A world-renowned astrophysicist says we won’t reach Mars for the reason everyone assumes — and Elon Musk’s plan may never make sense.
If humanity does go, it won’t be for exploration or curiosity — it’ll be because something forces us to. Watch the full video: https://youtu.be/aUnkkHuorto
Neil deGrasse Tyson is one of the most influential science communicators and a leading astrophysicist shaping public understanding of space. We cover: why Mars may be the most expensive project in human history, the three real drivers behind civilization-scale breakthroughs, what happens when private ambition collides with geopolitical reality, and the one scenario that could fast-track humans to Mars.
🎯 Support Into the Impossible on Patreon — get my weekly M.A.G.I.C. Message, unfiltered bonus content, and live monthly Office Hours with me: https://www.patreon.com/drbriankeating
To go to Mars is expensive.
If China says they want to put military bases on Mars,
we'll be in Mars in 10 months.
NASA doesn't have a spacecraft that'll get us there.
Guess who does? Elon does!
Pivoting to more recent events,
there's, of course, a great interest in
not only discovering life on Mars,
but putting life on Mars.
A man by the name of Elon Musk,
who you once called
Elon Musk is more important than Jeff Bezos,
Steve Jobs, and Mark Zuckerberg.
Wow, that's pretty awesome.
More important? I don't think I would use the word important.
I might have said he's more productive, or more...
There might have been a different word there.
Oh, it's an article?
Wow, okay.
You talk about this.
Anyway, recently you were on Bill Maher's show, I think,
and you talked about, you know,
what your thoughts were on it.
Maybe you can recapitulate those.
Well, it's hard to get all my thoughts in there,
because he doesn't really give you room.
If he doesn't agree with you,
he gives you less room to talk.
What are your thoughts? I mean, because...
My thoughts on what?
Your thoughts on Musk's desire to put Mars,
fill Mars with lifeforms, including humans,
and himself, potentially.
He said he wants to die on Mars.
I hope it's not on impact.
Clarify what you feel is the relevance,
or the importance of his mission
to extend consciousness to Mars.
I never want to get in the way of people's dreams,
especially if they're fed by advances and innovations
in science and technology.
I have no need to do that.
Especially since a dream, when executed,
even if the dream is not realistic, or even impossible,
it can take you along paths that produce
fascinating or other interesting developments
in science and technology that we benefit from.
So, I don't have any problems with dreams at all.
So, I don't run around volunteering commentary
on his dreams.
What happens is people come to me
and ask what I think of them.
And so, I wrote a whole book on this,
originally titled,
Failure to Launch,
The Dreams and Delusions of Space Enthusiasts,
chronicling the mismatch
of where people thought we'd be in space
versus where we were in space.
And so, it has every thought I've ever had
on the past, present, and future of space.
Now, you can say,
well, you have different thoughts, so you, okay.
But, these thoughts are not just opinions
that I'm expressing.
This is a very careful read of the history
of human engagement
in major advances in science and technology.
That's what I'm basing it on.
Not on my desires,
not on what I wish or hope,
it had nothing to do with that.
And all I'm saying is,
to go to Mars is expensive.
Likely, the most expensive thing
we would ever do as a species
outside of the waging of World War.
The history of very expensive things
sits squarely in the realm of geopolitics
and the praise of deity and royalty,
which is less of a driving force today
than it once was.
So, these are the three big drivers.
So, there's praise of royalty and deity,
that's what gets you the cathedrals
and the pyramids and this sort of thing.
Huge investments of human capital,
human and financial capital.
Then there's the promise of economic return.
That's a good one.
You want to do it because you want to get rich.
Talk about a motivator,
that's a good one right there.
And a third one is the
I don't want to die motivator.
Someone has somehow threatened you
by saying they're going to achieve
the new high ground
or they're going to look better than you
in front of people you're trying to attract.
So, I arrived at these three drivers
in an essay I wrote
for the Columbia History of the 20th Century.
That's the title of the book
and it's in there.
It's called Paths to Discovery.
And what I wanted to do,
what I did was,
the motivation was,
I asked myself,
what does it take
to motivate a civilization or a culture
to do something really, really expensive?
And if I want to go to Mars,
and that's really, really expensive,
let me look at
what has motivated people in the past.
And maybe we can recreate that in the present
and then we all just march to Mars.
Okay?
And I was ready.
I had a grid,
make a whole grid.
Here's the expense of the project
and here are all the possible causes,
possible drivers.
Just because we want to
or it's in our,
because we love it
or it's in our DNA
or it's just,
we're just curious
or we're humans
or we're Americans.
I was ready for this
and at the end of the day,
only three drivers emerged.
For the expensive things.
You have other drivers
for less expensive things
or non-expensive things.
The most expensive things
have only three drivers.
Like I said,
it's the praise of royalty or deity,
the quest for economic return
and the fact that you don't want to die.
