Paid signature gatherers are operating inside homeless encampments in San Francisco to collect ballot petition signatures for California's November 2026 propositions. Video evidence captured on the street shows signers being offered payment and instructed by gatherers to use other people's names and addresses, and the operation was still running the next day at a different location. When something goes wrong at street level, who is actually responsible?
In this episode, we sit down with JJ Smith, the San Francisco videographer who filmed the operation firsthand, James A. Kus, Fresno County Clerk and Registrar of Voters, and Susan Shelley, editorial writer at the Southern California News Group, to examine how the legal market for paid signature gathering creates the economic conditions for this kind of fraud. They break down the per-signature price spike driven by the November ballot deadline and why the subcontractor chain behind commercial signature gathering makes accountability difficult to trace.
00:00 - Intro 00:42 - Ballot Fraud Allegations and Investigation 06:02 - Legal and Ethical Implications 19:35 - Continued Investigations and Findings 23:44 - The Process of Collecting Signatures
There are a number of videos going viral in California showing people allegedly are getting
signatures for ballot propositions and paying Californians for their signature. Today we sit
down with citizen journalist JJ Smith who has actually filmed some of these videos. We also
touch base with some experts in this space to get their take on it. I'm Siamak, welcome to
So JJ you have this video you you shot this video that is showing somebody's getting paid five
dollars to sign on a clipboard that has to do with gathering signatures for propositions. Can you tell
us what you saw? I put the word out on the streets if you see people out there offering five dollars
for signatures or whatever or for blood pressures because they was doing medical scams around here.
I told people to let me know. So one person called me and told me that they're doing it on
six admission. So I went down there to check it out and I knew I was recording because that's
what I do. So first I want to see if the people in line know what they're signing. So I actually
got in line um the uh what's the line for and he explained to me that they're giving five dollars
out to sign a petition. I said a petition so I really wasn't interested in it but after they
are they asking for your information or whatever and he said he didn't know neither because he
ain't made it up there. So I went to the front of the line and I asked the woman hey what is this
for she said um you get five dollars you sign a petition and while she's speaking the girl to
the right of me see I overheard her tell one guy you already did two of them and I think she was
trying to get him to do a third one and then the woman that's in front of me I overheard her
telling the man the person on the left of me sign this name sign this city of Avalos city in this
address in my head start thinking like wait a minute they're not using their own name they're
signing it with somebody else's name and I looked at the document where the other person's name is
and it's like it's an official document who named that that their the things are on. So I said told
myself that's fraud that I asked her again what all do I need she just said you just need five
dollars just to sign it we'll give you five dollars and after that I rolled off. Wow. Lately there has
been a lot of people coming up to the tender line doing fraud like that they also do medicare fraud
out here. Is it that blunt where they have a line of people lining up and just signing these things?
Yes it's that blunt they don't care they do it in broad daylight right in the homeless area they
do it because the people who they're offering five dollars to they're getting in line doing it because
they could take that five dollars and go buy some more drugs. Which one of the ballot propositions
were they trying to to get the petition signed? I really don't understand those which which ballot
it was but it was three of them and one of them was for a better California and one of them was
for a retirement tax thing and I don't remember know what the third one was for. You mentioned
somebody told you that this is happening is this normal do people put the word on the street that
we're collecting signatures here and we're going to give you money? Yes it's a normal thing they've
been doing this for years and I never knew it was illegal to pay somebody to do that and I have
never even stopped at one of those desks before that does the ballots and petition but I always
see them around and every time they they've been doing it for years and every time they come they
offer money for people to sign. So during the previous times that they was doing it I didn't
I don't know if they was telling them to use other people's identity because I never stopped
but I wouldn't put it past them. And how did you decide to go after this this time? Just like any
other video I make I just go go all full in the reason why I decided to really go see because
what they're doing is wrong. It looks like there are some thoughts that this is going to get
investigated have you been contacted by anyone any of the authorities? Yes I've been contacted
by the state of California Secretary of State. And you're going to help them to find to find
out what's happening? Well I don't know about if I'm going to help them I mean I mean I helped
them by making the video but I don't know what more I can do. I didn't even know that it was
illegal when I made the video I just knew something was wasn't right. You've been doing a lot of filming
of San Francisco and you're trying to make a big impact on the city can you tell us why you're
doing that? The reason why I'm doing it because I see a lot of things that they shouldn't be the
it is in San Francisco. There has been billions and billions of dollars put in to solve what's
going on here and it still hasn't nothing been solved. Where's the money going? Where is all
that money going? The governor gave up billions of dollars to solve homelessness and it still exists
and it exists worse when they first gave up the money and it's still continuing they're not
actually helping anyone. Thank you so much for what you're doing for California and San Francisco.
