10 Pinterest Myths that Etsy Sellers STILL Believe

Myths and magic
3 followers
1 Video View·Apr 17, 2026
When it comes to Etsy, Pinterest marketing is the number one source of social traffic to the platform! This video explains how to use Pinterest effectively by avoiding 10 common myths.
When it comes to marketing your Etsy shop, Pinterest is the number one source of social
traffic to the platform, making it a great option for those who want to get more exposure
to their products.
But unfortunately, there's also a lot of bad Pinterest advice floating around on YouTube
right now.
Like, a lot a lot.
And some of it is being repeated so often that sellers start assuming that it must be
true.
So today, I'm busting 10 of the biggest Pinterest myths that are actively circulating online.
That way, you can avoid wasting time, energy, and even your traffic.
For those who are new here, my name is Starla Moore, founder of the handmade elf academy
for Etsy sellers and manager at E-Rank.com, Etsy's most popular SEO tool.
And since Pinterest has become such a hot topic for sellers lately, I figured this would
be the perfect time to debunk some of the worst Pinterest advice that's still making
its rounds here in 2026.
Because Pinterest can be an amazing traffic source for sellers, but only if you stop listening
to people who are still teaching strategies from 2018.
So let's get into it.
Myth number one, you need to pin 20 to 50 times a day to grow.
No, no you don't.
And who the heck has time for that?
This is one of the pieces of advice that keeps sellers from experimenting with Pinterest
in the first place.
Because it makes Pinterest success feel unachievable.
And that's not the case.
Not to mention, it burns sellers out if they attempt to keep up with this crazy pinning
schedule.
Pinterest's own business guidance says to create fresh content weekly and specifically
says not to anchor yourself to some magic number of pins per week.
In a nutshell, they want you focused on quality and relevance of the content, not just pinning
random products before lunch in order to hit an inexistent quota.
Remember, quality over quantity.
Myth number two, Pinterest is just another social media platform.
Anyone who scrolls through Pinterest for fun will be the first to tell you that this isn't
true.
Because Pinterest is a completely different universe with users having totally different
objectives than those scrolling on Facebook, Instagram, or TikTok.
This is because Pinterest works much more like a search and discovery platform than
a traditional social media app.
People go there to look for ideas, products, inspiration, and planning.
Want to organize your house?
Go to Pinterest.
Want the perfect wedding colors?
Go to Pinterest.
Looking for decor ideas for a nursery?
You guessed it, go to Pinterest.
This means that the strategy on Pinterest is completely different.
Searchability matters.
Relevance matters.
Keywords matter.
And long-term discoverability through evergreen content matters.
Oh, and the best part, you don't need to record weird videos of yourself dancing to
trending music to be successful on it, which is already a huge win for me because ain't
nobody got time for that.
Myth number three, you have to have a blog to succeed on Pinterest.
Are we still blogging?
I'm not blogging.
Guys, you do not need a blog to make Pinterest work.
If you're already a blogging fanatic, it's definitely not going to hurt.
But if you're like me and don't have the time to also run a blog page on top of everything
else that you do for your business in a day, it doesn't mean that you can't be successful
on Pinterest.
Pinterest supports product pages, shopping content, catalogs, and other website destinations,
not just blog posts.
So if you're a handmade seller, a product-based business, or someone who wants to drive traffic
to a sales page instead of a blog article, Pinterest can still absolutely work for you.
You just need to be mindful of keywords, pin quality, and overall relevance.
Again, no random speed pinning for the sake of doing as much as possible.
Myth number four, follower count is the main thing that matters.
For here on YouTube, yeah.
For TikTok, yeah.
For Pinterest, not so much.
Another saving grace for those of us who aren't interested in being the next lip-syncing content
creator just for the sake of getting your products out into the world.
Follower count is one of the most overrated Pinterest metrics because, again, Pinterest's
own guidance emphasize fresh content, relevance, and discoverability a whole lot more than
vanity metrics like followers.
In other words, a small account with strong, searchable content can still do very well
on its own.
Myth number five, keywords don't matter.
Guys, keywords always matter.
Always.
No matter the platform.
A keyword's like a fishing line that helps the right person find your content.
And if a platform has one of these, it's very likely that keywords are important.
In their official guidance, Pinterest tells businesses to use meaningful keywords in their
pin titles, descriptions, and other text fields like your alt text so content can be discovered
in search and browsing.
But where do you find these keywords?
