Alison Whyte | Venus With Cupid: Discoveries in the Conservation Lab

Incredible Finds
2 followers
2 Video Views·Apr 25, 2026
ISAC Podcasts
Venus with Cupid: Discoveries in the Conservation Lab
ISAC Museum Special Exhibition Lecture
Every conservation treatment begins with an investigation: How was the object made? What materials were used to construct it? And what has happened to it since it was created? Join ISAC conservator Alison Whyte to learn more about the discoveries made during the examination and treatment of OIM A30908, a statuette of Venus with Cupid, currently on display in the OI Museum special exhibition Making Sense of Marbles, Roman Sculpture at the OI, on view from September 15, 2022–March 12, 2023
I'm Kirsten Newham, Interim Chief Curator at the Oriental Institute Museum of the University of
Chicago, and I will be hosting today's talk. A few words of introduction to the OI,
if you're unfamiliar. The Oriental Institute of the University of Chicago is both a pioneering
interdisciplinary research center and a world-renowned museum whose aim is to understand,
reveal, and protect the earliest civilizations of the ancient Middle East. With 350,000 artifacts,
excavated mainly by OI archaeologists, the OI Museum houses the largest collection of ancient
Middle Eastern antiquities in the United States. Since its founding in 1919, a time when the
Middle East was called the Orient, the OI has pioneered innovative excavations and comprehensive
dictionary projects that serve as cultural encyclopedias of ancient civilizations. Of the
350,000 artifacts that make up the OI Museum collection, about 5,000 are on permanent display
in the main galleries, which are divided up in regions of the ancient Middle East.
In addition to the artifacts, the OI Museum collection also encompasses an expansive
archive collection composed primarily of materials related to the OI expeditions of the early 20th
century, as well as field journals, object logs, and archival photographs of excavations and objects
in situ. Additionally, the OI collection also includes more contemporary art pieces,
including large-scale paintings of archaeological sites as well as photographs.
The breadth of the collection is perfectly represented in our current special exhibition,
Making Sense of Marbles, Roman Sculpture at the OI, which inspires today's talk. So a few words
about the exhibition. On view as a group for the first time, the OI's collection of Roman
sculpture illustrates how we can make sense of marbles with divergent histories and the
fundamental importance of archaeological context in telling an object's story. The majority of
the collection was excavated by OI archaeologists at the site of Ptolemaeus in Libya in 1956 to 1958,
a veritable highlight being two life-size marble statues once displayed in the city baths at
Ptolemaeus. In the exhibition, this abundance of contextual information is placed in sharp
contrast with Roman works purchased from the antiquities market. 65 years after they were
first on view in the galleries of the OI Museum, we can appreciate the OI's collection of Roman
marbles in a new light, conscious of their complex history. And the exhibit was co-curated by myself
and Rocco Remora, PhD candidate in the Department of Art History at the University of Chicago.
Now, without further ado, I would like to introduce our speaker today.
Alison White is an Objects Conservator at the OI, where she has specialized in the preservation of
archaeological material from the ancient Middle East since 2001. She is a graduate of the Queen's
University Master of Art Conservation Program and also holds a BA in Anthropology from the
University of British Columbia and an MA in Ancient Studies from the University of Toronto.
In addition to her on-site work at the OI, Alison has participated in field projects in Italy,
Cyprus, Turkey, Israel, Afghanistan, Spain, and Uzbekistan. And now I will pass it over to
Alison for today's talk, Venus with Cupid, Discoveries from the Conservation Lab. Alison?
Thanks, Kirsten. Thank you all for joining me today for what I hope will be an interesting
presentation. We wanted to give you a glimpse of some of the work that the Conservation Department
does, and in particular, what we did in preparation for the OI's current special
exhibition, Making Sense of Marbles, Roman Sculpture at the OI, which opened in September
of this year and will continue until next spring. This talk will focus on the small stone sculpture
dating to the Roman period, 2nd to 3rd century AD, which depicts the goddess Venus holding a
block of hair in her right hand, although the connection to her own head is no longer there,
while Cupid stands at her left side beside his quiver with his hands bound behind his back.
The statue measures about 35 centimetres tall, 13 centimetres wide, and 7 centimetres deep.
