The First Principle Of Wisdom Is Not "Inconstancy". (It's Happiness)

People & Faith
22 followers
1 Video View·May 1, 2026
The first principle of wisdom is not inconstancy, it's happiness.
Wisdom begins with the desire to find long-term happiness.
It's important to keep that point in mind, especially when we listen to the teachings
on inconstancy or impermanence. Remember that the desire for long-term happiness
provides the framework for understanding how to use the teachings on inconstancy,
because a lot of people get it the other way around.
They say that wisdom starts with seeing how everything is inconstant.
Then from that point, you look at your desire for happiness,
and you realize that you've got to tame it, you've got to tone it down.
Just accept that things are inconstant. Long-term happiness is impossible.
So you grab what you can. Of course, as a good Buddhist,
you're polite. You don't grab too much. You hold on to things for just a bit,
and then you let them go. Whatever pleasures you can find,
you realize they're passing, and you milk them for the pleasure you can find in them.
And let them go. Then find another one,
as if you were dancing and kept changing partners. But if you think in those terms,
there's no reason to put any effort into finding particular forms of happiness.
And objectively speaking, no way of finding happiness would be better than any other.
You'd simply accept the pleasures as they come,
wherever they come from. With the bittersweet realization, you have to let them go.
But that's okay, because new pleasures will come up in their place.
This is all very wrong-headed, because it's got the framework and the teaching
that fits into the framework all backwards. This is similar to that issue of which teaching
is the framework. The four noble truths on the one hand, or the three characteristics
or perceptions on the other. The two issues are actually related.
The four noble truths tell us that the end of suffering is possible. Long-term happiness
is possible. We cultivate the desire for that long-term happiness as we practice the path.
We let go of any desires that get in the way that would lead to suffering.
And in letting go of those desires, we have to use the three perceptions
to develop a sense of dispassion. So, the three perceptions find their
role within the context of the four noble truths. In the same way, the perception of inconstancy
finds its role within the context of our desire for long-term happiness.
That desire is something the Buddha takes for granted. He says we all start with suffering.
When we suffer, we search for somebody who knows a way out. That search for a way out becomes wise
when we look for someone who's practiced. As the Buddha says, a contemplative or a Brahman,
by which he means a noble disciple or at the very least somebody who knows the Dharma.
And we ask that person, what when I do it will lead to my long-term welfare and happiness?
This is the point where your search for an escape from suffering becomes wise.
Because you recognize that it's going to depend on your actions and that there is such a thing
as long-term happiness. That's the message we learn from the four noble truths.
And of course, long-term is better than short-term. So, in that context, with any
happiness that's inconstant, you have to ask yourself, does this measure up?
Now, there are some inconstant pleasures that will measure up for the time being.
The pleasures of generosity, the pleasures of virtue, and the pleasures of meditation.
Even though these may not be permanent, they have their ups and downs. Still,
they're more long-term than your typical pleasures because they're totally blameless.
And as you look for happiness in these ways, you get a sense of self-esteem.
You realize that you're being responsible in your search for happiness. And you see
that being good in these ways makes other people happy too. In that sense of connection,
your happiness and their happiness are not in conflict. It warms the heart. It overcomes your
sense of being totally alone in this world. And as I said, it gives rise to a sense of self-esteem.
This is why when the Buddha identified the beginning of wisdom, it wasn't with the question,
is form constant or inconstant? That comes later. It begins with what, when I do it,
will lead to my long-term welfare and happiness. As for the inconstancy of form, feelings,
perceptions, fabrications, and consciousness, that's a teaching you use within the context
of that search for long-term happiness. As you get in the more advanced stages
of the practice, you look at the states of concentration that you can develop.
Sometimes you don't realize their states of concentration. The mind just gets really,
really still, very expansive, very bright. And you might ask yourself,
is this it? Is this what I've been practicing for? Well, you pull out that question.
