Parliamentary Law-Making - English Legal System

History of Law
11 followers
#education #law #learning
The Law Academy is a project designed to provide legal education for students studying law in the UK. Subscribe for more content.
A. Gillespie & S. Weare, The English Legal System (Oxford University Press, 2021).
E. Allbon & S. Kaur-Dua, English Legal System (Pearson 2020).
Disclaimer:
At no point are these video lessons intended to provide any sort of legal advice. These are for educational purposes only!
Image(s) Copyright: This Photo by Unknown Author is licensed under CC BY-SA
Welcome back everybody to our study of the English legal system. In this lesson what we're going to
do is talk about the lawmaking process that exists within England and Wales and within the English
legal system specifically. We're going to begin in this lesson and in the next couple of lessons as
well talking about the nature of parliamentary lawmaking, talk about the process by which
parliament passes legislation. This is going to be something of an introduction, just talking about
parliament in terms of its structure, in terms of the two houses, the concept of bicameralism
and the type of papers which lead ultimately to the creation of a bill which may then turn into
a piece of legislation. So this is going to be the start of our examination of the various sources
of law which exist ultimately within the English legal system. We're going to begin like I've said
by talking about the nature of the Westminster model of parliamentary legislation and the
Westminster model of parliamentary lawmaking, the process by which law is created in parliament.
So ultimately one of the key principles which we have in the constitutional framework of the UK
is this idea that lawmaking ought to be done through democratic means. This is a sort of
development, a principle which has developed over many many years. It is not one that is
necessarily enshrined by revolution in the case of some countries, for example the US,
but the concept of democracy is one that is deeply enshrined within the lawmaking process
of the UK's constitution. And so as a result of this, in the vast majority of cases,
the process by which law is made today is performed through parliament, an institution which is for
the most part democratically elected, at least the most powerful institution within parliament
is democratically elected. Now we do have lawmaking that takes place through the common
law and the development of the common law. This is of course when we talk about judge-made law
and the role of the judiciary. We'll get to that in future lessons time, but in terms of
how statutes are passed, how legislation is made, this is done through the institution of parliament.
Now ultimately the lawmaking process which parliament operates is done on a process of
three major elements. We talk about lawmaking that goes on in the house of commons, we then
talk about how lawmaking goes on in the house of lords, and then we talk about the role of the
crown in turning a bill into a piece of legislation through the conventional process of royal assent.
Now one of the things that exists within the legislative framework of the UK's constitution
is this idea known as bicameralism. Now what bicameralism tells us is the idea that essentially
the legislature within the United Kingdom's constitutional framework, i.e. the system,
the institution which creates legislation, is divided into two chambers. We call Westminster
Parliament bicameral because it is divided into two distinct chambers. We have these chambers
that exist and as we noted on the previous slide, the first chamber of course being the house of
commons, the second chamber being the house of lords. Now this is similar to a number of other
institutions around the world in terms of legislative institutions. So examples of
bicameral legislative institutions include, for example, the United States and Congress,
which is divided into two chambers. You have the house of representatives in Congress and then you
also have the Senate, which are the two chambers of Congress. You also have institutions which may
be tricameral. I believe the Spanish legislature, for example, is a tricameral institution where you
have three chambers. And so this is really just an examination of the kind of structure that exists
within the system of the UK's legislature. So given the fact that it is bicameral in nature,
we have two distinct chambers. Let's think about the first one, the house of commons. The house of
commons is made up of members of parliament, sometimes described as MPs, and there are 650
and they all are representative of a constituency around the country. So the United Kingdom is
divided into essentially, it's cut up essentially into 650 different sectors. Each of these are
called a constituency and every single constituency has one member of parliament that goes to the
house of commons and represents the people in that regard. All except for one,
because you have the speaker of the house of commons, who is a member of parliament in the
same way as the other 649, but is not allowed to have a say and has to be completely politically
neutral in terms of the adjudication of parliament. So the constituents of that particular constituency
are not technically represented in the same way as the other 649. But that's essentially how we
operate. We have a 650 member parliament and again the UK is divided into these 650 constituencies
and when you go to a general election, when you go to the ballot box, you will elect your member
of parliament. You do not elect a political party per se, you'll put a vote and your casting vote
is for that particular member of parliament in the particular constituency that you live. And
so as a result of which the idea of you electing a political party is a little bit skewed because
you are electing an individual person, but that person obviously is associated most of the time
and aligned with a political party. And so from that we have the representative in
parliament who is supposed to represent those within that constituency. Now the political party
that has the largest majority in the house of commons is the one which will be invited by
convention by the crown to form a government. So when you have the previous election was in 2019
at the time of recording. I'm recording this lesson on the 6th of October 2023. We are likely going to
have an election next year but that is for now we have an election we had an election 2019.
