Deadly Medical Treatments From History. Historical Medical Treatments. History Of Medicine Doc

What Was The Life
13 followers
1 Video View·Apr 27, 2026
What were some of the most useless and most dangerous medical treatments of the past
and what torturous looking instruments were used to carry them out?
In today's video from History Calling, I'm going to share with you some of the most
famous so-called cures administered by those who passed as doctors in days gone by but which we
would consider to be at best pointless and at worst either attempted murder or actual murder.
We'll be looking at how early modern medicine nearly wiped out the French succession to the
throne, at the recipe for an ointment invented by Henry VIII, at how Elizabeth I was treated
for smallpox, at the supposedly magical healing powers of monarchs, at failed attempts to protect
against or cure the plague and many others. Just to show that not all doctors of the past
were deadly to their patients though, if you stay till the end of the video I'll tell you
about one seemingly crazy medieval medical treatment that actually worked and saved the
life of one of England's most famous men. Notwithstanding that example though, please
don't try any of the practices I'm about to tell you about either on yourself or anyone else. This
video is for entertainment and to teach you about history. It is not medical advice, quite the
opposite in fact, and if you have any medical problem you should see your 21st century fully
qualified medical doctor.
The history of medicine spans the globe, encompassing all cultures and all eras of
human history, so of course it isn't possible for me to look at everything. Please therefore
just consider this video a sampling of some of the better known and to our eyes crazier
medical treatments, in inverted commas, that our ancestors used or were subjected to.
Don't scream at me in the comments if I didn't include something you wanted me to talk about.
Let's start with one of the most popular medical treatments of the past and one which I'll bet
most if not all of you have heard of, the practice of bloodletting. As the name suggests,
this involved deliberately injuring a person in order to draw off some of their blood,
and having been invented in ancient times in Egypt, it was used for a wide variety of illnesses,
all the way up to the 19th century. There were different methods, including cutting into the
inn, known as venesection or arteriotomy, or scarifying, which meant scraping the skin
with little bleeds. Yes, this was all as horrible as it sounds. The blood was then collected in a
and disposed of. The rationale, if you can call it that, was that the body was made up of four
humours, being blood, phlegm, black bile, and yellow bile, and illness was caused by an imbalance
in one of these. Removing some of the blood, if it was the humour that was out of balance,
was thought to cure the problem. Of course, it's all poppycock, we're not made up of humours.
Here we see some of the instruments invented to facilitate this practice,
including the lancets used to prick holes in people's skin during scarifying.
Leeches were a popular method too. The practice was detrimental in almost all cases, partly because
of the adverse effects of blood loss, and partly because piercing someone's skin creates an entry
point for infection. Nevertheless, it remained popular for a ridiculous amount of time,
even though it could have absolutely disastrous results. In March 1712, for instance, the two
immediate heirs to the French throne, Louis XIV's great-grandsons, who were both called Louis II
because royals love to reuse the same names and drive us all potty as a result, were terribly
ill with measles, an illness which had killed both their parents a matter of weeks earlier.
The treatment was bleeding, and within days, the elder boy, aged five, was dead,
thanks to this approach, which he couldn't tolerate in his already weakened condition.
His little brother, aged two, was hidden away by his governess to prevent any further bleeding,
and survived to become Louis XV at the age of five.
Then there's President George Washington, taken ill after riding in freezing weather in December
1799 and remaining in his wet clothes for far too long, then bled so hard, among other treatments,
that it's hard not to suspect that the huge 40% blood loss he suffered had something to do with
his demise shortly afterwards, though, among other theories, he has also been retroactively
diagnosed with epiglottitis, which is a swelling of the epiglottis, the flap of tissue underneath
your tongue at the back of your throat. Bleeding increasingly fell out of favour during the 19th
century, and is only used today in a tiny number of medical cases for issues like haemochromatosis,
polycythemia vera, and porphyria cutanea tarda. I also remember seeing a woman on the TV show
Botched having leeches put on her face after surgery, but that was under the supervision
of a modern doctor and was noteworthy for how rare it is.
