Little Ice Age The Witch Hunts World History Part 3 Extra History

Explore History
10 followers
55 Video Views·Apr 26, 2026
Does your coffee taste like it's from the Little Ice Age? We got you covered! Get a free bag of fresh coffee delivered to your door with any Trade subscription at https://www.drinktrade.com/extracredits
From the rain-spoiled crops to the advancing glaciers and droughts that kill off livestock. Mass starvation has set in and there can only be one culprit. Witches manipulating the weather!
The Atlantic, 1654.
Get the rope up!
The captain shouts.
Next to him, a sailor frantically ties an unfamiliar knot,
while a wave crashes over the side, washing freezing water over their ankles.
Haste men! We must stop the gale before we go under!
Passengers huddle on the deck.
A load of colonists bound for Jamestown,
hoping to start a new life after the devastation of the English Civil Wars.
The sailor throws the rope over a spar.
Not a sailing knot, but a hangman's noose,
that he then places around the throat of a drenched old woman shivering in the rain.
Catherine Grady!
The captain shouts over the thunder.
Thou stand condemned as a witch,
guilty of colluding with Satan to stir up this tempest.
For this, thou shalt hang from the neck until dead.
Grady kicks as they haul her into the air,
twisting in the winds that she does not and could never control,
and winds that long after she swings limp will still howl on.
Thanks so much to Trade Coffee for keeping us history-loving beans caffeinated.
Catherine Grady would not be the last person executed in panics
involving the strange weather of the Little Ice Age.
On the contrary,
the worst periods of witch-hunting across Europe and in colonial America
tended to happen after either unusual seasons,
strange cold, early frosts or droughts,
or extreme weather events.
In fact, one of the biggest catalysts to the witch-hunting movement
came in 1519,
when King James VI of Scotland,
later James I of England,
held a series of witchcraft trials
after Atlantic storms appeared to be trying to sink his ship.
After executing several supposedly magic assassins,
he wrote the book Demonology,
both defending and re-energizing the witch-hunts across Europe.
But weather also played a major part in these witch-hunts
when they began a century earlier,
and that was due to another book,
the Malleus Maleficarum,
or Hammer of Witches.
Published in 1487,
it was a popular guidebook to hunting witches
and did much to spread the practice.
It also leaned heavily on the idea of witches manipulating weather,
and as a result,
thousands across Europe would be executed as scapegoats
for the erratic climate conditions.
Because while people didn't understand
what was happening in scientific terms,
they definitely knew that something had changed.
Snow fell further down on mountains
than even the very old could remember,
glaciers advanced,
constant rain spoiled crops,
and baking droughts killed livestock.
Greenland became inaccessible due to ice,
unseasonable frosts would cause
entire harvests of wine grapes to be unusable,
and wine growing disappeared
from more northern latitudes like England,
whose vintages were beginning to rival that of France.
Between 1693 and 1697,
crop loss resulted in famines in Norway,
Sweden, and France.
In Central Europe,
failed harvests due to environmental factors
were a major part in the mass starvation of the Thirty Years' War,
and of course,
there were the spectacularly powerful storms and weather events.
Which seemed to help nudge history at every turn.
In 1588, for instance,
the Spanish Armada
that was supposed to restore Catholicism to England
was defeated partially by battle,
and partially by a freak series of gales
likely fueled by a new accumulation of ice off Greenland.
More ships and men were lost by tempest than combat.
Likewise, the Great Fire of London in 1666
might not have been quite as severe
had a drought not dried out the largely wooden city.
Lisbon, Portugal had eight snowstorms in a single winter,
and coastal flooding inundated the low countries,
ruining some reclaimed land that had been built out into the sea,
and of course,
the French Revolution was spurred on
by a series of extremely bad grain harvests
that pumped bread prices into the stratosphere.
But, while Europeans were seeing their climate change,
the European colonists in North America
were experiencing a land and climate entirely new to them.
They were shocked by the violent weather they experienced in the 1600s.
This was, after all,
quite literally a new world for them,
containing new people, animals, plants, and climate systems.
With no sense of historical weather patterns in the Americas,
they at first assumed that these deep snows,
frequent droughts, and constant Atlantic storms
were normal for the area.
This started early,
when the first English colonists at the Jamestown Colony
arrived in 1607 amidst a horrifying drought,
unable to grow enough food,
and keeping them dependent on supply ships
and trade with the native Poetan Confederacy.
But by 1609, a failed harvest, a lost supply ship,
and a conflict with the Poetan led to the Starving Time,
when the harsh winters of 1609 and 1610
forced the Jamestown colonists to eat horses,
dogs, cats, rats, seabirds,
and in at least one confirmed instance,
one of their own.
Now, you might be wondering why,
if this phenomenon was global,
we're largely talking about Europe and North America.
Well, there's a reason for that.
See, there's a major debate
about whether the Little Ice Age
was truly a global phenomenon
or whether it mostly influenced the North Atlantic region.
There are certainly events that seem to fit the pattern
and science to back up that this was a result of cooling,
but the evidence is not as solid or as dramatic
as that in the North Atlantic region.
