Real Madrid : Kylian Mbappé est-il le problème ?

Kylian Mbappe fans
3 followers
12 Video Views·Apr 17, 2026
In any case, Real will be going through its second winless season, just as if there had been a super cup at the beginning of last year.
Is it the failure or the fiasco of the Mbappé plan, the fact of having transferred Mbappé and bought Mbappé?
That's something you need to do for yourself.
Mbappé, even the match he's playing tonight...
It's the Mbappé plan.
It's not about having Mbappé; it's about the Perez plan.
Who doesn't want Mbappé?
90%, 95% of players want Mbappé.
They no longer want PSG.
Yes, they wanted it.
They wanted to keep him.
They did not pay him.
The problem is the team you're building around Mbappé.
You have Alonso when you take him.
You have a top coach.
It is not Hervé Loa.
He is a great coach.
But you don't give him the keys.
The players have so much power at Real that the coach no longer has any power.
Is it a failure or isn't it a failure, Hervé?
Is it a fiasco?
Mbappé at Real?
No.
The fiasco, we all know.
It was also the failure to anticipate that two players aged 35, 36, and 37 would leave.
And that you never made an effort to find one or two players of their caliber to replace them.
And it threw off your entire game.
Whether Mbappé is there or not, anyway, it's clear that something's wrong.
And that Real often tinkers around.
They tinker around quite a bit, often.
But you can clearly see that Kroos and Modric haven't been replaced.
And especially that it's not a 25-year-old player being recruited and leaving at the last moment.
They are players you knew were going to stop.
But if they don't take a lead against Bayer, over the two legs.
Because he's there too.
Now, Mbappé's plan is to stop taking sheets [of metal].
I still thought that buying Mbappé was about conquering.
Yes, I'm listening.
No, no, the point is, does the Mbappé plan mean that Real's failure is inevitable?
No, it's not about having made Mbappé.
It was the fact that we didn't put together a team that resembled a team.
There are still many criticisms regarding his behavior.
At Real?
Yes.
As for me, I think the behavior was rather very good both on the way there and on the way back.
On this double confrontation.
This is what somewhat masks the recurring problems found in the press.
You remember what we were saying two months ago, don't you?
In December, roughly speaking, everyone was saying, basically, it's Mbappé's team.
If he isn't there, it will be a team that explodes.
Remember, it was the same press.
A month later or two months later, they start assassinating him because he misses three games.
At some point, one must also find a little balance.
No, but perhaps there's a bit of truth to it.
But then, there are still facts.
There is an observation made about the recent weeks when he was not there.
L'Oréal was winning.
And ever since he's been here, there have still been five or six consecutive losses.
Or five, six matches without a win.
Yes, rather.
So, there might be a connection.
No.
So then, none of the games they won while he was there had any connection?
That is, we forget all the matches he won.
It is the behavior.
We rely on the matches he hasn't won.
He is reproached for his behavior.
It's not about him scoring goals.
The behavior of not helping teammates, not defending—everything like that has been criticized.
And I think they make that criticism precisely in those big matches where we might need more from him.
Yes, but the matches you were talking about, where, for example, L'Oréal lost, or Girond, etc.
But here, you shouldn't say these are big matches.
So, strictly speaking, he won't be criticized for not working all that hard.
A little bit, because he's still losing ground in La Liga during the last month.
Last month, he lost in La Liga.
That's a bit reductive.
The streak is four matches without a win.
There are two against Bayern.
So, obviously, against Bayern, you're a bit more exposed to losing Mbappé or not losing Mbappé.
Frankly, today there is...
Yes, but in doing so, you're diminishing Mbappé's impact.
No, I find that it's...
On matches like this, it's normal for L'Oréal to lose.
In fact, they took it anyway to win the titles.
Yes, but we need to put a team around it.
So it's been two years since there have been any titles.
But you, you are a high-level player.
You know what it is.
If you hadn't had a team around you to score goals when you made those kind of passes, what would you have done?
He doesn't have a team.
It is not balanced.
This team is unbalanced.
I think that tonight, she wasn't necessarily very unbalanced, nor was she last week.
No, not tonight.
Because I think his behavior was better.