Before we move on to the next historical medical practice, just a quick reminder to please like
the video, subscribe to the channel with the notification bell switched on, and join as a
YouTube member for bonus material and perks. You can also find me on Patreon, where I provide even
more bonuses, including early access to ad-free videos and extra podcasts. It's linked below for
you, as is my website, historycallingofficial.com, where you can sign up to my free mailing list and
get two complimentary downloads. Next, we move on to the sometimes related practice of cupping,
which is so old it was mentioned in a medical textbook from ancient Egypt called the Ebers
Papyrus, which dates to 1550 BC. It involves placing a cup over the skin and using heat or
suction to create a vacuum. This will cause redness, swelling, and or possibly draw blood
or cause a blister. This is why it's sometimes related to bleeding. Dry cupping means the
procedure does not draw blood, at least not on purpose. Wet cupping involves making little cuts
in the skin to suction out some blood. Again, the idea historically was to remove or balance
a bad humor, and again, this practice could be very harmful if it broke or burned the skin,
sometimes causing blood loss and opening up the body to infection. Plus, if the cups weren't
properly sanitized between uses, infections could spread from patient to patient. It was used to
treat a wide variety of illnesses, as a book written by several medical men and published in
1672 demonstrates. The list of ailments they gave, which could supposedly be dealt with by cupping,
is far too long for me to regurgitate here, but it included madness, dizziness, baldness,
headaches, ulcers, acne, asthma, gout, pain in pretty much any location in the body,
bleeding from the ears, and delirium. Despite the issues with it and dubious evidence of any real
usefulness, cupping remains popular with some people, which is why I was talking about it in
the present tense a minute ago. Still, it is widely regarded as a pseudoscience within western
medicine, and the best that can be said about it is perhaps that if it doesn't involve cuts or
burns to the skin, it isn't necessarily particularly harmful as long as you don't mind walking around
with ugly welts and red marks on you. In a blog post for Harvard Medical School, linked below,
Dr. Robert H. Smerling noted the following. A 2023 review of the evidence found that cupping
might provide some relief for a number of musculoskeletal and sports-related conditions,
including neck and back pain, but that the quality of the evidence was limited. A 2022
review found that wet but not dry cupping was effective for low back pain. One problem is that
The best studies are blinded placebo-controlled trials, in which neither the patient nor the
researcher knows which treatment, real or placebo, has been given to a study subject.
When medications are studied, coming up with a placebo pill is not difficult.
It can be much more difficult to create a convincing placebo comparator for cupping.
In addition, pain can be a difficult thing to measure, and the placebo effect,
improvement related to an expectation of benefit, can be quite powerful.
An article on WebMD said much the same thing. Some people report some benefits, but
The researchers said many of the studies they reviewed could have been biased and that better
studies were needed. So the jury's out on this one, but I think you'd be hard-pressed to find
very many qualified doctors, at least in the West, who'd recommend this, and even fewer who'd
say to pursue only this course of treatment for whatever your problem is, rather than also
including mainstream medicine. If cupping is likely useless, beyond maybe a placebo effect,
then other treatments were definitely so. For example, when Elizabeth I came down with smallpox
in 1562, she was wrapped in red cloth. This was a Japanese treatment with the colour of the cloth
believed to minimize scarring from the smallpox scabs, but I can guarantee that the red of the
cloth did nothing to help her, and in fact, she did have scars, which she took to hiding under makeup.
