The End Of Lab Diamonds ? Gia ’s Bombshell Announcement Explaiined

The Secret of Diamond
12 followers
G.I.A. just made the biggest announcement how they will change how they grade lab-grown diamonds.
This is a big deal. Are lab-grown diamonds getting downgraded from G.I.A.?
Or they're being treated differently for a reason?
In this video, I'll explain what is going on and why it matters if you're shopping for one.
Hi, welcome back to my channel. This is Bonnie with BuyBonnieJewelry,
where I talk about all things diamonds and craftsmanship.
Okay, so here's the press release that they will no longer use color and clarity.
That was developed for natural diamonds. Instead, they're revising into two categories.
Number one, premium. Number two, standard.
So immediately, like, my alarm goes off. Like, what does premium and standard mean?
So they're saying that these categories will be defined by a combination of metrics related to
color, clarity, and finish.
And if the man-made diamond fails to achieve minimum standard for quality,
it will not receive a destination from G.I.A.
So for decades, we've used the same 4C grading system.
So cut, color, clarity, caret to grade all diamonds, even when lab was first introduced.
So now, lab-grown stones have changed the game.
I mean, they're doing this because according to G.I.A.,
95% of lab diamonds entering the market in recent years
fall into a very narrow band of high color and clarity.
So G.I.A. said, why use the scale met for natural diamonds?
So basically, instead of using the full color grade scale, which is from D to Z,
and then FL to I clarity, G.I.A. will now label diamonds as premium versus standard.
So basically, G.I.A. is saying, okay, the quality is going higher,
so we don't need all the extra grading anymore.
So why does this matter? Like, when I saw this, I was definitely in shock because,
you know, people don't like changes all the time.
Changes are scary, especially as a gemologist,
we have been trained to grade a certain way for so long.
So I think this shift pushes people to send only the best to G.I.A.
I feel like it's already that way, but it might make the process a little bit faster.
I don't know if you have noticed, they actually took out the inclusion chart
for even a lot of the diamonds because they're so high in clarity.
They don't see the point of, like, circling every single clarity out.
But the problem that I see here is that this does not actually address the issue
that I always see, which is paper doesn't give you perfect diamonds.
So one of the things I want to point out that's so important is fancy cuts.
So anything besides round, already on the certificate,
you don't get what type of cut grade it is for anything besides round
because there's so many combinations to how a fancy diamond can sparkle.
So changing this doesn't make my grading process easier as a curator
because when I look at the cert, now there's even less information to look at.
So it just further makes my point of, like,
the paper doesn't buy you a perfect diamond even more true
because I've seen paper-perfect lab-grown diamonds all the time.
It doesn't matter if it's IGI, GCAL, or GIA.
It matters more what it looks like when you're looking at it.
And oftentimes people don't understand, like, diamond roughs.
If the rough is poorly manufactured, you actually get tinges in the diamond.
You'll get all types of things that are not listed on the certificate.
So of course I have to listen in to what the internet is buzzing.
So some people are saying,
GIA is oversimplifying things.
What if a standard diamond looks amazing to the eye
but doesn't sound impressive because it's standard, not premium?
I kind of see that point where it's like,
oh, so if you're buying a standard lab diamond, does that mean that it's not good?
Some other people are saying,
well, it just gives competition like IGI or GCAL more room to step in
to grade.
But let's be real, GIA is still the golden standard.
When they move, the industry listens.
And I'm actually seeing a lot of jewelers or people in the industry commenting,
saying that it's actually a really good thing.
Even in GIA's press release, it says,
this change to how GIA describes the quality of laboratory-grown diamonds
will help consumers understand the important differences in the two products' origin,
ensuring their confidence and enabling them to make
informed and educated purchase decisions.
That I do like because I make every single video saying that,
hey, those are all the new products that are available on the market.
Make your own choices and kind of learn.
So I guess this might be a good way to help people understand.
In conclusion, I still think that the report, aka the paper,
does not tell the full story about a diamond.
I've made plenty client story videos before where they come
and they show me this perfect surf where the stone looks horrible.
It's out there. The internet is wild.
And remember, the stone is only such a small part of just the whole ring itself.
What about craftsmanship?
What about everything else that goes into the ring that makes it beautiful?
Remember, a badly crafted ring with a flawless diamond,
it is the worst recipe you can get
because you're gonna end up with a not sparkly ring.
Not because your diamond is not good.
It's because the rest of the setting, the metal, the craftsmanship, all of that.
That is something you need to remember.
Okay, now that I've addressed this buzz, I want to know what you think.
Tell me in the comments.
Do you think GIA is making the right move?
Do you think that standard versus premium is easy for people to understand
instead of like DEF, VVS, VS, SI?
Tell me in the comments below.
Don't forget to follow me on social media,
and I'll see you in my next episode.
Bye!