Thank you. Now we go to James Koss who's an expert in the elections in California to see what he
thinks. There are some videos going around in social media that are showing people getting
paid to sign petitions for ballot propositions in California. What are your thoughts on this?
So that would be illegal. So really pretty straightforward. While you can pay to go get
signatures to have an organization out getting signatures pay for signature gatherers you can't
pay a person to actually sign that document and I think some of those videos have even gone so far
to actually have people saying go ahead and sign a different name. All of that is illegal and those
groups those people that are responsible for those petitions the people that are the circulators
that are putting those out there they need to be held responsible for that. How common is this
in this space? Fairly uncommon but right now we're at a very stressful time for petition gatherers.
There are a fair part of two dozen state propositions and of many local petitions that
are circulating right now all looking to try to get on the November 2026 ballot. That makes it a
lot of competition and that has driven up the price that people are paying to have their proposition
be on top of the the pile to get that signature and thus that the amount per signature that
they're paying and when there is an opportunity like that there are going to be unscrupulous
individuals who are going to do something illegal. They're going to bend and break those rules
to try and maximize their profit and that's just wrong. We have another exciting event in April
with Yanni Ekelec who's the senior editor at Epoch Times. He wrote a book called Kill to Order.
He's exposing what's going on in China with organ harvesting and he's here to tell us about the book.
We're going to have one event in our studio in Irvine and another one in San Diego. We're going
to leave you a link below so you can sign up. We'll see you then. Now let's go see the rest of
the episode. How much do they pay for these signatures? Because we we have heard from some
people that you have to have these paid signature gatherers to get on the ballot. Is that true and
how much is the pay? So you don't have to do that. For a state proposition, yes it's probably going
to be required because of the large number of signatures necessary for a law change, a legislative
change, or for a constitutional change for a California proposition. We're talking hundreds
of thousands of signatures that are necessary from across the state. Now if you start that process,
you're allowed to circulate your petition for six months time. If you start that process well ahead
of your target election, you can do a grassroots effort where you have volunteers or very relatively
low paid individuals out doing that work and you collect your signatures over those six months,
no problem. And especially for local election situations, if you're not rushed, you don't need
to pay because at the county level, major cities, you've got six months to circulate your petition.
If you have planned ahead, if you've started your petition 13 to 18 months ahead of time
from your target election, it's very easy to do it as a grassroots. There's a lot of work,
but no, you don't necessarily have to pay for that. A lot of the propositions that we're seeing
right now, they're right at the end of the race, but they barely started too. They started late and
they don't have much time. They're not able to circulate for the full six months because the
deadline to be on the November ballot, to be verified to be on that ballot, is coming up
very quickly. So it's a competition for resources. And in any good economic model,
when you've got a competition for resources, the cost is going to go up to get those resources.
And so that our audience understands, is it that these people are getting paid per signature
that they collect? And how much roughly is it that people are getting paid per signature?
So when you are out and about and you run into a signature gatherer at a grocery store,
at the mall, that person, they're doing work, they're being paid for their time,
but they may also be receiving a bonus per signature that they return. So they return
a petition section with 10 signatures on it. They could be getting paid for that amount.
And their organization that they're working for is going to be paid to go out and get
50,000 signatures from LA County or from Riverside or Orange, or 25,000 signatures
from Fresno County. And so they're getting paid a certain amount and that gives the organization,
I can go out and pay X amount for my actual circulators in the field in this. I can make
a profit by doing this process, which of course, which is the goal of any business in that sphere.
How much they're being paid per signature, that really depends on what the rush is and
what the competition is. So right now, $10, $15, $20. I've heard it as high as 18 to $20
at the moment. It can be different upon what market you're looking at and what type of
competition. When you're in a market that has local petitions, as well as the state petitions,
the cost for those locals to actually even be seen is going to be actually potentially even
higher than the cost for a state proposition. So very much depends on what your competition
looks like out there. Do these people that are gathering these signatures,
would they ask you to sign multiple of them at the same time?
Multiple petitions at the same time is allowed. So when you're out there and you're actually
running into a circulator out there in the field, they can have multiple petitions on
that they would like you to sign. So you'll see them, they'll have their clipboard there and
there'll be multiple documents on there. Now, they're being paid the most probably for you to
sign whatever petitions on top and maybe the least for the one that's down on the bottom.