The way smallpox was eventually defeated was through vaccinations, and I have a video all
about how that was done, which I'll link for you. Next up, we have trepanning. This was the practice
of boring holes into the patient's skull, and it dates back to antiquity. It has been used to try
to treat both physical pains in the head and mental health problems. An astounding five to ten percent
of all Neolithic skulls found so far show signs of trepanning, and interestingly, there is evidence
of healing on the skulls of some people who underwent this, showing that they survived the
despite the risks of doing this without modern hygiene practices, and not to mention modern
anesthesia. I also read a theory in an article by a professor, Miguel A. Faria, which I didn't think
there was sufficient evidence to prove, but that's just me, that the Neolithic practitioners of
trepanning were trying to revive patients, believing that those who were unconscious,
or even dead, could be brought back by making a hole in the skull to, quote,
allow the demon to leave the body or the good spirit to enter it for the necessary
undying, meaning waking up, process to take place. I'll leave the article linked below.
Trepanning is also interesting because while it was brutal and dangerous, unlike some of the other
items on this list, it can nevertheless be seen as a precursor to a widely accepted medical treatment
used today, neurosurgery, which has saved and continues to save many lives. Still, you didn't
ever want to be trepanned in the past. Imagine going to your doctor for a headache, and without
any idea of what's causing the problem, he or she says, okay, so here's my treatment plan. I'm going
to bore a hole in your skull while you're awake and see what happens. Makes you grateful for
aspirin, doesn't it? Then there were blisters, those nasty little things you might get from new
shoes while you break them in, and which I at least prefer to avoid like the plague. Historically,
though, other people have deliberately brought these on by putting an irritant on the skin.
Here's a description of how this worked from the Royal College of Physicians of Edinburgh.
Vesication, or blistering, was a common method of therapeutically breaching the skin that lasted
well into the 1800s. An irritant, usually composed of ground-up cantharidin, also known as blister
beetle, or Spanish fly, was coated on a plaster which was then applied to the skin. The resulting
blister was then either left to heal or continually irritated to create a constant weeping sore known
as an issue. As well as being applied to the skin, blister beetles were also ingested, a method of
treatment which could be highly dangerous, even deadly. They were believed to cure a wide range
of diseases from rabies to deafness. Honestly, as someone who doesn't love bugs at the best of times,
this just makes me so glad that I live in a first world country in the 21st century and no one's
rubbing ground-up blister beetle onto my skin and telling me to be grateful for their medical
expertise. Moving away from physical treatments historical doctors would carry out on you,
let's look at things they might have recommended you ingest, inhale, soak in, or do. With those to
be ingested quite often called physics, not to be confused with the scientific study named physics.
Some were harmless enough like making a pilgrimage to an especially holy site to try to cure fertility
problems, Catherine of Aragon liked to do that, or sitting in the thermal spring waters in the
English town of Bath for things like skin diseases, muscle aches, infertility, and leprosy.
Furthermore, research has shown that the waters at Bath could have some benefits for things like
reversing to an extent the effects of lead poisoning, while the act of simply getting
people to sit outdoors because the baths were outdoors exposed to sunlight and soaking up
vitamin D plus hydrating their skin in the water could help with things like rickets, eczema, and
psoriasis. Ingestible physics could be lethal however, thanks to the inclusion of ingredients
which we now class as poison. Mercury for instance was a popular treatment for syphilis back in the
day. Rather than curing it though, all it would do was add mercury poisoning to your list of woes.
Syphilis wasn't the only thing that was used for either, President Abraham Lincoln used to take it
for what was termed melancholia, though he stopped before his death, and 21st century scientists
suspect he was showing symptoms of mercury poisoning including insomnia, tremors, and fits
of rage. Even Lincoln himself suspected something was amiss, telling a friend he'd stopped taking
his little blue pills in 1861 because they made him cross. It was hardly surprising, he was taking
9,000 times the maximum safe dosage. 9,000 times, that's not a typo, that's what he was taking.
