Creamy Vanilla Ice Cream From Scratch – So Simple!

Ice Cream Recipes
122 followers
Hey y'all, I'm Ali.
Welcome to Little Hill Homestead.
We recently did our favorite kitchen gadgets
and a lot of people said,
hey, can you share the link to your ice cream?
So I went and looked for it and I was like,
we have chocolate, we have butter pecan,
we have strawberry,
but I never showed you guys our basic vanilla.
I have my grandma's recipe for vanilla on there,
but it's not the one we use
because it's more like an ice milk versus an ice cream.
Anyways, so today I'm gonna be showing you
our base ice cream recipe.
This is the vanilla that I,
this is my favorite.
I'm a vanilla person.
I could eat vanilla every single day of my life
and never get tired of it.
So this is the base recipe
and then we just add stuff to it to make other flavors.
We add like cocoa powder if you want chocolate
or strawberry, dehydrated strawberry,
blend it up if you want strawberry.
You can add nuts, you could add marshmallows,
you could add chocolate chips,
you could add mint flavoring,
anywhere from this recipe,
but I just do vanilla.
This is what I do.
So the first thing you guys need
is two cups of heavy cream.
This is that eight cup batter bowl.
I just love this thing
because I can go right off of the side.
This is the new one.
I don't know it as well.
Let me grab my old one
because I know it better.
I was telling somebody they're a little bit different,
just enough so that, you know.
Anyways, you need two cups of cream.
I tend to like a cleaner heavy cream,
but my store was out of them,
so this is what I have.
Then you need one and a half cups
of whatever milk you want.
I have not made this dairy free yet
because you have to have heavy cream
to really get ice cream.
So I haven't gone that route yet.
If you want me to try it,
maybe I could try like a heavy coconut.
I don't even know, you guys.
Anyways, just stick with the original.
This is the one I know and the one we use.
Like I was saying in our video,
we ate some regular ice cream from the grocery store
after only eating this for a couple years,
and it gave us both stomach aches.
We're not used to the gums and the funky stuff
that's in some ice creams.
If you look at the ingredients,
it's kind of shocking, actually.
Anyways, you need a cup and a half of milk.
I am not just eyeballing it, by the way.
There's a measuring in cups on the side,
and I'm just going off of that.
You need three quarters of a cup of sugar.
I use organic cane sugar or regular old white sugar,
your choice.
I haven't tried it with other sweeteners,
but you totally, I'm sure, can.
You need a pinch of salt.
It kind of just helps everything
kind of pull together really nicely
and tastes really, really good.
You need a teaspoon of vanilla.
This is our homemade vanilla.
We keep like a mother jar.
I just keep adding.
Anytime we make more, I just keep adding it to this,
and then eventually I will use the beans
to make vanilla bean paste, which I need to do very soon.
I'm gonna add a tiny bit more
because my spoon wasn't all the way full.
Alrighty, there we go.
The next thing I add, and this is,
if you buy certain brands
and they have the little specks of vanilla all through them,
this is how they do it.
It's vanilla bean paste.
I ran out of mine, so when I was at Trader Joe's,
I grabbed their bourbon vanilla bean paste.
I'm gonna use it because I bought it,
but it reminded me of how much I really, really like ours,
so I'm gonna be making more of ours.
I use vegetable-grade food glycerin to make ours.
It's really easy, you guys.
We have a video on it.
This stuff can get pricey.
This one, to me, is like, I don't know.
What do they actually have in it?
It's like gelatinous.
I can't read.
That's a size one font, and I'm over 40.
Let's be real.
Anyways, I just add a teaspoon of vanilla bean paste.
You can totally omit that.
All it does is add the little pretty flakes.
You know, the little bean, you know.
I'm gonna move this out of the way.
The last thing you need, two egg yolks.
I don't use egg whites in it because it gets funky,
but the egg yolks, and this can be omitted.
I know some people are freaked out
about eating raw egg yolk.
It doesn't bother me.
These are our chickens, our chicken eggs.
I know that they're fresh.
I know they're good.
It's a you do you situation.
Totally, it does add a creaminess,
and it makes, any ice cream has egg yolk in it.
If you look at the back, it's got it right on it.
Just saying.
All right, so all I'm gonna do is,
I'm gonna strain this off because I'm actually,
we have a ton of eggs right now.
Our chickens have gone completely crazy laying,
and so I'm gonna be making you guys very, very soon
a angel food cake to get some of the egg whites used up.
