ISAC Special Exhibition Lecture Revisiting Roman Sculpture at the OI: Ptolemais and Beyond
Kiersten Neumann, Interim Chief Curator, ISAC Museum; and Roko Rumora, PhD candidate, Department of Art History, University of Chicago, join us for a lecture that explores the newest ISAC Museum special exhibition, "Making Sense of Marbles: Roman Sculpture at the OI." On view as a group for the first time, the Institute for the Study of Ancient Cultures’s collection of Roman sculpture illustrates how we can makes sense of marbles with divergent histories and the fundamental importance of archaeological context in telling an object’s story.
The special exhibition, co-curated by Kiersten and Roko, will be on view from September 15, 2022 to March 12, 2023.
Thank you all, both here in the room and for coming out on this beautiful day
here to the OI, and also welcome to everybody who is joining us remotely.
It's a great pleasure and honor to welcome you here to this new exhibit at the OI,
Making Sense of Marbles, Roman Sculpture at the OI. This is one of those shows where we
like to feature lesser known aspects of the collections that we have in the building,
and where we can demonstrate some of the breadth of the collections that we have. And that
breadth is, I mean, both in a geographical sense and in a chronological sense. Because
if you go into the museum, not into the special exhibit that we are talking about now, but if you
go into the orientation area, there is this huge map with all the spots indicated where the OI
ever conducted excavations and is still doing excavations, you will see that the westernmost
spot where the OI has excavated is actually the one in Libya, modern day Libya, where these
sculptures come from. I have to be careful though, what I just said, it is the westernmost spot
where the OI has ever excavated. If the opening had been, let's say, two months ago, it would have
been absolutely true. But just a few weeks ago, one of our archaeologists, Professor David Sloan,
returned from Spain, where he, near Malaga, has started an excavation with Spanish colleagues
of an old Phoenician colony. So that is now our westernmost spot. But anyway, so Libya,
if you look on the big map, you will see that it is a real outlier for where the OI has worked.
And also, in a chronological sense, it shows the breadth of what we have in the sense that it is
for our, to our standards, what we do in the OI here. It is very late, it is Roman era,
but it is very interesting, and you will hear all about it this afternoon
in the lectures by Kirsten Newman and Rocco Romura, whom I will introduce later.
Another thing that we want to highlight, that you will see highlighted in the exhibit,
is the research that was done for this exhibit. And that is something also that
Kirsten and Rocco will tell you all about. And your attention will also be drawn in the show
to such timely discussions as where do these things come from? How did we get them? Why do
we have them? Those questions will be addressed as well in this show. Now, of course, a show like
this is a real collective effort of the entire museum staff, so I want to thank here from the
conservation department, who had a lot of work on the statues and the other sculptural elements
that you will see, Laura D'Alessandro and Alison White, our two conservators. I hope you will
agree with me when you've seen it that the show is beautifully, yeah, done. And so I really want
to thank here our exhibit designers and producers, Robert Bain and Josh Tulisiak. In the sense of
what I just said, that we want to draw attention to why are these statues here?
That is an element for which we needed our OI archivist, Anne Flannery. And of course,
these, all the materials that you will see come from our basement where our registrars
reign, and they are Helen McDonald and Susan Allison, and I want to thank them too for
all their work. I mentioned the research done on the sculptures that you will be seeing.
There was a spectroscopy analysis performed on a pigment sample from one of the pieces,
and that was done by the University of Chicago Materials Research Science and Engineering Center,
which is supported by a grant from the National Science Foundation, so thanks to them as well.
And then let me, without further ado, briefly introduce to you the two curators of this
particular exhibit. Kirsten Newman will be the first speaker. She is our interim chief curator
here at the OI. She got her PhD from Berkeley in Near Eastern Art and Archaeology, and she joined
the OI in 2015. She has excavated in Turkey and Greece, in Athens at the Agora, and just this year
she published a book that she co-edited, the important Routlet Handbook of the Senses in the
Ancient Near East. And she's also, if you look at her website, the author of an already quite
impressive number of articles. Kirsten also lectures at the art history department here at
our university, and you probably know her from earlier shows that she curated here at the OI.
Persepolis, Images of an Empire. And then the show that preceded this one, and I hope you have seen
it, that was the Joseph Lyndon Smith, the Persepolis Paintings, which was another very
unusual show for the OI, but I loved it. It was very striking and well done. And I hope you saw
it, because it may be another 100 years before you will see those paintings all together.
