The Nature of Law - English Legal System

History of Law
11 followers
#education #law #learning
The Law Academy is a project designed to provide legal education for students studying law in the UK. Subscribe for more content.
Citations & Further Reading
A. Gillespie & S. Weare, The English Legal System (Oxford University Press, 2021).
E. Allbon & S. Kaur-Dua, English Legal System (Pearson 2020).
Disclaimer:
At no point are these video lessons intended to provide any sort of legal advice. These are for educational purposes only!
Image(s) Copyright: This Photo by Unknown Author is licensed under CC BY-SA
In the previous lesson we introduced the concept of the English legal system
and what we're going to do in this lesson is talk about the nature of law more generally
because we can't understand the structure and the processes of the English legal system without
trying to understand what it actually is to call something law. Now we're going to try and just
take an overview to that question being very reticent of the fact that we are going to be
covering this in far more detail when we look at the philosophical dimensions of law in our
series on jurisprudence because essentially the questions that we're asking in the series
on jurisprudence relates to this kind of topic. What is law? What does it mean to call something
law? This lesson is just going to try and give us a bit more of a working definition of the kind of
things that we're talking about, the idea of law, the nature of law, the nature of enforcement of
legal principles. So we're going to examine and look at the nature of law and the idea that law
can be representative of a collection of rules and in doing so we're going to try and come to
some kind of definition of law making it very clear that we are talking about the way in which
law is operationalised within society to reflect often morality or some kind of societal condition
and to try and generally understand what the purpose of law is within the broader construct
of society itself. Now according to Robertson from 2006, they describe law as a set of rules
that are created and are enforceable by social or governmental institutions to regulate behaviour.
That is considered to be a generalised, often quite uncontroversial, definition of what law
is. It's a set of rules and that we create these rules to be enforceable. They are enforceable by
some way through societal or governmental institutions, i.e. a judiciary or a court,
and the purpose of them is to regulate behaviour, to regulate societal behaviour.
And what this essentially does is define law as a special kind of rule, a collection of rules,
and if we were to talk about the kind of rules that they are, they have certain special
characteristics and features attached to them. But then what are rules? Well, if we understand
and we try and understand law through the lens of rules and the idea that law is just considered
and can be just considered to be a collection of rules, we suggest that rules therefore are
general principles which are said to be enforceable in some way. So they are enforceable through
society, in the case of a sort of general rule of society, or they are more enforceable through
the specific institution that said rules are supposed to govern. So, for example,
the offside rule in football is a rule that is applicable to the sport of football. The offside
rule is not something that is operationalised and something that is enforceable to broader society,
it is something that is enforceable specifically and it only makes sense to be enforceable
specifically within the context of football, if you're American soccer. And so, as a result of
which, these are ideas of rules which are regulated internally within the sport itself.
And then so when we take this a level higher, we talk about the level of society as a whole,
we represent the rules that govern said society and we define that as law, and we define laws
as the kind of collection of rules which govern society in the same way that rules in football
govern the sport of football itself. So, for example, everyday societal issues such as buying
a house, getting married or divorced, purchasing from a shop, business and commerce, regulating
crime, they are all done through and under the auspices of a certain collection of societal
rules, and we call these rules law, and that is how we understand law to what it means in this
context. However, Robinson also makes a reference to this idea of enforceability through government
institutions. Well, what do we mean when we talk about the enforcement of rules and the enforcement
of law? So, how is it the case that law is enforced? Well, the enforcement of law is actually one of the
main things that you study as a law student or as a future lawyer. There is often a violation of
law or there may be a dispute arising out of legal principles, and so the enforcement of your personal
rights or the enforcement of a state's right to prosecute, for example, might be what is
constitutive of the enforcement of law, the enforcement of rules. And given that we can
describe law potentially as a mechanism for social control, a little bit like what
Robertson said in 2006, the formal mechanism for enforcement of such rules will also exist.
So, law can be enforced in a number of different ways depending on the type of law that we are
talking about. Now, in the next lesson, what we're going to do is examine the distinction and the
delineation between the civil and the criminal law, but there is a certain differentiation in
terms of enforceability between those two areas. For the most part, you'll be studying the
enforcement and interpretation of law through the structure of courts, the judiciary, and this is
sort of the government institution that represents an enforcement mechanism for laws
which are alleged to have been broken, to be violated, or disputes between individuals as to
their private rights within a legal system. Now, like I said just then, courts represent
part of the state judiciary, a branch of the government which is tasked with the job of
enforcing and interpreting laws which are passed, and so they also represent a mechanism by which
new law is created through the common law, through the fact that a court decision on a particular fact
may be influential for future decisions on similar facts, for example. And so, as a result of this,
we can see that the enforcement of rules relates to this idea of a judicial enforcement of rules,
the sort of mechanising of enforcement through judiciary and through the establishment of the
common law, and also through other kinds of judicial functions like tribunals, and you also
have things like alternative dispute resolution, for example. So, when we talk about the difference
between rules in the context of sports and laws in the context of the state, rules have an
obligation to be followed. There is obviously an obligation if you're playing football to
follow the rules within the confines of the sport of football, but if you do not follow those rules
then the consequences of that are limited to your playing of football, they're not limited to the
state as a whole, because if you break the law you will be penalised, there will be penalties
including fines, there may be injunctions, and there may even be prison time. And so, there is
also an obligation to follow the law by everyone. Everybody has to follow the law. Compare this,
of course, to the context of sport, where only those who are playing the game have an obligation
to follow the rules of said game. It's almost like the rules of society are the laws that everybody
has to follow. So, this is how we understand a basic principle of the rule of law, in fact,
the idea that nobody is above the law, there is equality before the law. These are things that
we're going to talk about in a future lesson in both this series on the English legal system
and also in the series on public law.
