The Law Academy is a project designed to provide legal education for students studying law in the UK. Subscribe for more content.
UK Constitutional Law refers to the body of law and principles that govern the structure, functioning, and organization of the United Kingdom's political system and government. Unlike some countries with written constitutions, the UK's constitution is not found in a single written document but rather is a combination of various sources, including statutes, conventions, common law, and historical documents.
A. Bradley, K. Ewing & C.J.S. Knight, Constitutional & Administrative Law (18th edn, Pearson, 2022). R. Masterman & C. Murray, Constitutional & Administrative Law (Cambridge University Press, 2022).
Disclaimer:
At no point are these video lessons intended to provide any sort of legal advice. These are for educational purposes only!
Image(s) Copyright: This Photo by Unknown Author is licensed under CC BY-SA
So in the previous couple of lessons we've been talking about the principles of the UK
constitution. We've explored the idea of the rule of law, we've talked about the concept of the
separation of powers, and we've been spending a lot of time talking about the concept of
parliamentary sovereignty. Now the principle of parliamentary sovereignty is arguably one of,
if not the most important, of the basic principles of the UK constitution.
Now constitutional scholars will maybe disagree with me in that regard, some may say that the
rule of law is more important, others may say that the idea of the constitutional monarchy is
more important, but I would I would wager that arguably the most important principle of the UK
constitution is this idea of implied repeal, sorry this idea of parliamentary sovereignty.
And we've been talking a little bit for the last two or three lessons about the
doctrine of parliamentary sovereignty, and this lesson is going to talk about one of
the contingent elements of parliamentary sovereignty, which is this idea called
implied repeal, as I've been constantly trying to stop saying at the start of this lesson.
So we're going to explore some of the underlying principles relating to the principle of
parliamentary sovereignty, almost described as almost subsidiary elements of the principle of
sovereignty. We'll spend most of our time examining the doctrine of implied repeal of
legislation. What does the doctrine of implied repeal actually tell us about the
nature of sovereignty of parliament? Well it is one of the most important elements of the doctrine
of sovereignty that parliament today will not be able to bind successive parliaments in the future.
This suggests that the concept of parliamentary sovereignty is one which is temporal in nature,
the idea being that future parliaments cannot be limited and restricted by parliaments of the past,
and this suggests that therefore, because of this, there would be a limitation on
parliamentary sovereignty of future parliaments if this would be allowed.
And one of the ideas that is representative of this is this idea of implied repeal.
The idea that parliament cannot bind successive parliaments in the future
means that parliament cannot pass a single piece of legislation which would subject future
parliaments against their will to it. It suggests that any future parliament can repeal and replace
any of the parliamentary legislation that is passed in this parliament or parliaments before,
and this is one of the interesting elements of parliamentary sovereignty. It doesn't suggest
therefore that you can't pass legislation which may have some kind of political binding authority.
Some argue that things like the Human Rights Act is relatively strong and stable in its ability to
bind politically future parliaments because of the fact that it is so foundational and
constitutional in nature that it suggests therefore that it would be very politically
disadvantageous to try and abolish the Human Rights Act. But the idea here is we're not
talking necessarily about the political elements of parliamentary sovereignty,
we're talking about the legal. And in the context of the legal elements there is no
mechanism which is limiting the ability for parliament to repeal and replace the Human
Rights Act. Now parliament has the ability to expressly repeal whichever piece of legislation
it so chooses. If parliament passes a piece of legislation in the future that suggests
the repeal of previous legislation that is perfectly within the remit of parliament to do
so and perfectly within the remit of parliamentary sovereignty to do so. For example if parliament
was to pass legislation that expressly repealed the House of Lords Act or repealed the Companies
Act for example, it could do so and those pieces of legislation would be no longer binding.
What about this idea of impliedly repealing something, using implied repeal? Well the idea
of implied repeal is that where you essentially take a future piece of legislation and you
have that legislation contradict previous legislation, the doctrine of implied repeal
tells us that owing to the idea that parliament doesn't bind successive parliaments, the future
legislation has impliedly taken away and impliedly repealed the earlier piece of legislation.
