda, and they once attempted to
fly up to the sun. One flew too high and had his wings scorched, falling back down. That's
a nice parallel to the motif of the failed ascent. Remember, in some versions, Atana could not reach
the ultimate highest realm. In Garuda's story, he ultimately is rewarded by Vishnu for his exploits,
and becomes immortal without needing the nectar himself. I'm certain that someone in the comments
will be explaining how everything actually came out of India, but the Atana story long
predates Hindu epics. And I know I'm putting my neck out here, but I have been loosely researching
this for an upcoming very long video, but I think even the Homeric epics predate the Hindu epics.
Maybe the consensus doesn't seem to go that far, but over the past few years that I've been
suspicious of this, I've seen more and more evidence and scholars arguing this too. But the real answer
most likely isn't that the Greek came first, or that the Indian came first, it's just that they
are descendant from some Mesopotamian, or maybe up into the Turkey or Caucasus area. Stories here
likely inspired both, not the other way around. And history and legend often blend when it comes
to Alexander the Great, the Macedonian conqueror from the 4th century BCE. Among the many fantastical
exploits attributed to Alexander in the later Alexander romance literature, is a celestial
journey that is reminiscent of Atana's ride. One popular medieval legend, which may even stretch
back to the late Roman period, describes how Alexander devised a contraption to fly into the
sky. In one version, he tames griffins or giant birds by holding pieces of meat above their heads,
and he ties them to a basket or throne in which he sits. Like a carrot on a stick,
this meat on a stick makes them fly upward, and as he ascends, Alexander beholds the earth shrinking.
The same perspective change Atana experienced in marvels at the circle of the earth and the ocean.
Some stories even say he just did this because he wanted to see the earth shape.
But after he has seen enough, or the birds tire, he returns back to solid ground. In the Ethiopic
Alexander legend, it says, he made himself small and flew through the air on an eagle,
and he arrived in the heights of the heavens and explored them. Another variant says that it was
Alexander's men who were the ones lifted by the giant birds to scout ahead the country of the
living, and they returned with wondrous tales. Many scholars just call these Alexandrian versions
of the Atana myth, and they tie both Alexander and myths about Nimrod to the original Atana theme.
Nimrod is the mighty hunter and king mentioned in Genesis, who was later elaborated on in Jewish
and Islamic folklore. In an Arabic legend recounted by commentators like Al-Tabari,
Nimrod becomes arrogant and desires to confront God in heaven. He constructs a flying machine,
usually described as a chest or throne harnessed to four great birds, usually eagles or vultures.
By dangling meat above them, he causes the birds to carry him upward. Nimrod ascends,
but this story ends in failure. After soaring for some time, the birds veer off and falter,
and Nimrod comes crashing down, this flying machine smashed to pieces on the ground.
Researchers often see parallels here with the Tower of Babel, building something to reach heaven,
and it's rebuked as an act of hubris. The Quran might be alluding to these types of stories with
Pharaoh wanting to ascend to heaven. In chapter 40, verse 36 to 37, and the Pharaoh said,
O Haman, build for me a tower that I may reach the ways, the ways of the heavens,
and look upon the God of Moses, though I indeed think him a liar. Both the Alexander and Nimrod
legends show us how the motif of bird-powered ascent lived on through all these ages.
And Alexander himself was often eager to prove that he was divinely favored, like Atana, that
his true father was Zeus, but also syncretized with Amun, that he goes to the oasis religious
site of Siwa in the Egyptian desert in order to get this confirmation that he was also the son of
the Egyptian god Amun, while also this aspect that his ascension tale has this quasi-scientific tone.
He wants to know the length and breadth of the earth, a scientific adventurer wanting to go up
into heaven and document it. And so it's kind of funny, the more primitive version, primitive just
meaning prime, the first, the closest to the original way. And so the most primitive version
of this story might just be individual people or shaman who think that they're a spirit animal or
themselves just turned into a bird and roam the heavens in this new form. Then it is that a man
works with a bird, and if that seems silly to later cultures, they go, no, no, it was a technology,
some bird-powered craft. Like I said, all the way up to the moon landing module where we go,
no, of course, these myths are silly, but yeah, we're still going to call it the eagle.
