Building THE PERFECT Compost Bin For My Garden!

FFG - Food Forest Garden
176 followers
12 Video Views·Apr 19, 2026
For years now I've wanted my very own compost bin and my last trip to Maine gave me the inspiration to finally make it happen. In this video I go over how and why I built my bin the way I did and how to build your first compost pile.
Welcome back to Jacques in the Garden. Today we are working on a long-awaited project,
one that I've been wanting to get done for quite some time now. Actually,
ever since I was in Maine working on this Home Depot project out there,
I built a two-bay compost system that had a really nice design. It looked super clean,
was really easy to use, and quite frankly, it made me feel bad about my setup here in San Diego.
So I've been thinking about dreaming up the way to build an even better system for myself here,
one that fits my needs. It's going to be a little bit different than what you see out there
because I decided to get really weird and particular about it, and we'll get more
into that later. But first let me tell you what has happened thus far, because currently I only
have one compost bin, but up until just yesterday I had two bins in this exact spot. So right now
I'm crouched exactly where my old bin used to be, the second one, and you could basically see that
this wood is entirely rotted. There's almost no structural integrity left to it. It's been
either consumed by termites or the microbes that are actively eating this pile up. But what's
interesting is that this dimensional lumber, just regular stuff that you could pick up at Home Depot,
is entirely fine. It actually still feels hefty, and that's a little bit surprising to me. I
thought that regular dimensional lumber would not hold up very long in the compost setup,
but it turns out it's absolutely fine. So this new bin is also going to be made out of just regular
old dimensional lumber that I got at Home Depot, and that's going to make life a lot easier because
it's standard, it's easy to find, and I don't have to do any guesswork or look for any sort
of exotic woods. Now this original system was a two-bay setup, which I grew to hate. I have been
wanting a three-bay setup for a very long time now, so that is what we're going to be building.
But the first thing I have to do is shovel out all of the remaining compost here and get rid of this
old bin. So we're going to get working on that, and then I'll get deep into the build, show you
exactly what my ideas are, my setup, and how we're going to put it all together. So before we kick
off this project in a major way, I did call Paul to come help out. Yeah dude, you're gonna need a
lot of help for this. There's a lot of building going on. There's a lot of wood. It's quite heavy,
I know, because when I was moving my pile, I even managed to twist my back a little bit yesterday.
So I don't want to push it. I'm gonna have Paul help me out. We also have quite a bit of compost
to move. And before we get too deep, I should mention this video is sponsored by Home Depot
because we want you to go over to the Home Depot YouTube channel and watch this whole series. Paul
and I worked really hard while we were up there. Oh yeah, moved a ton of rock. Oh yeah, ton of
everything. And it was a lot of fun, and the project itself was amazing. We worked with a lot
of really cool other people like Chaya Ming from Coastal Homestead, Aaron the Impatient Gardener,
and Urban Gardening with Gray, aka Gray. We're all up there to make this amazing project come
together. So I'll talk more about that probably a little bit later when we get closer to the compost
bin build. But for now, let's get this old one out of here. So Paul and I just finished moving
all the compost. Oh yeah, it was like almost a yard of compost. Yeah, I think it was actually
more than a yard, which defies my calculations because that last bin was basically like 32 inch
by 32 inch cubes. And that's a little under a yard, and we ended up with like a yard and a half.
Well, you didn't account for all the compost that was against the the fence, right? Yeah,
the bin had a lot of big gaps in it, so a lot of spill out. I'm accounting for that a little bit
in part of the design with some of the complications that I've added to this. Otherwise, it's supposed
to be a very simple build, and you'll see some of it right here. So these are the first boards that
we're going to be working with. This is going to be making up the back wall of the bin. So this
whole bin is going to be 10 feet wide instead of like the standard 9, because most people do
three 3-foot actual bins. Instead, I wanted to go to 10, because A, that's a type of dimensional
lumber you could already get standard, so I don't have to cut it. That's a great start. That makes
sense. And then also, as I sketched out this design, which took me a lot longer than I cared to admit,
because it turns out lumber math, while it's very simple, it's all plus minus of regular numbers
that have pretty easy digits. You have to account for a lot of different things, like where is the
wood going to fit against the other one? This is a two by six board, which in reality means it's
actually one and a half by five and a half, which I'll never understand. I'll never understand that.