The first step in any conservation treatment is to examine not just the artifact itself,
but the artifact's history. Where is this object from? How did it get to the OI? What's happened
to it since it was first made? Is there evidence of previous restoration or conservation treatment?
And what's been done, and who might have carried out this work?
Concurrently, we want to learn as much as we can about what the object was originally made from.
The answers to these questions will have an influence on how we approach
any conservation intervention. When researching the history of an object,
conservation will look to several other departments in the OI to get information.
We work not only with the curators for the exhibit, in this case Kirsten Newman and Roko
Omura, but we also consult our registration records and the OI archives. Registration
and archival records indicated that the Venus and Cupid statue was purchased together with
this life-size statue of a boy. Both were bought by former OI director Karl Kraling in the 1950s
in Beirut, Lebanon. Kraling used funds from Mr. and Mrs. Hans von der Maurits,
and the sculptures were exported with the permission of Lebanon's Department of Antiquities.
On the left in this slide is an image of the invoice from this purchase, dated March 21st,
1957. The invoice provides no provenience for the boy statue, but the Venus and Cupid
sculpture is said to have been found in Rostan, which is a reference to the town of Al-Rostan,
known as Erechtheza in Hellenistic times, which is near Homs in modern-day Syria.
From the OI accession card dated to July 5th, 1957, and shown on the right in this slide,
we learn that the items were acquired in Beirut, Lebanon from antiquities dealer
Eli Boustan. Note that the accession card describes both the boy statue and the Venus
and Cupid statue as having been found in the vicinity of Baalbek. So there's some conflicting
information here, which highlights one of the many difficulties in trying to understand the
provenience of purchased objects. This is in fact one of the main themes of the Making Sense of
Marvels exhibit. Was the statue from Al-Rostan, as indicated in the invoice, or Baalbek, as the
OI accession records indicate? Baalbek was a famous oracle pilgrimage site in the Roman period
when it was known as Heliopolis, and the remains of its impressive temple complex meant it would
have been a very well-known archaeological site in the 20th century when the statue was acquired.
Roko Umura, in his presentation for the opening of the Making Sense of Marvels exhibit,
suggested it was possible the dealer who Kralin purchased the statue from might have suggested
Baalbek as a provenience in order to raise the market value of the object he was trying to sell.
Roko also noted, however, that Al-Rostan, or ancient Arafusa, an important city in the
Unfortunately, as is the case with most purchased antiquities,
the circumstances surrounding the discovery of the object are unclear. OI archivist Anne Flannery
was also able to find these early photographs, which she thinks likely date to the time period
when the object was acquired by the OI, so in the mid to late 1950s. Here's a side-by-side view
comparing the earlier photo with how the object appeared when it came to the conservation lab
earlier this year. It's hard to compare color and black and white images, but more or less it
looks like it's in the same condition. And I'll go into more detail about the condition a bit later,
but for now it's enough to note that the object has been repaired from several pieces.
There's damage to the lock of hair held in Venus's right hand. A white substance has
been used to fill some of the gaps around the joins in the right arm, neck, and other areas.
In short, the repairs and restoration that were apparent when the object came to conservation
earlier this year look unchanged from the earlier photograph. We were also able to find out that
this object was exhibited once before at the OI in 1957, as indicated in this communication.
And here's an image of graduate students visiting that 1957 exhibit, which also featured these
larger marble statues. These statues were excavated from the site of Tolmeus in Libya
and are part of a Making Sense of Marbles exhibit. We also know that the Venus and Cupid statue,
along with several other objects in the current OI exhibit, were lent to the Smart Gallery,
now the Smart Museum of Art, also in the University of Chicago campus. This is a communication from
1973 between Gustavus Swift, OI museum curator, and Edward Maser, founding director of the Smart,
in which Swift makes a reference to the state of the crude mending of the Venus and Cupid statue.
And initial examinations of the object showed certain irrefutable evidence for the loan to the
Smart Gallery. As you can see here, a paper label was adhered to the underside of the base of the
object by the Smart Gallery. Also visible in this photograph are three pieces of cork that were
presumably glued to the base of the statue in modern times to help it stand more stably. However,
although Swift wrote that something ought to be done about the crude mending of the statue,
it doesn't appear that anything happened conservation treatment-wise in the 1970s.
