Do the Benefits of Citizenship by Merit⧸Exception LAST?

The Visa and Passport Channel
4 followers
Apr 29, 2026
Okay, let's talk a little bit about an esoteric topic here, which is
how proven a citizenship is, right? How proven it is. A citizenship that has clearly defined
grounds and a path to naturalization eligibility is not necessarily proven. Countries can not
actually naturalize people. They can exercise their discretion, lawfully or unlawfully,
to not naturalize them. So the fact that there's a path
in the country statutes to naturalization eligibility doesn't make the citizenship
a proven citizenship. Not even getting the citizenship makes the citizenship proven.
That's not necessarily a proven citizenship. A proven citizenship is one that has it and its
benefits still intact 20 plus years later. A proven citizenship is a citizenship that's robust,
lasts for multi-decades, the rest of your life, the lives of your children.
When you look at citizenship through this lens of robustness, you quickly start to realize that
the method of acquisition of the citizenship oftentimes has to do with how robust it is.
They're not all created equally. Unfortunately, this fact is one that's kind of buried by what
I call mobility influencers, passport bros, passport influencers in the industry.
They're not incentivized to help you realize that some citizenships acquired by some bases
are more robust and proven than others. And right now, the hottest thing, the hotness
in the industry is citizenship by merit slash exception. These are basically high-priced
citizenships. It's not just financially tied. A lot of them have to do with showing some sort of
roots or ties to the community, especially business community in certain countries.
A lot of these mobility influencers are selling these things or advertising services for these.
These are unproven citizenships. What I mean by that is we don't know how they're going to be
treated 20 years from now, both by the country that's issued them, so perhaps a new government
comes into power, and we also don't know how those citizenships are going to be treated by
third countries vis-a-vis springboard benefits. We don't know whether those
citizenships, visa-free access, satellite residency rights, treaty benefits, passport
recognition abroad, we don't know how that's going to be treated by other countries.
That's lower on the totem pole of robustness and how proven citizenships are.
So there is a totem pole. There is a hierarchy, actually, in fact. You have citizenships that
are acquired by dissent, whether it be through automatic operation of law or by naturalization.
Those are pretty robust. We're talking about generally speaking here. We have
citizenships that are acquired through naturalization after a period of residency.
Those are pretty robust, generally speaking. We have citizenships that are acquired by use solely,
so birth on the ground. So when a person acquires those, those are pretty robust.
Those are pretty respected. Those are at the high level of the robustness totem pole.
On the lower level, we have, as I mentioned, citizenship by merit exception because it's
simply an unproven commodity. It's not Lindy to use a Nassim Taleb term. It hasn't been around
for that long for us to see how this thing is treated long-term. And then we have, unfortunately,
citizenship by investment as well, which is on the lower end of the totem pole of robustness.
It's under a lot of attack. A lot of CIUs of citizenship by investment program countries
are incentivized to really put their own citizens through the ringer even after they've got the
citizenship in order to stave off pressure from the EU, the UK, the United States, or even just
rags, even just newspapers like The Guardian that hate citizenship by investment.
So understand that there's a hierarchy of robustness, of longevity, likelihood of longevity
of these citizenships. It's an unpleasant fact, but it's the truth. And it's not one you're going
to hear that often from mobility influencers. Now, what does this mean? Does this mean don't
get citizenship by merit? Absolutely not. It doesn't mean that. Does this mean don't get
citizenship by investment? No, absolutely. I'm not saying don't get these things. These things
are good. They can still help people with certain profiles and certain scenarios. It might still be
worth it for you to get that thing, but understand what it is. Understand the different elements of
citizenship, the different benefits, the different legal bases of these benefits, core mobility
benefits being much more robust and secure than satellite benefits and springboard benefits.
Understand the vulnerabilities and make your decision accordingly. So that's it for this
video. I'm sure this is not going to be that popular among people who are mobility influencers
and CBI salesmen and agents, but this is just the truth of the matter. So that's it. Hope this helps.
