Every Scottish Monarch From Kenneth I To James Vi | A Brief History Of The Scottish Monarch 848-1625

What Was The Life
13 followers
Apr 15, 2026
A ninth son who took the crown, a baby killer, a queen who became a saint,
a king who got murdered in a sewer by his own subjects, and many more.
Before Scotland joined with England to form Great Britain, it was ruled by a long and dramatic line
of monarchs, some heroic, some infamous, some almost forgotten, and a shocking number of whom
came to horribly violent ends. In this documentary from History Calling,
I explore every Scottish king and queen between Kenneth MacAlpin and James VI,
tracing the full history of the Scottish crown across more than 750 years of war,
intrigue and legacy, from the 9th century AD to the year 1625.
You'll hear about powerful rulers like Robert the Bruce, the supposed freedom fighter who
became a national icon, and I'll even show you a replica of his skull.
The tragic Margaret Maid of Norway, whose early death sparked a succession crisis,
James IV, whose marriage to Margaret Tudor laid the groundwork for uniting the thrones
of Scotland and England, and Mary Queen of Scots, whose escapades ended in execution.
From medieval power struggles to royal scandals and the eventual union of the crowns,
this is the complete royal story of Scotland, told one monarch at a time.
Before we start, I should say that it was tricky to actually know where to begin with the Scottish
monarchs. Unlike in England, there isn't a very clear event, like the Battle of Hastings in 1066,
to demarcate a completely new and single royal dynasty with a clear line of succession,
which can be used as a jumping off point. What is now Scotland was, in the deep past,
not a single administrative unit, and was instead divided up into various mini-kingdoms
with different rulers, some of which you'll hear about in a minute.
The process of these units combining into one kingdom was slow and messy.
The surviving sources are often few and far between, and leave a lot to be desired in
terms of what they tell us, and as a result, there were arguments for beginning this video
with lots of different kings. In the interests of not being here for a month, however,
I had to pick one, and that's what I've done. I'm sure some people won't like who I chose,
as they'll think I should have begun even earlier, but by the end of the video,
I don't think you'll be able to say that you were short-changed and that I didn't look at
an awful lot of Scottish history for you, though of course I can only very briefly
summarise each monarch's life for you here. Thankfully, the decision about where to stop,
with James VI, the last monarch who was, for a time, King of Scotland only,
was much easier to make. There were also no contemporary images for the earlier kings,
so I've sometimes had to resort to stock images or footage to make up the shortfall,
which I hope you'll forget. If you're interested in the monarchs of England from 1066 up to 1603,
and of Britain from 1603 to the present day, I'll leave my videos on them linked below for you,
and also remind you about them in the end cards when I finish this video.
If you'd like to look at the book I used as my main source for this episode,
and learn much more about the Scottish monarchs than I can tell you here,
it's edited by Richard Oram, it's entitled The Kings and Queens of Scotland,
and I've linked it in the description box for you and added it to my Amazon storefront.
I'm also providing a review of it to my historical figure and time traveller patrons this week,
which you can find by joining one of those tiers on my Patreon site at
patreon.com forward slash history calling, also linked below.
Alright, let's begin our list.
The first monarch I'm introducing you to is Kenneth Magalpin, otherwise known as Kenneth I.
Born in 810, he ruled over the kingdom of Dalriada from about 840,
then became king of another group known as the Picts in 848, before dying in 858.
Having combined these earlier two kingdoms together, he is generally acknowledged as
the first king of Scotland, though there was actually still a long way to go
before it would become the country we know and love today, and for many years yet,
the rulers you're about to hear about are referred to in contemporary annals
as kings of the Picts or of Alba.
Kenneth's successor was his brother Donald I, born about 812, and who reigned from 858 until 862.
We know next to nothing about him, though he was renowned as a great warrior.
The next ruler was Kenneth I's son, Constantine I, born in around 836.
His reign, following that of his uncle rather than his father, highlights the fact that in
this era, the succession was not yet based on the idea of the crown passing from father to son.
What was really important was being an adult male and part of the royal family,
but even then, the rules were flexible.
Constantine died in 877, fighting off invaders from Dublin.
Then came his brother Hugh, another son of Kenneth I.
We don't know when he was born, though the 830s seem like a good guess,
and he ruled from 877 until 878,
when he was killed by his cousin Jerach or Gregory, son of Donald I.
