The Iris Nebula (NGC 7023 or Caldwell 4) - Deep Sky Videos

Time Space
7 followers
6 Video Views·Apr 20, 2026
Okay Professor, what have we got today? Where are we going in space?
So I thought we'd have a look at this guy, which is Caldwell 4.
That must be a Hubble image, it's so good.
Nope, that's from my back garden.
You took that?
Last week.
Very nice.
Hot off the press.
Caldwell 4. So I don't know how many times we're going to do this,
but do you want to give me a quick one-sentence summary of the Caldwell catalogue?
Yeah, so a reminder that this is a catalogue that was put together by Patrick Moore.
It's called Caldwell because N was already taken for the Messier catalogue,
so he wants it to be the C catalogue.
So he compiled this list of things which are mostly not Messier objects,
but that are nice to look at in the sky with a relatively small telescope.
They're ordered somewhat unusually from how far north they are down to how far south they are.
So the low numbers are the ones that are very far north,
which is why this is so good for my back garden,
because I can actually see the northern part of the sky really clearly.
My house doesn't get in the way, the trees don't get in the way,
so it's an ideal one for me to look at.
Okay, what is it? It looks kind of cloudy and fuzzy.
It's one of these things called a reflection nebula.
So nebulae come in various different types.
There are absorption nebulae, which are just where light is being absorbed,
and in fact there's a bit of an absorption,
you can probably see there's kind of a dark patch up here where there are fewer stars.
There's actually a lot of absorption around this thing,
so there is an absorption nebula there as well.
There are emission nebulae, which are where the gas has been excited to glow all by itself,
and there are these things called reflection nebulae,
which are just basically reprocessing light.
So you can see there's a bright star in the middle here,
and what you're mostly seeing here is light that's being kind of emitted by that star,
and then scattered back towards us.
Professor, when I think of a nebula,
the first thing I go to is something like the Crab Nebula.
It's kind of the debris from an explosion.
Is that what this is?
Has something exploded and this is the debris,
or is this like stuff that's going to form a star?
Yeah, this is very much more the beginning of the life rather than the end of the life.
So there is a cluster of stars that has formed here,
but there's a load of gas and dust left over,
and so you're seeing the leftover bits and pieces from that process of that forming a cluster,
which maybe one day will form some more stars.
So if there's a bunch of stars in there,
what's kind of lighting things up?
It feels like there's a source in there somewhere.
There is one particularly bright star here.
That's mainly what you're seeing,
is that bright star is doing most of the illuminating there.
What I wanted to talk about, really, about this thing,
I mean, other than saying how pretty it is,
is to talk about why it's blue.
And so I thought I'd talk about why reflection nebulae in general are blue.
It's sort of related to something else which we've never talked about,
which we should have done,
which is why the sky is blue.
Why is the sky blue?
So the sky is blue through a process called Rayleigh scattering.
If you think about it,
where you're seeing the sky,
it's not where the sun is.
So clearly it's not light that's just come straight to us from the sun.
It's light that's come from the sun,
ended up in a bit of the atmosphere,
and then been scattered to us.
And so we see it light up because it's something,
sunlight that's kind of been scattered in our general direction.
And the process of that scattering was first figured out by Lord Rayleigh.
What's really happening is kind of at the molecular level,
you've got some light coming along,
there's a molecule there.
Molecule is a bunch of positive charges with electrons around it.
Light's an electromagnetic wave,
so it means it's got a varying electric field.
As it passes that molecule,
it jiggles the electrons around.
It tugs them backwards and forwards as the light goes past.
So the sort of cloud of electrons in that molecule
will get left and right as the light goes past.
Essentially, that means that that charge is being accelerated
because it's moving first one way, then the other way.
And when charges are accelerated,
that produces electromagnetic radiation.
It's one of the ways you can produce electromagnetic radiation.
So you produce more light.
And so basically the light comes in,
it jiggles the electrons around,
which produces light,
and that light can go off in any direction,
some of it comes back towards us.
So that's the kind of the physics of the scattering process.
The reason why it's blue is because
if you've got high-frequency light coming in,
so bluer light,
that jiggles the electrons backwards and forwards very quickly.
That means they're being accelerated very quickly.
And when you accelerate charge very quickly,
you produce more intense light.
If redder light comes along,
that will also tug it backwards and forwards,
but it does it more slowly, more gently,
and that means it produces less light.
That means that this scattering process
preferentially produces blue light rather than red light,
because blue light is more readily scattered than red light.
