Monday, Apr 20 – Hour 3

WBSM 1420 AM
58 followers
1 Video View·Apr 20, 2026
Chris talks about the latest Karen Read news, and a "loophole" in Massachusetts regarding teachers having sexual relationships with students.
Happy Monday morning, boy, it's beautiful out there. Hope you're enjoying it.
508-996-0500, so I can get on the program. A lot of stuff happening in the news. Again,
I want to thank Representative Justin Thurber for coming over and spending the hour with us
here on Patriots Day. And certainly his opponent, if they want to come in for an hour,
I'll give him that as well. We discussed a lot of his work as a representative.
We did touch on his campaign though, so if his opponent wants to come in and talk about his
campaign, I'm certainly welcome to do that. He's got no Republican primary opponent,
but looks like if he gets the signatures, and I think he will, he'll have a Democrat opponent
in November. So I'm certainly willing to offer him some equal time.
The news was full of stuff that I'd love to talk about with you. Do you see that Karen Reid
is being sued? Karen Reid, who was found not guilty, right, of killing her boyfriend,
John O'Keefe, with the automobile, was found innocent of that. But she is being sued,
not just by the family, I believe of O'Keefe, for wrongful death.
And again, it's civil, so the standards of innocent and guilt, or responsibility and
not responsible, are lower than they are in the criminal way of presumed to be innocent.
So you remember we did that with OJ Simpson. OJ Simpson was found innocent,
and then he was found guilty in the civil, responsible in the civil action.
Not that I'm equating Karen Reid with OJ Simpson at all, much different set of circumstances.
But anyway, I see that she and Aiden Kearney, I believe that's how you say his name. I say
his name Turtle Boy. Turtle Boy was a major force in social media all around the world,
but primarily in the United States and certainly here in Massachusetts, New England.
Turtle Boy, he's been named as a defendant in the lawsuit as well.
So those two are different people with different circumstances. I looked into this over the
weekend, spoke to an attorney or two. They broke it down for me, and I'm gonna communicate that to
the best of my ability. If you have something better, I'd certainly like to hear, or worse,
I'd like to hear it regarding the Karen Reid Turtle Boy lawsuit. They're being sued
as individuals by the people whose home the death took place on the front lawn, right?
So O'Keefe, the prosecutor's alleged he was hit by an automobile and left to die
on the front lawn of a McCabe family home. And Karen Reid put on a defense that said
that John O'Keefe was beaten to death in the house and then deposited on the lawn
that she had nothing to do with it. That is how she put her defense on.
Now, the district attorney's office did not pursue any of that, and many of you
have problems with that. Obviously, I wasn't there, most of you weren't there
that night, and all of you likely were not there that night who are listening.
But we don't know, but we can speculate, responsibly speculate, I put that out there.
Now, Karen Reid is entitled to defend herself, and she's indemnified for most of what she says
in the courtroom, or her lawyers say in the courtroom, in pursuit of her defense, okay?
So Karen Reid says, I didn't do it, they did it, okay? That happens a lot with criminal defense
defendants. Criminal defense attorneys make that argument all the time. They may not have the names,
but they say, well, it was this person or that person, parties known and unknown to the grand
jury, right? We hear that all the time. Karen Reid is entitled to put on her defense,
and she's indemnified from court action related to the defense, to the degree that she says it
within the court, within the boundaries of putting on her defense.
Now, where it gets into some level of responsibility is when she says it in public
outside of the court, and tries to state it as fact. Now again, there's going to be a whole
bunch of legal wrangling back and forth. But people who now claim that they were libeled,
slandered by Karen Reid and Turtle Boy are suing her, Aiden Kearney,
known to most of us as Turtle Boy, who's had his own legal problems over and above this lawsuit.
But the difference between Turtle Boy and Karen Reid is Turtle Boy was not charged
in the death of John O'Keefe, so he wasn't putting on a defense.
And as you read this lawsuit, if you read it, or listen to some of the lawyers that are
commentating on it, or if you want to banter about with some of your own friends who are lawyers,
which I think is a very interesting way to spend time, because everybody knows
something about this case. We would fill the phones constantly,
and have Representative Mark Ian, who's now running for district attorney,
the Democrat. We talked about this case for months as it was going on, Aiden Kearney
reporting on the story. There are allegations within the lawsuit to make it worth your reading,
where what the people who are claiming they were maligned, harmed by Turtle Boy and Karen Reid
are alleging a conspiracy. They're alleging that information was funneled from Karen Reid and her
lawyers to Turtle Boy to put out on the Internet to influence the outcome.