Is it constant or inconstant? You have to watch it. You realize that if it's something
you have to put together and you have to maintain, it's not going to last forever.
And there's the stress. Even though it may be very slight, there's still the stress
in the maintaining. So you ask yourself, is this worth it? Should I claim this as my goal?
Well, no. That inspires you to move on, to look for something better.
So the perception of inconstancy is a tool that you use within the larger context of
your search for happiness. It's for testing whatever form of happiness you arrive at
to see if it's the real deal. In the meantime, it encourages you to look for forms of happiness
that are relatively long-term. It's in the context of giving priority to the search for
true or lasting happiness that the whole practice of merit makes sense. It's not simply that you
happen to be strange and like to be generous and virtuous, whereas other people like to find
their happiness in other ways by being selfish and heartless. It's because you realize that the
kind of happiness that comes from merit is better, say, than the happiness that comes from simply
trying to grab hold of pleasures in terms of sights, sounds, smells, tastes, and tactile
sensations. It's wiser, less harmful, and more conducive to further progress on the path.
So the Buddha's teachings on the search for happiness are not different strokes for different
folks or just whatever happens to catch your fancy. You want to think through your search
for happiness. Think about the fact that happiness will be long-term only if it doesn't
cause harm to other people. That realization is the beginning of compassion. And happiness will
depend on your actions. That realization is the beginning of purity. So when you think carefully
about happiness, you realize that the wise search for happiness includes compassion and purity.
And here, you've got all the qualities of the Buddha. His wisdom, his compassion, and his purity.
These are the things we admire in him. If we follow his example and search for happiness
in a way that's responsible and well thought through, we'll develop those qualities within
ourselves. And that augments our happiness. So it's not just a matter of switching partners
whenever a certain pleasure falls away. It's building qualities within yourself
that you can rely on in the long term. The Buddha was never the sort of teacher who would say
that the search for happiness is bad and that you shouldn't try to look for your own happiness.
Quite the contrary. He says to search for happiness, but do it wisely.
Think about the implications of what a wise search for happiness would be.
And when you do that, that's when you begin to be genuinely wise.
A Healthy Understanding of Kamma We talked last night about how kamma
is often misunderstood and as a result often disliked. Part of the problem, in America at least,
is that the teaching on kamma is sometimes seen as psychologically unhealthy. This is
because it's believed to be deterministic. As a result, the complaint is that the idea of kamma
makes people get fatalistic about their own suffering, complacent about their pleasure,
and callous and indifferent to other people's suffering. But this view is based on a
misunderstanding of the Buddha's actual teachings on kamma. Tonight I would like to show how the
Buddha taught kamma in a way that is psychologically very healthy. The first step will be to talk about
what constitutes a healthy attitude toward action. The second step will be to see how the Buddha
taught a healthy attitude toward action to his own son, Rahula. And then the third step
will be to draw some implications from what he taught Rahula.
To begin with, suppose you have a child. When you train your child, what principles would you
want to teach the child to give it a healthy attitude to his or her own actions? The first
principle would be think before you act. Choose carefully what you want to do because your actions
do have results. Some actions can be very harmful, others can be very helpful.
That's the first principle, the principle of heedfulness. The second principle would be
your intentions make a difference. If the child breaks something intentionally,
the punishment should be very different from when he breaks it unintentionally. The third
principle would be pay attention to what you're doing and see the results you're getting.
If you see that you're doing something hurtful, stop. Further, if you see you've done something
harmful, resolve not to repeat it. This is the principle of compassion. The next principle would
be admit your mistakes. If you broke something, don't say that it was already broken before you
stepped on it. If you've made a mistake, talk it over. Don't be debilitated by remorse. But at the
same time, don't be callous about the harm you've done. This is the principle of integrity along with
truthfulness. Finally, learn from your mistakes so that you don't have to repeat them. Now, in order
to teach your child these principles, you have to be a good parent too. If your child comes and says
that he crashed your car, take a long deep breath and tell him not to do it again. If you fly off
the handle, your child will never admit a mistake to you ever again. So these are the basic principles
in teaching a healthy attitude toward action and toward the mistakes people make in their actions.