The same may be true for the sculptures right now on display. The other curator, Rocco Romura,
he is a doctoral candidate in art history, also here at the University of Chicago, and a graduate
curatorial intern in the Department of Antiquities at the J. Paul Getty Museum in LA. Born and raised
in Croatia, Rocco completed his BA in art history at Columbia University, and he was previously also
a curatorial intern at the Department for Ancient and Byzantine Art at the Art Institute here in
Chicago. And his research is very closely tied to what you will be hearing about and what you
will be seeing after reception. His research namely focuses on the evolution of sculptural
aesthetics in the Roman Empire, and he focuses there especially on marble statuary displayed on
monumental facades, decorating civic buildings in the Roman East, and that is what this show is all
about. As both Kirsten and Rocco will tell you, so I hope you will join me in welcoming Kirsten and
Rocco here to the podium. Thank you, Theo, for the kind introduction and to everyone for coming out
this afternoon. Since its founding in 1919, over 100 years ago, the OI has carried out large-scale
excavations at pivotal historic sites across West Asia and North Africa. In the early 20th century,
these excavations made important contributions to the growing collection of the new OI Museum,
which opened its doors to the public in 1931, its displays covering the material culture of
present-day Egypt, Sudan, Israel, Syria, Turkey, Iraq, and Iran, and occupying the same galleries as they
do today. The means by which these excavations arrived in Chicago to join the OI Museum collection
was through a legal system of partage, also known as the division of fines. This practice traditionally
took place at the end of each fieldwork season and entailed the regional administrators for the
Department of Antiquities reviewing the excavated materials and allotting a portion to the OI.
It was with such ambitions that in the 1950s, OI director Carl H. Kraling turned his eye towards
the site of Ptolemaeus. Located near the modern village of Ptolemaeta in Libya, this culturally
diverse Mediterranean coastal city was founded in the mid-3rd century BCE, likely by Ptolemy III,
the third ruler of Egypt's Ptolemaic dynasty. As one of the five cities of the pentapolis of the
region of Cyrenaica, Ptolemaeus prospered during the Hellenistic period and the Roman era and
continued to be occupied through the Byzantine period, so altogether from the 4th century BCE
through the 7th century CE. The OI's expedition to Ptolemaeus would come to fulfill two of
Kraling's desires. First, quote, to explore a site which would contribute to our knowledge of the urban
development of the eastern Mediterranean in Hellenistic and Roman times, end quote, and second,
to form a representative collection of classical sculpture in Chicago. Until this time, Kraling
was known for his work at Gerash in present-day Jordan and Gero Europos in Syria. The initial
impetus for the Ptolemaeus expedition, however, began with a letter dated August 25, 1952 from
Honorable Henry S. Villard, then serving as U.S. minister and subsequently accredited as the U.S.
ambassador in Libya, to a Mr. Herman Dunlap Smith. Smith was both a trustee of the University of
Chicago and a member of the OI's visiting committee. The letter was inquiring after the university's
interest in fieldwork opportunities in the new kingdom, the United Kingdom of Libya, having only
been established a year earlier, so 1951. As a representative of the university, Kraling responded
favorably when the inquiry was shared with him, first carrying out a survey of the region in 1956
and then a sounding at Ptolemaeus in 1954. Following, he applied to the Department of Antiquities
of Cyrenaica, then headed by the Comptroller of Antiquities, Richard G. Goodchild, for permits to
excavate the site on behalf of the OI, receiving licenses for three field seasons. These took place
in the spring of 1956, 1957, and 1958. Prior to the OI's expedition, Ptolemaeus saw partial excavation
and conservation work, as well as the first iteration of a museum storeroom during Italian
excavations in the 1930s, 40s, and 50s. An exploration of the full site was carried out
in order to contribute most fully to a better understanding of urban development in the eastern
Mediterranean. However, Kraling's team focused their excavation efforts on three complexes within
the ancient city walls. The first was a Roman villa with a colonnaded courtyard and lavish
banqueting rooms that were decorated with inlaid marble floors and mosaics. The second complex, dubbed
the private house by Kraling, was a private residence located along the street of monuments
and which had been transformed into the seat of the city's highest public official. And the third,
luxurious city baths of the late Roman and Byzantine periods that included marble-clad pools
and colonnaded porticos. Within these complexes, the expedition revealed large quantities of marble
sculpture, ranging from decorative monumental statuary to reliefs, honorific portraiture, and
inscription, as well as columns and elaborate mosaics. Alongside the OI's work at the site,
Ptolemaeus was also excavated by British archaeologists through the 1970s, and most
recently it has been the focus of excavation and non-invasive surveys carried out by the Institute
of Archaeology of the University of Warsaw from 2001 to 2011. The site has also been a popular
tourist destination and hosts a modest museum that contains many of the sculptures as well as
mosaics that were excavated during the OI expedition. Efforts continue to record and
conserve the Ptolemaeus monuments, and in 2020 the permanent delegation of Libya included Ptolemaeus
on their tentative list submitted to the UNESCO World Heritage Convention.