That's all laid out. They're alleging that in their complaint. Now, here's the other thing.
The law firm that is doing this complaint on behalf of the McCabe's, Hickey, the former federal,
I guess he's still, I'm not sure if Hickey is a federal agent anymore or not. But anyway,
he's in the lawsuit as well, looking for damages. The law firm that is handling the case on their
behalf is the same law firm that handled the Sandy Hook trial, the Sandy Hook complaint
on behalf of the parents whose children were murdered in that school shooting.
That Alex Jones said that it was all a fake thing. Remember that case where Alex Jones,
who's an international broadcaster, alleged that there wasn't a school shooting,
that it was a hoax and all of that. They sued and the law firm that represented the
parents against Alex Jones is the law firm out of Connecticut that is representing
Jen McCabe and I think it's Brian Hickey, but I'm not sure.
You can read the lawsuit yourself. It's all available online. So that is interesting
that you have a very successful, remember they got $1.2 billion judgment against Alex Jones.
So these are serious players involved. But I would imagine that Karen Reed and Turtle Boy
who have significant resources, I believe. One of the allegations, or I guess it's an
accomplishment really, but within the complaint filed in Barnstable Court is that Turtle Boy was
making $40,000 to $50,000 a month during the period of time he was reporting on Karen Reed
and the trial, $40,000 to $50,000 a month in revenue.
Now, I don't know how they establish those figures and I don't speak for their accuracy
whatsoever, but they'll have to establish that in open court unless this goes to a settlement.
Although if I'm Karen Reed and Turtle Boy, and I'm not sure if they're going to have a joint
defense or if they can sever and do it as individuals. And we'll try to track that down
as it happens. But it's a really interesting development that came in on Friday and really
developed over the weekend. So 508-996-0500. There's that and a whole lot of other stuff to
talk about here on this hour of the program, which is brought to you by the cold beer in the world's
best chicken wings at Rose Alley Alehouse in downtown New Bedford. What a great day to stop by
and sit on the deck and slam down some beers. Stick around, we'll be right back.
Every day you can make money talk. This is your chance to win $1,000.
1-9-4. 1-9-4. Enter it right now at WBSM.com or on the WBSM app for your chance to win cash on WBSM.
This portion of programming on WBSM is brought to you by Dee's Hot Dogs in New Bedford,
where you can get two hot dogs, chips and a soda for just six bucks.
Back to Chris McCarthy and South Coast now on WBSM. Call 508-996-0500.
The tree of life, I just picked me a plum.
You came along and everything started into hum.
Still, it's a real good bet the best is yet to come.
Best is yet to come and babe, won't that be fine?
Welcome back to the program. I'm Chris McCarthy and that's a little Frank Sinatra. I don't know
how many of you read the Boston Globe. I do, so you don't have to. There was an interesting
article here from over the weekend on Saturday, Yvonne Abram. Yvonne Abram,
the headline of the article is time to close the loophole. What's that loophole? Well,
that loophole is the fact that it is not against the law in Massachusetts for a teacher
to have sex with a 16-year-old student, okay? Think about that for a second.
Not everybody go out and sign up for teacher's college now because I think they're going to
close that loophole. But what I'm saying is that you can be a 54-year-old math teacher and quite
handsome even though you have kidney problems. And you can strike up an affair with a 16-year-old
girl and have sex with her, carry on a relationship with her. And obviously when we're
dealing with this in other districts, you could have a female teacher in her 40s as an example,
or her 20s having sex with a 16-year-old boy or I guess a girl, right?
Even though they're a student in the classroom, that is not against the law.
They're trying to close the loophole. And as the columnist at the Boston Globe, Yvonne Abrams,
talks about, close the loophole. There's a guy, he wasn't held responsible criminally.
He was having sex with students. He started grooming them, they believe,
when they were 13, 14, 15 years old. But as soon as they hit the age of 16, he was ready to go.
And so were they. And he started having sex with them.