So I'm saving my egg whites for that,
but all I do is go the back and forth,
and then I just plop it in there.
All right, get that out of the way.
Let me just wipe some of that off.
I'll put this in the laundry, and just stir it up.
Like I was saying, if you wanna do chocolate,
we do Dutch chocolate.
I use a red alkalized from Azure Standard
or Dutch chocolate.
We had some that I loved from the Amish stores.
I can't find it down where we live,
and I'm getting this everywhere.
Good job.
But Dutch chocolate's my favorite.
You can use Hershey's cocoa powder too.
You add a half of a cup to it at this point.
If you wanna do strawberry, we add dehydrated strawberries,
or freeze-dried strawberries.
Sorry, not dehydrated, freeze-dried,
and we blend them up to make a powder.
We add those in here.
You can add nuts into it.
You could make, I don't even know, y'all,
what flavor you want.
You can go for it.
We did it with eggnog before.
We did heavy cream and eggnog.
Oh my gosh, it was like the richest ice cream
you've ever had in your life.
But this has to be done in an ice cream machine.
We have this one.
Let me grab the base for it.
We have one that has a condenser.
It's huge, guys.
It's heavy.
I don't like it.
It's hard to use, so I won't promote that one
because I don't like it.
But the one that I do use all the time,
they don't make anymore,
and it's very similar to a KitchenAid.
I'll show you the bowl.
Hold on.
It's just one of these freezer ones,
and we keep it in our big freezer to the side.
It just sets down on there.
It is a two-quart machine.
If you do one half, you kind of have to watch it
because it will start to overflow as it freezes.
This just, whoops, I forgot to put the paddle in.
This goes in.
This pops right on top.
You turn it on.
For the vanilla, because it has no add-ins,
I do 40 minutes.
I find that chocolates and things that I do add-ins with,
I do for less time.
If you're gonna be adding nuts or chocolate chips
or anything like that,
I do it the last very, like, two minutes of it.
If you're gonna be doing something
that's more like a flavor add-in,
like a cocoa powder or a strawberry or an extract,
I do it now.
And then I do 35 minutes.
I don't know why.
It needs a little less time.
So I just get this thing turned on.
Make sure your sugar isn't stuck on the bottom.
And then pour it in.
This is one of those ice creams.
It's super simple, super,
like, you know all the ingredients that are in it.
But anytime company comes to visit,
even if they're saying, like,
I'm doing keto right now or I'm dieting right now,
and we say, hey, you have to try our homemade ice cream,
they end up eating it every night that they are here.
Just saying.
It's really good.
It's super basic, but it's so creamy.
Anyways, I'm gonna let this go for 40 minutes.
I'm gonna bring you back to show you
kind of how we store it,
which is a whole other issue for us.
But I'll bring you back to show you
what our vanilla ice cream looks like on the other side.
Our ice cream is done, you guys.
Okay, so I will talk about containers in a second.
This just pops off, and I'm gonna throw it in the sink.
And then this, I just lift off, as you can see.
See how I was saying the ice cream
starts to encroach on the top so far
that, like, if you do add-ins,
it adds more volume to your overall liquid,
and so it does come over the top.
It's okay, this thing's really easy to clean.
Most of them are.
They are aware that they can do that.
But, you know, you know.
Anyways, I'm just gonna pop this out.
And I'm just gonna use my little spatula
to scrape anything off of here.
Now we have found, if you want, like, a soft serve ice cream,
you're good to go here.
But we usually make this in the morning.
We usually try to make it by, like, 11 a.m.
if we're gonna eat it that night.
But, you know, it just needs a little bit of time,
because I'll show you.
It's, like, just thin enough.
Boop.
And it can't really get too much firmer
because the ice mixture
that's in this double-walled container,
it starts to defrost.
So you'll end up not being able to freeze
any further than what you, farther?
Whatever the word is.
More than you already did.
All right, so it's like that.
I mean, it's thick enough to be like a soft serve,
but if you pop it in the freezer,
I'll show you the consistency that it turns into.
And I just do this.
And then, you know, if you do it first thing in the morning,
you have to have ice cream.
You have to test it out, right?
So you can have ice cream as early as, like, you want.
Just saying.
All righty.
Here we go.
Let me pop this in here.
Now, all I do is kind of smooth it like this,
just to get it in a nice little layer.
Now, let me talk about containers.
Okay, so that's done.