Anyway, other dangerous substances were mass-produced and aimed at children. Here's an
advert from 1907 for Mrs Winslow's soothing syrup, designed to help little babies with their teething
pains. Aw, do you want to know what was in it? Morphine and alcohol. Here's a quote from the DEA
museum in the United States about this product. Quick side note before I share it, did anyone else
know the DEA has its own museum? Because I sure didn't. I was pretty impressed though. Okay, here's
the quote from its site. Some infants who consumed Mrs Winslow's soothing syrup went to sleep and
never woke up. While morphine is addictive for people of all ages, it can be fatal to children,
even in small doses. This is awful, but what's worse is that problems with this so-called medicine
and others like it had been clear even in the 1890s, long before the advert you just saw was
published, and yet it continued to be produced. Over in Australia, surgeon and politician William
Frederick Taylor gave a speech to the Queensland Legislative Council in 1891 in which he said,
We have a very high infant mortality in this country, and no doubt a great deal of that is
owing to these medicines. Medical men are constantly being called in and finding infants in a state of
syncope, coma, pupils contracted, and evidently cases of opium poisoning. After a great deal of
difficulty, the mother or nurse may be induced to admit that the child has had a dose of some
infant's preservative, possibly Mrs Winslow's soothing syrup, which is largely used, or
Steedman's powders, which contain morphia. Honourable gentlemen will see that if we are to
save the lives of these little creatures, we must place some restriction upon the sale of these
medicines, which contain opium or poisons of that sort. Back in America, the DEA notes that,
public outcry over poisonings and contaminated food and medicines led Congress to pass the
Pure Food and Drug Act in 1906. The Act required the listing of certain ingredients on product
labels, including opiates, cocaine, and cannabis. Shortly after, the American Medical Association
denounced Mrs Winslow's syrup because of its dangerous combination of ingredients and link
to infant deaths. Even that wasn't enough though, and despite this denouncement and the fact that
the syrup was listed as a baby killer in the book Nostrums and Quackery, published in 1911
by the American Medical Association, it continued to be produced and was available for purchase
until the 1930s, which is another classic example, not that America needs one, of producers of
medicines or so-called medicines putting profits before people. In other cases, especially before
medications were being mass-produced, people would make up ointments and other supposed remedies for
themselves. And here you see a Scottish home medicine cabinet from the 19th century, complete
with some substances that were known to be poisons even then. Now it's not possible for me to take
you through all the different remedies that people cooked up, as the list will essentially be endless.
But to give you just one example, here's a recipe for an ointment for skin sores that Henry VIII
invented at Hampton Court Palace. Take chamomile flowers, mellot flowers, rose leaves, honeysuckle
leaves, in the same amount equally. Boil these in water of rose and honeysuckle flowers as much
as shall suffice. Then strain and take thereof one ounce. Then take hensuit, well washed with
rose water, of province more than lukewarm, two ounces. Then take letharge of gold, two ounces,
tutti, a crude zinc oxide compound, preparated, rinsed to purify, red coral, in the same amount,
half an ounce, pearls, two ounces, unicorn horn, one ounce. All these finely powdered,
mixed with the decoction, and hence boil them until it be an ungent. I'm not a chemist,
but I don't think there's anything actually harmful in there, though what a waste of two ounces of
pearl. And a quick google told me that zinc oxide is actually useful on minor skin complaints and
is used in sunscreens, so maybe that did do something for him, though I doubt the unicorn
horn, most likely narwhal horn, had any medicinal properties. Moving forward to 1803 and across the
Irish Sea to my neck of the woods, I found this recipe for a laxative in the letter of a Mr.
William Drennan of Dublin, which was meant to treat the earache of old things, which was then
plaguing a relative of his called Thomas. Imperial, made by dissolving two teaspoonfuls of cream of
tartar in a quart of boiling water, with a little lemon peel, and sweetening it with white sugar to
his taste. A half pint of this, taken lukewarm during the day, will affect his bowels, and ought
to be taken once every 10 days, or whenever he appears heavy or soupy in the daytime. If the earache
continued, which I imagine it might well have done, as I can't see how a laxative would have helped it,
then Thomas was to, quote, put a warm poultice to it at bedtime, and that will make it the sooner break.