Hopefully you guys on the other side of the pond using the metric system don't have nominal
dimensions, but that's a tale for a different day. So what we're going to do here is we're going to
be screwing all these into the back wall itself. So I do need to make a couple cuts. This is a six
foot board. I got 12 foot two by sixes at Home Depot and I asked them to cut them in half because
I realized I could not fit a 12 foot board in my van. I was able to squeak in the 10 foot boards,
barely, but 12, not going to happen. So this is going to be cut into, we're going to get four
36 inch boards. That's going to be the support for the back wall. And we're going to be using
this Ryobi 12 inch miter saw. Now I had this exact saw up in Maine when I built the compost
bin there. And I realized how much I needed a miter saw this whole time. I've been using a
regular circular saw and it gets the job done. Of course it cuts, but it's so much easier to
get straight, repeatable cuts, angles. And also having the stand here is just going to make this
insanely easy because this has the ability to build in stops and we're going to be doing a lot
of repetitive cuts. So let's go ahead and get this cut into 36 inches and we'll get that back
wall built. The beautiful thing about a setup like this, where you have an actual miter saw stand,
because I've used miter saws before, but I've never had the proper stand. And now I understand
the beauty behind it, because what I could do now is I could measure this out, make sure my blade
hits at 36 inches where I want the cut. And then this right here is actually an adjustable stop.
So all I have to do now is pull every single board onto the stand, pull it up to this,
and it's going to measure the 36 inches every time. I don't have to measure. Now I probably
still will because it's the first time I've done it. I just want to make sure in my head that this
is working as I intended. Whenever you're using power tools, especially ones that are quite loud
like a saw, you want to have some safety in place. At a bare minimum, hearing protection. I've got
these little ear foam plugs. I'm going to roll them up, install those. And I'm also going to
be wearing these safety glasses to avoid any sort of stuff from flying into my eye. We've got the
stop set up, 36 inches on the spot. We could get to cutting. Now we've got all the first pieces
ready to install the back. So now I'm going to explain what is going on and why all this layout
looks so weird. First off, I cut some scrap blocks. These are one and a half inch, just like
everything else, because the gap between each board on the back and all the sides is one and
a half inches. That way you get a little bit of airflow into the compost pile without like losing
too much big stuff out of the pile as it's building. The other thing you're going to see
here is this line. Now I had to think about it. I made a couple wrong lines over there because I
realized this is the back. And I'll show you exactly what that means. First off, we want to
make sure that all these boards are indeed in line with each other. And as they are set up right here,
they're perfectly in line. And now the reason why this line is here, this is measured at about
four inches. So that way, if I take this backboard, what's going to happen is I want this
board to line up against all those lines. So when I set it down, I'm looking on the back of the
board here and making sure that each one of these lines is right on the edge of that board. Once I
do that, that looks good all the way down. I could verify that by taking my little speed square here
and right here is the one and a half inch mark. And that's exactly where I'm at.
And it'll make a little bit more sense once this is stood up, but there's going to be four of these
boards on the back to support the whole thing. And then we'll stand it up and start putting in
the members that stick outwards. So now we're going to set up the other side the exact same way.
And then two more of these boards are going to go into the middle section. And that's going to
define the walls of the bin themselves. This is probably the hardest, most annoying part of the
build, which is supporting the very first wall or the wall, the back of the compost bin. So what
we have here is that we're going to match these bottom boards. And at this point, I guess I'll
tell you why I decided to make this so complicated by using two by eights at the bottom of two by
sixes. And that has to do with the fact that the old one was all two by sixes with two inch spacing.