Two divisions of finds took place during the span of the OI expedition, the first in 1957
and the second in 1958. These resulted in a total of 10 objects being acquired into the OI museum
collection. Six of the objects were marble sculptures, and five of those are listed in
this export license of 1957. Two life-size headless statues, one female and one male,
a medium-sized head of a bearded male, a small marble head, and a headless figure of a sheep.
With the arrival of the first share of Libyan marbles in Chicago, the OI museum opened an
exhibition of Roman sculpture, here photographs showing graduate students alongside the two
life-size statues. As luck would have it, in carrying out our research in the museum archives
for their current exhibition, we came across a press briefing for this mid-century exhibition
among the OI director's correspondents. In this document is an enlightening quote from
Kraling on the significance of this collection. Quote, Chicago does not have a representative
collection of classical sculpture, and it is difficult to obtain them at this late date.
In Libya, thanks to the splendid cooperation of the representatives of the young Libyan government,
it is still possible to excavate and obtain good pieces. With luck and with the support of our
members and friends, we should be able to still find others and give to Chicago more of what it
needs of monuments of classical art. End quote. Also referenced in this document as being part
of the exhibition are sculptures purchased by Kraling for the OI that same year by way of the
International Antiquities Market. Quote, there are also two pieces from Lebanon, one a marble
funerary statue of a boy and a small Aphrodite Cupid ensemble from a tomb. End quote. Already
earlier in the 1950s, Kraling had started to look to the antiquities market to supplement the
Roman sculpture collection in anticipation of the acquisitions from Tholmes, purchasing first
in 1955 a small head of Hercules, shown here to the left, from Elias Solomon David, a dealer based
in New York. Following in 1957 were the two pieces from Lebanon mentioned in the press briefing for
the exhibition. Kraling purchased this pair from the Beirut-based dealers L.A. Boustan, also named
Elias Boustros and Fouad Alouf, with funds from Mr. and Mrs. Hans von der Marwitz, and they were
exported with the permission of Lebanon's Department of Antiquities. This group of three sculptures
from the antiquities market represent the beyond in the title of our talk today, Ptolemaeus and
Beyond. Combining the Ptolemaeus and the purchased marbles, the OI's representative collection of
classical sculptures, to once again quote Kraling, totaled nine, and this group remained housed at
the OI for the coming decades. Then, in 1973, conversations started up regarding a long-term loan
of this group between the OI and the new David and Alford Smart Gallery, today the Smart Museum
of Art of the University of Chicago. A letter from Edward Messer, director of the Smart Gallery,
to Gustavo Swift, OI museum curator at the time, starts, quote, I hope that you will remember our
conversation earlier this year regarding the classical antiquities in the collection of the
Oriental Institute, which you were willing to send to the Smart Gallery so that it can begin to
develop a coverage of the history of art from classical times to the present, end quote. Here,
Messer echoes Kraling's original ambitions for the OI, yet with reference to a different UChicago
institution. A letter from Swift to John A. Brinkman, then director of the OI, professing his support
of the loan, similarly speaks to this shift in perspective. Here, Swift writes, quote, I'm happy
to make this loan in order that the materials may be seen, enjoyed, and studied on this campus,
and because their nature and value is essentially outside the core of our own field, end quote.
Ultimately, in 1974, two loan agreements were signed between the OI and the Smart Gallery,
one for seven objects for exhibition, including the portrait head of an older woman, the head
of a Herms support, and the two life-size statues from Ptolemaeus, from Lebanon, the portrait statue
of a young boy, and last, the head of Hercules from New York. A Byzantine mosaic from the site
of Khirbet al-Karak in modern-day Israel was also loaned from the OI collection for the exhibition.