During the period,
glaciers advanced to their maximum modern extent in New Zealand.
Also, both Aztec and Mayan chronicles speak of poor harvests,
and supporting those documents
is work charting the amount of maize pollen and charcoal
in core samples suggesting some areas of Mesoamerica
showed a decrease in population and settlement.
Recent work has also been done
in charting the vast economic damage
the inclement weather wreaked on the Ottoman Empire,
which had a heavy dependence on agriculture.
Indeed, it appears a major rebellion in 1596,
the most severe internal crisis
the Ottoman Empire faced in centuries,
was directly tied to the government raising taxes
at a time of unprecedented agricultural devastation.
Similarly, in China,
it had been proposed that the periods of cold winters and dry summers
helped exacerbate the famines of the later Ming dynasty,
opening the door for the Jurchen tribes
of the later Jin dynasty under Nurhaci
to overthrow them and found the Qing dynasty.
Interestingly, Nurhaci's remains would later disappear
until they showed up at a Shanghai nightclub in 1935
when an American archaeologist bartered them to a crime lord Lao Tse
in exchange for a diamond called the Peacock's Eye
once owned by...
Wait a minute, Rob.
Is this just the beginning of Temple of Doom?
Nice, okay.
Scratch that.
Nurhaci founding the Qing dynasty, yes,
but remains disappearing
and being part of an elaborate nightclub brawl, no.
As in no more time for love, Dr. Wrath,
because we got to get back to the point,
which is while the story of the Little Ice Age
seems to be broadening,
it is still generally centered around the North Atlantic,
where people were beginning to gain an appreciation
for the aesthetics of snow.
Dutch Renaissance artist Peter Bruegel the Elder
turned his brush to winter landscapes
with his 1565 work The Hunters in the Snow,
the first of several paintings
depicting snow-capped roofs, icicles,
and town watercourses frozen solid.
And other artists of the Dutch Golden Age took the same tack,
filling landscapes with winter themes and gloomy days
when previous paintings emphasized clarity and sun.
In Britain, artists turned out pictures of ice skaters and curlers,
but some of the most famous of these
depicted the frost fairs held in London,
which started whenever it got cold enough
for the Thames to freeze.
These were unofficial holidays,
when carnival tents and vendors would set up on the ice
and ply their wares to merry, if shivering, Londoners.
Because as things got colder and the weather got more erratic,
people did, well, what they always do.
They adapted.
Humans are resilient creatures after all,
and they made innovations to agriculture, architecture,
and society in order to get them through.
And that's what we're going to talk about next week
as we cap off this series.
But right now in our story,
something troubling is happening.
Not in Europe, but on an island in Indonesia.
Mount Tambora, Dutch East Indies, April 10th, 1850.
The explosion is so big
that people 16,000 miles away in Sumatra think it's gunfire.
Above the village of Tambora,
the mountain bursts in a flood of burning magma.
10,000 die,
caught in the largest human-witnessed eruption in history.
Pyroclastic flows race down the mountain,
covering the villages in burning ash
before the whole of the peninsula starts to collapse,
shelving into the ocean.
Lava flows wipe out nearly all vegetation
and slop into the sea
with the mixture of pumice and tree trunks
hardening into floating stone rafts
up to three miles wide.
10 billion tons of rock.
The top 5,000 feet of the mountain's elevation
are ejected 141,000 feet straight into the stratosphere.
Then the ash rains down,
smothering and burning crops across Indonesia.
But the fine particles,
the winds catch those,
spreading them around the globe,
blocking sunlight.
By June,
Londoners were observing that the sunset was different.
Beautiful pinks and purples above,
with the horizon a deep red.
They had no idea that they were about to experience
the worst year of the Little Ice Age,
the year without a summer.
You know, even saying those words
makes me feel a little bit freezing inside.
It's a good thing I brewed up some warm and tasty coffee
from trade to cut through that cold.
We love working with trade
because the EC crew drinks a lot of coffee.
They're this awesome subscription service
that delivers fresh curated for you coffee
from local roasters right to your door
when and how you want it.
And they use their expertise to map your specific taste
against hundreds of different coffee flavor profiles,
which is to say they help you find
the perfect roast and grind just every single time.
Case in point,
trade just matched me with a great blend
from a local NYC roaster
with a historically named reference
on the front and everything.
And not only did they grind it perfectly
for my French press,
but it showed up at my door fast.
And I know that Jeff has been having a great time
trying out all of trades,
dark, dark espresso beans
because he totally doesn't have a problem.
So if you'd like to join us
in upgrading your morning routine
with just way better beans right now,
trade is offering one free bag of coffee
with any subscription.
If you use our link,
drinktrade.com slash extra credits.
This is not a drill people,
free coffee.
You can sign up for trade right here.
You're going to love it.
And once you're fully caffeinated,
check out another of our videos here.
The biggest bean thanks to
Ahmed Ziad Turk,
Angelo Valenciana,
Arclight Games,
Dominic Valenciana,
Izzy Coin,
Joseph Blame,
Kuyakoy,
and Michael Hoggett
for being our legendary patrons.