And you saw how much compost was like spilled out of everywhere. And the basic idea, as far as I'm
thinking about it, is as the compost pile gets further down and more mature, it's going to be finer
stuff at the bottom that's more broken down. So I'm hoping that this will just give me a little
less spill out. Honestly, I don't know if that made sense, but we did it. So here we are. The other
reason I will say is that I couldn't get the math to perfectly work out to be like at three feet high
with the two by sixes without having gaps I didn't like. So that's another cop-out excuse there. But
honestly, whatever I thought at the moment, I'm sure it made sense to me at least. So we'll screw
this in. All right. So that one's in. I'm going to go do the other one and then we might move it
into place and screw in the rest over there. Yeah. One of the harsh realities of my yard is that
there's not a single level surface here. So even though that wood is squared up against that wood,
the ground isn't level. But once all this weight is in and it's all set in place,
it'll settle in just fine. A hundred percent. So now that the sidewalls are on, the back wall is
done, this front board is left uncut. And the reason for that is that it keeps the entire
system rigid because these boards here are going to slot in. They're going to be removable, but
we want the bottom board to actually keep this whole structure in place. Otherwise, it's just
going to blow out. Yeah. So the only downside of this design of having the two by eight on the
bottom is that now I do have to have a little bit harder time actually getting the last bits of
compost out. And will I regret the decision? If I do, all I have to do is replace this and a lot
of stuff. So we'll see. But for now, this is what we're doing. And I'm not unhappy with it. I think
I always overthink everything that I build. And this is no exception. So this build is really
starting to come together and it feels like it's actually going to work. Now, I do want to mention
that if you want to see me and Paul build a compost bin that's much more straightforward,
this was inspired off of that design. But that one was a nice two-base system without any of
those different woods and choices that I've made here that I'm now regretting. So that one is on
the Home Depot channel when we did the From Scratch series. We did eight episodes together, partnered
with Home Depot. We flew up to Maine, me, Paul, Chia-Ming, Aaron, and Gray, and also Kevin, of
course. And we built out an entirely new space, new garden beds, an outdoor kitchen, including a
greenhouse refresh, and all sorts of everything in between that is required to sustain a place
like that, including a compost bin. So that is actually episode three, if I'm not mistaken.
And right now, almost all of the episodes are out. So head over to the Home Depot YouTube channel,
check it out. Thanks to Home Depot for sponsoring this video as well and helping me get a compost
bin at my place. And Ryobi and their fantastic tools. I gotta say that miter saw with the actual
stand and the stop guards to make repeatable cuts was a game changer. And the actual impact driver
and the drill so far are working fantastically. And of course, we use the exact same things in Maine
and they held up through all the different crazy stuff that we did to them. So thanks to Home Depot.
Please check out this series. It was really fun. It was something new that we haven't done before,
partnering with a bigger group like Home Depot. And the whole thing came together really, really,
really amazingly, I have to say. And the people that we worked with were incredible. I think you
guys will really enjoy it. So thank you. And now let's get the rest of this thing done. And we're
almost there. Let's do it. Put these in here. The compost bin is officially built. Mostly done,
right? Yeah. I mean, like the actual structure and everything that needs to be done is done.
The only thing I'm missing is I have to cut a couple more of these boards. My math wasn't right.
And then I just have to cut a couple more. But here's how it works. You basically slide it in
just like that, like butter. And as you're building your pile up, it just keeps getting taller and
taller. And then when you need to move it, you just remove the boards and you're able to scoop
it out. But the thing I like about this is it's like really, really stiff. And there's a lot of
weight that goes into a compost bin, as we know, since we moved the last pile. And this looks
really clean. Thank you for your help today, because this honestly, I definitely wouldn't
have finished or got to this stage. Yeah, I don't think so, man. Not at all. Especially
with how heavy this is, the superstructure itself. So tomorrow morning, I'll come back through and
I'll add in the last bits of the compost we moved. And I'll show you guys how to start your new pile
so it's off to a great start. But that's it for today. The sun is on its way to setting,
but it was a very productive day. It was. So thanks for your help. Of course, man. So now
let's talk about how to build a compost pile from scratch the first time. And at this point,
hopefully you will have accumulated some greens. In this case, we've been holding off on the compost
since I've been moving it and getting ready for a new one. I have an entire bowl here of leftovers
and trimmings from the kitchen. That's one of them. I also have my compost bin, which has plenty
of stuff in it. And this is a bucket of compost we generated throughout the week as we were waiting
to add to this. So all of this is basically greens. Now on this side, I did mix in a little
bit of browns just to stop it from getting too funky because this is about a week old at this
point. And then I also have some green branches. Those were trimmed from over here that were just
in the way of the compost bin project. Greens are anything that is alive or anything that is fresh,
essentially. So if you're looking at like a green onion that's rotting in your fridge,
that is a green because it's still not dry. Leftovers like old brown rice, that might be
on the edge of green and brown, but anything alive from the garden, any sort of trimmings,
tomato leaves, branches, all of that is green waste and that will contribute to the heat of
your pile. Now the greens have nitrogen in them and they also have a lot of moisture and the
bacteria that eats it, the microbes, will generate a lot of heat in the process. But in order to
break down that material, they actually need carbon. This does not have enough carbon. It has
a higher nitrogen to carbon ratio. That's basically the thing that dictates whether
something is a brown or green and how hot it gets. Whereas anything that's a brown like these chipped
up wood branches here, those will be higher in carbon than any of the green stuff that we're
adding to this pile. So we basically don't worry about it. None of it actually really matters. The
only thing that really matters is that you're balancing some amount of browns with your greens.