The second agreement was also, or sorry, the second agreement was for a loan for three objects
for the purpose of teaching and research in the art department, the male head and the statuette
of a ram from Ptolemaeus, and from Lebanon, the Venus with Cupid statuette. Archival photographs
of the Smart Gallery's 1974 inaugural exhibition showed the female statue flanked on her left by
the statue of the young boy, and on the right by the head of the older woman, and in the wall
mounted display case further to the right, the head of Hercules. A selection of these pieces
were later included in the Smart's classical collection publication of 1999, the loan agreement
having been extended a number of times throughout that same year, so until 1999. This volume is the
sole publication of the OI's Roman sculpture beyond those that were included in Kraling's
1962 publication of the excavations of Ptolemaeus in the OIP series, titled Ptolemaeus, City of the
Libyan Pentapolis. The recently opened exhibition, Making Sense of Marbles, presents to the public
for the first time the OI's full collection of Roman sculpture. That being said, it was not simply
this opportunity of completeness that ignited our drive to create this exhibition, to display to the
public a selection of beautiful and engaging marbles. Rather, it was the exceptional opportunity
this group presented for demonstrating the importance of revisiting artifact and archival
collections with new questions, new perspectives, new technology, and the increased knowledge that
comes with the passing of time, of object comparanda, but also of history more generally.
Museums do not require new artifacts, new acquisitions, in order to tell new stories.
Here, I'm showing a selection of the headings from the exhibition to relay something of the
sense of our presentation of these stories, as these likely relay, in addition to new stories
specific to the identities and significance of these individual sculptures, aspects of which
Rocco will dive into shortly with case studies on select works, the OI's Roman sculpture collection
presents an unparalleled opportunity to contribute to the growing discourse in academia, but also the
wider public, on collecting practices, on provenience, meaning archaeological find spots, and provenance,
meaning ownership histories, on archaeology and the art market, and to do so with an accessible
group of nine artifacts, and select archival documents in a modest space. Having been discovered
through scientifically controlled archaeological excavation, the works from Ptolemy has presented
an unparalleled opportunity to understand the diverse roles that sculpture played in the lives
of the city's residents. Conversely, the Roman works acquired from the art market lack the same
type of archaeological information, and so their study was limited to research into their ownership
history, technical examination, and stylistic analysis. The data provided by these methods often
produced as many questions as answers, and here I will turn it over to Rocco to walk us through
some of these artifact analyses, replete with their challenges as well as revelatory moments.
Thank you Kirsten. So as you have already heard, the majority of the objects in the exhibition
come from the site of Ptolemaeus. Ptolemaeus was a Hellenistic, Roman, and Byzantine harbor town
located in the ancient region of Cyrenaica, in modern-day Libya, east of Benghazi. As Kirsten
mentioned, it belonged to a group of five prosperous cities known as the Pentapolis of Cyrenaica,
of which the most important hub was the city of Cyrene, established in the 7th century BCE by
Greek colonists. Ptolemaeus itself emerged first as the harbor town dependent on nearby Barca,
but as its name reveals, it was refounded in the Ptolemaic period in the mid-3rd century BCE.
About a century later, the region of Cyrenaica achieved substantial independence as a state
under Ptolemy VIII, only to be bequeathed to Rome by his son Ptolemy Apion in 96 BCE,
and with that began the period of Roman rule in Ptolemaeus. By the end of the 1st century BCE,
the situation in the region had stabilized, and Cyrenaica, and Ptolemaeus specifically, began
to prosper. For the next century and a half, Ptolemaeus saw the development of the city's
public buildings and private residences, many of them facing the street dubbed the Via Monumentale
by its Italian excavators. We know less about the fate of the city in the 2nd and 3rd centuries
CE, but Ptolemaeus must have continued to prosper to a certain extent, because by the time
Diocletian had set up the province of Libya Superior, Ptolemaeus had become the provincial
capital. A key structure of this late period, facing the Via Monumentale, were the city baths,
one of the three buildings excavated by the OI. Built in the 4th century CE, perhaps in
response to a violent earthquake around 365 CE, the baths were designed according to the
standard planning model of the time. They featured multiple types of bathing rooms,
including the hot water caldarium, the cold water frigidarium, and a room temperature tepidarium.