A poultice, according to the Oxford Dictionary Online, was a piece of cloth covered with a thick,
often warm substance, wrapped around an injury to reduce pain or swelling, and in this case
Thomas's poultice may be made of bread and milk with oil, or a well-boiled onion. Again, not sure
what those ingredients were going to do for a sore ear, or indeed a sore anything, but I suppose the
heat in it might have helped, and if he got hungry, it'll have provided a midnight snack.
If you'd like to look into your Irish family tree, by the way, maybe you're even related to
the Drennans, then I've got just the book for you. It's called Find Your Irish Ancestors Online,
written by yours truly, and it's available on Amazon as either an e-book or a paperback.
I'll leave the link below. Some treatments, dating back millennia, leaned into either superstitions
or religion. For instance, in the Christian world, one might wear an image of a certain saint for
protection, while the use of crowned rings was popular in England because they were thought to
These rings had to be blessed by the monarch, though, in a special ceremony, and their use
declined after the death of Mary I. This is because her successors, bar James II,
were at least nominally Protestant and didn't believe in such things. Mind you, all the way up
to Queen Anne, English monarchs were still touching for the king's evil, a practice which held that
could heal scrofula thanks to the king or queen's divine link to God. In other cases,
people relied on herbs and flowers for protection. During outbreaks of plague in the early modern era,
for example, the received wisdom of the time was that the disease was passing through bad smells,
and so people took to burning sweet-smelling herbs in their homes or hanging oranges stuffed
with clothes around the house. They would also carry around sponges soaked in vinegar under
their noses when they went outdoors, and if they were doctors, they might wear beak-shaped masks
stuffed with herbs to supposedly cleanse the air around them. That didn't work, by the way. In fact,
in the absence of any effective treatments, one of the only ways to halt the spread of plague,
and one which we were all reduced to using again back in 2020, was lockdown. See my video on the
As long as no poisonous materials were being used in charms or poses, none of these practices were
harmful, of course, and using charms and rings or being touched by the monarch might at least have
had some placebo benefits. The last thing I'm going to mention is tricky to talk about as I
don't want YouTube to think I'm talking about something else. I'm going to have to describe it
in a roundabout way for that reason. You know how pregnant women often get morning sickness,
and you know what the main symptom of morning sickness is, and it's in the name? Well, that's
something that men and women would often do to themselves on purpose in order to purge their
system of something they thought was making them ill. I guess it's a bit like the modern day
detoxes, though I think those tend to focus on getting you to detox out the other end,
if you know what I mean. Anyway, unless you just ingested something poisonous to you,
then I don't see that this would have had any medicinal value. It would just weaken a person
and cause acid damage to their windpipe and teeth, but it was something doctors of the past
loved to recommend. Now, of course, many of these medical treatments were used in conjunction with
each other and others. And so to finish this section of the video, let me just give you an
example of what a person could be put through in the past, all with the supposed aim of curing
them of ailments, which were often probably less problematic than the so-called treatments.
In 1833, the Reverend Dr. J.S. Reid of Carrick, Fergus in Ireland, wrote to a person I take to be
his son, because this man was also called James S. Reid and was then studying medicine in Edinburgh.
The elder Reid told of a family member or friend called Edward, who had been seriously ill for
eight weeks with what looked like hydrocephalus, water on the brain. Dr. Reid, quote,
called in Dr. Thompson, a physician who has been incessant in his attention. For the first three
weeks, by blistering and bleeding with leeches, they beat the disease. A very violent attack of
convulsions succeeded. They then rubbed in a large quantity of mercury and the convulsions have never
returned. But he has lost the use of the right side, is emaciated to a degree beyond what I could
have conceived possible, and for the last four weeks we can scarcely observe any change, for
better or worse. His sight and hearing are quite good. He only says yes or no, and that not oftener
than once in the two or three days. He is fed with gruel, etc., but he takes very little nourishment,
and they have ceased giving him any medicine but to keep his boils open. In other words,
they were pumping laxatives into him. So this poor guy, already very unwell, was repeatedly bled
and injured with blisters for three weeks, then poisoned with mercury and given only gruel to eat,
plus laxatives so that he wouldn't even be able to properly absorb the nutrients from that food.