And the best way to know that is basically, is your compost pile stinky? If it's stinky, it's
probably too wet and doesn't have enough browns. Just add some more and mix it and you'll probably
be fine. Now I do also want to talk about sources of browns because I know that this could be tricky
for people like me who live in an urban area that's kind of a desert. There's not that much
sort of free biomass around. So what I have here is chipped up mulberry branches. These are from
my tree that I ran through a tripper. And the reason why this is so good is that these are all
these tender young branches. You can see one of the branches right here. It's a very small diameter
branch. This is what's called rameol wood. Now younger branches have a much higher carbon, uh,
or sorry, have a much higher nitrogen ratio than regular wood. So this is closer to a green. It's
not a green, but it'll break down pretty quickly in the pile. So this will serve as a good brown.
Another fantastic source of brown is just fallen leaves or any sort of dried plant matter. So I
collected this from the bushes over in my driveway. It's just a bunch of leaf litter,
little branches that are broken through time, entirely bone dry, fantastic source of browns.
And then over here I have some straw, another really fast sort of decomposing brown. Um,
but essentially in the end you want as much diversity as possible and you also want some
level of chunkiness. The bigger chunks like this wood here will allow air to penetrate your pile
better and will just lead to a better process throughout the time. So I'll give you a little
on that in a second, but I also want to share another free brown resource and this is a coffee.
This is from my local coffee roaster. What this is is coffee chaff. So this is the material that
comes off the coffee beans when they roast it. And it's a really fluffy light colored.
It has a coffee smell to it, but this is entirely a brown. It is very fine and it tends to clump,
but this is a great source of browns that you could oftentimes just get for free from your
at mine. They just leave it in bags out on the driveway and I just go by and grab it whenever
I want. So now we've covered some browns, we've covered some greens. Let's go ahead and get some
of this into this pile. And the other ingredient I wanted to mention that's a great way to especially
kickstart a pile is dirt. Now in this case, my compost bin is directly on soil, so I don't have
to worry about adding any, but if you don't have any soil or dirt near your pile, I would recommend
grabbing some from your garden and sprinkling it on top of your pile because that will introduce
some microbes that will help kickstart the whole process. Now of course I've had compost here for
quite some time, so I'm sure I have plenty of microbes already available. The first thing I'm
going to add is my old bucket of compost waste and some browns that I already mixed in. It's
already broken down a decent amount. Then we'll go ahead and add this compost pail, some leeks,
some kale stems. And then we got this here, some more greens from the kitchen. I got some banana
peels, some old grapes from the back of the fridge, a rotten onion, and some orange peels, which I am
totally fine with throwing in the compost. Some people are weird about it. I don't know why. In
my case, I feel like they break down just fine. Now as for these branches here, they're nice, fresh,
and green, but you don't want to put it in whole. With compost, it's all about surface area. So
at the very least, I'm not going to go crazy on this because it's going to take too long,
but I want to at least break this down into some smaller chunks. That way it'll help it
break down a little bit faster. So now at this point, we have our greens in there and what I want
to do here is I'll just go ahead and kick it since I have my foot here, but a fork would be an
ideal situation. We're going to spread it out to get more surface area. We want the browns to cover
as much as possible here. So now we have our base layer of sort of decomposing waste. Now we could
go ahead and add some browns. So here's some of that leaf litter I collected. And actually another
thing that I forgot to mention is that at the bottom of your pile, one of the best things you
could do is just add some old sticks. You want to make sure this is all dried up so it's not going
to actively regrow in your bin. But what this is going to do is it's going to provide some chunkiness
and it's going to force more air into our pile because now it's not going to be able to settle
as much. It's going to have to deal with these sticks in the way. That's another reason why I
wanted to mention chunkiness and why it's so important. When you have big chunks of material
in your pile, there's just more air. There's more harbor for some of the stuff that likes to break
down your pile and it's always going to be beneficial. So what I like to do is when I sift my
compost to use it in my garden beds, I save all the big chunks and I add that back to my hot pile.