Upon entering from the street, which you can see on the bottom of the graph,
the visitor would first encounter a spacious interior peristyle, shown here in the middle
of the floor plan, surrounded by spirally fluted Corinthian columns of blue marble.
Marble covered both the floors, cut in opus sectile, as well as the walls. Initially akin
to a palestra or a gymnasium exercise hall, this courtyard was later renovated through the addition
of a central octagonal pool, as well as five basins cut into the form of niches in the courtyard's
eastern wall. Over the first century of the bath's existence, the town of Ptolemaeus suffered
a terrible water shortage. Here is how 5th century Ptolemaeus was described by Procopius of Caesarea.
There is a certain city there, in Libya, Ptolemaeus by name, which in ancient times had
been prosperous and populous, but as time went on, it had come to be almost deserted, owing to extreme
scarcity of water. For the great majority of the population, driven by thirst, had moved from there
long ago and gone wherever each one could." Although this dire situation must have rendered
the city baths unusable, the town bounced back yet again in the 6th century CE during the reign
of Justinian, who resupplied the city with water. Their baths were put in use again, although
significantly reduced in scale and capacity, and they must have survived in this state for a couple
more decades. Although it's not possible to say exactly when, it's likely that during one of these
later campaigns of renovation or repair, the civic administrators of the city made the decision to
move multiple examples of high quality statuary into the baths. The OI expedition excavated most
of these sculptures in the area of the peristyle frigidarium. On the eastern side of the portico,
shown here in detail, the two statues of standard honorific life size featured in the exhibition
were discovered in front of bases set against two columns. The male statue, dateable to the
Antonine period, repeats the so-called Eskenese sculptural type, which was very frequently used
for honorific portraits of worthy local elites, and it's likely that this man too must have
represented one such Ptolemaic. In front of the adjacent column, a more unusual statue was found.
It represents a female figure wearing a peplos, over which she wears a leather strap, possibly
for a sword or a weapon of some kind. The key to the figure's identity lies with her head,
which was found in a nearby room and which remained with the Libyan state after excavation.
The head represents an idealized woman with long hair, wearing an elephant headdress or
so-called exuviae. This rare attribute is usually employed to geographically signify Africa,
whether as a broad region or one of its subdivisions, such as Mauritania or even Alexandria as a city.
Similar representations of the personified Africa are known in a variety of media,
such as in this 3rd century CE sarcophagus from Rome. Here, however, the female figure is clearly
secondary in importance, more so intended as an evocative indicator of a faraway place.
This makes the well-preserved standalone Ptolemaic statue all the more unique,
for we know of no other comparable representations on this scale. Upon excavation, the Ptolemaic
statue was first interpreted as a portrait of Cleopatra I, the 2nd century BCE Hellenistic
queen and wife of Ptolemy V. While an allegorical representation of a Ptolemaic queen is certainly
not impossible, the identification of the figure as Cleopatra is somewhat doubtful owing to the
imperial date of the statue's manufacturer, its style of carving suggesting that it too was made
sometime in the 2nd century CE. What is more, the headdress combined with the strap worn across the
body strongly suggests that this figure is not a realistic portrait of a specific woman, but rather
an idealized representation, personification of a place. Thanks to the accurate excavation records
that document the discovery of these two 2nd century statues, we are able to say with confidence
that the statues were found in a secondary display context. That means that they were brought from
elsewhere and displayed in the brand new baths at the time when the statues were roughly 200 years
old, if not more. Their redisplay may have been motivated by several factors. In late antiquity,
it was not at all unusual for civic administrators to move earlier statuary to
urban baths, fountains, or other such places where the ancient stone sculpture would be both attractive
as decoration, but also protected from damage. For example, in the Roman town of Sagalassos in Asia
Minor, a group of earlier statues, some of them mythological in nature, was placed inside the
niches of a monumental fountain as late as the 6th century CE. We see similar relocation of
statuary also in the Ptolemaic baths. For example, in one of the niches of the frigidarium, trailing
steam found the remains of a life-size statue of Hercules. Its inscribed base declares that a
dedicated the statue with his own money to the city. The same inscription was found on three
more statues that were excavated in the city's council hall, or buloterion, suggesting that they
formed some sort of group dedication. However, it seems that it was only the statue of Hercules
that was moved to the baths. Another find from the Ptolemaic baths indicates that
the civic administrators were concerned with aesthetics and the decorative use of statuary,
as well as their safekeeping. In the opposite portico of the frigidarium, between two columns
of the colonnade, a makeshift pedestal for a statue group was built up of small stones.