I'd say he could have done without the incessant attentions of Dr. Thompson and the oversight of
Dr. Reid. Now, you might think that all these dumb-as-a-post medical treatments are from the
19th or early 20th centuries at the latest, and in more recent times we're all so smart that we
would never be duped into believing in any of this clearly crazy claptrap, but you'd be wrong.
Well into the 20th century, smoking, of all things, a practice with absolutely no redeeming
features whatsoever, which seriously increases your chances of lung cancer, makes you smell bad,
gives you yellow fingers and teeth, and costs you considerable amounts of money in the process,
was being peddled as medicinal and even as a cure for asthma, which is just wild given how much worse
it would make asthma. Still, I hear you say, that was decades ago. We're smarter now, even the smokers
know that what they're doing is terrible for them. Well, that's true, but unfortunately, despite all
our advancements and better understanding of the human body, we still aren't out of the woods yet
as shown by the sales of the dipstick stuff that the likes of Gwyneth Paltrow and other
self-proclaimed lifestyle and wellness gurus blog. I don't think I've ever recommended another
channel's video on my own channel before, but I'm going to make an exception here and link a short
video by the excellent Dr Mike Ballou, which takes you through how disingenuous and even dangerous
the products that Paltrow advocates for and sells are. It's too much off topic for me as it's current
rather than history, and in any case, I think you'd rather get that type of information from a
medical doctor, which Dr Mike is. As promised, let's finish up with a story of a medieval medical
treatment which did, rather miraculously, save the life of one of England's most famous men,
none other than Henry V, though the incident in question occurred before he was king.
Prince Henry, as he was then, was shot in the face by an arrow at the age of 16 during the
Battle of Shrewsbury in 1403. He was treated at Kenilworth Castle by a doctor, John Bradmore,
who invented a screw to extract the arrowhead from deep in the prince's cheek, and was careful to
keep the wound clean using, quote, purified linen and rose honey. He himself wrote about what he did
next, saying, I cleansed the wound with a syringe full of white wine and then placed in new probes
made of wads of flax soaked in a cleansing ointment. This is made thus. Take a small loaf of
white bread, dissolve it well in water, and sift through a cloth. Then take a sufficient quantity
of flour and barley and honey and simmer over a gentle heat until it thickens, and add sufficient
turpentine oil, and the healing ointment is made. And from the second day I shortened the said wads
soaked in the aforementioned ointment every two days, and thus within 20 days the wound was
perfectly well cleansed. And afterwards I regenerated the flesh with a dark ointment.
And note that from the beginning right up to the end of my cure I always anointed him on the neck
every day in the morning and evening with an ointment to soothe the muscles, and placed a
hot plaster on top on account of fear of spasm, which was my greatest fear. And thus, thanks to
God, he was perfectly cured. You may not have understood why his methods worked, but his attention
to hygiene, including the use of alcohol to clean out the wound, and the fact that he used honey,
which has mild antiseptic properties, probably went a long way towards preventing infection.
I have a video all about this event, which goes into it in more detail, and which I'll leave
linked for you. That brings us to the end of this brief foray into the world of historical medicine.
I hope I haven't grossed you out, and that we're all a little more grateful right now
to live in the times we do with access to the medicines and procedures we have,
which by the by will probably look terribly antiquated and even barbaric to people in the
future, so I guess we shouldn't feel too smug and superior to our ancestors. Let me know below
which of the historical treatments mentioned here you think was the worst, and to learn more about
some icky medical treatments and the horrible results they could have, as well as some that
were much more successful, try one of these videos next. I'll be back next time, and until then,
keep learning!