You can kind of get an idea of where their priorities are there. You may also just run
into people that are doing this kind of as a grassroots function. Maybe they have a table
set up and they have separate, each petition has their own plate, but you are allowed as a
registered voter to sign any of those petitions, all of them, just one, whatever you want to do
there. The circulator may want you to sign them all because they may be getting paid for every
one of them, but it's up to you, which ones you would like to sign and support.
And is it possible to know if they're getting paid or not?
So on the petition itself, it will say whether it's being circulated, whether the circulator
is being paid at the very least, it will say something along the lines of this petition
may be being circulated by a paid circulator. You may ask the circulator if they're being paid.
So you do have the right as a petition signer to ask the circulator, whether they're being
paid or not. They're supposed to be showing you actually a bit of information. You have full
access to that petition, not just the portion that you're signing, but all of that document,
take your time to read it. Circulator might not like that. You're going to take the five,
10 minutes to kind of skim through that, understand what you're signing.
There are additional documents that may be part of that paperwork or a separate page that's
attached there that has information on the top supporters of that petition. All of that
information is available for each of those petitions. And if they aren't, you as a voter
have a valid complaint against that circulator. They must provide that information. Otherwise,
that's not a valid petition. Those sections should be thrown out.
And in this case where people were getting paid to sign, what parts are illegal? Is all of the
process illegal? Can you pay somebody to get the signature, even if they're signing on their own
name? You should never, cannot pay for someone to sign your petition. You can be paid as the
circulator. And even based on the number of signatures you're bringing in, receive that bonus,
but you cannot pay for that signature. Very similar to the idea that you cannot pay someone
in any way or fashion to vote, whether to vote for a certain thing or just vote in general,
you cannot pay for that signature. So that's an illegal action.
Some of the videos we've seen out there actually have additional legal actions in them where
they're telling them, don't sign your own name, sign this name here or sign multiple times.
All of that is illegal and should result in massive penalties that would financially,
logically make it not worth the time to do. Move that via the risk and the circulators and the
organizations are at risk there. James, you've been in this space for a long time and you're
pretty passionate about it. What were you thinking when you saw those videos?
I was disappointed. I was mad because that the petition process, the proposition process in
California is an example of true democracy at work. It's an opportunity to actually go beyond
the Republican model of our government where we elect representatives to actually go out there
and represent us within the legislature and create laws for our society. Here, you have a direct
impact on what laws are actually being put forward to be part of our constitution or California
codes. So it really is an opportunity and it's been a way for the people of California
to have that say and to see that process being manipulated, being ruined by someone doing
something clearly illegal. It was very disappointing and I hope that some action
was able to be taken because you had pictures, you had a record and I hope that we're going to
be able to see charges filed. What do you think will happen next? Do you think the state has to
go after them? We saw some reports that the state might go after them. What are your thoughts on
that? Primarily, they were state propositions so they would kind of have the first bite at the
apple. Some counties also have public integrity units in their district attorney's office. So
some cities or some counties may also be capable of going after illegal proposition petition
circulation situations, but they'll be coming first from the state. And so you'd be seeing
the state AG in conjunction working with the California Secretary of State to be able to
collect evidence and I hope to be able to actually bring some type of charges, fines,
stop this from happening. James, for people that are concerned about the elections in California,
there's a number of people that are worried about elections in California and elections in general,
the integrity, and they see these kind of videos. Do you have any thoughts for them,
any messages for them? So for a video like this one, where we're looking at a commercial group
that is manipulating a basic process that you need to share it, you need to provide this to
your government, bring it to our attention. So we found out about very quickly, we brought it to the
attention of the Secretary of State. And so officials that can take action are going to be
the action that they can take. So that response is there. You need to talk if there's a concern
with your representatives. And I know that actually having spoken to one of my representatives just
yesterday in the legislature, that they have an interest in, let's take a look at the commercial
side of petition signature gathering and what type of controls do we need to add there? There
are controls already, but could we add something more basically? And no details yet, this is too
early in the process in response to this occurring, but that's a place to go. And that's going to need
to be at the state level, but you can bring it to the attention of your local representative.
So actually make use of that government to kind of build for that change. We need this state
proposition process is that way of direct democracy for us so that we have this process of
interacting with our laws and being able to have our voices heard. And we want it to be
as accurate and true process as possible. James Koos, it was great to have you on California
Insider. Thank you. It was a pleasure to be here. After these discussions, JJ got back to us and
told us that despite the state investigating, allegedly he saw people still collecting these
kind of signatures in his community. JJ, we had you on yesterday to talk about what you saw in
the San Francisco city with people collecting signatures and paying for people to sign up
for these ballot propositions. Right after our interview, you went out there and you found out
that people are doing it in another side of the city. We're going to show a video of what you
did. They had me do this on six the other day.