Jerach now took power for 11 years until 889,
and of his life and reign, we know very little,
though he may have shared power with a cousin called Eochid son of Rune, king of Strathclyde.
The pair might have been deposed rather than killed, that's how vague and sparse the sources are,
for in 889, we hear of a new king.
This was Gerach's or Gregory's cousin, Donald II, son of Constantine I.
He reigned until 900.
Again, we don't know when he was born, but he dealt with a number of Viking raids during his reign,
and died it for us in Moray of an unknown cause.
From this point on, we see the crown swinging back and forth a lot
between the descendants of Constantine I and King Hugh,
a situation not unlike the much later Wars of the Roses in England,
when descendants of several of Edward III's sons juked it out for the crown,
and if you know how many of them were actual jukes, you'll know what a pun that was.
I'll leave my playlist on the Wars of the Roses linked for you if you want to learn more about it.
Power now went to Donald II's cousin, Constantine II,
who was the son of Hugh and whose birth year is unknown.
He is notable as the first monarch known as King of Alba rather than the Picts.
Writing in the Oxford Dictionary of National Biography, Dovet Brune says that
Since Alba had hitherto denoted Britain in Gaelic,
this represents an extraordinary change in terminology,
suggesting that the adoption of Alba as the kingdom's name
represented the corning of a radically new identity,
and perhaps signifying an attempt, following a period of disruption and uncertainty between 875
and 889, to establish a new political order based on dynastic kingship.
Constantine also successfully fought off more Viking raiders and reigned until about 943.
Different sources give different years somewhere between 940 and 945.
Whatever the exact dates, this was an unusually long reign,
which provided a level of continuity and stability not hitherto known in nascent Scotland.
But even more strange, though nice for Constantine,
is that he didn't lose his throne because he died or was deposed.
Instead, he abdicated, perhaps due to his age, and became a monk at St Andrews.
Old habits die hard though, and he still engaged in one last raid into England in about 950,
before dying and being buried at St Andrews in 952.
He was succeeded by his cousin, Donald II's son, Malcolm I,
though Malcolm only lasted until 954 when he was killed at Moray and supposedly buried at Iona.
The throne now went to Constantine II's son, Indolf,
who was born about 927 and reigned from 954 until his death in 962,
when he was killed by the Vikings at a place called Invercullen,
which was probably either a cowey or a cullen. He too was supposedly buried at Iona.
Malcolm I's son, Dove, took the reins, ruling for just four years until 966.
Indolf's sons wanted power for themselves, and as a result of the fights that broke out in the
royal family, the king was killed by the men of Moray at Forest. Fun fact, his death apparently
coincided with a solar eclipse on the 20th of July that year.
His successor was Indolf's son, Cullen, who lasted all of five years before being killed.
You'll note that a shocking number of these blokes are getting killed after very short reigns.
This one was wiped out by the son of the king of Strathclyde for having done something
very bad beginning with the letter R to the guy's daughter.
The throne now went to Kenneth II, son of Malcolm I and brother of Dove,
who came to power in 971 and had a fairly lengthy reign, certainly by Scottish standards,
lasting until 995. He is remembered for invading England and taking part in a conference of kings
at Chester in 973, at which the English king, Edgar, was also present.
Quarrels over power led to his murder on the orders of Fenella,
daughter of the Earl of Angus, who was taking revenge on Kenneth for having killed her son.
Next we have Constantine III, known as Constantine the Bald, for what I assume are obvious reasons,
who lasted all of 18 months before being killed by his successor, Kenneth III, in 997.
Constantine was the last ruler to be descended from King Hugh.
Kenneth III was the son of King Dove, who had died back in the summer of 966,
so that at least tells us that Kenneth wasn't born any later than 967,
though we don't know his actual year of birth. He ruled from 997 until 1005,
when he was killed in battle by his cousin, Malcolm. He may have been buried at Iona.
Malcolm II, born in an unknown year to Kenneth II and his Irish wife,
his maternal grandfather may have been the King of Leinster, ruled from 1005 until 1034.
