What DNA Revealed About The Neanderthals - They Never Went Extinct

miracles around us
225 followers
If you are not of primarily Sub-Saharan African descent, approximately 2% of your genome
does not come from modern humans.
It comes from a species that went extinct 40,000 years ago.
The Neanderthals occupied Europe and Western Asia for around 300,000 years.
They had fire.
They had tools.
They had culture.
They buried their dead.
They made pigments.
They adapted to ice age conditions that would kill an unprepared modern human within days.
They had, on average, slightly larger brains than we do.
They were not the hunched, dim-witted brutes that 19th century reconstructions invented.
They were a sophisticated human species, deeply adapted to the harshest environments on Earth.
Then modern humans arrived in Europe.
Within 5 to 10,000 years, a geological instant, the Neanderthals were gone.
For most of the history of paleoanthropology, the explanation was straightforward.
Modern humans out-competed them.
Better tools, better social organization, better cognition.
The Neanderthals were replaced.
The two species had lived separately for hundreds of thousands of years, and the contact, when
it came, ended in extinction.
That explanation had one problem.
It assumed the two species had stayed separate.
The first Neanderthal fossil was identified in 1856, three years before Darwin published
On the Origin of Species.
For 154 years, the Neanderthals were studied, debated, reconstructed, and argued over.
And throughout that entire period, the separation between their lineage and ours was taken as
foundational.
They were the other branch, the dead end, the species that lost.
The separation between modern humans and Neanderthals had been the foundational assumption of human
evolution for over a century.
The physical differences are real and measurable.
Neanderthals had a projecting brow ridge, a differently shaped skull, a stockier build
suited to cold climates.
Studies of mitochondrial DNA from Neanderthal remains in the 1990s appeared to support the
separation.
The sequences were clearly distinct from modern human mitochondrial DNA, suggesting no interbreeding.
The conclusion held.
Two branches, one extinct, no mixing.
The problem was that mitochondrial DNA, passed only through the maternal line, is a narrow
window.
It tells you about one lineage, one thread of inheritance.
It says nothing about the full genome.
In 2010, Svante Paabo and his team at the Max Planck Institute for Evolutionary Anthropology
published the first draft sequence of the Neanderthal genome.
The project had taken years, required the development of entirely new contamination
protocols, and drew on DNA extracted from three female individuals from Vindica Cave
in Croatia, bones roughly 40,000 years old, preserved just well enough.
The genome was compared against the genomes of five modern humans.
Individuals from France, China, Papua New Guinea, Southern Africa, and West Africa.
The people from France, China, and Papua New Guinea shared more DNA with the Neanderthals
than the people from Africa did.
That asymmetry has one explanation.
At some point after modern humans left Africa, and before they spread across Asia and into
Europe, they encountered Neanderthals, and they interbred.
The Neanderthal DNA entered the modern human gene pool.
It was then carried east and west as modern humans spread, but not back into the populations
that had stayed in Africa.
Which is why African populations today carry essentially none of it, and everyone else
carries roughly 1-2%.
The separation had not held.
Here is where this stops being ancient history.
The Neanderthal DNA in your genome is not inert.
It is not archaeological residue sitting passively in your cells.
It is functional sequence that has been under natural selection for 40,000 years, meaning
the parts of Neanderthal DNA that survived in modern human populations survived because
they were useful.
The most studied example is the immune system.
Many of the HLA alleles, the gene variants that govern how the immune system recognizes
pathogens that are common in Eurasian populations today, were inherited from Neanderthals, and
separately, from Denisovans.
When modern humans arrived in Europe and Asia, they encountered a pathogen landscape that
Neanderthals had been adapted to for hundreds of thousands of years.
Picking up Neanderthal immune variants through interbreeding was, from a survival standpoint,
immediately valuable.
Those variants are still running in your immune system right now.
The COVID-19 pandemic produced the most striking recent demonstration of how present the Neanderthal
inheritance actually is.
In 2020, researchers identified a segment of chromosome 3, a cluster of genes carried
by roughly 16% of people with European ancestry, that was strongly associated with severe COVID-19
outcomes.
Carriers of this variant were at significantly higher risk of requiring intensive care.
The source of that chromosome 3 cluster, a Neanderthal who lived in what is now Croatia,
roughly 50,000 years ago.
The identical sequence was found in the Vindica cave Neanderthal genome, the same individual
whose DNA helped break the interbreeding question in 2010.
A different set of Neanderthal origin gene variants, on chromosome 12, tells the opposite
story.
Variants in the OAS gene cluster, present in roughly 30% of people with European ancestry,
were found to be strongly protective against severe COVID-19.
These variants increased the production of antiviral enzymes.
They also came from Neanderthals.
Two Neanderthal inheritance events.
One made you more vulnerable to a 2020 virus.
One made you more resistant.
The Neanderthals have been extinct for 40,000 years.
Their genes were deciding clinical outcomes in intensive care units in 2020 and 2021.
The immune variants are the clearest functional story, but they are not the only one.
Neanderthal DNA has been linked to variation in pain sensitivity, a gene variant affecting
sodium channels in pain pathways that is found in some European populations and traces to
a Neanderthal source.
