The Surprising Complexity of Dogs in Renaissance Art

Art of the Renaissance Period
59 followers
7 Video Views·Apr 24, 2026
Dogs appear in countless works of Renaissance art. But what do they mean? That's a tricky question to answer! This video explores the wide range of dogs found in Renaissance art, and then takes a close look at two dogs on the Gates of Paradise by Lorenzo Ghiberti.
Find the full bibliography and image/music credits here: https://docs.google.com/document/d/1OXNOVITVUqA-yjYWBt6aK6vzvljCoHdVlY6ZMKyWOSo/edit?usp=sharing
These are Lorenzo Ghiberti's Gates of Paradise,
a masterpiece of early Italian Renaissance...
No, wait, hold on a sec.
Those are actually a modern copy of the Gates of Paradise.
The originals are now here in Florence's Duomo Museum.
Okay, so these are Lorenzo Ghiberti's Gates of Paradise.
And if you look closely, you'll spot two greyhound-type dogs
just about in the center of this panel.
What are those dogs doing there?
What do they symbolize?
If you nose around in Renaissance art long enough,
you're likely to start noticing dogs everywhere.
They're in religious paintings and mythological scenes and portraits.
Sometimes they're just curled up sleeping
while their person forgets to take them out for a walk
because he's so busy translating the Bible into Latin.
What is it with all these dogs?
What do they all mean?
Maybe you've heard something like,
dogs are symbols of faith or loyalty.
But that's not really accurate.
I mean, sure, some dogs can be symbols of faith or loyalty.
But that's a small fraction of what's really going on.
These dogs on Ghiberti's doors, for instance,
don't really have anything to do with faith or loyalty.
By the way, put a pin in that modern copy of the Gates of Paradise.
We're going to come back to them later.
Before we get too deep into that image, let's take a step back.
We need to dispel some myths about dog symbolism
and get a better picture of just how wide-ranging this imagery is.
Buckle up for a lightning round of...
People in the Middle Ages and Renaissance had lots of ideas about dogs,
judging by their writings and art.
It's just that these ideas weren't always consistent.
For example, dogs could be praised for their faithfulness, wisdom,
sense of justice, mystical abilities, and more.
The early medieval scholar Isidore of Seville wrote,
there is nothing wiser than dogs.
They have more senses than any other animal.
But dogs could also be associated with anger, greed, promiscuity,
even the devil himself.
The medieval Italian poet Dante included hellhounds in his Inferno,
including black she-mastiffs, ravenous and swift of foot as greyhounds,
who rush forth to tear apart a damned soul.
In visual arts, we can see a similar range of views.
So dogs might be vilified and associated with Christ's tormentors.
These images from Northern Renaissance art feature dogs who seem to egg on the abuse.
Or dogs might be symbols of lecherous desire,
as might be the case with Correggio's painting of the abduction of Ganymede.
But dogs are also shown as faithful companions and friends.
These might be portraits of real people with their dogs,
or images of mythical, historical, or biblical figures,
like in this painting of Tobias and the Angel.
By the way, this painting is attributed to the workshop
of the Italian artist Andrea del Ferrocchio,
and at least one art historian has suggested that a young Leonardo,
who was in Andrea's workshop, painted the dog.
Not a bad pedigree for this pup.
Dogs were also associated with Saint Dominic,
whose mother had a dream of a dog with a torch in its mouth while she was pregnant.
But before you go identifying every dog-walking saint as Dominic,
keep in mind that Saint Brock is also regularly shown with a dog.
Apparently a dog helped him out while he was sick with the plague.
Dogs appear in the rooms of scholars,
both as references to real-life companions,
as in the case of known dog lover Petrarch,
and as symbols of wisdom and the pursuit of knowledge.
They show up in family portraits.
There's even an image on a portrait medal of Michelangelo
that shows a pilgrim, probably Michelangelo himself,
being led by a guide dog.
Dogs could also be a means of expressing or showing off wealth.
Anyone who's bought a bag of dog food or paid for a vet visit
knows that keeping a dog is not cheap.
And it wasn't all that different in the Renaissance.
Packs of hunting dogs like these were expensive.
Even a small lap dog, like the one in this portrait of Cardinal Pompeo Colonna,
would have been costly.
It's pretty clear that Cardinal wants us to appreciate that he is a man of means.
In some cases, dogs can just be dogs.
These frescoes of the Annunciation to the shepherds
show dogs reacting in apparent anger or fear
to the sudden appearance of an angel announcing the birth of Jesus.
This is a very natural thing for a dog to do
at the arrival of an unexpected visitor,
especially when that visitor is floating in the sky.
Some artists, like Pisanello and Durer,
very clearly sketched dogs from life
and beautifully captured their canine essence.
In short, dogs are everywhere in Renaissance art.
And they can represent a range of ideas.
Everything from a portrait of a beloved companion
to the animal embodiment of wisdom.
If you've got a favorite pup from art history,
I'd love to hear about it in the comments.
This lightning round is not exhausting.
It's just meant to give a taste
of how widespread canine imagery is in the Renaissance.
All of which gets us back to this.
The Italian Renaissance sculptor Lorenzo Ghibert
worked on his gates of paradise for over two decades,
from 1425 to 1452.
They're very big doors and working in bronze
is really hard work, so we can cut him some slack.
The doors contain about 40 episodes
from the Old Testament spread across 10 panels.
Each panel is a masterpiece of composition
and figurative arrangement.
As the art historian Amy Block notes,
this is the most artistically innovative
and dazzlingly beautiful Old Testament cycle
completed in Florence during the early Renaissance.
She literally wrote the book on these doors,
so she knows a thing or two about them.
We're going to focus on just one panel,
the biblical story of Jacob and Esau,
and the two pups right here,
the hunting dogs that belong to Esau.