The fragmentary female figure, which survives from this group, shows that the composition in
question was that of the three graces. And I'm showing you here a more complete version of the
just to give you a sense of what it would have looked like. If we look again at the fine spot
of the Ptolemaic graces, in between the two columns, we see that this was a clever kind of
display for a statue group that is quintessentially two-sided, allowing viewers to see it from both
sides of the colonnade. In fact, this intercolumnar display of the three graces finds a close parallel
in the Roman baths of the nearby Libyan town of Cyrene, where two groups of the graces were
placed on either side of a columnar passageway, thus permitting passing viewers to see them from
both sides. That a similar display strategy was present in Ptolemaeus suggests that the late
Roman administrators of the baths were concerned with more than just the safekeeping of the old
statues. They wanted to display them in an aesthetically charged manner. Like the pair
of large statues on view in the exhibition, these additional finds from the Ptolemaeus baths offer
an exceptional example of a rich archaeological context, giving us insight into the lives and
afterlives of individual objects. Other objects from Ptolemaeus tell a different, more complicated
story. The second of three buildings excavated by Kraling was a complex structure just across
the street from the city baths. Kraling dubbed it the quote-unquote public building, a rather
generic name that reflects its unclear history. In its earliest phase, dating back to the first
century CE, the area was occupied by two residential houses, which were then united
into a single structure in the second century. The whole building fell into disrepair by the third
century CE and lay unused for about a hundred years, only to be renovated again at some point
in the fourth century. Finally, in the first half of the fifth century CE, the building was
transformed one last time, and exceptionally, we know who to thank for this final renovation.
An inscribed paving slab attributes the renovation to a certain Paulus, who is described
as hypotikos, or of consular rank. The renovated building housed his offices as well as bathing
facilities, and during the terrible period when Ptolemaeus ran out of water, these bathing
facilities were made available to the public. In summary, while the public building
may have been public during some parts of the 400 years plus that it was in use, it was also at
different times a residential private space, and thus any objects found within must be interpreted
with caution. This history of the public building is crucial, for example, for interpreting this
exceptional female head. The portrait head, just about life-size, represents a mature woman with a
stern expression. Her hair, held up, is encircled by a fillet which originally had a medallion-like
bump at the top. The exceptional nature of this head lies in its manner of portrayal.
Unlike the vast majority of female portraits from the Roman period, this head does not represent
its sitter with idealized features. Instead, with its uncompromising shadows and sharp angles,
it achieves a vivid reality effect, suggesting that we are seeing the woman as she really was
in her old age. Now, our own reliance on photographic media might incline us to see
this face as a truer depiction of the woman than those offered by idealized portraits,
and we might be forgiven for thinking that this portrayal is closer to the
quote-unquote real features of the woman represented. However, it's important to note that
precisely because marble sculptures aren't photographs, any such reality effect is just an
effect. In other words, this woman's face looks like this because someone, quite possibly the woman
herself or her immediate family members, actively wanted to depict her in these terms. In fact, judging
by the contemporaneous conventions of male portraiture, it's quite possible that what we
are seeing is a desired exaggeration of some of the woman's signs of age. This attitude towards
displaying signs of age was most widespread during the final decades of the Roman Republic in the
While dozens of male portraits in this so-called varistic style are known, only a few comparable
female portraits survive. The Lady from Ptolemaeus is one such work, although its date may be closer
to the first century CE rather than BC. The head was excavated in the southwest corner of the
courtyard of the so-called public building, and Kraling described it in the Ptolemaeus publication
On the one hand, this seems like a very precise context, but the story is more complex.
Namely, in that same courtyard, remains of a lime kiln were found. Such kilns were used to reduce
scraps of marble into lime. This particular kiln seems to have been used during the century or so
that the building lay in disrepair, and it is quite possible that the head was actually destined for
the kiln. Of course, in that case, the obvious question is, why wasn't it destroyed? Unfortunately,
it is difficult to say. What we do know is that this portrait head represents a private individual,
as mature women belonging to the imperial house were always represented with many more idealized
features than what we see here. We also know that the head was made fully in the round,
rather than in relief, indicating that it was made to be inserted into a statue or, perhaps more
likely, a bust. While Romans sometimes represented members of their own family in their private
residences, these were overwhelmingly images of male ancestors. Likely, the initial display context
for the Ptolemaeus head was a funerary one. The head may have belonged to a portrait erected in
a family tomb. How it ended up in the public building and why it was spared the lime kiln
are questions for which we will likely never really have exact answers. However, the very
existence of this female head at Ptolemaeus is telling. It testifies to the existence of a social
class that is wealthy enough to produce such portraits at an early period. Finally, it says
something about living conditions in Ptolemaeus in the early Roman period, if only indirectly.