Sleep patterns carry Neanderthal signal.
Several circadian rhythm gene variants in modern humans appear to have been inherited
from them, affecting chronotype, whether you are a morning or an evening person.
Skin and hair pigmentation in Europeans carries contribution from a Neanderthal origin variant
in the BNC2 gene.
There is also a negative signal worth noting.
While some Neanderthal DNA was preserved because it was adaptive, a larger fraction was not.
Studies of the modern human genome have found that certain regions, particularly regions
involved in brain development and testis function, are conspicuously empty of Neanderthal sequence.
These are called Neanderthal DNA deserts.
The interpretation, Neanderthal variants in these regions were harmful to hybrid offspring
and were removed by natural selection over the generations following admixture.
The Neanderthal DNA that survived in us is, by definition, the fraction that natural selection
decided to keep.
The rest was edited out.
The picture that has emerged from 15 years of Neanderthal genomics is not of a species
erased.
It is of a species partially absorbed, their genome dismembered by the process of hybridization
and natural selection, most of it eventually lost, but meaningful functional fragments
preserved in precisely the populations that most needed the adaptive advantage those fragments
offered.
Across all modern humans outside Africa combined, approximately 40% of the total Neanderthal
genome can be reconstructed from the fragments scattered through living people.
No individual person carries much.
But collectively, humanity outside Africa has preserved most of what the Neanderthals
had.
The extinction was not complete.
It was a dispersal.
Why did the Neanderthals disappear?
The genetic evidence rules out simple replacement.
The interbreeding means the populations were not reproductively isolated, and the Neanderthal
DNA in modern genomes is proof of genuine admixture, not just occasional contact.
Something else ended them.
The leading hypotheses are not mutually exclusive.
Modern humans may have brought diseases to which Neanderthals had no immunity, the same
dynamic that devastated indigenous populations across the Americas in the 16th century, now
playing out in Pleistocene Europe.
Demographic pressure may have tipped small, dispersed Neanderthal populations below viable
size over generations.
Climate shifts at the end of the last glacial period reorganized the environments Neanderthals
were adapted to, and the interbreeding itself, over thousands of years and multiple generations,
may have gradually diluted distinct Neanderthal populations into the expanding modern human
gene pool.
The most likely answer is all of these, operating together across 10,000 years of contact.
Not a conquest.
A slow dissolution.
The scale of what was lost in that dissolution is worth holding for a moment.
Neanderthals had occupied Europe through multiple ice ages.
They had survived conditions that modern humans had never encountered, temperatures that dropped
the treeline to the Mediterranean coast, glaciers that covered most of northern Europe, megafauna
extinctions that removed their prey species.
They had adapted, repeatedly, over 300,000 years.
Their anatomical cold adaptations, the wide nasal cavity for warming air, the stocky body
plan for conserving heat, the robust skeleton for physical endurance, took hundreds of thousands
of years to develop.
All of that specific, hard-won biological adaptation was gone within a few thousand
years of modern human contact.
What survived was 2% of their genome in the bodies of the people who replaced them.
The interbreeding was not a single event.
Genetic analysis has found evidence of multiple separate admixture events between modern humans
and Neanderthals, in the Middle East as modern humans first expanded out of Africa, and possibly
again in Europe during the later period of overlap.
The Denisovans, the third human species, first identified from a fingertip in Siberia, also
interbred with Neanderthals, and separately with modern humans, producing a layered inheritance
that is still being untangled.
The question of what Neanderthal society actually looked like remains open.
Evidence from El Cidron cave in Spain, where the remains of 13 related individuals were
found together, suggests family-based social groups.
The Altai Neanderthal genome showed extreme inbreeding within a small population, father-daughter
or equivalent.
Whether Neanderthal populations were typically small and isolated, or whether they had wider
social networks, is not settled.
The last Neanderthals are also not fully located.
The most recent confirmed Neanderthal remains date to around 40,000 years ago in southern
Europe.
Whether small, isolated populations survived longer, in refugia where modern humans had
not yet reached, is a question that new site discoveries occasionally reopen.
The Neanderthals went extinct, that is not in dispute.
What is in dispute is what extinction means when 2% of the genome of billions of living
people carries their sequence.
When their immune gene variants are in the white blood cells of people who have never
heard the word Neanderthal.
When their circadian rhythm genes are running in the bodies of people waking up too early
or staying up too late on a Tuesday night.
When their antiviral genes were, in 2020 and 2021, saving lives in ICUs across Europe and
Asia.
Svante Paabo was awarded the Nobel Prize in Physiology or Medicine in 2022 for the Neanderthal
genome project and the discovery of the Denisovans.
The Nobel Committee described his work as revealing something fundamental about what
it means to be human.
The Neanderthals are gone.
Their bones are in museums and caves.
Their culture, their language, their specific way of being in the world, all of it is lost.
But 40,000 years after the last of them died, their DNA is still functional, still selected,
still doing work inside the bodies of people who descended from the species that replaced
them.
The case is not closed, the species is not gone, it is distributed.