Is that Lord Raleigh up there?
He was a president of the Royal Society.
It is indeed, yes.
We're in Ed Copeland's office.
I gave that picture to Ed when he won the Raleigh medal.
Yeah.
And that, yeah, so there we go.
That was not planned.
Anyway.
So that's why the sky is blue.
Yeah.
And it's a very strong effect in that,
you know, blue light is very much more strongly scattered than red light,
which is why the sky,
when there's no clouds around,
does appear a very deep shade of blue.
It's because maybe you're mostly just seeing blue light.
But sunsets being pink and red,
that's a whole other thing.
No, that's actually the same thing.
In that what's happening when the sun's setting
is that there's a lot of atmosphere between you and the sun,
and this scattering process is working there.
So which means that the light that was coming in your direction,
some of it gets scattered away.
And because this scattering process works more effectively
on blue light than red light,
more of the blue light's being scattered away,
which means more of the red light gets through to you unaffected.
So here's the story.
What I've just told you about works in the limit where
the thing that's doing the scattering is very small
compared to the wavelength of the light.
And that's what Rayleigh was able to figure out,
you know, in the late 19th century,
he did the mathematics to figure out what happens in that limit.
In the case of an object like Cold War 4 here,
the thing that's doing the scattering is this stuff
that astronomers refer to as dust,
which is little grains of material,
carbon and other sooty material and all sorts of bits and pieces.
And they're comparable in size to the wavelength of light.
And that really complicates the physics of what's going on.
And you can kind of understand it.
And if you think about it,
remember what I told you before is that,
well, what's going on is that the electrons are being tugged
backwards and forwards as the light passes.
If you've got a larger grain
comparable to the wavelength of the light,
that means that as the waves passing, you know,
some of the bits of it are being tugged one way
and some are being tugged another way,
just because they're in different bits of that wave.
It's not the sum of all the tugs and the different...
Right, but they're doing it in a kind of a coherent fashion
in that, you know, some bits are being tugged one way
and exactly one wavelength away,
other bits are being tugged the other way.
And so, you know, it's just kind of a more complicated story
is what's going on.
That was first figured out by a guy called Gustav Mee,
German physicist at the beginning of the 20th century.
So the maths were more complicated,
so it took a little bit longer to figure it out.
This more kind of general thing where the object's bigger
is a thing called Mee scattering.
The most important aspect of this
is that you get the strongest scattering
when the wavelength is kind of comparable
to the size of the object.
So that means that, you know,
if you've got lots of very big grains,
then you'll end up scattering red light effectively
because there the wavelength is longer
to match up to the size of it.
If you've got lots of very little grains,
then blue light scatters more effectively.
So the reason why this thing appears blue
is because astrophysically almost always
there are more small grains than big grains,
which means you end up seeing the object being blue.
So it is still Rayleigh scattering
because it is the electrons,
excited electrons, giving us the light.
In some sense, Rayleigh scattering
is a special case of Mee scattering,
where it's the limit where you've got
very, very small grains.
Mee scattering deals with much more general things
where you can have the grains big, small, and in between.
But in this case, you know,
the grains really are big enough
that you can't deal with it in that Rayleigh limit,
so you have to do the whole Mee scattering analysis.
Okay, done.
There you go, and why the sky is blue.
But you've got more to say.
I have more, yes.
Yes, I want to talk about,
so let's go back to looking at this image again.
You can see that it's basically blue,
but if you look really carefully,
you can see there are bits of it
that are kind of redder in colour.
And so one of the still,
to an extent, unsolved problems in astrophysics
is what's called extended red emission,
or ERE, it tends to get called.
Well, I've got a theory
based on what you've already told me.
There are patches that have bigger grains.
Which indeed is one of the theories
that people looked at,
and it doesn't seem to work.
But actually, you know,
there's no particular,
I mean, you know,
there's no huge difference
between these different bits.
So the question is,
why would something which starts out blue,
suddenly, you know,
where it's a single feature,
parts of it are blue,
parts of it are red.
So it seems likely
there's some other emission mechanism,
and there are things that will emit red light.
For example, if you've got little grains
of amorphous carbon,
so kind of little chunks of dirt, basically,
they'll emit in the infrared
and all the way through
to the red part of the spectrum
if you excite them just right.
So there are ways that you can do it,
but no one quite knew
what the answer was.
And it turns out
that one of the important clues
to figuring this out
came from studying this object,
Cornwall 4.