So the I don't want to die driver,
I don't want to die poor driver.
And I don't want,
and all right.
So,
Musk says he wants to put people on Mars
and I put it through this filter
and I ask,
is it in praise of a deity
or royalty?
Well, I said those are no longer drivers.
Okay?
Is there an economic return on it?
Well,
clearly no.
Okay?
Not in putting the first people on Mars.
Do we feel threatened
so that we have to do this?
Well, not at the moment,
but maybe one day we will.
Like I said,
if China says,
because China's all the buzz in Washington lately,
what do we do with our frenemy around the world?
And if China says they want to put military bases on Mars,
we'll be on Mars in 10 months.
Except,
NASA doesn't have a spacecraft that'll get us there.
Guess who does?
Elon does!
So Elon rolls out his starship
and then we go to Mars on Elon's ship.
You know something?
If we do that,
it's tax money that sent it there.
Not money out of Elon's pocket
or out of his profits,
margins,
or anything.
So all I'm saying is
that I don't foresee us going to Mars
unless we believe it is in our geopolitical interest.
And if it is,
it's not private enterprise that's going to do it.
It's governments.
And he could go to Mars as a vanity project.
I don't mean that in any pejorative sense.
It's just that he could choose to go to Mars
with no expectation of a return on that investment
because he's either,
will one day be wealthy enough to do that
or he can band together money from Bill Gates and Jeff Bezos
and put together the 800 billion or a trillion dollars
and then send astronauts there.
That would be fun.
I don't have a problem with that.
But don't tell me that it's part of your business model
because that would be without precedent
in the history of civilization
that you would spend that much money
and somehow figure out how to make money off of it.
No.
The way this typically happens,
especially if it's never been done before,
the first Europeans to the New World
were not the Dutch East India Trading Company.
It was Columbus,
sent by Queen Isabella and King Ferdinand.
By the way, there was some private investment in that,
but the full motivation and the full driver
was geopolitical.
Find a shorter way to the Far East.
Look for India.
But he gets to the New World and he calls them all Indians.
Okay?
That's kind of weird.
All right.
And then,
but he gets to write down where the trade winds are
and where the hostels are and the friendlies
and where the food is
and he can characterize that voyage
such that a private enterprise
who didn't have to take those risks,
whereas geopolitics will take those risks in a heartbeat,
businesses can't do that
because they're usually using other people's money
or even if it's your own money.
This is what I'm saying.
It has nothing to do
with whether we're technologically able to do it.
We have an SUV-sized rover on Mars.
Of course, we can get to Mars.
Of course.
That's not the issue here.
This is my point.
But I don't want to stop him,
but people keep asking me,
what do I think of it?
And I'll say, I don't think it's realistic.
Not because we don't know how to do it,
but because at some point,
somebody's got a right to check
and it's not because it's next thing to explore.
That has never been the reason.
I think I'd add one thing
that maybe dovetails to the deity,
but not really,
and it's eschatological.
Effectively, you know,
worrying about existential risks
and basically—
No, that's the I-don't-want-to-die driver.
That's fine.
That would not have to invoke deity.
The deity is,
I fear this entity more powerful than I am
and I better do things to appease them.
And so you build pyramids,
you build cathedrals,
you do things for God
because you want to be treated well in death
or even in life.
So that as a motivator,
because religions don't control societies
as much today,
certainly not technologically able societies
as they once did.
That's all.
But there's still the, yeah,
the Ernest Becker denial of death
and we do things in part
to stave off these horrific fears
that otherwise would drive us crazy.
Then it's the I-don't-want-to-die driver
and that's a really big driver.
Yeah.
But why does it have to do with Mars?
I always point out we, you know,
how much of the ocean have we really explored
and isn't it a little bit more practical
to build underwater cities
and backup drive?
Yeah, I don't put,
those are all false comparisons.
I don't, yes, it's more practical,
but so, just do both.
NASA's budget is 0.4%,
four-tenths of one penny on your tax dollar
and you're saying don't spend money up there,
put it in the ocean, do both.
I'm not going to stop you.
Yeah, and I think even what you say
in your, in your, you know,
in his response to you, it's,
I don't, I didn't see his response,
but he's defensive, of course,
because he's, he's got a whole business there
and I don't have a problem with him
jumping in and getting angry.
I'm not saying this because I'm decreeing it,
I'm saying it because that's how people have behaved.
That's all.
Don't shoot the messenger.
Right.
I'm not even going to get in arguments with people.
And by the way, I put it all in,
in this book,
not even any of the books you've mentioned thus far.
There's this other book
which the publisher renamed
because they didn't like the word failure in the title
because it was failure to launch,
dreams and delusions.
The word failure and delusion was in the title.
So we can't have that.
We renamed it Space Chronicles,
Facing the Ultimate Frontier.
And in there, all of this is detailed.