We're gonna pop that into the freezer.
So these are Rubbermaid containers.
I have no idea what they actually are for or used.
These are the ones we use.
We were gifted some from one of y'all.
Or two of y'all.
That we really liked.
They were from Dollar Tree.
But Dollar Tree's prices have gone up,
and every so many times I would use them, they cracked.
And although I don't mind having to replace stuff,
especially if it's cheap,
these ones we've had now for, like, two years,
and they've held up decently well.
They're not my favorite, but they do well enough.
So we have, we always have two.
We have a vanilla and a chocolate running.
And then sometimes I use this container.
This is a produce saver from Rubbermaid,
and this is what my vanilla is in right now.
So I wanted to show you the consistency.
This one we made a couple days ago.
I can't, with stuff on the counter,
it drives my eyes crazy.
This one was from a couple days ago.
It's totally solid now, and it freezes.
But I wanted to show you how it scoops.
So for scoops.
This one is a Rada, R-A-D-A, Rada, however you say it.
And I like it because this end is, like, kind of pokey.
So when it gets to the bottom,
and you can't get it out of, especially these containers,
you can get in there and really, like, you know, dig it out.
This is a weird tradition that I started.
My grandma worked and ran an ice cream parlor
when she was, you know, young, gir.
My mom worked at the ice cream parlor.
I think my uncles even worked at the ice cream parlor.
So when she passed away, I inherited her ice cream scoop.
It was one of those, like, we were young,
and we needed an ice cream scoop.
We were doing our kitchen at the time,
because she passed away right around the time
we got married, and we got her ice cream scoop.
Well, then my grandpa passes away a couple years later,
and we got his ice cream scoop.
And then Sean's grandpa passed away.
We got his ice cream scoop.
It became, like, a tradition.
So now we have four grandparents' ice cream scoops.
I don't know why.
It's just weird.
So this was actually, I believe my grandma's
or my grandpa's, I can't remember.
My grandma's broke, so this is probably my grandpa's.
Anyways, long story short,
we have a lot of ice cream scoops.
But these are the two that I mostly use.
I had a company reach out to us.
I tell you guys all the time,
we have companies reach out to say, like,
hey, do you wanna rep our product?
And most of it's like, no.
There's no way I would ever use that,
or neither would any of you.
But this one, I was like, maybe.
It was a heated ice cream scoop.
So the end gets hot, and I don't know.
You wanna see us get, I don't know.
Anyways, how do you scoop this with an ice cream scoop?
So it stays fairly soft,
but also at the same time, it's firm,
if that makes any sense.
So, I mean, we just finished lunch,
but we gotta go in here, right,
and get ourselves a pretty good scoop of this stuff.
So it scoops fairly easily.
If you're like, man, this will not scoop,
because it does get pretty dang hard,
we pop it in the microwave for 15 seconds,
and it's just enough to make it scoop really, really easily.
Let me get a spoon.
So let me bring it in and show you,
well, let me bring you in and show you the consistency.
Okay, here is our ice cream.
It looks like ice cream, right?
I mean, it's got a good, it melts really nicely.
It's a good consistency.
It's creamy, and oh, so good.
Okay, let me.
What, what does Little Hill Homestead ice cream taste like?
It is heavenly.
It's super vanilla-y, but not so much so
that it's like, whoo,
but it's the perfect amount of vanilla.
Sometimes I feel like you eat ice cream nowadays,
and it's foamy, if you know what I mean.
They put so many gums and stuff in it,
but it's like eating a cold marshmallow.
Like, it just has a thing.
So our ice cream does not have that.
It is like what you remember having as a kid.
It's like nice and cold.
It melts perfectly.
I love to put milk over mine
so it gets little ice crystals.
We also have our Guinness chocolate syrup
that is so good to put over this,
and then we put, this is the weirdest thing in the world,
I know, powdered malt.
You can buy powdered malt like, you know,
like you make malts out of,
but we sprinkle the powder directly on our ice cream,
and it adds like this chewy, amazing,
kind of crunchy thing with adding the malt flavor.
Anyways, it's so good, but there you guys go.
I've been running around today, can you tell?
That's our ice cream, you guys.
Let me know if you have any questions.
I know there's a few of you that have told me
like some of these crazy concoctions
and versions that you have made.
Let me know what they are,
because I'd be curious to see.
Anyways, go make our ice cream.
You won't regret it.
It's really good, you guys.
Thanks for watching.
