Shohei Ohtani s Most Important Skill

Baseball Channel
134 followers
Record-setting contract, MVP, 50-50, World Series, that was last year for Shohei Ohtani,
but this will be the year that he pitches again. And whenever Shohei Ohtani is a two-way player,
he ends up playing more baseball than anybody else. Between 2021 and 2023, he averaged 635
plate appearances per year as a hitter and faced 575 batters on average as a pitcher.
That adds up to a little over 1,200 batter-pitcher matchups per year.
So in a league where the hardest-working pitcher will face 800-some-odd batters this year and the
hardest-working hitter will take 700-something plate appearances, Shohei Ohtani could reasonably
expect to have 1,200. This video is about how he does it, and it's not just saying,
oh my gosh, he's an alien, oh my gosh, he's a robot. This is like an actual,
concrete, provable skill that he has that will allow him to integrate pitching back into his
workload in 2025. The answer is energy allocation and expenditure. And don't worry, if that sounds
boring, we're going to make this video really exciting, really fun, really jazz it up. We're
going to look at a spreadsheet. If Ohtani is indeed a robot or android, that means he still
has a battery. And the analog we're going to use for battery life here is his fastball velocity.
So first and foremost, here's a look at times through the order. In the green here, we have
Ohtani. In the blue, we have the MLB average. This is for 2021 through 2023. And the reason
I've put together this spreadsheet is not to show you that Shohei Ohtani throws a baseball
harder than the average MLB starter. You know that already. As you can see, his numbers up top
in terms of velocity are typically three or four miles per hour faster. It's about the energy
allocation and expenditure. We can see the first time through the order, Shohei is throwing 96.1
miles per hour on average. The MLB average for a starter, 93.6. By the time we get the third time
through the order, you can see that the MLB starter doesn't really change their average
velocity at all. It goes 93.6, 93.4, 93.4. The velocity is flat. The graph is unchanged. What
Shohei Ohtani does is he ramps it up a little. He likes to ramp it up a little. He likes to go 96.7
second time, 96.9 third time through the order. This, of course, has corresponding WOBA values
as well. Now, WOBA is just condensing the triple slash let's average on base and slugging into one
number. The average is going to be about what the league average on base percentage is, which is
always around 320-ish. 320 is going to be the average here. You can see that according to the
MLB average, the WOBA of a hitter increases first time, second time, and especially third time
through the order. We see a 11 point bump between the first and the second time and a 16 point bump
between the second and third time. This is when we start to get into the category of the third
time through the order penalty. Even then, the penalty doesn't look as harsh on this graph
because by the time you get to the 2020s, a lot of pitchers aren't allowed to face the third time
through the order to begin with because this penalty exists. You're kind of filtering out
for pitchers having bad days or bad pitchers. Only good pitchers get to face the third time
through the order extensively at the very least. Shohei Ohtani, meanwhile, because he's throwing
harder as he goes deeper into the game, does not have to worry about this penalty at all. In fact,
he has a jump up the first time through the order to the second time through the order,
so he's at a 284 WOBA from a 254 first time, but then he actually goes back down to 272
third time through the order WOBA, so he generally tends to be about the same throughout the game
in terms of his effectiveness first, second, and third time through the order, and that bucks the
trend of the MLB average, and that is because to counteract sort of the familiarity that the
hitter is gaining each time they face Shohei Ohtani in the game, he is ramping up the fastball velo,
ramping up his effectiveness as the game goes along. That is part of the energy expenditure
and allocation. This next tab is base runners, so we see Ohtani versus the MLB average in terms of
bases empty, runners on base, and RISP, aka runners in scoring position. So when the bases are empty,
Shohei Ohtani's established baseline velocity is going to be 96.1 MPH compared to the MLB average,
which is 93.5. If we skip ahead just to runners in scoring position here, the MLB average is 93.8.