This does two different things. First, this is all full of life already. It's already been
inoculated because it's been in an active pile so it's full of the microbes that will help kick
start this process. The other thing is is that they're all chunks. This will again provide more
aeration and breathing for our pile. So I'm going to just go ahead and add this whole bucket
because at the starting point I'd rather have more browns than green to soak up any of the extra
liquid that might settle out of the pile as it begins to decompose as we build it out. It's been
one week since we put this compost bin in place and over that time period I've been busy. I've
added two new features to this compost bin which I think maybe everyone should have and I'll show
you those in a second. But first, I wanted to just talk about how good this looks. It looks so much
better than what was here before which was just a dilapidated multi-bin system literally thrown
together that was falling apart and spilling its contents everywhere. Now with the full wall of
wood here it really just doesn't look like anything bad at all. It just looks like a little structure
in the back of your garden area. Nothing gross about it and actually one of the future things
that I might add would make it look even better but we'll talk about that in a second. Now in this
one week I have been busy and I already have about a one foot high compost pile and it's already hot.
It's in like the 100 to 120 degree range. You can see some moldy pita breads on top that we just
added in but there's a whole bunch of chopped up garden debris. Now this is stuff like bolted
chard. I have some bolted broccoli here that I'm going to show you how to process in a second but
the other thing I wanted to mention is that I've also now placed some of my browns right next to
my pile to make life super easy and there's also a couple other tools here that I think is going to
change how quickly and easy it is for me to make compost. Now one of the browns that I'm working
with here is a bag full of coffee chaff. This is stuff that you could get for free at your local
coffee roaster. It's a byproduct of roasting your coffee. So what I'm going to do here is just go
ahead and sprinkle some of these browns right onto the pile just to keep the moisture down, keep the
stink down and get this thing activated even further. So now what about when we're adding
stuff to the garden? The most important thing to compost is surface area. The finer something is
cut up before you put it in, the faster it'll break down and turn into rich beautiful compost
and that is where the first new addition to this compost bin comes into play which is the compost
chopping block. I think at this point you guys see the machete and you get the idea of what this is
and I will point out that I actually built one at first using one of the leftover boards. This was
one of the two by eights and I decided I needed something a little bigger so I ran back to Home
Depot and got a short 2x12 here and this is the perfect size chopping board. So now the deal is
whenever I haul something large out of the garden, even a pile of nasturtiums or like a bolted rocket
like this, I could just take it, take my handy machete here. What I could do is really break
down this material quite substantially and now when I move it into the compost pile I just have
to push it and all of it will break down even faster. This should speed up the process and also
just make your pile look better. It's also actually very satisfying and fun to use a gigantic machete
to chop up your plants. There we go. Tons of surface area, a little bit of dirt from the roots, no big
deal and who cares if this board gets chopped up because it is essentially a sacrificial board here.
Now to build this what I did is I got the board to the length of my bin and I put a couple stop
blocks on the ends here. That's to stop it from sliding around. It makes it really easy to move
back and forth like this and honestly I don't know why I never had one of these in the first place.
It is probably the best addition to this compost bin thus far. Now I did want to talk really quickly
about how this compost system is going to work. In here I have the pile that existed in the previous
one and it's still breaking down. Right now it's sitting at just under 100 degrees. Once that drops
down into like the ambient temperature under 80 degrees, all of this is going to be scooped into
the final box where it'll sit to mature and I can basically start using it from that point on.
Once it's cold under 80, if I turn it and it doesn't heat up again, that's effectively finished
composting. It's not mature. Some people like to mature their compost by allowing it to sit for
even longer but at that point it's essentially ready to be used in the garden. Now I won't be
moving this bin over until it is absolutely full. At that point I'll scoop it, move it over, that'll
give it another kick and it should break down quite fast. Now the other feature that I added is
one that's all around the outside of the bin and you might even be able to see some right over here.