It's not just related to him either.
It is also related to the way in which...
That's somewhat what they reproach him for.
To slightly unbalance everything...
No, but he repositioned himself.
He did the work as anyone else could have done.
I find it was more noticeable in these two matches.
Tonight, they must have run 7 or 8 miles less.
Is it going to be him?
I don't know.
Don't rush into the rooms because sometimes you might be surprised.
At halftime, it was 5.
At game time, it was 5.
It was 5 kilometers less.
It was 50 to 55.
They're running less too, perhaps, tonight.
Because they were better organized defensively.
So, you're doing fewer big shopping trips.
7-8, it's still starting to...
Still, it interests me.
Because there comes a moment when you still have to run.
What are you saying?
Is that his fault or not?
That's how the team is made up.
It's like the stories about Kamavinga, who is to blame.
That is, the way the team is composed.
There are a few players who wanted it.
Naturally integrating Mbappé, who was the cornerstone of the project.
Nobody was there.
Almost nobody.
I'm not saying to give all the keys to the coach.
At least.
I find it difficult to say
Mbappé, he's going to be the star of my team.
even though there were still some stars who were there
and those who won without him.
It wasn't the same team.
When Thierry Henry arrived at Barcelona,
He is not the superstar.
They know there is a team in place.
He tunes in with the team.
Neymar, in the same spirit,
He doesn't show up saying, "It's me, the superstar."
He arrives saying, "I'm going to play for the team."
Here, we arrive, we put it on.
He may not be the sole responsible person.
We put it on saying now
all the others who have won without him,
He is the star, and you are going to play for him.
Hervé, Johan, simply,
if you have a little memory,
Modric and Kroos were not replaced.
Carvajal as well.
I'm referring to what Sébastien was telling us
at the beginning of the broadcast
About an hour ago,
One of the three stars must
Agree to play on a different register.
Tonight, you have won the match
and the implication of Mellingham.
Wait, I'm not done yet.
Is it the coach's job?
to establish hierarchies
and to make a star understand
To all those who have won
What are you playing for him?
You have to say Mbappé,
Everyone.
For example, one has often spoken
from Vinicius and Mbappé.
One can assess the technical relationship,
No problem.
But it happens that they get along very well.
Mbappé really likes Vinicius.
And Vinicius really likes Mbappé.
There are more problems with Mbellingham
who is less liked by these two.
Yes, because we also used to say
what about what you're saying
It bothers them to make the effort.
for the others.
Frankly, Vinicius and Mbappé,
There is no problem.
After Vinicius, I think it's more
The Ballon d'Or and relative failure.
The race for the Ballon d'Or has affected him.
We can discuss anything.
But that's just how it is.
Bellingham, you're pointing at the behavior
for several years now, Mbappé
And you certainly have the right to have your opinion.
Mellingham, for example, is a boy
who is causing problems in the England team
to such an extent that at one point,
You manage the team's departure.
because of the behavior,
even outside the field,
is not necessarily satisfactory.
Or, as part of the England team,
There are many good players,
but the must-sees,
There aren't that many.
Mbellingham should play every day.
I do not deny the fact that Mbappé
In a group, it's not easy to manage.
I completely agree with you.
But I think it's not just him.
And I think a boy like Mbellingham,
Even a boy like Rodrigo,
That was very problematic.
Can you explain it to me?
all possible reasoning,
but actually, them,
They won without him.
But they won with Kroos and Modric.
And with someone else.
No, and with someone else.
And with another coach.
It was Bachmanaman who said it.
in a recent podcast,
When you are the coach of Real Madrid,
He did play for Real Madrid, after all.
the strong point, in quotation marks
It is the players who decide.
A coach like Carlo Ancelotti,
He, what he had, he had intelligence
to listen to his stars, his top players,
just as Zidane had it, more than Benitez
for example, when Benitez was the coach.
Last year he was there, Ancelotti.
Two years ago.
Ancelotti, last year.
So, since his name is Ancelotti,
He has the intelligence to listen to his players.
And that is crucial.
Today, you take Xabi Alonso,
The difficulty he had, himself, is stupid.
because he's really a coach
what we wanted to see at Real Madrid,
It's that he imposes his choices.