Namely, as some studies have suggested, the percentage of Romans who would live to see
their 50th birthday was as low as 15%, certainly not the majority. Therefore, the fact that this
woman lived long enough to be believably represented as a mature woman is something
of a remarkable achievement, especially in a corner of empire where prosperity was far from assured.
Our third and final case study from Ptolemaeus gives us a glimpse into the broader cultural
context of the city, as well as its regional specificity. Although only its trunk remains,
the shape of the body and the textured surface of the animal's skin tell us that this small
sculpture represented a ram. It was found in the third building excavated by Kraling,
the Roman villa, alongside another very similar ram which remained in Libya. Today, the villa is
also known as the Villa of the Four Seasons, after a wonderful mosaic which paved one of its
dining rooms. On the one hand, it is not at all unusual to find sculptures of domestic or farm
animals in the context of a Roman villa. Wealthy Romans decorated such residences with all kinds
of cute figures representing an idealized, tamed version of the natural world. However,
this ram is different. On its marble underbelly, an indentation is all that remains of the
herm head which once supported the animal's weight. The sculpture belongs to a series
of objects characteristic of Cyrenaica, showing rigid, upright rams supported by herms.
A more complete version, shown here from Cyrene, shows this unusual configuration.
There, the double herm has a face of Zeus Amon on one side and a female deity on the other.
Many of these rams appear in context tied to Zeus Amon, a syncretic deity who had had a
famous oracle at Siwa in the Libyan desert. While the enduring popularity of the Zeus Amon cult
in Cyrenaica might explain the survival of this unusual motif, the ram sculptures have their origin
in a much more ancient, indigenous Libyan worship of the animal, which predated the arrival of the
Greeks and lasted well into the Roman period, especially in the Libyan countryside. In the
case of the Ptolemaeus ram, then, we see the adaptation and transformation of an ancient
Libyan silbo into the Roman cultural idiom. The iconography may be indigenous, yet both the marble
material and the technical details of carving reflect Roman contemporary sculptural traditions.
Hopefully, these three case studies from Ptolemaeus demonstrate the range of interpretive
options afforded by their recorded documentation of scientifically controlled excavations.
However, as Kirsten had already discussed earlier, our exhibition also includes objects
purchased by Kraling from the international antiquities market, which lacked archaeological
provenience. Placed side by side with a Ptolemaeus material, these pieces demonstrate the very
different set of skills, methods, and approaches required to make sense of these objects as
archaeological objects. Provenance research, or the study of ownership history, is crucial,
for example, in understanding two marble objects that Kraling bought in Beirut, Lebanon, in 1957.
One is a life-size portrait statue of a nude boy, while the other is a statuette showing Venus and
Cupid on a tall base. The invoice for the acquisition of these two works by the OI is dated
March 21st, 1957. This document, on the left, was signed in Beirut, Lebanon, by the antiquities dealer
Eli Boustan, or Elias Boustros, operating on behalf of another Lebanese dealer, Fouad Alouf.
It references a large marble statue of a boy, listing no provenience, as well as a small statue
of marble, the Venus and Cupid, for which it says that it was found in Rostan. The name Rostan
refers to the town of Al-Rastan, or ancient Arethusa, near Homs in present-day Syria.
However, as you can see on the right here, by the time that these two objects appear in the
OI's accession records several months later, both objects are described as, quote,
How do we reconcile this conflicting information? Were the two objects really found in Baalbek,
or was the smaller statuette from Al-Rastan? While usually dealer-provided information may
often be helpful, such origin stories should be taken with a grain of salt.