So the second new feature that I added to this compost bin is right here. It is a stainless steel
gopher protective mesh that I've wrapped all the way along the outside of my compost bin. Now this
is doing a couple different things for me actually. First and foremost the idea behind it was to not
make this rodent proof because a compost bin that's rodent proof is probably just a fool's
errand. It's really not worth the effort to try to go through it. Eventually they'll find their
way in. Instead I wanted to deter them from licking at my pile in the first place. So this gopher mesh
it's way too small for anything to crawl through but it also still allows airflow because these
slats are here to provide air into the compost pile. They're about an inch and a half. Now obviously
it's not doing that much. It's not like it's injecting oxygen into the center of my pile but
still allowing the outside to breathe and that is something valuable to have. The reason why I put
this mesh on the outside here is for a very simple reason. I always see these compost bin designs that
put all this mesh on the inside or even sometimes remove the wood replace it with mesh to get the
most airflow but that just looked like a nightmare. I thought about the fact that I would shove my fork
in there and constantly get caught on the wire. I'd rip it up. It looked like trash in no time
so I didn't want to do that so I put it on the outside. Now this is doing the second thing for
me which is to stop particles from spilling out of my bin as easily. This mesh is fine enough that
pretty much most things are not going to just randomly fall out the edges like they did in my
old pile which quickly became a mess and also helped rot the exterior faster. Just wasn't a
good system. So this mesh now will block rodents. Slow them down at least. They obviously come in
from above but it also still allows airflow while blocking stuff from constantly spilling out. So
even on the second bin here where I already have a compost pile that's basically broken down,
I added it and I haven't seen much spill out. Of course some things will get through but
it will keep this whole system way tidier. So now I wanted to cover some future ideas of things that
I might add to this compost system. So with the build entirely complete what are the other features
I was considering adding to this bin that just didn't make the list? The first one would be some
sort of lid or roof system for this compost bay and there are a couple reasons to do that. If you
live somewhere really wet and rainy you definitely want some sort of way of covering this or putting
a roof on it because too much water in your compost pile will lead to it becoming an aerobic
which means there's no oxygen. It'll be too wet. It'll smell terrible. It'll be really heavy. You're
not going to have a good time composting if it is soaking wet. So definitely consider a roof or
lid system if you live somewhere quite rainy. But here in San Diego we do have another problem which
is that we have a lot of sun and sunlight is UV rays which is sanitizing and can kill life
and microbes. So even right now on this bay where I have just maturing compost that's still breaking
down what I did is I threw a burlap bag on top of it to protect it from direct UV and that should
stop this from getting like cooked on the surface and killing anything or drying it out too far
too much. Now beyond that there was something else I considered which was a aeration system or some
amount of extra airflow into the center of the pile. People usually do this using perforated
drainage pipe that you could either build out at the bottom of your bins or directly put them
right in the middle to get oxygen straight to the center and that will provide more airflow
which will heat up the pile faster and everything should break down substantially faster. But
decided it was just a little bit too complex. I like this low-tech idea as much as I love pushing
things to the limit. I might add that to the future if it becomes a problem where I just simply am
running out of space and I cannot make my compost fast enough. I just don't think that's going to be
a true reality for me. So it is something I've considered and I might easily be able to add that
in the future but having the chopping block system, the mesh all the way around it, those were
fantastic things that I'm so happy I did. Now the other thing I'd love to hear from you guys is what
part of this system do you like that you wish you had on your compost bin? What do you think I should
add instead? What did I forget to like consider? Anything else about composting? I'd love to hear
you guys with thoughts and I'd also love for you guys to go over to the Home Depot YouTube channel
and watch the From Scratch series. We here at Epic Gardening partnered with them to make this
entirely From Scratch series where we started with basically nothing, built out an entire garden,
outdoor kitchen area, pergolas, refreshed a greenhouse. It was really fun working with a
fantastic group of people including Paul, Urban Gardening with Gray, Gray himself, Chai Ming from
Coastal Homestead and Aaron from the Impatient Garden. We had such a blast doing this whole
project. It was really fun. Most of the episodes should be live now on the Home Depot YouTube
channel. Please go check it out and let us know what you think about this compost bin and I'll
see you guys next time.