So if you look at this region,
just to the kind of lower left
of the centre in my picture here,
they pointed one of the instrument
on the Hubble Space Telescope
towards that little bit.
I think it's a different way up
in this orientation.
And here's the emission
from that gas and dust around it,
which is, I have to say,
absolutely beautiful.
It's kind of that beautiful
wispy, slightly ethereal nature to it.
But you can also see
that there's kind of red edges to here.
And so that's what they were studying.
And what they were interested in
is something that we've already
talked a little bit about,
which is what kind of light
is it that's exciting that emission
in the first place?
What light is it that's coming in
that's then causing that red glow?
And the analysis these guys did,
and I've got that paper here.
Here it is.
It's called
The Excitation of Extended Red Emission,
New Constraints on its Carrier
from Hubble Space Telescope
Observations of NGC 7023.
And NGC 7023 is another name
for Caldwell 4,
which I should also have said
is also called the Iris Nebula,
because it looks a little bit like an iris.
The iris flower, right?
Yeah.
This was the analysis
that these people did,
looking at this emission
to try and figure out
where this extended red emission
was coming from,
what its cause was.
And they used this rather clever method,
which is that they looked at
and they noticed
that it was just this edge here.
And they said, well,
I know why you only see an edge there.
It's because whatever the light is
that's causing it
is only penetrating a certain distance
into that cloud.
Different wavelengths of light
will penetrate to different depths.
Generally speaking,
like for example,
far ultraviolet won't get very far in,
whereas the infrared
will get a long way in.
So from the depth it's penetrated to,
we can actually figure out
what kind of light it is
that's causing that emission
in the first place.
And you can see
it's quite a long paper, right?
They went through pages and pages
of analysis to figure it out.
But basically,
they were able to figure out
the wavelength of light that does it.
It's about 100 nanometers,
which is kind of far ultraviolet radiation,
because it's actually restricted
to this very narrow layer,
which tells you that it's
the kind of radiation
that doesn't penetrate very far,
which is what this far
ultraviolet radiation does.
Where's the light come from?
That's come from a star.
Yeah, it's the same star
that's illuminating everything else
is emitting ultraviolet,
far ultraviolet radiation.
It's quite a hot star.
And so that far ultraviolet radiation
is kind of illuminating this layer,
doing something
which is then causing it
to emit red light.
But then you hit a snag,
which is that you can figure out
how much energy is coming in
in that far ultraviolet radiation.
And it's less than the amount of energy
that's coming out in that red light,
which immediately destroys the idea
that it's just, you know,
that radiation being reprocessed
because somehow you're getting
energy for free then, right?
There's actually more light coming out,
more energy coming out
than when it went in
in the first place,
which kind of complicates the story.
So the only way they can figure it out
is, OK, so what's happening
is that far ultraviolet
radiation is coming in
and is creating something
in that thin layer,
which then interacts
with all the rest of the light
that's coming in
and produces the red stuff
that we're seeing.
And there is a candidate
which they suggest,
which is there are these things
called PAHs,
polycyclic aromatic hydrocarbons.
They're basically molecules
that are made up
of multiple rings of carbon.
You have to talk to the chemist
if you want to know
more about them, I'm afraid.
But basically they have these kind
of multiple benzene rings
linked together
to produce these largest molecules.
We know they exist in space
because we can see
their emission lines and things.
So they've been detected in space.
If you take one of those
and bombard it with this
far ultraviolet radiation,
you can ionize it.
You can rip off
some of its electrons.
And it turns out
that the key thing here
is that there's enough energy
in those far ultraviolet photons
to rip off two electrons.
So you take one of these PAHs
and then you rip off two electrons
and then it just sits there
as an ionized PAH
with missing two electrons.
All the rest of the light
coming in then interacts
with these ionized PAHs
and it turns out
that produces red light
more or less exactly as seen here.
So there is at least now
a plausible story,
if a rather long one,
as to what it is that's producing
this extended red emission.
It's due to ionized
polycyclic aromatic hydrocarbon.
So when we look at that huge cloud
around Chordwell 4 as a whole,
you kind of think of it
as all being the same gas,
but it's not.
There are some patches
that are rich in some material
and there are other ones
that are rich in another material
and different patches
have different personalities.
To an extent,
although there are probably PAHs
all the way through here,
it's just remember
that far ultraviolet radiation
can only ionize the ones
that are very close to the edge.
So there we go.
That's the story.
Nice.
It was coming in from the south,
crossing the plane of the ecliptic,
going over the top
as it rounded the corner near the sun
and then plunging back down again.