What most people don't realize is that Pinterest has their own trend tool totally free to access
which can help you to find the right language to use in your pins.
I'll go ahead and pop the link in the description down below so you can save it for later.
Myth number six, and probably the most common one I hear, boards don't matter anymore.
They do, just not in the way that I think that they did a few years ago when all the
coaches said that you needed to spend 20 hours researching, building, and following thousands
of boards.
Today, boards still matter for organization, context, and discoverability.
As in, they still help for search and that's where keywords come into play yet again.
In their official guidelines, Pinterest recommends giving every board a proper title and description
which can help people discover these boards in search.
And when you hear the words title, description, and search together in a sentence, that automatically
means that you need to use good keywords.
Myth number seven, the only metric that matters is outbound clicks.
Okay, of course you want clicks, especially as a business.
The whole point of marketing is to get people to click the thing that you want them to buy.
But clicks aren't the only success metric that you should be looking at.
And if you're only focusing on clicks, you may end up giving up before you've fully
reached your potential.
Instead, you also want to look at saves or repins.
Pinterest says that when your content is saved, it sends strong signals that your content
is resonating, leading it to get shown to more people over time.
Just like Etsy listings in search.
Think of every save as an opportunity for your pin to be seen by even more people, helping
to amplify it louder and louder over time.
Remember, clicks are great, but saves and repins are like having an unpaid marketing
team who circulates your products for you.
Myth number eight, you have to create totally new content from scratch every time.
Y'all, if this were the case, I'd never pin because it's a fast track to burning
out and giving up.
Pinterest has explicitly said that you can repurpose existing assets and use different
formats like video, carousels, and collages to keep content fresh without reinventing
your whole business every single week.
And you can literally do this with free tools like Canva.
So don't spend days, weeks, and months reinventing the wheel when you likely have a treasure
trove of content that's already at your fingertips.
Take what you already have, like product photos, email content, videos, or mockups, and rework
them into fresh Pinterest content so you can save time and brain energy.
Myth number nine, Pinterest is all about photography.
Definitely not.
Pinterest supports multiple content formats, including image pins, but they also allow
video pins.
This means that listing videos or even videos that you may have already posted on platforms
like TikTok can easily be recycled for Pinterest.
And Pinterest themselves encourage businesses to use the formats that best fit their content
and audience.
Remember, platforms evolve over time, which means that as sellers, we need to adapt to
those changes.
Now, before we move on to the last Pinterest myth, I do want to quickly mention that this
Friday, we'll be hosting a very special Pinterest-themed episode of the Friday Bean
with our very own Michelle Badger.
Many of you already know that over the last few months, Michelle has been in cancer recovery,
and during that time, she's been deep diving into the ins and outs of Pinterest strategies
that actually work for an Etsy business model in 2026.
And in celebration of the launch of her all-new Pin to Grow microcourses, she's joining
us for an hour and a half this Friday to answer Pinterest questions, debunk more Pinterest
myths, and to share strategies specifically for creative sellers.
So if Pinterest is something that you want to master this summer so you can reap the
benefits during Q4, definitely come hang out this Friday.
Okay, back to business.
Myth number 10, Pinterest growth relies heavily on love.
This one is probably my least favorite because it dissolves control entirely, as if every
pin is like playing the lottery.
Believe it or not, you have more control over your success than you think.
It just takes a bit of time and hard work.
And Pinterest gives businesses very clear strategies and tools.
Things like trends, keywords, fresh content, search optimization, board building, content
saves, analytics, product feeds.
All of these things can provide useful data that can help you to make more strategic decisions,
especially when you start to identify what's working for your own unique audience.
So you can create and pin more of the content that works based on analytics and data.
Is there testing involved?
Of course!
Anything with a search bar and an algorithm requires testing, monitoring, analyzing, and
refinement.
That's just business, baby.
But summing it all up to luck is what people say when they don't understand the system
well enough yet.
In summary, Pinterest still works for Etsy sellers and creatives, but it only works when
you understand that Pinterest has its own algorithm, its own guidelines, and best practices.
And those who spend time understanding how Pinterest works will see significantly better
results than those who just pin and hope.
Let me know in the comments which of these Pinterest myths do you see repeated the most
online, and were any mentioned today that you've actively believed until this video?
And don't forget to join Michelle and I this Friday for an exclusive Pinterest-themed
episode of The Friday Bean, where she'll be answering your questions live.
Until next time, pookie!
