As artificial intelligence continues to dominate headlines and investment markets, an important question emerges: Are we experiencing an AI bubble?
In this segment of the Northern AI Business Symposium, panelists examine AI through an economic and societal lens — comparing today’s momentum to the 1999 dot-com boom while exploring what makes this technological shift distinct. Discussion topics include: • Historical parallels to the dot-com era • The current profitability challenges of major AI companies • AI’s significant contribution to GDP growth and data center expansion • The environmental demands of large-scale AI infrastructure, including electricity and water usage • The economic impact on rural communities hosting data centers
For graduating high school students preparing to enter college, understanding innovation cycles is essential. Emerging technologies often move through periods of rapid growth, intense investment, and eventual market correction — a pattern sometimes described as the “hype cycle.” The panel concludes that while AI may currently be in a phase of heightened enthusiasm and market pressure, the long-term trajectory of artificial intelligence as a transformative force in business, science, and society is unlikely to disappear. Developing the ability to analyze technological trends critically — rather than react emotionally — will be an essential skill for students navigating the future economy.
Yeah, I would only, I would add, I think for me, what I'm seeing is definitely for like an everyday person
that just has access to these tools everyone does,
research is easy. Like I feel like that the AI
has, oh, like we had the internet and then there's different ways,
okay, now we're gonna click blue links to find out things.
But I think the real magic is that it really is a much better way to experience the world's information, I think, because the
if you search something, you're getting back a much more personalized response.
So from like a research perspective as business owners, I think that's key too.
Like what are the market trends I should be aware of or if I have this or that?
And then second use case, I think from a generative standpoint, so everyone kind of mentioned that too,
which is if you need to generate something that's maybe not your strength to generate social media ads or report,
to me, it's a really, really good thought partner and then you can access that with just just general AI.
And then what I think will happen and what we're starting to see is things you'll have to pay for as a business,
but starting to automate some of those overhead tasks.
So you guys had mentioned that too and I think some of that.
But I was curious if you all think kind of where are we at if you look at like the kind of hype curve, right?
So you have like the trough of disillusionment and you have like this, you guys have seen that, and
sometimes I feel like I'm traveling through that a bit.
It's like I get super excited and I'm like, this thing doesn't work at all.
Or I'm like, oh my god, this is the best thing I've ever used and I'm like, this is really garbage.
So I'm curious for you all.
Do you think there's like some hype there and like where should some focus areas be if you set some specific examples?
We can hop around or if anyone has ideas.
I have a pretty strong opinion on this.
So, you know, I came up in the digital media industry in the late 90s, right?
And I was there for the big dot-com boom days of 99, 2000.
And my company felt it when we busted in 2001.
We went from, gosh, at that time I started a digital media agency.
I started out of my apartment with three guys working out of an apartment in Brooklyn.
Within a year and a half, we grew to 70 people with two offices in Manhattan, one in LA.
And once we did that, after a year and a half, we went to four people in six months, right?
Because of the hype cycle.
Now, we all know the internet was here to stay.
However, the amount of investment that was being pumped into all the dot-coms at that time,
just because people were, you know, they had FOMO.
They were afraid of missing out, right?
They saw this big boom and so they were, you know, placing big bets on all of these dot-coms.
You know, but for, you know, for the investors, it was okay.
I'm investing in 100 companies.
As long as one hits really big and 99 go out of business, that's right.
That one company will recoup the losses of all of the other 99 companies that I invested in, right?
I think we're going to see a very similar pattern happening with AI, right?
But I think the hype cycle is going to be very quick and I think we're going to get over it very fast, right?
So, I think what you'll see is you'll see big investments going into AI like you're seeing today, right?
We're already starting to see some of that fall out because companies were very, you know,
jumping on the bandwagon saying, we need to build agentic AI, we'll automate our workflows and everything else.
And then guess what happened?
People weren't adopting it, right?
They weren't changing their ways of working.
Or they didn't implement the technology properly.
It was making mistakes.
It was, you know, it was breaking down in certain areas.
Or from a data privacy standpoint, right?
Like, depending on what type of industries you're in, right?
There's a lot of regulations.
And so, they started to realize there were privacy issues.
So, companies started to pull back a little bit, right?
And now people feel like, oh gosh, now what's happening?
Now there's all this backlash.
That's going to be temporary, right?
All these things are going to start to work itself out.
But I do believe we are in a hype cycle right now where it's going to explode
and then you're going to find it, people are going to dial back.
And then you're going to start to see a real boom that becomes more sustainable.
Very similar to what we saw with digital marketing and digital media.
Yeah, I agree.
We're definitely in the, not quite the peak, but we're on the upward slope of the hype cycle.
Is open AI profitable yet?
I don't, I don't, yeah.
The billions of billions of dollars.
But they're worth half a trillion dollars.
Yes, that the billions upon billions of dollars and the scrambling to get a piece of open AI
and they have not yet turned a profit.
So, I kind of keep that in the back of my head that the biggest of dogs in the fight
has not yet turned a profit.
And carefully evaluating where my investment or one of my clients' investment is going to go.
Well, also just keep in mind too, like right now when we think about economic growth, right?
Right now, all GP growth is being driven by AI technology.
Yes, and data centers, everything else.
And now imagine when that, when that bubble busts, we probably will find ourselves in a recession.
But then what comes out of that, we'll probably find ourselves being a lot more
sustainable in terms of how AI technology is being leveraged.
Yeah, the majority of GDP growth that you're just reading was data centers.
And with taking out data centers, you had like 0.1% GDP growth or something.
So, pretty, pretty amazing.
Data centers specifically being built in like not urban, suburban areas,
like areas like the middle of Texas, where the cost of electricity is very,
very cheap and it's highly available.
So, you're having all this development, all these millions of dollars going in areas that otherwise
don't serve like an employed workforce.
So, I do worry some there.
I have some pause over what like the long-term impact is going to be
to those areas where these data centers are being put up very quickly.
Well, actually, to that point, I think there's been three or four projects in the past,
maybe six months or less, from the largest companies that have actually not gone in.
And the reason is because the electricity costs in those areas that the data center goes in
tends to triple for local residents.
And there's been no subsidy from those large players.
So, basically, these rural areas don't see much benefit from these data centers.
So, you could make the argument there's this societal benefit from these data centers.
And I think that's actually important for our area,
because we have a lot of talks about bringing data centers here.
And I think I have concerns too, because unless those companies will subsidize
to keep electricity costs at parity, then people are honestly just suffering.
And there's a big societal buy-in that I think has to happen now,
where society has to say, we will give you enough runway,
unprofitable company, X, Y, Z.
We'll give you enough runway and enough clean water and power
till the end of time or when, so that we can see this benefit.
So, I think there's a little bit of a struggle going on there.