As we saw before, the statue looks the same as the time of its acquisition in the 1950s.
So knowing a bit more about the history of the object, or at least as much as we could learn,
we started to examine the object in more detail in the conservation lab. The statue is made from
an off-white colored stone that certainly resembles marble. It's been repaired from
several fragments, and there's quite a complex break pattern. On the Venus figure, we can see
joins at the neck, the right shoulder, the top of the right arm, the wrist, the waist, across the
upper thighs, and at the shins. A break also extends across the Cupid figure at the top of
the thighs. There's a yellow shiny adhesive in some of the joins, as you can see in the bottom
image at the right. This adhesive appears to extend onto the finished stone surface in several areas.
Also a white material, likely plaster of Paris, was added at the joins in Venus's neck, shoulder,
arm, and waist. And you can see a close-up of this film material on Venus's waist area in the top
right image of this slide. There are also breaks that run vertically through the statue, as you
can see here. You can also see some unevenness to the color and surface quality of the stone.
In some areas, it's lighter in color and smooth and shiny. In others, it's darkened and pitted,
like on Venus's left arm and Cupid's left side. It's almost to the point where you start to
question if these pieces even go together. But it's not unusual for archaeological stone fragments
from the same statue to undergo different weathering processes, depending on where the
fragments ended up buried in the ground. It depends on a variety of factors, including soil composition
and degree of water that's around. So it's possible that these different colors that you
see at the proper left of Cupid on the left image here and on the torso and arms of Venus
are just a result of differential weathering of the fragments during burial. It was clear from
the outset that in addition to the discoloration on the stone, there are also remains of a reddish
pigment in the folds of Venus's garment here. And here in this close-up before treatment photograph,
you can see the remains of some red pigment on Venus's lips. In addition, we can see the
condition of this previously carried out plaster fill at the neck and the right shoulder. This
restoration work appears unfinished and honestly a bit sloppy. Perhaps whoever was carrying out
this work was interrupted or unable to finish for some reason. The plaster clearly goes beyond the
edges of the area of loss and is covering some of the finished surface at the neck. Here too,
the plaster applied to cover the joints of the shoulder extends onto the finished stone surface,
particularly at the underarm. And note this dark line here that extends over both sides of the
shoulder joint. Another issue that we noted in the preliminary examinations was that the proper
right arm joint was loose. It was possible to fully detach the arm and so we did that and it
revealed that holes have been drilled into the stone surface on either side of the joint and
metal pin have been inserted. Here's a view of that same area from the back. And here too,
you can see that plaster is extending from beyond the break of the wrist onto the surface of the
stone. This is probably a good point to talk about how art conservators today operate differently
from the time this initial mending and restoration was done. Art conservation as a profession is
relatively young. While the Fogg Museum at Harvard had a kind of apprenticeship program
in the early 20th century, the oldest university degree granting program in art conservation in
North America, which is NYU, dates to the late 1950s. So it predates those early photographs
we saw of the Venus and Cupid and the restoration that I've been commenting on so far. Training
today usually consists of a graduate degree offered by a handful of universities and the
curriculum includes both theory and practice in material science, instrumental techniques
for analysis of artwork, and hands-on practice. Above all, conservators today are required to
adhere to a code of ethics that stipulate, among other things, the thorough documentation
of conservation treatments, a commitment to use chemicals and products that are proven to be
stable and reversible over time, and when it comes to compensating for losses, to not falsely modify
the known aesthetic, conceptual, and physical characteristics of natural property, especially
by removing or obscuring original material. So a lot of thought goes into whether or not
modern material, whether for adhering or compensating for losses, is applied. For
example, intentionally drawing a pencil line on an object to mark where a join is
just wouldn't be done today. The circumstances behind conservation treatments are now reported
in written form and we create a detailed photographic record of what the object looked
like before the treatment, during, and after. For example, here's a selection of the before
treatment photographic documentation that I carried out before I treated the Venus and Cupid
statue prior to its exhibition this year. There's also an equivalent amount of during and after
treatment photographs. This documentation of conservation treatments is extremely time-consuming
but also totally essential so that the next generation of conservation professionals
responsible for the care of a collection will have as much information as possible
about what circumstances precipitated the conservation treatment, what sort of treatment
was carried out, what products or chemicals were used, and why. Unfortunately, we just don't have
any of that documentation for the early repair and restoration treatment that occurred before
the statue was acquired by EOI. I want to turn now to talk a bit more about the paint remains
that were noted on the statue. I've already referenced the most obvious ones, the red color
on Venus's garment for example. Red is also visible on the lower portion of the statue beside
Cupid's quiver and here's a close-up of that dark red on Venus's lips. Dark red was also noted on
the top of Venus's foot and this detailed image on the right also shows some of the adhesive
residues I mentioned before exuding from the join near Venus's toes here. We also noticed a pink
pigment on the marble between Venus and Cupid and between Cupid's legs. Less obvious initially
but most certainly there were small dots of red pigment on Venus's torso indicated by these arrows.