Me, I never realized, I always thought it was 18. I never realized the age of consent was 16.
And I just never knew. It was never really a top priority of mine.
I was trying to get together with older girls, not younger girls.
But today, your 16-year-old son or 15-year-old son could be being groomed by a teacher,
male teacher or a female teacher, cuz that's obviously possible as well, perhaps likely.
There's nothing you can do about it. And at 16, that's the age of consent. The teacher
can start giving them presents and taking them to dinner and have sex with them.
And I gotta tell you something, I think it's wrong. I think the legislature
should do something about it. There's been a bill brought in front of them. But no surprise,
the supermajority Democrats don't act on it and they vote it down when they do.
Allowing teachers, members of the Mass Teachers Union as an example, to have sex with your child
at the age of 16. While they're grading their papers, while they're influencing their future,
whether they can get into a good college or not with a grade. In other words, there's real
power dynamics between a public school teacher and a private school teacher.
This applies to private schools as well, okay? Your kid could be at New Bedford Vogue as an
example, Bishop Stang, Tabor Academy. And you got some teacher there who takes a liking to them
and wants to have sex with them. And they're around them all day long, right? Deciding
whether they do this assignment or that assignment, and whether they stay after school.
And write them a hall pass to the bathroom, and give them extra credit here and extra credit
there. There's a lot of power that a school teacher has. Now, most school teachers, in my
experience, sadly, this never happened. This never happened to me, right? Sadly, I just was
too well parented, or maybe sadly, I'll admit, not attractive enough to Lauren, a teacher.
But I didn't even think it was an option. I didn't realize. So is this more about me wanting
this to be made illegal to justify my own sad existence as a student who didn't have sex with
his teacher? I don't know. I don't know the psychological ramifications of why I support
this law, other than to say, it doesn't seem right to me. It doesn't seem right to me that
some guy now can be teaching math, or history, or God forbid, health.
Think about this. Your daughter's health teacher, as well, you're really not getting this reproductive
unit correct. You're gonna have to stay after school, and I'll give you some extra credit here.
We're gonna do a whole lesson on how to prevent pregnancy, right? We're gonna do a whole lesson
on how to prevent pregnancy. And any mistakes, we'll have to do it again, and again, and again.
This is going on because the supermajority Democrat legislature
will not outlaw it. I think it's outrageous. What do you think? Do you think it should be okay
for teachers to have sex with their students from the ages of 16 on up?
And do you think that you, the taxpayers, aren't liable for this? Cuz I got another thing
coming to you. If you don't think you are, believe me, you are. And in multiple jurisdictions,
multiple school districts, there are lawsuits right now going on over allegations of grooming
children as young as 15 years old, men and women, teachers, other school employees.
Cuz remember, this applies to anybody. Could be a youth leader, could be a coach,
could be a security guard in the school, could be a janitor in the school, right?
Could be a police officer who goes to the school as a resource officer, could be a firefighter.
Look, think of all the people who have titles, badges, control over your child,
and potential to be a sexual predator. And it's totally legal, totally, totally legal,
508-996-0500. I wanna hear some outrage here. Good morning, thanks for holding.
Good morning. I've known in the past, I believe you've had paper from the school department
or school committee come on the program. If you can pull that off again,
I would ask them this question. Why are you not supporting this? Because to me,
it's almost like dealing with the Catholic Church again, except it's in the school system.
Yes. But I would push it. I would ask these school officials, why are you not for this?
Why do you wanna hide this? You really think it's right? Like you said, a 50-year-old,
60-year-old, going after a 16-year-old and you find that appropriate? Come on.
Well, here's the thing, just to back up for a second. This is not at the school committee level.
This is at the state legislative level. No, I understand that. But if you've got somebody
from the teacher's union or something, didn't you used to have somebody from the teacher's
union coming on? We probably, we had candidates endorsed by the teacher's union.
I haven't had the teacher's union. I'm gonna be happy to have people from the teacher's union on.
I just, they just haven't reached out to me. But it's a pretty good idea, right? I'm not sure what
the official position of the mass teacher's union is on this. I'm really not. Well, why don't we
find out? Yeah. Because then if it's something that's opposite of what the Democrats up there
were going to say. It's not, it can't be. That puts the light on the Democrats, not on the
teachers. No, it can't be. Because right now, this is putting the light on the teachers.