What was happening, JJ? As soon as I got off the call with you, I walked outside and looked right
as right in front of my door and they was sitting right on the side of my building doing it.
They was signatures for ballots for the petition on a petition and they was paying people five
dollars. But this time I had the gentleman explain what was the petition for and who was
it for. He gave up all that information. He also stated that he gets fifteen dollars per signature
and he gives, I guess, he gives a person five dollars up out of the air to sign.
How did he advertise that he's paying five dollars? Was it very obvious?
He was just telling people. In the video, you can tell people you'll get five dollars
if you sign up. I asked him, well, if I do two petitions, will I get ten dollars?
He said, no, you'll just get five dollars. Who were the people that were signing this?
All of them was drug addicts that was out there signing them. The people that was signing there,
I knew all of them and they're addicted to drugs. And they weren't really reading what
they're signing. They just wanted the five dollars. They didn't read it. They was just
putting their name on a dotted line. And the state has been saying they're investigating this.
What are your thoughts? Is it the word hasn't got out to these people that are getting the signatures
that this is illegal? Well, I don't think they're investigating it because it's running rapidly
around here. After I seen them, I went around the corner. It was the most people around there
doing the same thing also. So it's like a team out here that's doing it and they're all doing
it simultaneously. Do you think it's the same petitions? It's the same petitions. Actually,
right now, today, right now, as we speak, they're down the street right now doing it again.
These ones, they were asking for you to sign your own name, right?
I don't know. I didn't really pay attention to that one, but I didn't hear them tell nobody to
sign a different name. But who knows if the people that was signing it was actually using their real
name? It wasn't checking for any ID identification or anything. The people signing, did they know
that this is illegal? They shouldn't be doing that. Nobody should pay them to sign. It doesn't
make a difference if it's illegal or not illegal. They didn't care. They just want that money to
get their drugs. At least two of the people that I've seen here is not even from California.
One is from Wyoming and another one is from Oregon. What do you want to see happen? I want
the state of California secretary to investigate this because they shouldn't be coming down here
preying on the homeless and people that's drug addicted. It was great to have you back on. Thanks
for keeping in touch with us and hopefully this will get investigated. J.J. Smith, it was great to
have you on. Okay, thank you. In California, it's very common to pay for signature collectors to go
out there and get signatures, but they are not supposed to pay Californians for their signatures.
Now we go to Susan Shelley to see what her thoughts are on this. You guys have run a lot of
these ballot propositions and what are your thoughts on these paid programs where people
are getting paid to collect signatures? I know that this is a big part of running
propositions in California. Well, it's perfectly legal to pay people to collect signatures.
That's not the issue. The issue is paying people to sign petitions. That's not acceptable. And to
use the voter roll and then ask people to sign someone else's name, obviously that's just
fraudulent. And the person who signs the bottom of a petition is called the declaration
of circulator. That's at the bottom of the petition. And that person is swearing that they
saw those people sign the petition personally and that to the best of their knowledge, that is the
person who signed it. So when someone pays a person on the street to sign someone else's name and then
signs that declaration of circulator, I believe that's penalty of perjury. So they could be
prosecuted for that, I believe. It's certainly not what the proponents of a measure want to see
happen on the streets. You want to see people honestly collecting signatures. And it is hard
work and sometimes people are paid to do it, but it shouldn't be fraudulent. Is it possible to do
this with volunteers or is it almost impossible to collect the signatures without paying the people
that are asking with clipboards for getting the signatures? Well, it is possible. It's a lot of
signatures in a short period of time. So it's a little less than six months that you have to do
this. And it's a lot of volunteers on the street to collect more than a million signatures because
it's a percentage of the number of people who voted for governor in the last general election.
And if you had a high turnout election, you have a higher number of signatures required. And it's a
higher number for a constitutional amendment by initiative than just a state law by initiative.