Nobody is born totally perfect. So we have to be willing to admit the fact that we will make
mistakes. But we should also be willing to learn from them. These are actually the same principles
that the Buddha taught to his son, Rahula. The commentary says that Rahula was seven years old
when the Buddha gave him those instructions. The basic instructions are these. The first principle
is to be truthful, which means not only being truthful to other people, but also being truthful
to yourself. As the Buddha told Rahula, if you feel no shame at telling a deliberate lie,
you're totally empty of goodness. Truth is the basis for all progress in the life of the mind.
Then the Buddha taught Rahula how to use his actions as a way of purifying his heart and mind.
First he said, before you act, ask yourself, what are the consequences you anticipate from the
action? This applies to actions of the body, actions of speech, actions of mind. If you foresee
any harm from the action, don't do it. If you don't foresee any harm, you can go ahead and do it
while you're doing it. If you see that it's causing any unexpected harm, stop. If you don't
see any harm, you can continue with the action. Once the action is done, you're still not done.
You have to look at the long-term consequences. If you see that the action did cause harm,
talk it over with someone else who has experience on the path to gain that person's perspective
on what you did wrong and what might have been better to do instead. And then,
resolve not to repeat the same mistake again. If you don't see any harmful consequences,
take pride in the fact that your practice is developing and continue trying to get better
and better. When you look at these instructions, you see that they embody the four principles of
a healthy attitude toward action. Heedfulness, compassion, truthfulness, and integrity.
Heedfulness in that you take the results of your actions seriously.
Compassion in that you don't want to do any harm. Truthfulness in your willingness to admit
your mistakes. And integrity in taking responsibility for any harm that you've done.
These are good qualities to bring to meditation practice as well.
Other lessons that can be drawn from these instructions concerning the nature of action,
what might be called the metaphysical implications of a psychologically healthy
attitude toward our power of choice and the power of our actions.
1. You are free in how you choose to act. If you didn't have freedom of choice,
the whole idea of teaching a path of practice to put an end to suffering wouldn't make any sense.
For no one could choose whether to follow the path or not.
2. Actions have results.
3. Your intentions are important, but good intentions are not enough. You have to learn
how to make your intentions skillful. This is why we have to check the results of our actions.
Simply meaning well, we can still cause harm. It's through experience, learning from our mistakes,
that we learn what genuinely is helpful and genuinely is harmful.
In fact, to see things in this way is the beginning of wisdom.
You may remember from the first passage in the Kamma readings,
that the question leading to discernment is, what, when I do it, will lead to my long-term
welfare and happiness? The wisdom here consists in understanding two things.
The first is realizing that happiness and suffering come from your actions,
and the second is realizing that long-term happiness is better than short-term.
There's a passage in the Dhammapada where the Buddha says that if you see a long-term happiness,
that would come from abandoning a short-term happiness.
You should be willing to give up the short-term happiness for the sake of the long-term.
A British translator once translated this passage into English and added a footnote saying that this
could not possibly be what the passage really means because the principle is so basic that
Still, even though everybody may know it, not everybody acts on it,
which is why the Buddha has to remind us.
A fourth metaphysical implication that can also be drawn from the Buddha's instructions to Rahula
is that the results of actions follow a pattern. Otherwise, you couldn't learn from a mistake.
If you do one thing today and the same thing tomorrow but get different results,
you can't learn from your past actions. However, it's because there is a pattern to actions and
their results that we can learn. This pattern has two features. In some cases, you do an action
and you can see the results immediately. This is why the Buddha recommends looking for the
results of an action while you are doing it. In other cases, you don't see the results until
a long time after. This is why he recommends checking the results of the action after it's
done. Sometimes the patterns combine so that you see the results both immediately and after a long
time. As we will see tomorrow, these two features of the causal pattern are very important.