We're fortunate in the conservation lab to have a digital microscope. Here I'm using it to examine
and record some of the decoration on Venus's torso. This is a dino light microscope which
as you can see is handheld and allows the user to capture magnified images with a lot of flexibility.
You can also see in this slide that there wasn't just red pigment on Venus's torso
but also what appears to be gold. On the right is an image captured using the digital microscope
of Venus's navel and you can see the vestiges of gold shining here. Here's another image of the
torso where you can see both gold and red pigment and here's another image of the torso area and I
think here you can see particularly in the area indicated by the arrows how the gold and red have
been applied in the same area. It's possible that the red pigment was applied first and the gold
was then applied over top of it so the red would function as a whole. In other words it would have
been applied as a preparatory layer or to provide a richer quality to the appearance of the gold
that was applied over it. This technique was certainly known at the time the Venus and Cupid
statue was made and I'm showing here an example of a painted marble caryatid head from the site
which dates to the second century AD. Gilding was found lying over top of red ochre in certain areas
of the statue's hair and interpreted to have been meant to display a sort of highlight in the hair.
Similarly there's this statue fragment of a leg also from Aphrodisias that shows gilding
overlying two preparatory layers. First a white calcium carbonate brown was applied and then a
red ochre. The gold was applied on top and there's a cross-section showing these layers at the right
in this slide. With the digital microscope it was also possible to image the tiniest remnants of
gold on this area of Venus's left arm where there's a dark line which suggests Venus may
have worn a gold armband. Here's a more highly magnified image showing the gold. Curator Rocco
Remora also noted a series of raised dots around Venus's neck which suggests the remains of a
necklace which might have also had paint although no paint is currently detectable with the naked
eye or with the microscope. So the Venus figure would have originally been highly decorated
and here I've added some dots to this photo to help you visualize the pattern of this body
jewelry. Rocco and Kirsten were able to confirm that this kind of body jewelry was not unusual
for small statuary of this type from this time period and provided several examples of comparable
statuary including this example of Venus and Cupid figurine from the Exus Museum in Turkey.
Another perhaps even more compelling example is provided by this statue the so-called Venus in a
bikini from Pompeii that's in the Archaeological Museum in Naples. This statue has especially
comparable gilded decoration in the torso and upper arm area. In addition to looking at the OI
sculpture under the microscope we also viewed it under ultraviolet light. This is a tool commonly
used in the examination of art collections and can be very helpful when trying to evaluate the extent
of previous restorations or any kind of coatings or adhesive residues that might be present on the
surface. I had already seen a fair amount of a clear yellow looking adhesive on the surface of
the object under the microscope but the UV light was very helpful in showing how extensive those
residues were. For example in this image of the underside of the statue that we saw earlier
in addition to the smart gallery label you can see that there is some yellowish clear adhesive
in the join line and perhaps you can see that a bit of it is extending onto the stone surface
itself. But under long wave UV light this becomes a lot clearer and you can see the extent of the
adhesive residues is really quite significant. You can also see some other details.
Like it looks like one of the modern pork feet was originally further back. In the region indicated
by this blue arrow you can see a pork foot shaped circular residue of slightly more yellow adhesive.
For some reason this pork foot got moved maybe it fell off and got glued back on in a slightly
different area. Many more adhesive residues were visible throughout the surface of the object.