We can see just across the board there's not a big change in terms of fastball velocity
with or without runners on base or with runners in scoring position, so there's not much of a
change there in terms of the quality of the fastball in terms of the velocity. For Ohtani,
meanwhile, if he gets a runner on base, he's going to ramp it up a little bit. He's going to add 0.8
MPH from that 96.1 baseline with the runners on base, and he's going to add a tick and a half from
that 96.1 baseline with runners in scoring position. With runners in scoring position, Shohei Ohtani
averages 97.6 MPH on his fastball. That is intentional. That's not him getting amped up
or anything. That's him establishing an intentionally low baseline so that he can go above it when he
really needs to and when it matters in terms of run prevention and when it matters in terms of
winning the game versus losing the game. That's what Ohtani is all about, and the WOBA corresponds
with this as well. So you can see with the bases empty, the bases empty WOBA across the league 2021
and 2023. 3.13, it's 3.26 with runners on, 3.22 with runners in scoring position, so the hitters
do get a little bit better with runners on and with runners in scoring position. This is, again,
kind of a filtering thing that's happening, right? Like a pitcher that allows a base runner is doing
worse than a pitcher who doesn't allow a base runner, and so you may also lose the ability to
shift or move in filters around in some cases. So what's going to happen is hitters will tend to be
more effective with runners on than with runners empty, bases empty. Ohtani, not the case. With
bases empty, hitters average a 2.76 WOBA against him. It's 2.58 with runners on and 2.33 with
runners in scoring position. This sounds like clutch, right? This sounds like he's clutch,
but what he's really doing is establishing a low baseline so that he can go above that baseline
when he really needs to. You can also look at this escalation in terms of the number of outs
in any given inning because the more outs there are in an inning, the higher the leverage potential
there is, right? If you get into a situation, let's say Shohei Ohtani's in the sixth inning,
there's two outs, the team is threatening to score, the leverage is going to be high in that
because it's either get that out or you're allowing runs, right? So there is an escalation
there even based on the out state. So in MLB, there is a similar escalation. They're adding
0.6 MPH between pitchers with zero outs and pitchers with two outs in the inning. Again,
that's kind of filtering some as well because a pitcher who gets pulled in the middle of the
inning is going to get replaced by a reliever and that reliever comes in with two outs. You
understand it. You're going to throw harder basically. Good pitchers get to two outs and
they throw harder because they get to three outs, they finish the inning. Hopefully that makes
sense. For Ohtani, there is a larger escalation, right? So if the MLB pitcher adds between zero
outs and two outs, 0.6 MPH, he doubles that out. He goes from 95.8 to 97 flat. That is plus 1.2
MPH between zero outs in the inning and two outs in the inning. The Woba corresponds as well. He's
when there's two outs in the inning. That's when he wants to get out of that inning and that's all
about the energy allocation and expenditure. So we've looked at his ability to ramp it up based
on times through the order or runners on base or outs in the inning, but he can even do it
on an even smaller, finer level than that. This is within the count fastball velocity. So if we
establish his velocity at 96 MPH on 0-0, so the first pitch of an at bat, he's at 96. MLB is at
93.1. By the time he gets to two strikes, he has added about two MPH. That's 97.9 MPH. MLB,
meanwhile, average has only added one MPH when it comes to making that two strike pitch. I guess the
point I'm trying to make here is you will get Shohei Ohtani's strikeout pitch when he's in a
situation. He will not throw you the strikeout pitch unless he's ready to strike you out. He's
not going to throw you that on 0-0. That would be a waste of energy. And this is about using that
energy efficiently in terms of run prevention and in terms of getting your team in a position to win
the game. And you can see big split here between himself and MLB in terms of the 0-0 average Woba
and the two strike average Woba. So if you manage to swing and put Shohei Ohtani's fastball in play,
you will do better than if you do that against the league average fastball,
even though his is still three MPH higher. That said, for MLB, the gap in terms of fastballs
decreases from 400 to 236. So that's a 160-170 point decrease between 0-0 and two strikes.
For Ohtani, that's more like a 260-270 point decrease because he's going from 439 to 173.