My friends, a small archive we've come across
while he is still a player for Paris Saint-Germain,
March 5, 2023.
Kylian Mbappé talks about his relationship
with Paris Saint-Germain.
Then, the famous deadline— we're in 2023.
Paris has not yet lifted the AC1.
Listen to what the Kix tells us.
I think that if I read my future
in the Champions League, and I'm not missing out
Out of respect for the club, I would have left a long time ago.
What he had told us, the Kix.
We forget the context, actually.
When we isolate something, we forget the context.
With all that has been said, I would like to add one name,
It's Courtois.
Put a guardian with him.
We forget, that is to say, we isolate.
It is not an individual sport.
Give him a racket, and he'll win.
But Courtois, he was there last year, wasn't he?
Yes, but almost not this year.
So you're changing, there's no more Maudritch,
There's nothing left, whatever it was.
They're not the same guys anymore.
You tell me he's winning, but we can't.
It's Courtois who has been making their results for a long time.
You no longer have the same Courtois as two seasons ago.
You are telling us
that a player does not win a season
all by himself in the Champions League.
He needs a team; that's pretty much the message.
Do you think they have a team?
Occasionally.
Tonight, they have a team.
But they don't have a team every week.
Otherwise, they wouldn't be stuck.
That still makes a big difference.
They also associated a central defender.
with many injuries,
with very important players, unfortunately.
No, I'm not looking for excuses.
We can go back to the sentence.
The phrase, for example
It blows up in his face, of course.
But as for us,
if we bring up things from two years ago,
I imagine there are things that could blow up in our faces.
He is part of the team.
Coming up with something like that is a terrible absurdity.
I agree.
You're laughing.
One often sees it.
Yes, we bring it out now.
Because PSG won.
It's normal.
When he takes it out,
I found that outrageous.
It went by like that.
It has been discussed quite a bit.
You already.
It's normal that we bring it out.
He's leaving for a team,
He no longer earns anything.
A team that doesn't win, he wins.
It's the problem of everyone else.
It's normal to have raw results.
It's no use.
Why don't you have any results?
If you don't have the same team,
if you don't have the same coach,
You don't get the same results.
Dembélé was indeed in Barcelona.
He was in Barcelona.
Did he win the Champions League with Barcelona?
No.
He won it with PSG.
It can happen.
It's too easy.
You're talking about not individualizing.
You're reducing the Real's result too much.
simply because Mbappé is
the symbol
I'm going to get straight to the point.
With Mbappé,
One can have a mindset.
oriented toward the collective?
The fact that he is extremely talented,
extremely fierce,
extremely individualistic
Does it put a small virus?
in the team's mindset?
The virus,
It could be just a series of penalties away.
He has two titles, two world champions.
Yeah, we're talking about a club.
If it works in a team,
If you are twice a world champion,
It still means that you are capable.
He's missing something.
whether we like it or not.
I tend not to understand
so much criticized.
But he's missing something.
it is that he is not, for the moment,
training with the entire team.
For example, what happens to generate
Lionel Messi in Argentina
Where are the guys who are ready?
to do anything at all.
I think they would accept.
I'll break your leg,
Messi scored a brace,
The guys accept.
It's because there's the aura of a long career,
but there is also
The player's aura that brings others along
with him. And that, for now,
He was not able to do it.
The question is interesting.
Do you train the others?
Isn't he lacking this simplicity?
It's not simple. It never was.
As soon as he was 17, he hoped
be the best player in the world.
I'm not saying the opposite,
But that's what he is. He is Mbappé today.
At this level, he is capable of scoring as many goals
because that's just how he is.
Otherwise, you wouldn't have Mbappé.
So he will always remain, one might say, a solidifier.
Actually, it's going to be a fantastic solo performance,
but a cursed soloist.
Indeed, he has that project right in front of him.
He has that construction site right in front of him.
It's been years since we've been talking about this.
For the moment, it hasn't changed.
He is 28 years old.
It's been years since we've been talking about this.
It has not yet evolved or changed.
It has not evolved or changed.
He has not yet provided sufficient evidence at this stage.
that he could coach a team.