The fact that there are actually two patterns interacting is what allows the Buddha's teachings
on causality to avoid determinism on the one hand and chaos on the other. In other words,
there are patterns, so there is no chaos. But you are free in the present moment to change your
which means that there is no strict determinism. In this way, the Buddha finds a middle way
that allows for freedom within the patterns of cause and effect in our actions.
In fact, these interacting patterns form the basic metaphysical principle
on the nature of causality that the Buddha discovered in the course of his awakening.
Together, they form the fourth metaphysical implication of a healthy psychological attitude
toward actions. That actions have a pattern that we can learn and master,
but that the pattern is not deterministic. We can use our understanding of this pattern
to manipulate causes and effects in the direction we want. This pattern and its implications will
be the theme for tomorrow night's talk. Finally, the instructions to Rahula carry
some implications in terms of the qualities of mind that need to be trained in order to
follow this practice. The first quality is attention,
in particular, appropriate attention, asking the right questions about your actions before you do
The second quality is ardency, which is the whole-hearted desire to be skillful.
This grows directly from appropriate attention. If you see that something is skillful,
you want with your whole heart to develop it. If you see that something is unskillful,
you want with your whole heart to avoid it. This connects with the principles of
heedfulness and compassion. When these two principles combine,
they form the foundation of wisdom and discernment. The third quality you need to develop
is alertness, the ability to see clearly what you're doing while you're doing it,
and the results you're actually getting as they arise. In other words, you don't see just
what you hope to be getting, you see what actually happens as a result of your actions.
This connects to the principle of honesty or truthfulness.
The fourth quality is mindfulness, remembering to keep asking the right questions,
the ability to remember your purpose in practicing, and also the ability to remember
what you've learned from past actions, where to look in the present moment,
and how to handle different issues as they come up. When you combine mindfulness with ardency,
they connect with the principle of integrity, in that you want to remember your mistakes and not
repeat them. These four qualities are the qualities that go together in establishing
mindfulness, which is the topic for tomorrow morning's talk. All of these qualities should
be developed in all of your actions, which is why the Buddha's instructions to Rahula
are a good example of how to give beginning instructions in meditation.
The Pali word for meditation, bhavana, means to develop, and specifically to develop good
qualities of mind. Now, this process doesn't begin only when you sit down with your eyes closed.
It begins in the way you conduct your entire life, because the same mind is acting in all
whether your eyes are opened or closed. If you're dishonest in your daily life,
you'll find it hard to be honest with yourself in meditation.
If you're careless in your daily actions, it's hard to be careful as you meditate.
As I said earlier today, having purified virtue is one of the qualities that develop mindfulness,
and one of the reasons why this is so is that the qualities of mind implicated in the Buddha's
instructions to Rahula are developed through observing the precepts. To observe the precepts
requires these same qualities of mind. You need to use appropriate attention to ask yourself
how you will observe the precepts in your life, and in particular, what changes you need to make
in your behavior to bring it in line with the precepts. You also need ardency and the whole
hearted desire to follow the precepts strictly, alertness to make sure that you really are
following them, and finally, mindfulness in keeping the precepts in mind. Without these qualities,
you cannot observe the precepts. When you observe the precepts, you reinforce these qualities.
When they're reinforced, you can bring those developed qualities into your meditation.
It's important to realize that the lessons from these instructions to Rahula
go all the way from the most basic level of the practice to the highest. When the Buddha,
in another context, discusses the role of emptiness as applied to concentration practice,
he tells you to examine your state of mind to see where it still contains disturbance
and where it's empty of disturbance. If you detect any disturbance,
you ask yourself what you're doing in your concentration to cause that disturbance.
When you see a perception that causes a disturbance, you let it go in the same way
that the Buddha told Rahula to examine his actions and let go of any unskillful ones.
As you follow this process of looking for disturbances and their causes and letting
go of the causes, the state of mind empty of disturbance gets greater and greater.
