A.V. Dicey and the Rule of Law _ English Legal System

History of Law
11 followers
#education #law #learning
The Law Academy is a project designed to provide legal education for students studying law in the UK. Subscribe for more content.
A. Naidoo, Complete Contract Law: Text, Cases, and Materials (Oxford University Press, 2021).
M. Chen-Wishart, Contract Law (Oxford University Press, 2022).
Disclaimer:
At no point are these video lessons intended to provide any sort of legal advice. These are for educational purposes only!
Image(s) Copyright: This Photo by Unknown Author is licensed under CC BY-SA
In our previous lesson on the English legal system, what we did was introduce the subject
of the rule of law. Now this lesson is just going to continue this in a brief amount of detail by
talking about one of the most prominent interpretations of the rule of law,
this being the rule of law theory that is pushed forward by and is elucidated by
A. V. Dicey, which I've written here as D. V. Dicey, but it is A. V. Dicey's interpretation
of rule of law, A standing for Albert. We know already, and I've made mention of A. V. Dicey
in previous lessons, and we'll talk about Dicey in a lot more detail when we continue looking at
the UK constitution, but we know that A. V. Dicey is one of the most consequential
legal minds and constitutionalists this country has ever seen. Specifically within the late 1800s,
he contributed a number of different theories, principles, and understandings
of the UK constitution, the various role of the institutions within the UK government,
and as well as this principles of constitutional law and our English legal system. The two most,
arguably the two most important theories that he developed were his elucidations of the principle
of parliamentary sovereignty, which we'll touch on very briefly in this series, but in a lot more
detail when we do it in public law, as well as this, his theory of the rule of law. We're going
to talk about his interpretation of the rule of law, and this is arguably one of the most popular
views on what the rule of law constitutes, what the rule of law actually outlines and tells us
we should do and how one should act. So A. V. Dicey believed that the rule of law is derived
out of three main principles of law. So we noted in the previous lesson that one of the things that
the rule of law is difficult to do is to define in a quite succinct and clear way, and so as a result
of this people tend not to try and make and come to a complete definition of the rule of law,
instead they try to look at the various different principles which the rule of law is said to
inhabit. So different principles that, assuming you have these different principles and assuming that
we can elucidate these different principles, we can then make the conclusion therefore that these
constitute the rule of law. And A. V. Dicey is no different. He comes to the conclusion that there
are three main principles which, in conjunction with each other, we say is sufficient to create
the rule of law. These principles are the fact that there is a lack of arbitrary power in the state,
the law is equal, and then the final of these being that the law is supreme. So these are the
three major principles that derive out of the principle of the rule of law. Beginning first
then with the first of these principles which is this idea that there is a lack of arbitrary power.
The law does not establish, just establish sorry, the limits on what people in society can and
cannot do, but the law also sets limitations on what the state can and cannot do. So we know from
previous lessons when we looked at what the law is, we suggested that the law is essentially
an elucidation of rule making within society. It limits what people can and cannot do within a
society. But for A. V. Dicey, one of the principles that is elucidated within the rule of law is this
idea that it is not just what society can do and what society cannot do, individual people within
society, but it is also a limitation on the power of the state. And so in doing so, where the state
is acting beyond their power, they are said to be acting beyond their authority. The Latin
phraseology for this is to be acting ultra vire. And if they are acting ultra vire, then the law
can step in and hold them to account. This is what the idea of lack of arbitrary power
enshrines, that there is not this arbitrary power that exists within the legal system of England and
Wales. Instead, where there is the acting of arbitrary power, where there is the acting of
power beyond their authority, where the state does act ultra vire, then the law exists as a safeguard
against arbitrary power and therefore holds them to account and checks their authority.
Now, this is done in a lot of places through the process of administrative law, and we will get to
this when we look at judicial review in the second half of our public law series. But when we talk
about judicial review, it is a process by which we can limit the power of the state to be acting
ultra vire, to be acting beyond their authority. And so this is where judicial review comes in.
There is also other elements of administrative law that exist that can hold the government to
account, but this is what the process of judicial review essentially entails. And the understanding
here is that the state is limited by the rule of law, and the reason why this is the case is to
protect a number of very fundamental and very foundational principles of the state. These
include principles pertaining to democracy, as well as principles which protect the people
against dictatorship and despotism. The second principle of the rule of law is this idea that
the law is equal, there is equality. It means that not only is the law equal in and of itself,
but that the law applies in an equal manner. It must apply to everyone equally. And so discrimination
within a legal system is a fundamental violation of the rule of law, and as a result of this,
it applies the maxim, the equal maxim implies that nobody is above the law itself. So when we
talk about the application of law, I made this very clear in the previous lesson, that it applies to
whom it needs to apply to essentially. So for example, the criminal law applies to everybody,
it is universal. But if you, for example, do not own a company, or do not operate within a company,
then it doesn't make sense to suggest that the UK's company law applies to you, it applies to
everybody who owns a company equally. Similarly, if you do not have kids or children, then you're
not going to be subjected to child law, so long as you don't have kids. If you then have kids,
then you will be subjected equally. That's the general rule that is applied. And it means that
it does not matter how rich an individual is, how poor they may be, whether they are black or white,
male or female, they must be treated equally under the law. Now one of the things that is
quite interesting here is the constitutional position of the monarchy in this regard,
because the monarchy, from a constitutional perspective, is actually seen as above the law.
They are the makers of law, they are the administrators of law, it is the crown
subjects, i.e. the people, where the law applies to. It applies to the people and the crown owns
the law, if you will. And so there is this question of, well, if the monarch, if King Charles III,
decides therefore to commit a crime, how does this reconcile with the principle of the equality of
and the fact that nobody is above the law? Now, strictly from a constitutional perspective,
the monarchy is seen to be above the law, but in terms of practical application, if, for example,
the king was caught speeding, they would probably, as a system, actually apply the law themselves,
or at least have the law applied onto them, and accept any kind of legal punishment that is
imposed, owing to the way in which the monarchy, by convention, is viewed as above the law on paper,
but in reality is seen as a subject of the law in a similar way, because essentially this begs the
question about where sovereignty lies. And that's a quite interesting debate and discussion to be
had. In fact, there are quite a few different debates and discussions that are had relating
to what the monarch can do in a certain situation, whether that be violating the law, or
declaring war, or even things like refusing royal assent for bills to become legislation. All of
these things really put the constitution in crisis if they were to ever happen. The final principle
that A. V. Dicey elucidates is this idea of supremacy of the law. Essentially what this
refers to is the principle of supremacy of law, and I've written here the principle of supremacy
when it comes to parliament, but it doesn't necessarily refer specifically to parliament,
because at the time that A. V. Dicey was writing, the idea of statutory provisions becoming and being
a significant source of law was less of a factor than it is today, for example. The statutory
provisions within the legal system are far more substantial in today's common understanding of
the constitution than previously, but essentially A. V. Dicey is elucidating that the idea that the
law has supreme sovereignty and authority, and we then can tie this into the principle of
parliamentary sovereignty in the sense that parliament today is the supreme law-making
authority in the United Kingdom. Nothing is above parliament, nothing is above parliament's ability
to create new law, and so essentially this means that parliamentary legislation is supreme.
Parliament has the ability to make and unmake any law they so choose. We'll get onto this in more
detail in a few lessons on the English legal system, and we'll get into it in a great amount
of detail in lessons on constitutional and administrative law in future lessons time
on that particular topic as well.