Like the application of the plaster it looks like the adhesive used to glue the object back together
was not applied in the most careful or clean way. And you can really see the adhesive residues
fluorescing in this image on the right particularly around Venus's foot and extending
over toward Cupid's feet. Beyond these residues however we also notice something else. The pink
pigment that we had seen on the surface of the statue between Venus and Cupid's legs also appeared
to fluoresce under the UV light. However the dark red pigment noted on Venus's foot and on Cupid's
quiver did not fluoresce. It's probable that this fluorescing pink pigment was made from the root
of the matter plant. Pigments made from this plant are known to have a characteristic pinkish orange
fluorescence under UV. This is an example from the Museum of Fine Arts Boston cameo website
showing a small figurine with different shades of pigment from red brown to pink on the front
of the figurine's garment. Under UV light you can see the characteristic orange pink fluorescence
of the areas that were painted with matter. Matter was first used as a dye in Persia, India and Egypt
and then its use spread westward and it was commonly used in classical Greek and Roman
times as both a dye and a pigment. So its presence on our statue is not surprising.
In fact matter was also found on the Venus in a Bikini statue seen at the left in this slide
as well as this other statue shown at the right known as the Venus Marina also from Pompeii.
In addition to looking at the statue using UV light we also examined it using the Conservation
Lab's Portable X-ray Fluorescence Spectrometer or XRF. This machine is extremely helpful to us
in conservation because it allows us to determine the elemental composition of the materials we
analyze. In other words it can tell us what chemical elements are present on the surface of
an object. The best thing about it is that it is non-destructive. We don't need to remove a sample
from the object we are analyzing. We just hold the machine up to it and run the analysis. The diagram
at the right in this slide shows how it works. Inside the instrument there's an X-ray source
which fires X-rays out of the nose of the instrument and those X-rays interact with the
surface of the object being analyzed. The interactions are depicted in the schematic
of the atom shown directly below the machine. X-rays from the XRF interact with the electrons
in the atoms that make up the various elements on the surface of the object and cause a characteristic
fluorescence which is then read by a detector in the machine. Electron orbital structure is unique
for each element on the periodic table. The energies that are produced during fluorescence
incited by XRF by the electrons of each element are also unique, characteristic, and known.
And in this periodic table you can see all the energies listed out under the symbol for each
element. For example iron which is indicated by Fe has an energy listed at 6.405. The XRF
then converts the energies into a spectrum that looks like this. It's a series of peaks with each
peak more or less representing an element on the periodic table. So you see in this particular
spectrum we have the iron peak at 6.405. We also have peaks for lead represented by Pb and calcium
Ca. This is a very simplified explanation of this instrumentation and it can be quite
complicated sometimes to interpret the spectra especially when analyzing archaeological material
which is often heterogeneous and rarely perfectly flat which are two criteria that are ideal when
using portable XRF. But it still can give us some good information and the fact that we don't have
to remove a sample from the object is obviously a plus as far as the conservation department is
concerned. One other thing to keep in mind is that the portable XRF spectrometer cannot detect
elements below sodium or above uranium on the periodic table. So unfortunately we can't see any
of these elements with this technique. Here are some results of the XRF analysis for the Venus
and Cupid figurine. The area of analysis is indicated by the blue square on the front of the
base that Venus and Cupid stand on. So this is an analysis of the undecorated marble surface and it
mostly calcium which is exactly what we would expect. Marble is calcium carbonate and as we
just learned the XRF won't be able to detect the carbon and oxygen that's present so we just expect
to see a big calcium peak which is what we're seeing here. We also analyzed one of the patches
of gold on Venus's torso and you can see here characteristic peaks for gold with the symbol AU.
We analyzed the red on Venus's right hip and the XRF picked up mercury which is the symbol HG
and sulfur the symbol S. This is a scan from the region of Venus's navel where again you can see
the characteristic spectrum for gold but also there are some peaks for mercury and sulfur in
this region too. In the area of Venus's red lips we also found mercury and sulfur and the dark red
near Cupid's quiver also showed presence of mercury and sulfur. We suspected that this red
pigment containing mercury and sulfur was likely cinnabar, a pigment made from naturally occurring
mercury sulfide ore. One of the limitations of the XRF technique is that while it can tell you
what elements are present it doesn't tell you how they all fit together into a molecule. So we can
look at this spectrum and infer that because mercury and sulfur are present in the area of
the red pigment they probably are part of the same molecule but we can't actually say for certain
that we found molecule cinnabar. We can only say that we found individual elements. So we decided
to turn to a different technique for confirmation of the molecular structure of this red pigment.