Yeah, well, I would say this. If you can find out what the teacher's union, I'd appreciate it.
Because I'm sure they've taken a public position on this somewhere else in the media. And thanks
to the call, I do appreciate it. If you can do that, that would be great. Because at this level,
it is at the legislative level. So it's House and Senate on this bill.
To close the loophole that allows for an older person to have sex. Because again,
most people, when they have their first sexual experience, they remember it. They do.
They remember it. And it could be good, bad, or otherwise. But you talk to any psychologists,
it's a very meaningful experience. Think about yourself. It's a very meaningful experience.
So if you're imagining, as many people do, that they're going to be with this person forever.
I was speaking with a lawyer over the weekend. We were discussing this case specifically. Well,
this matter specifically, not a case. But in addition to being a lawyer, he's also a parent.
His children are adult now, but they were once adolescents. And he's got a mixed bag. He's got
a daughter and sons. So I think you're gonna be with somebody forever. But most of us have
found out that's not really the case. And we might not have cared at the time anyway.
But for a lot of people, it is a meaningful experience. And particularly if it's an older
person. And then you find out and you get really hurt. And it could be a really rough experience.
And again, particularly if later on down the road, you have to come to realize
that you were manipulated into doing it because you had other desires.
As a youth, you were young and you were 15. In this article, which again, I encourage all of
you to read, called Time to Close the Loophole by Yvonne Abram in the Boston Globe. She names
two women and the teacher they had and how he seduced them. But he did it for many more than
just the two in this. There are about five or six that have come forward with similar patterns.
Cuz let's face it, if it works, if it ain't broke, don't fix it, right?
This guy was at a private school up on the North Shore. And he was grooming girls year after year
and getting them. So it's up to the legislature if they wanna make it illegal.
And I really think they ought to. The power dynamics are outrageous.
508-996-0500, that's how you can get on the air. We got this and many more things to talk about.
We'll take a break and then we'll be right back. Stick around.
You talk with us every day and now you can win cash with us every day. We're making the money
talk with your chance to win $1,000 every day. Listen, weekdays from 8 until 5. In each hour,
you'll hear a code to enter in the WBSM app. The more you enter, the better chance you have
at hearing that money talk and winning 1,000 bucks. Then this Thursday is $1,000 Thursday,
where we will up the prize to 5 grand. Download the WBSM app for the rules and details.
And to win with money talks, money talks on WBSM is brought to you by Whaler Inn and Suites,
Ryan's Sports Pub and Billiards. What a great place. Morgan's Cantina, another great place.
And MJ's Pet Training Academy. Don't go anywhere else, go to MJ's Pet Training Academy.
So I guess you people are all right with the pervert loophole. Maybe it's a bonus to become
a teacher. Not only can you make up to 100 grand, you can also have sex with 16-year-olds.
So maybe that's the reason they're not doing it because I know there is a shortage in teachers.
And maybe they go, well, if we put any more strictures on these people,
maybe they won't join. So maybe the pervert loophole is part of the recruiting.
I don't think it is, but could be it is, could be it is. All right, so on the record,
Channel 5, on the record, they do it on Sunday. They had a really interesting guest today,
or yesterday rather. Gentleman from the Gambling Commission,
right, the Gambling Commission, talking about problem gambling.
Got me thinking, do you realize we have a Bristol County casino now?
Up and running, it's small, but the Native Americans, the Wampanoags,
the tribe from Mashpee, North Aquinnah, the Mashpee tribe, it's opened a casino in Taunton.
There's a casino in Taunton. I know some of my friends go there. Some of my other friends that
go there, tell me about the other friends that they see there. Right at the end of 140,
it's not the end, but the middle of 140, the real highway part, right?
The highway part, right before 24. There's a casino there now.
So I wonder what you thought of that. Anyway, we're also taking your calls on anything else
that matters. Good morning, thanks for holding.
Good morning, Chris.
Good morning.
Who named it the pervert loophole? Are you gonna give attribution?
Oh, hey, this is Senator Mark Montigny. He's the guy who named it the pervert
loophole. So your phone's blocked, I couldn't tell who it was.
Well, of course, I don't want you having my number.
