Top 10 Best Midwestern American Sandwiches | Best American Food

American Cuisine
12 followers
May 1, 2026 #AmericanCuisine
Here, in the Midwest, eating is a form of entertainment unto itself. Locals shovel
food into mouths with both hands, and the sandwiches served at Midwest diners and
county fairs demand all of a consumer's attention. Here's a list of sandwiches unique to the Midwest,
most of them are unwieldy and unhealthy, but absolutely all of them are truly amazing and
incredibly delicious. Hi! You're on the Best American Food channel, and this is a selection
of the 10 Best Midwestern American Sandwiches. Number 10. Shredded Chicken Sandwich.
Shredded Chicken Sandwich is a sandwich that's a specialty of Northern and Central Ohio.
It is made by cooking and fork shredding chicken, that is then cooked in chicken broth or condensed
chicken soup with flour, bread crumbs, or crushed potato chips. The combination is seasoned with
black pepper before being served on hamburger buns. The sandwich was especially popular in
the 1960s, when it was a staple of school lunch menus, dairy bars, and church gatherings. It was
made with leftover old and tough chicken meat, so what anyone could do is to simply make creamed
chicken, then serve it in buns or over biscuits. Number 9. Polish Boy. Polish Boy is the signature
sandwich of Cleveland, Ohio, consisting of a kielbasa sausage, coleslaw, fries, and barbecue
sauce in a bun. It is believed that Polish Boy was most likely invented by a restaurant owner
named Virgil Whitmore in the 1940s, who combined a smoked beef sausage with other available
ingredients that he had in the restaurant. Today, there are some variations on the original, such as
the addition of pulled pork to the already huge sandwich that is Polish Boy. Number 8. Butter
Burger. Wisconsin's messy contribution to the world of burgers is called Butter Burger. For some,
Butter Burger is authentic when the ground meat is combined with butter. For others, it's when the
The only thing that everyone can agree on is that there must be enough butter to drip off the meat,
which will usually form a small pool of butter on one's plate. A mainstay of greasy diners
throughout Wisconsin, Butter Burger may not be good for one's health, but it will certainly
satiate one's hunger. Number 7. Maxwell Street Polish. One of the street foods that are synonymous
with Chicago, the Maxwell Street Polish sandwich is said to have been created in 1943 by a
who operated a hot dog stand, now called Jim's Original, back then located in Chicago's old
Maxwell Street Market District. Served on a bun, the grilled or fried Polish sausage is topped
with grilled onions, yellow mustard and optional pickled green sport peppers. Soon after its
invention, Maxwell Street Polish grew to be one of the Windy City's most popular local fare,
and remains a staple of its hot dog stands until this day. Number 6. Runza. A specialty of Nebraska,
Runza is a sandwich consisting of a yeast dough bread filled with beef, cabbage, onions,
and various seasonings. It can be baked in many shapes such as squares, triangles, or half moons,
although the authentic Nebraskan version is almost always baked in a rectangular shape.
It is believed that the original Runza sandwich has German and Russian roots,
dating back to the 18th century, and the recipe eventually made its way to the Midwestern area
of America, where it was originally served as lunch for the field workers. Number 5. Pork
Tenderloin Sandwich. The pork tenderloin sandwich consists of a breaded and deep-fried pork cutlet,
that is usually served on a hamburger bun. Typical side dishes include french fries and
onion rings, while the condiments of choice are usually mustard, lettuce, pickles, or mayonnaise.
The sandwich is popular throughout the Midwest, especially in the states of Indiana and Iowa.
Number 4. He Burrito. He Burrito is a unique Chicago sandwich with Puerto Rican roots,
which made with smashed, fried plantains instead of bread. The sandwich is typically
filled with garlic mayonnaise, meat, lettuce, tomatoes, and cheese. The origins of he burrito
are somewhat hard to untangle, as some claim that the sandwich is originally a Puerto Rican
invention, while others claim that it was created by Juan Figueroa at the Borinquen
restaurant in Chicago in 1996. The most probable theory says, that the sandwich was invented by
Feliciano and Jorge Munoz at Platano Loco restaurant in Aguada, Puerto Rico, and Figueroa
probably read about it, which inspired him to make another version in Chicago.
Number 3. Chicago Style Hot Dog. Chicago Style Hot Dog's history begins with street cart hot
dog vendors who first started selling them during the harsh times of the Great Depression.
Chicago Dog was born as the vendors offered a flavorful, hot meal on a bun and started selling
it for only a nickel. Vienna Beef Hot Dog was placed in a steamed poppy seed bun, then topped
with numerous ingredients, green relish, yellow mustard, fresh, diced onions, red tomato slices,
kosher pickles, a bit of pickled peppers, and a sprinkle of celery salt. The customers absolutely
loved the unique combination of hot and cold, crisp and soft, sharp and smooth, and the hot
dogs became an authentic icon of the city. Number 2. Juicy Lucy. Named one of Time Magazine's 17
most influential burgers, Juicy Lucy, also purposely spelled without the I, is a twist on
the classic cheeseburger, in which the cheese is melted inside the patty. Hands down a Minneapolis
favorite, the cheese-stuffed Lucy burger is an exquisite experience, which actually requires
some skill in order to know how to eat it without burning your mouth with a hot shot of the flowing
molten American cheese locked between the two ground beef patties. Apart from the succulent
beef, this cheeseburger also carries another quarter-pound of controversy, mostly due to the
its origin, as there are two Minneapolis burger eateries claiming its invention. This rivalry
continues to amuse the people of Minneapolis and adds just a pinch of that extra spice to make you
want to try both Lucys. Number 1. Italian Beef Sandwich. Italian beef is a popular Chicagoan
sandwich consisting of thinly sliced, seasoned layers of roast beef in a dense and chewy Italian
style roll, topped with either pickled giardiniera relish or roasted green bell peppers. The sandwich
is typically dipped in jus, on one end, both ends, or completely soaked in the flavorful gravy.
Additionally, mozzarella or cheddar cheese can be added to the sandwich, according to personal
preferences. Italian beef sandwich is a staple of Chicago's cuisine, found at numerous restaurants
and hot dog stands across the city. What's your favorite Midwestern American sandwich?
Share your opinions on today's selection in the comments, subscribe to my channel not to miss the
interesting video about the best American food, and I say goodbye to you until the next video.
Thank you all, bye, everyone.