That is what implied repeal tells us. So where there are two pieces of legislation which seem
to contradict each other in some way, the traditional view is that the more recent
legislation will have been impliedly repealed and the legislation that existed previously
will no longer be in effect and it would have been replaced by the new future
and more up-to-date piece of legislation. So as such the previous legislation cannot protect itself
from being repealed in the future. If you have a contradiction between two pieces of legislation
it is always the most up-to-date and most recent legislation that is going to take precedent.
The reason for this is of course the fact that parliament cannot bind future parliaments and if
you had two pieces of legislation, one that was being passed today and one which had been passed
20 years ago, and you had a situation where the earlier legislation was the one that took precedent
then that would imply that the previous parliament that existed 20 years ago could bind the the wills
and the wishes of the future parliament that is passing legislation today, which is of course not
allowed. And one example of how this has been illustrated in the case law is in the case of
Vauxhall Estates Ltd versus the Liverpool Corporation from 1932. The compulsory purchase
of housing took effect as a result of a piece of parliamentary statute. Where there was the
compulsory purchase of housing there was the ability for the previous owners of that purchased
housing to gain some form of compensation as a kind of remedy for the compulsory
purchase of said house. Now there were two pieces of legislation both of which outlined the
regulation of this compensation scheme. The first of which was the Acquisition of Land Act from 1919
and this used an open marker method of compensation. You don't need to know necessarily what this
actually entails but you should just know that these are two different pieces of legislation
which regulates the concept of compensatory remedies for the compulsory purchase of housing
in different ways. The second piece of legislation was the Housing Act from 1925 and this used a value
assessment on the basis of the quote land as a site cleared of buildings. Both different
ways in which you can calculate and essentially conceptualize the concept of
compensation and both pieces of legislation that essentially provided regulation of compensation
over the same area of industry and of the compulsory purchase of housing.
So you would think okay well what happens here is there is a contradiction between the two pieces
of legislation. The previous legislation too also sought to protect itself from reform by providing
that in section 7 subsection 1 if there was a legislation which was inconsistent with the Act
it would have no effect. So not only is there two pieces of legislation both regulating the
same area of law but are contradictory against each other but the earlier piece of legislation
attempted to try and protect itself from reform by suggesting that anything that contradicts
the Acquisition of Land Act from 1919 will have no effect. So if we were to apply this piece of
legislation, if we were to apply section 7 subsection 1 of the Acquisition of Land Act
it would mean that the 1925 Housing Act would have no effect owing to the fact that section
7 subsection 1 meant that it would render any future legislation void if it was inconsistent
with the Acquisition of Land Act. The issues here are very easy to see. The question was for the
court a whether or not the 1919 Act can have this prospective binding effect i.e. whether or not
subsection 1 of section 7 was actually legal and then secondly the question of okay well if that
is the case or if that is not the case what is the piece of legislation which should take effect
which of the two should take effect. Now you should know already the answer to both of these
questions if you have been listening to my conversation about implied repeal. Ultimately
it was held that the Housing Act of 1925 had impliedly repealed the Acquisition of Land Act
from 1919 specifically the provisions related to compensation and this was the case owing to the
contradiction between the two pieces of legislation. As such the more recent piece of legislation took
effect and section 7 subsection 1 was null and void owing to the fact that it would be a violation
of parliamentary sovereignty. The final thing I want to talk about in relation to implied repeal
is this idea of how this operates in relation to the law of the European Union because of course
even though we are no longer members of the European Union the concept of EU law was very
much a substantial element of the UK's constitutional framework going back to the 1970s when we joined.
According to section 2 subsection 4 of the European Communities Act 1973 it says that
the provision that may be clear sorry that may be made under subsection 2 above includes
subject to schedule 2 of this act any such provision as might be made by act of parliament
and any enactment passed or to be passed other than one contained in this part of this act
shall be construed and have effects subject to the foregoing provisions in this section.
Essentially what this provision is telling us is that while the UK was a member of the European
Union the concept of implied repeal seemed not to apply to the application and implementation of EU
law. We'll get to the concept of EU law in the future as a challenge to the traditional view
of parliamentary sovereignty but for now keep in mind the idea that there are elements of
the UK's constitutional framework which did and still to this day does
present something of a challenge to the concept of this traditional view of sovereignty.