Actually, yeah, I'm glad you're bringing this one up. As you know, I hesitate usually to call in
just because I think it should be for the callers. And I get to come on or come over there and knock
on your window or trouble you when there's something we wanna bring out. But on this one,
I wanted to because this is something that if people are as outraged as you are and I am,
the loophole can be closed. But I don't think it's fair to blame it on one or the other,
although you can always blame it on leadership.
Because there's many of us, both Democrat and Republican, who are infuriated by this. I filed
a bill to close the loophole a long time ago. Like much of what happens in Washington and
on Beacon Hill, it's two things that kill good bills. One, special interest influence, and that's
on all sides. And it's really horrible. If I were writing a book, it would be a short one about
everything wrong with the system. But that's not limited to one party or the other. It's the
lobbyists and the special interests who ply their trade.
Second reason, which I think is more likely in this case, is simply inertia. People are not
outraged enough. There's 6,000 to 7,000 bills filed a year. And as Representative Serber said
earlier, you don't want most of them to pass. There's a lot of funny quips and sayings about
when the legislature is in session, watch out, right? Well, you certainly don't want
some of the silliness that gets filed to become law.
But sadly, things like this where there's no excuse, and a reporter once asked me why I was
having so much trouble passing anti-human trafficking language, which as you know,
I was the first and most persistent in the country probably on the issue.
There's no lobby against it. People don't care enough. They're not outraged enough.
And we have a very, very tragic local case here. So it's past due. I can say this unequivocally
since you mentioned Democrats. I will vote for it in any form filed by anyone. I don't
care who it infuriates in leadership. I don't care if it's filed as part of the budget by
a Republican. I'll vote for it every chance I get. But the truth is, it's shows like yours,
articles like Yvonne that need to just get people involved to call
their rep or senator to push leadership to do it.
Because there is no one, I believe there's no effective lobby against it as much as it
just is sitting there like so much and inertia gets in the way.
We're speaking with Senator Mark Montigny. So what you're saying, Senator, and I know this is true.
People, when they call offices of legislators or send emails, which seem to be the more
reasonable way to do it, send an email to your legislator. You guys do listen and you guys do
take action. Of course. I mean, those of us that don't listen are gone, right? I mean,
I listen to your show. I take phone calls and emails. I mean, look, I was at an event this
weekend with the Cape Verdean community for Chubby Tavares. And I think I knew every person
in the room. If you're out there in your community, you know and you listen, don't
always agree. I get taken on publicly and privately. And I say, guys, sorry, not with you
on that. But if you don't think I'm doing enough, well, you know, you know what you can do, right?
You can you can write someone in, vote for an opponent. But for the most part,
most people are reasonable and know that there'll be a fight the next day. But the number one thing
they can do is communicate that through shows like yours, through emails, through direct personal
contact. That's how we get this stuff, although some of it we should just get on our own.
When you describe this loophole and what has happened in our own community and across the
state, everyone should be outraged. I don't need to hear from anyone on it,
because I completely agree. It's got to be closed.
Do you have any idea, Senator, where that bill is?
Well, here's the thing. Joan Lovely, who's one of my dear friends in the Senate and has
really talked about her personal experience with sexual abuse when she was younger. She's been
very, very effective bringing the issue up. I've also filed a bill. I think we can get it done
this year, I hope, Chris. I mean, I don't like to predict until
the votes are there, but this is not one that would lose if it were on the floor.
Yeah, is that maybe the reason why it's not on the floor?
It's hard to tell, because I don't see any effective lobby that's standing there somehow
defending this. Think about it. You just described it as well or better than I could,
that is the incentive to groom at a very young age. But even if that weren't the case,
no 16-year-old in school should ever be pressured by somebody who's got that
kind of power over them, ever. The person should be gone and criminally charged.
Yeah, no, I agree.
And it's outrageous.
It's totally, totally outrageous. Hey, Senator, anything else you wanna tell the audience?
No, I'll keep you posted on it, though, because we continue to do everything we can in our power.
But I'll keep you posted on it. If I have any news, good or bad, I'll come on and talk to you
about it. Thanks, Senator. Do appreciate your friendship and the fact that you listen to the
show and can chime right in. See, that's what we're looking for. We'll take a break,
and then we'll be right back. Stick around. Welcome back to the program. So, Senator Montigny,
always listening to the program, and I do appreciate that when he chimes in.