Using mythic symbols is one of the most human things out there. We seem so reluctant to give
it up, and honestly, I hope we never do. And if you made it this far, I think it'd be cool to
understand how we actually know this story. It comes down to us through clay tablets written
in cuneiform, but these were found across centuries and in different regions across
the ancient Near East. Coming from three main periods, the Old Babylonian from 1800 to 1600 BC,
Middle Assyrian from 1400 to 1200 BC, and Neo-Assyrian or Standard Babylonian of the
7th century BCE. And although the oldest surviving tablets date to around 1800 BC,
many sources think the myth is at least as early as 2100 BC. Based on earlier oral or literary
traditions, and scholars see signs that the myth was already circulating in Sumerian or early
Akkadian tradition during the Ur III period, well before these versions we have that are written
down. Atana is mentioned in the Sumerian king list, which was compiled around 2100 BC, and
remember it's already calling him the legendary king of Kish who ascended to heaven. And so it
must be referencing some understanding of this story that already existed. And scholars reconstruct
the full story by combining overlapping fragments, using one tablet to fill in what's missing in
another, while acknowledging that there are different versions. Some seem to be missing
whole side plots, and then there's some name changes like the eagle not just being a generic
eagle, but Anzu in later versions. But with all this careful cross-referencing, you actually do
get a more complete picture of the Atana myth and the impact it had on the culture, a more profound
understanding than any single tablet could offer. Think about it, you could just have one version
that was perfectly preserved, and that would be nice, but many scholars are happy that we have
so many different versions across so many different centuries. And we also have all these
cylinder seals. Several cylinder seals and seal impressions from the Akkadian period, from around
2300 to 2200 BC, depict a scene almost unmistakable in its content. A man clinging to the back of a
large bird, soaring upward, while below him animals and humans gaze up. These tiny carved
seals were rolled onto clay to make an impression, and often used by officials or elites. The fact
that so many seals show the same man-on-an-eagle motif, show that this story of Atana was widely
known, and symbolically important, even in early times. Likely before the earliest written fragments
of the myth. Oral traditions came first, and I'm saying it has the same three core characters of
the snake, man, and eagle in that Gobekli Tepe stone from 11,000 years ago. So there's every
reason to think that a story like this was existing in Mesopotamia long before it was actually written
down. And the first way it was recorded is actually in pictures, in these little scenes from these
cylinder seals. And these too would exist for over a thousand years. Some Middle Assyrian seals from
the 13th century also show this man-on-an-eagle motif, and it likely influenced later Iranian art.
The symbol of a bird carrying a hero appears with Zal, the father of the hero Rostam in Persian
legend, who was said to be raised by the Simurg, a giant bird. Rostam's father was carried away by
this giant bird. And there's one last really interesting take I want to throw in here. Some
scholars think that this is related to a motif called the winged temple. It's a step structure
that might relate to rituals of a ruler's ascension. It's not literally flying, but with all
the wing symbolism and the king going up the steps up toward the heavens, which are just impressively
tall even for modern standards. You know, nothing close to a skyscraper, but still. These are probably
more impressive to the people of their day than skyscrapers are to us. I think the scholarly
consensus is that the winged temple comes later. It's not what inspires the myth, but like I said,
from shamanic experience all the way up to the Atana myth, the bird soul ascension motif is what
influenced the wing designs in the temple. And they're playing that out symbolically going up
these steps. But it's an interesting theory I wanted to bring up. What we can say concretely
is that Atana's name, this story, and the worldview it wants to assert was prominent in Mesopotamian
culture for two millennia. We've had Christianity for 2,000 years. And just think of how much
cultural impact that has had, how much it shapes our worldview, how even the most anti-christian
philosophers, think of someone like Nietzsche for example, they show just how hard it is to get out
of this cultural matrix, this framework that shapes our minds. You end up debating ideas
within a Christian worldview. It's so hard to get out of it. Cultures from Ireland to the Philippines
have been dominated by this, a system which from a secular level can be seen as both incorporating
or emerging from earlier traditions. I'm not talking random zeitgeist level arguments,
but deep scholarly work that thinks yes, there are connections to Dionysus and tons of other
Greek influences, but the earliest Christians would have agreed with this. They would have
seen their New Testament as an incorporating this, as an updating, a more complete and better version.
And it eventually gets spread by popes and kings. Well, it's the same story 2,000 years before
Christ. The similar dynamic of the state and the church, the royal palace and holy temples
throughout Mesopotamia. You cannot forget that at the core, this myth is taking a shared experience
from people far off in the Americas. This myth encoded in writing is to legitimize the king's
rule. Taking these personal experiences of soul flight and kind of using that logic and that
worldview to say our king had a soul flight and received a boon from a god. Our rule is the will
of the gods. While not being overly cynical, it's not like it's devoid of moral teachings here. You
should keep oaths. You shouldn't be greedy and even at a time of surplus, go over and eat your
neighbor's kids while also remembering forgiveness and also remembering that forgiveness and nurturing
others will be necessary for the fulfillment of man's purpose. Necessary for ascension.
That's it for this complete breakdown. It took so long, it's dark out and I got a wardrobe change.
If you like it, please hit the like button. It really does help out a lot more than people think.
And leave all your comments, suggestions and all that down below and I'll see you in the next one.
Thanks. Bye.