The largest majority in the house of commons was of course the Conservative government. The
Conservative government was invited by the then Queen of the United Kingdom to go and
form a government in her name. Now for the most part it is the government which is the representative
on which is represented as the majority in the house of commons who has a say on the formation
of new laws. So for the most part the government owing to the fact that they have a majority of
members of parliament essentially controls the timetable and the schedule for that particular
parliament's legislative agenda. This also fits in line with the democratic legitimacy of that
government. It makes sense to suggest that the political party which was voted in as having the
largest majority in the house of commons commands the largest majority of support from the population
of the United Kingdom and so as a result of which they ought to have the majority say in terms of
reigns of the legislative agenda such as putting into and implementing their manifesto pledge
owing to the fact that on paper they were elected on the basis of the delivery of this manifesto
that they proposed. The house of lords on the other hand is seen to be the quote-unquote upper house
it is or the upper chamber within parliament. It is the unelected branch of the Westminster
parliament and despite it being considered the upper house or considered or at least coined
colloquially as the upper chamber the house of lords actually has very little power compared
that to the commons. This is obviously owing to the democratic nature of the latter. Historically
the house of lords was particularly powerful but over very many years many centuries in fact
the power of the house of commons begins to grow as we start to get into this idea of democratic
legitimacy and then over time the house of lords ultimately is subordinate to the house of commons.
Now the house of lords can do very little often to block legislation. We have the parliaments
acts from 1919 and 1949 to make that very very clear and we also have constitutional conventions
which make it very unlikely for the house of lords to be able to block legislation that is
passed by the house of commons. For example the Salisbury convention tells us that when we talk
about a piece of legislation which is part of the winning party's manifesto the convention is that
the house of lords cannot block that piece of legislation because not only are you in doing so
blocking the legislation itself but you're also technically blocking the will of the people
in the sense that you are blocking what the political party that had the largest majority
is in government for in terms of their manifesto. So if they were elected on the basis of a manifesto
pledge then they cannot block that manifesto pledge from taking place that is the Salisbury
convention in a nutshell. In terms of the early process by which legislation is made we have to
make a delineation between green papers and white papers. Now the government ministers will have a
civil service set of employees and the civil service will then be able to work for them
and advise them on matters of policy. So the process of getting a manifesto and being elected
on the basis of a manifesto and then taking that manifesto forward and being able to implement
those policies into legislation is of course a very long and an arduous process one that involves a
lot of civil service employees and a lot of government ministers being advised on matters of
policy. Now when major policy issues are then brought up the government department in question
whether that's the treasury, whether that's the department of health, whether that is the
department of education, whether that's the home office, that government department will then issue
what are known as green papers and then white papers. A green paper is simply a document which
outlines a topic of policy or of law reform and essentially what that is supposed to do
is try to provide the government with some kind of consultative guidance on the issue of that
particular policy. It's supposed to essentially give the government a certain amount of guidance
as to the direction of which that policy ought to go. It's not necessarily as formal and as
substantive and as concrete as the second of these types of papers because it is only supposed to
outline a topic of policy or a topic of law reform. A white paper on the other hand is then published
and is supposed to be a far more substantial position on what the government believes to be
the correct course of action in a particular set of circumstances and so as a result of which we
go from a green paper to then a white paper and this then turns into and begins to formulate a
formal piece of legislation or at least a formal bill which will then go through the legislative
process and we're going to get into the legislative process and the types of bills in the next few
lessons time.