This is especially true in the case of a famous origin, such as Baalbek. Located in modern-day
Lebanon, Baalbek, or Heliopolis in the Roman period, was renowned in antiquity as an oracle
and pilgrimage site. The impressive ruins of its enormous temple complex made Baalbek one of the
most famous ancient sites during certain decades of the early 20th century. In fact, by the time
that the two marble objects were purchased by the OI in the 1950s, Baalbek was a household name
both among professionals and archaeological amateurs. Consequently, aware of the site's
reputation, Boustros and Alouf may have hinted at such a provenience for the two sculptures
in order to raise their market value. On the other hand, the description of the Venus and
Cupid as coming from Al-Rastan, or ancient Arethusa, is perhaps more plausible. In the
first century BCE, Arethusa was the first capital of the Emessan kingdom, a vassal state of the
Despite this early period of prosperity, the town's fortunes soon declined and did not recover.
By the late 19th and early 20th centuries, the modern town of Al-Rastan was a smaller,
economically impoverished place. In the decades which preceded the acquisition of the Venus and
Cupid statuette, the area around Al-Rastan saw numerous armed conflicts, and it is possible
that illicit or unsupervised excavations took place on the territory of ancient Arethusa.
Thankfully, in recent years, scholarship on the small-scale Roman sculpture of Syria
has been growing, and hopefully further studies in this area will clarify the possible origins
of the OI statuette. And finally, in addition to provenance research, technical analysis
can be a helpful tool for contextualizing objects without archaeological provenience.
In the case of the OI's Roman sculpture purchased from the market, a series of examinations,
both by us as curators and by OI conservators Laura D'Alessandro and Alison White,
revealed helpful findings. On the Venus and Cupid statuette, numerous traces of pigment
were identified on the nude body of Venus, many of them applied as individual dots. By connecting
the dots, so to speak, we were able to reconstruct the elaborate body jewelry worn by the goddess,
including an X-shaped body chain worn across the abdomen. Under a raking light, furthermore,
what might at first seem like damage around Venus's neck was shown to be the remains
of a radiant necklace, of which only the slightly raised surfaces remain, and this image doesn't
really show them that well because of the shadow of the head, but if you go into the galleries,
you'll see what we're talking about. Finally, a yellow metallic substance was noted on the upper
arm and torso of the goddess, and portable XRS spectroscopy of the goddess's navel confirmed
its identification as gold. This high degree of body jewelry is not at all unusual in portable
figurines of Venus made throughout the imperial period in the Roman East. I'm showing you
here an example from Ephesus, which makes the lines of the jewelry a bit easier to understand.
In this and many other comparable examples, however, the jewelry is also executed in relief,
which means that it can be appreciated today even if the original pigments are no longer visible.
For our statuette, however, technical imaging was instrumental in understanding the original
appearance of the applied ornaments. We hope that this brief overview gives you a sense of not just
the range of Roman objects in the OI's collection of sculpture, but also of the different ways that
we as scholars can interpret their stories and present these insights to the public.
I will now hand it over to Kirsten for some concluding remarks.
While OI Museum curator Gustavus Swift deemed the OI's Roman sculpture collection in the 1970s
as being, quote, in their nature and value essentially outside the core of the OI's field,
end quote, we hope that the talk today, in unison with the exhibition itself,
has successfully proven otherwise. Since its inception, the OI has been devoted not only to
understanding complex civilizations of ancient West Asia and North Africa, but also to assisting
and protecting the cultural heritage of these regions and remaining committed to intellectual
and technological innovation as a research institute and a museum. As perspectives and
approaches in the field shift, we strive to find ways to stay at the forefront and to share new
avenues of inquiry, new methods, and to make accessible new findings. With this project in
particular, we aimed to bring transparency to our process, to make explicit the methods with
which we cast new eyes and pose new queries of this artifact group, along with its archival
documentation, and the varying levels of confidence we held in each and the outcomes they produced.
In taking up the subject matter of archaeological context and object histories of provenience and
provenance and exploration and interpretation in this study of the OI's Roman sculpture collection,
we hope to have in some ways destabilized the museum voice as one of unquestioned authority,
to instead have brought visitors, and you today as audience, with us as we revisited an old yet
somewhat enigmatic collection of marbles. So thank you for joining us today, and also a
profound thank you to ROCO for collaborating with me on this adventure, and also to the full OI
museum team for making this exhibition possible. And here I'll leave you with the information
on our upcoming special exhibition programming. Thank you very much. For over 100 years, the OI
has been a leading research center for the study of ancient Middle Eastern civilizations.
Join us in uncovering the past and learn about the beginnings of our lives as humans together.
Become a member by visiting oi.uchicago.edu slash member