So this year, it's been 875,000 signatures for a constitutional amendment, a little less, but
basically that. And in order to make sure that you have enough valid signatures, because
people can make mistakes, in order to make sure you have enough valid signatures, you have to
collect well above that 875,000 number. If you just figure out that you've got volunteers who can
collect 10 or 20 or 100, and you multiply the number of volunteers that you need, you can
see that's a huge effort by volunteers. It can be done, but it's very difficult. So for the most part,
a lot of these ballot propositions have to go the paid route. They have to pay people to
go collect signatures. That's been the case. I think mostly initiatives that have had a big
volunteer effort have gotten the majority of their signatures from a paid signature collection effort
also in parallel. Even the biggest volunteer efforts struggle to get that number. So it's
very challenging, and there is a time limit, and it's difficult to do. What about people that are
seeing, like Californians? What should they do when they're approached by these people that are
trying to get signatures from us? Well, there's nothing wrong with that. If you sign the petition,
if you're a registered voter, and you sign the petition to get the measure on the ballot, there's
nothing wrong with that. You're not voting for it at that moment. You're just signing a petition to
get it on the ballot. So if you want to, great. And if you don't want to, certainly you're right.
Something that people should know is that it's illegal to use this information on the
petitions for any other purpose. So you can't use this for a commercial list. You're not getting
yourself on a mailing list when you sign a petition on the street. That information only
goes to the counties where the signatures are validated, and it can't be retained for commercial
purposes or any other purpose. You're not on a mailing list when you do that. So the people on
the street do not work directly for the proponents of the ballot measure. The proponents of the
ballot measure hire a petition management company, and those companies have subcontractors, and those
companies have subcontractors. And you'll see sometimes an ad on Craigslist or somewhere else
that you can pick up extra cash by being a signature collector. You're working for someone
way down the chain from the people who are the proponents of the measure. So it's always
disturbing to the proponents to see that someone down the chain is doing something that's illegal
because that's just going to mean the signatures aren't valid, and they're paying people to collect
valid signatures to try to get something on the ballot. It's important to recognize that there are
multiple companies involved in this, and it's not just the people on the street directly working for
the people who are behind the measure. So it could be that the people that are on the streets that
are offering to pay or doing these illegal things have absolutely no connection to the
ballot measure or even to the company that hired them, because it could be some individual acting
on their own. It absolutely could be that. It absolutely is. But someone should look into how
they got the voter rolls, because if they're pointing to a piece of paper and saying, you're
going to sign this person's name, here's the address to write down, somebody gave them that.
Because you can't just walk into the Register of Voters and say, give me the list. You have
to sign a piece of paper that says it won't be misused, and you have to have a legitimate purpose,
research, election-related efforts. It's not public information that you can just
download off the internet. What was it like for you to experience what is in these videos?
Well, it's horrible. It's horrible, because when you're trying to do the qualification
of a ballot measure, the last thing you want to see is invalid signatures. The last thing you
want to see is someone being paid to sign it, which is just going to cause more headaches for
the whole effort. At the end of the signature collection, when the petitions are turned into
the counties to be verified, we want those signatures to be valid. We want it all to be
perfectly fine so that the measure qualifies quickly. It's disturbing to see something like
that, because it discredits the whole. It discredits, in some ways, the whole initiative
process. It should be legitimate, and those people should not be doing that. It's not the way
that we want it to be done. What's the value of these initiatives for California?
Well, the initiative process is so important. We have had this since 1911, and this is a
constitutional right that the people of California have to write their own laws,
go around the legislature, go around the governor, and write their own laws, and collect signatures
to put them on the ballot and pass them. That is an incredibly important protection for the
people of California, because sometimes, as was the case in 1911, the legislature is corrupt or
indolent, I think was the word they used at the time, lazy and not wanting to do anything,
and there were big problems. You know, we saw in 1978 that property taxes were getting completely
out of control. People were losing their homes because of inflation. Property was taxed on the
current market value at that time, and the tax rate was a statewide average of 2.67 percent,
and the legislature wouldn't do anything about it. So Howard Jarvis collected signatures and put
Proposition 13 on the ballot, and it passed with a two-thirds vote, and that has protected people
in their homes ever since. Your property cannot be reassessed to market value for as long as you
own it. It can only go up maximum two percent a year. So you are protected. You know what your
taxes are going to be way out into the future, and you don't have to live in fear that somebody
sold their house down the block for some crazy price, and now you're going to get reassessed
and pay higher taxes. That's because of the initiative process, and that is incredibly
important, and the people of California have supported the initiative process in every poll
that's ever asked about it. So it's a really important protection for the people of this state.
Well, thank you so much, Susan. Thank you, CIMAC. The California Secretary of State Office has said
they're going to investigate this issue. We reached out to Shirley Weber's office for a comment we
haven't heard back yet. What do you think about what's happening in California right now with the
ballot propositions and signature collecting? Tell us in the comments or email us at
cimacacaliforniasatter.com. We read all of your emails and comments. I'm CIMAC Kourami,
this is California Insider. We'll see you next time.