This is an image of a Raman spectrometer on the left. Raman spectroscopy uses laser light to
vibrations in the sample being analyzed. It produces a structural fingerprint by which
molecules can be identified. A Raman spectroscopy analysis will produce a spectrum like you see on
the right which can then be compared with spectra of known materials and so you identify your sample.
The Raman instrument that we had access to required that a sample of the red pigment
be removed from the object. So I took a tiny bit of red pigment from the top of Cupid's quiver.
The image at the right far right is a picture of the sample that was removed
and the scale there is in millimeters. So it was a really tiny amount of sample.
Raman spectroscopy is non-destructive in the sense that the sample is not consumed by the analysis
so we actually retain the sample equipment in the lab. We were lucky to be able to work with
Justin Dreweller of the University of Chicago Materials Research Science and Engineering Center
who analyzed our sample for us using their facilities. The results of the Raman analysis
of the sample from Cupid's quiver were consistent with cinnabar. So it's likely that the red paint
that contained mercury and sulfur that we saw in other places on the statue including
Venus's lips and torso are also cinnabar. Like matter and gold the presence of cinnabar on the
Venus and Cupid statue is not surprising as this pigment has been used for decorative purposes as
early as the 9th millennium BC and there is evidence of it being used on marble statuary
in the Roman period. For example in this late 3rd century relief sculpture from the site of
Nicomedia, Turkey where the red pigment used to decorate the human figure's leggings has been
identified as cinnabar. So despite its mostly undecorated appearance today we've been able to
confirm that at least two different types of pigment pink matter and dark red cinnabar as well
as gold leaf were used to decorate this statue and it probably had a much more colorful appearance
when it was first made than it does now. Unfortunately the time and resources available
to study this object in the run-up to the current exhibition were limited. There's a lot more
analysis to be done and we'll look forward to continuing to study this piece when it comes off
display at the conclusion of the Making Sense of Marbles exhibit. And I just want to finish up this
talk today with a summary of what was done in terms of the actual conservation treatment for this
object. We decided to remove as much as possible of the unfinished marble plaster restoration that
existed around the joins at the neck, waist, right arm, and wrist. That material was likely
originally added in an unfinished attempt to make the object look intact, something that's not a
priority today. A before treatment image is shown on the left in this slide and an after treatment
is shown at the right. And again this is before treatment on the left and after treatment on the
right. Some close-ups here. I removed the metal pin that had been inserted between the join at Venus's
right wrist as well as the white plaster and replaced it with a modern adhesive that's been
tested for reversibility and long-term stability. As I mentioned at the beginning of the talk,
the item that Venus is holding in her hand is likely meant to represent a lock of her own hair,
something that didn't quite work with the previous plaster restoration.
Once that old plaster had been removed, we noticed there wasn't any connection between the
lock of hair and Venus's upper arm and we were concerned about the stability of the wrist forearm
connection. So a small amount of restoration made up primarily of an acrylic adhesive was added in
this area to help stabilize the join between the hand and the arm. And in this slide you see the
before view on the left and the after on the right. I also removed as much of the overlying
adhesive residues as possible. This was very tricky in areas where there was pigment or gold
also on the surface so that work had to be carried out under the microscope and in some cases it
wasn't possible to remove the adhesive residues so some do remain. But much was able to be removed
from the underside of the face as you can see here. We hope if you haven't already that you'll
be able to come and visit the Making Sense of Marbles exhibit at the OI so you can see this
object in person along with several other Roman marble objects from the OI's collection.
Several colleagues helped with different aspects of the research and analysis of the Venus and
Cupid statue as well as the preparation of this presentation and I'd like to acknowledge them
here. And I also want to thank you so much for tuning in today. For over 100 years the OI has
been a leading research center for the study of ancient Middle Eastern civilizations. Join us in
uncovering the past and learn about the beginnings of our lives as humans together.
Become a member by visiting oi.uchicago.edu slash member.