He mentioned that we dealt with this locally, and I'm gonna go to a New Bedford Light article
by Anastasia Lennon, really good journalism about an incident out at Greater New Bedford,
Regional Technical Vocational High School. You can see this article in its entirety at
NewBedfordLight.org. Jacob Pothier Family Sues New Bedford VocTech Administrators.
By Anastasia E. Lennon. New Bedford, Jacob Pothier's family is suing the Greater New
Bedford Regional Vocational Technical High School and four district administrators in federal court,
alleging the school violated federal and state laws, including Title IX, a federal law that
protects students from discrimination based on sex, including sexual harassment. The lawsuit,
filed Friday in the U.S. District Court of Massachusetts, comes about 10 months after
Jacob's family filed a letter with the school officials expressing their intent to sue.
The complaint names school superintendent Michael Watson, principal Worley Williams,
human resources director Nancy Markey, and Yolanda Dennis as defendants. Jacob Pothier
had just turned 18 and was a junior at the school when he died in a car crash in January 2024 in
Dartmouth with former school employee Kathleen Martins. Martins, now 45, worked as a security
officer at the high school until March 2023, when she resigned. She was also the other vehicle
occupant, and owner, and only survivor in the single car crash. Martins is also named in the
The family alleges the district and its administrators failed to protect Jacob from an
inappropriate sexual relationship with Martins while she was an employee. The new complaint
alleges Martins sexually groomed Pothier, and that school officials failed to provide a supportive
environment for Jacob when notified of the alleged relationship, instead treating him like a
perpetrator who could get in trouble. One of Jacob's sisters said she learned of the relationship
between Jacob and Martins in December 2022 and alerted principal Williams in January 2023 by
phone, The Light previously reported. That month, Jacob was questioned by administrators about the
allegations, according to emails the family shared with The Light. In early March, Martins resigned.
The district, GNB-Voctech, Watson, Markey, Williams, and or Dennis did not treat and or
regard Jacob as a victim of grooming, sexual harassment, stalking, sexual abuse, and or sexual
violence, and instead, regarded him as a perpetrator who could be criminally punished and also
disciplined by the district and or school, the 55-page complaint reads. The district was
deliberately indifferent and violated Jacob's well-established constitutional rights and treated
The family also alleges Martins would take Jacob out of class while she was an employee,
and that after she resigned, she would enter the school to bring him food. The lawsuit claims 25
counts, including violations of the due process and equal protection clauses of the 14th Amendment,
Title IX protections, the Massachusetts Civil Rights Act, and the Child Abuse Victims Rights
Act. Other claims assert wrongful death and negligent retention, training and supervision
of an employee. Scott Lang, attorney for the Pothier family, only referred to the complaint
in response to a request for comment. Every parent should feel confident when sending their child off
to school, that their child is in a protected, safe academic environment, Stacey Pothier,
Jacob's mother, told The Light on Friday. Any high school student, regardless of their age,
should be protected from sexual abuse and sexual assault by any school staff member,
including security staff.
So you can read more about that article, I have the robot read it to you,
at the newbedfordlight.org. Again, we sometimes disagree with the editorial slant,
but they are doing a great job bringing us the facts from cases that most of us don't have the
time or the budget to cover. So congratulations again, New Bedford Light, you can find that
article by giving the search, they got a pretty good search engine over at newbedfordlight.org.
So again, it's not just about school teachers, this case about a security guard,
could be about a janitor, could be about a coach, could be a youth pastor.
Think of all the different people, adults that are around your children,
when they're 15, 16, 17 years old. And most of them are what I would call normal people.
They don't touch children, or what I consider a child, regardless of the law.
But you only need one, or if you look at the Stoughton Police Department,
the allegations are a couple of them, right? To cause a big problem, cause a big problem.
Well, anyway, listen, I appreciate all of you that participated today. We'll do it again tomorrow,
God willing. Guy Richard is not here today, he'll be back tomorrow, as will I. It's up to
whether you're here, or hope to hear from you next show at 508-996-0500. If you call that number now,
nobody will answer it, because we're going to syndicated broadcasting
to cover Barry's show. But Howie Carr,