So very effective with two strikes. That's because you're getting a nastier strikeout pitch
above the baseline. To get an idea of how Ohtani can be two different pitchers, one that's working
really hard and one that isn't, we can take a look at this by combining some of the situations we've
talked about. Times through the order, runners on base, outs in the inning, count. So here's
the situations we're looking at here. We're establishing his baseline performance at first
time through the order. Base is empty, a 0-0 count, zero outs. So basically, the first pitch
he throws in any given inning, first time through the order. And then the clutch moment. So these
are the moments later on in the game where he might need to ramp it up. So that's going to be
second or third time through the order. That's going to be runners on base. That's going to be
two strike counts, and that's going to be one or two outs in the inning. The sample sizes for these
is quite similar, by the way. That's what I found, and that's why I ended up going with these
criteria. So here he is versus Major League Baseball in terms of the fastball velocities,
right? So in the baseline situation, the average MLB starter is going to throw 92.7,
and in the clutch situation, they're going to throw 94.1. So they're going to add 1.4 miles
per hour. For Otani, he's starting at a 94.5 baseline and going up to 98.3 in the clutch. So
he's adding almost four miles per hour on average on his fastball. So obviously the increase for him
is much greater, and that's kind of what I'm trying to illustrate here. It's the idea that
Otani is able to be whatever level of pitcher he needs to be given the situation, whereas your
typical MLB starter is really only going to have one mode. Otani has several, and that's what
separates him from the pack, and that's what allows him to use his energy efficiently, and that's what
allows him to hit, essentially. That is the argument I'm putting forth here. It's not just fastball
velocity. That's what we've looked at so far here. I want to talk about the sweeper. So the sweeper in
the baseline situation for Otani, he's throwing at 82.4 MLB average, and the baseline is 81.4.
In the clutch situation, he's going up to 85.2, whereas MLB average is 82.6. That means the MLB
pitcher throwing his sweeper in the clutch situation is adding 1.2 miles per hour above
baseline, and that Shohei Otani is adding 2.8 miles per hour, over two and a half mile per
hour difference between the baseline and the clutch, but it's not just that. It's not just
throwing the sweeper harder. It's throwing the sweeper nastier, and that's what we're talking
about here. That's what we're talking about two different modes of pitching for Shohei Otani. He
can cruise at the baseline, and then he will get you out when he really needs to. So at the baseline
horizontal movement, he and the MLB average are the same. They're averaging about just under 14
inches of horizontal break, of sweep, of glove side sweep on that sweeper in the baseline situation.
In the clutch situation, it's still the same basically for MLB. Still about 14 inches,
whereas Shohei is up to 16 inches. So not only is he throwing it 2.8 miles per hour harder,
he's adding 2.3 inches of horizontal sweep. It's not just throwing it harder. He's throwing it
nastier. I think that's a great illustration. So I've looked through at even Stuff Plus for some
of these pitches. You know, I looked at T.J. Nestico, Thomas Nestico's Stuff Plus calculator
for this. I will put a link down in the description. His is different from, you know, let's
say Eno Saris's model, so I'll be sure to explain the difference, but essentially at the baseline,
both of these were at 99. So assuming, you know, at baseline, they're throwing a league average
slider slash sweeper. For Shohei Otani, his Stuff Plus is going up to a 123 in the clutch situation.
Now, the standard deviation for Thomas's Stuff Plus calculator is 12. So he's moving up 12
standard deviations. Basically, the way I would sum this up is I would say at the baseline,
he's throwing an average sweeper, and in the clutch situation, he's throwing like a top 2%
or 3% sweeper in the league. And you're just not seeing that increase across the MLB average,
and that's what makes him special. Otani's ability to ramp it up when he needs to really
calls into question the definition of clutch, because truth be told, when it comes to hitters,
I don't really believe in clutch as a repeatable skill. I don't really think there's a hitter out
there that can overperform their baseline performance in higher leverage situations
across a large and healthy sample size. I don't really think that exists. I think being
clutch is simply being good and then being as good as you normally are in the clutch situation.
But a starting pitcher can simulate clutch by setting an intentionally lower baseline performance
and then greatly exceeding that baseline when the moment calls for it, and nobody does that better
than Shohei Otani. I promise you, dear sweet viewer at home, this ad read will only take
words. Seek eek. Code. Foolish. Admittedly, that first word is a compound word.