In case you're not familiar with this story
from the book of Genesis, here's a quick summary.
Jacob and Esau were twins born to Isaac
and his wife, Rebecca.
Esau was the older twin and he is described
as red and hairy from birth.
He grew up to be a great hunter,
whereas Jacob preferred to stay at home.
The twins' parents each had a favorite.
Isaac preferred Esau, thanks to all the venison
he brought home from hunting,
while Rebecca preferred Jacob.
It's not clear why, but that's not important right now.
One day, Esau returned from the fields,
faint with hunger, and asked his twin
for some of the stew he had made.
Jacob said he'd only give him some stew
in return for Esau's birthright,
that is, his rights as the firstborn.
Esau agreed and got his stew.
Baby, you got a stew going!
Years later, when Isaac was old and blind
and on his deathbed,
he asked Esau to go out and hunt
to bring him back some meat.
This would be for a meal before giving Esau
his blessing as the firstborn.
But Rebecca overhears this,
and when Esau leaves for his hunt,
she tells Jacob, her preferred son,
of a plan to trick Isaac into giving him this blessing.
She has Jacob bring a couple goats to her,
which she prepares into a meal.
She then dresses Jacob in Esau's clothes
and uses the goatskin to cover his hands and neck
so he'll feel hairy like Esau if Isaac touches him.
Jacob does this,
serves his father the meal Rebecca prepared,
and indeed tricks his father
into giving him his blessing.
When Esau returns to his father,
he finds out about this
and is understandably not happy.
What's worse, Isaac doesn't take back the blessing,
but instead gives Esau
a pretty crappy second-class blessing.
Eventually, the brothers work things out,
but that's not important right now.
What we want to focus on is this scene right here.
In the panel's foreground, roughly in the center,
we can see Isaac, his firstborn son Esau,
and Esau's two hunting dogs.
One pup has unfortunately lost the tip of his snout
in the centuries since this was finished,
but the overall intent is still clear.
This scene is sometimes said to be the moment
before the hunt,
when Isaac asks his son to go out
to bring him back some meat.
But it's more likely that this shows the episode
after the hunt,
when Esau learns he's been conned
out of his blessing.
Note how he has the quiver for his arrows
around his waist.
The biblical story explicitly states
that Isaac tells his son
to get his hunting equipment.
The passage reads,
Now therefore take, I pray thee, thy weapons,
thy quiver and thy bow,
and go out to the field
and take me some venison.
Because Esau already has his quiver
and his hunting dogs,
we can assume this is after the hunting trip.
Now look closely at the dogs.
Look at their poses and how they're portrayed.
They're both hunting dogs,
similar in appearance to modern greyhounds.
But one dog is very clearly shaggier
with coarser hair.
This dog is also hanging his head
as though in defeat,
and he raises a tentative paw.
The very clear distinction in the dog's fur
is a clue that there is more going on here.
Remember that Esau, as described,
is born hairy.
His brother Jacob,
in order to fool their father
into thinking he is his twin,
must wear goat skin.
Now the shaggier dog
is starting to make more sense
viewed in that context.
The dog is a reference to,
or a representation of,
the hairier Esau.
The slightly lifted paw
makes this more explicit,
as it mimics Esau's pose across the panel.
He's always portrayed with
one foot planted and one foot lifted.
So does that make the other dog Jacob?
Look at the smooth-haired dog's stance and pose.
This dog is standing more confidently
with raised head and alert ears.
Such an assertive pose calls to mind
the decisive and active Jacob,
who on two occasions worked to take
what was rightfully his brother's.
Meanwhile, the dejected stance
of the coarse-haired dog
suggests Esau's emotional response
to his defeat at the hands of his younger twin.
So here we have an example of dogs
not as generic tropes,
not as symbols,
but as specifically linked to the meaning
and interpretation of the total image
in which they appear.
The dogs reflect the emotions and actions
of their human counterparts,
as well as the brothers' differing histories
and future destinies.
In some ways,
it's like the Renaissance version of saying
that people end up looking like their dogs,
or vice versa.
Now let's quickly return to these doors,
the modern copy of the Gates of Paradise
that are currently in place
on the Florence Baptistry
In the modern copy,
both dogs are depicted with shaggy fur.
This completely erases the original intent
and meaning of Ghiberti's portrayal of the dogs.
One other point that's worth mentioning
about the dogs
has nothing to do with their possible significance,
but is just as important.
Look again at the dogs in this scene,
as well as at two more from other panels
on the Gates of Paradise.
There's a herding dog in the Cain and Abel story,
and a shaggy pup in the Solomon panel.
All of these dogs very clearly indicate
the eye of someone who was observing
real-world pups.
These dogs look like dogs.
In addition to perspective and composition
and human figures and emotion,
all the usual things we associate
with the Renaissance,
Ghiberti is also demonstrating his mastery
in representing the animal world.
That's very tricky,
as anyone who's ever tried to draw their pet
likely knows.
If we can say anything
about the representation of dogs in this period,
it's that more and more artists
were interested in portraying actual dogs,
and not just stylized representations
of anonymous or stock dogs.
In a sense,
it's the beginning of what would eventually become
pet portraiture,
at least in Europe.
And that is what would eventually lead
to the contemporary practice
of taking countless photos and videos
of our four-legged friends.
It may be a lot easier today
than what Ghiberti had to do,
but it's also not quite as cool
as immortalizing a pup in bronze
on the most famous set of doors
in European art history.
Thanks for watching.
I also want to give a huge thank you
to Amy Block,
who very generously shared her research
on Ghiberti's dogs with me.
That whole section is based on her research.
For a list of all my sources and images,
check out the links in the description.
If you enjoyed this,
give it a like and subscribe for more videos.