The disturbances and the perceptions causing them get more and more subtle until you finally reach
awakening. This process follows the same pattern that the Buddha taught to Rahula.
Examining your actions, seeing the causes and the results in your mind in the present moment,
letting go of anything unskillful, this can take you all the way to the end of the path.
Several years back when I was teaching the passage on the Buddha's teachings to Rahula
to a group of people in America, there was a psychotherapist in the group. She was teaching
a mindfulness-based therapy group and so she took the instructions to Rahula, copied them out,
gave them to the members of the group for their last session together the next day.
After they had read the passage, she asked them,
What do you think of the Buddha as a teacher and a parent? They replied,
If our parents had taught us like this, we wouldn't need you now. Q.
The Buddha trained Rahula in how to comport himself so that he would not be a nuisance
to other people. Unfortunately, not everyone in the world is Rahula. What attitude should
one adopt in the face of people who do things that are unreflective and who have no sense of
their own limits? Should we develop patience, tolerance, forgiveness? What other things
should we do, especially given that we have not yet attained the first level of awakening?
A. When dealing with difficult people, the approach we take should be determined by
whether they are responsive to our actions or not. Some people are responsive and we can actually
have a good influence on their actions. In that case, try to be proactive in helping them.
Others are difficult to deal with and will not respond. That's where you have to develop
equanimity and forgiveness. And this is why it's good to think about the principle of kamma
in general that helps put your actions and the other person's actions into a larger perspective.
Q. Some people are upset because other people don't share their point of view or because other
people do things that they think are stupid or say things that are stupid or useless from their
point of view. What advice can we give such people to understand that maybe the problem is not with
other people but with them? A. First, make sure the problem is not with you. Then if you see
that the problem really is with that other person, you would probably have to give advice in an
This will take time, but often in cases like this, indirection combined with a lot of compassion
is a lot more effective than direct comments.
Q. Do you think that there is a god or a creator? A. In the Buddhist cosmology,
there are gods and some of them think that they created the world. But according to the Buddha,
they did not. Many of the gods are just as deluded as human beings are, and some even more so.
There's a famous story in the canon, in Daga Nikaya 11, where a monk is meditating and begins
to see some devas. So he asks them a question, which boils down to this. Where does the physical
universe end? They reply, We don't know, but there are devas who are higher than we are.
Maybe they know? So the monk meditates some more and meets a higher level of devas.
He asks them the same question, and they reply, We don't know, but there are devas
who are higher than we are. Maybe they know? So the monk gets sent up, up, up, up, up the deva
bureaucracy in this way until finally he reaches a level of devas who say, We don't know, but there
is a great Brahma. He should know. So the monk meditates some more and finally has a vision of
He asks the great Brahma, Do you know where the physical universe ends?
And the great Brahma answers, I am the great Brahma, knower of all, all powerful, creator
of all that has been and will be. Now, if this were the book of Job, the monk would have said,
Okay, I understand. But this is the Pali canon. So the monk says, That's not what I asked you.
I want to know where the physical universe ends. But the great Brahma simply says again,
I am the great Brahma, knower of all, seer of all, creator of all etc. altogether three times.
Finally, the great Brahma pulls the monk aside by the arm and says, I don't know,
but I have this large multitude of followers, and they believe that I know everything.
They would be disappointed if I admitted my ignorance in front of them.
So the Brahma advises the monk, Go back to the Buddha and ask him the question.
So the monk goes back to the Buddha. And the Buddha says, That's the wrong question to ask.
The right question is, Where does the experience of the universe end? That ends in the mind,
the awakened mind. The consciousness of awakening is what goes beyond the universe.
That's the story. There is another place where the Buddha says that if you think there is a
creator God, who is responsible for the pleasure and pain you experience, you can't really practice
the Dharma. You have to realize that the important issues are the things that you create.
When you solve the issue of your own creations, then you're done with the problem.