This man was later known as the Aggressor and the Destroyer, which I think gives you a good
insight into his personality, his actions and why he lasted so long in an era when a lot of
kings were struggling to make it even a decade without getting murdered. He has a generally
positive reputation as an effective king, though he had his losses, such as his unsuccessful siege
of Durham in England in 1006 and being forced to submit to King Canute of England, Denmark and
Norway in 1031. He did, however, defeat a Northumbrian army at Carrum-on-the-Tweed in 1018,
alongside his ally, Owen, King of Strathclyde. This meant that Lothian, north of the Tweed,
was now part of Scotland, and when Owen died soon afterwards, possibly of battle wounds,
Malcolm II was able to take Strathclyde too. Scotland's borders as we know them today were
finally taking shape. Malcolm apparently wanted his grandson, Duncan, child of his daughter,
Bethoch, to succeed him, and wiped out a few more relatives to help to clear a path to power for
this young man. Perhaps because of this, there are rumours in later sources that he was assassinated,
but all we know for sure is that he died at Glamis on the 25th of November, 1034.
Now we get to King Duncan I of Shakespeare fame, who was born around 1010 and ruled from 1034
until 1040. The image of him as an old man, presented by Shakespeare in his play Macbeth,
is therefore entirely fictitious. This guy was in his twenties. Macbeth, another man whose
posthumous reputation has been heavily altered by Shakespeare, was the ruler of Moray. His wife,
Gruauch, you may know her as Lady Macbeth, was probably the niece of Malcolm II and granddaughter
of Kenneth II. He and Duncan clashed at Pitcavenny, near Elgin, and Duncan was defeated and killed.
And so we have arrived at the infamous King Macbeth. Born in roughly 1005,
his father was the King of Moray, of which Macbeth became ruler in 1032. He was likely either the
nephew or grandson of Malcolm II, and was the King of Scots from 1040 until his death in 1057.
He faced down numerous threats to his position during that time, including a 1046 rising by
Earl Seward of Northumbria, sponsored by the English King Edward the Confessor. Seward actually
defeated Macbeth and appointed a puppet King of Scotland, who doesn't seem to have control very
much land, but the pretender was overthrown and possibly killed by Macbeth soon after.
The King was secure enough in his position to go on a pilgrimage to Rome in 1050, and he and his
Queen were known patrons of the Church. Gruauch, by the way, is the first Queen Consort of Scotland
whose name is known to us, and her personality, from what we know, was nothing like the scheming
Lady Macbeth's. In medieval Scotland, of course, no one was safe for long, and in 1054, Seward was
back to try again, invading Scotland in support of King Duncan's son, Malcolm Canmore, whom Edward
the Confessor hoped to make a vassal king under his own control, and who was also possibly a
relation of Seward through Duncan's wife. Seward won, though it was something of a pyrrhic victory
that cost the life of his son, among others, and was difficult to capitalise on, with Malcolm not
yet reigning over very much Scottish territory. He kept fighting, though, and on the 15th of August
1057, at the Battle of Lamphannan, he succeeded in defeating and killing Macbeth once and for all.
Malcolm didn't become immediate King of the Scots, however. Instead, Lulac Mac Kilcumgaon,
who was Queen Gruoc's son from her first marriage to the King of Moray, born no later than 1032,
and known as the Unlucky or the Simpleton, was the titular King until Malcolm killed him too
the following March. Malcolm III was the first monarch of the House of Canmore,
and this surname, which began as a nickname and was only given to him centuries later,
means Great Head or Great Chief, and it shows you just how successful he was.
As is the case with so many of the men I've discussed so far, we don't know when he was born,
but his father died in 1040, and he was evidently old enough to assume power in the mid-1050s,
so I would say he was born no later than the mid-1030s. He married Ingeborg in around 1060-1065,
again sources differ, who was the widow or daughter of the Earl of Orkney, and had three
sons by her. She was dead by the end of the decade however, and he remarried in 1069 or 1070
to Margaret, sister of Edgar Aethling, the Anglo-Saxon claimant to the English throne
which had by then fallen to William the Conqueror. She was also the great-niece of the deceased
Edward the Confessor, and a real-life saint. Yes, Queen Margaret of Scotland became a saint,
just like her great-uncle Edward. The couple would have six known sons and two daughters,
with the boys, because realistically girls didn't get to inherit at this point,
having a claim to the English throne thanks to their mother's lineage, which is perhaps why
Malcolm chose their oldest son, not his first boy by Ingeborg, to be his successor.
Partly because of this marriage, relations with the Norman invaders to the south were fraught
of the time, and after King William invaded Scotland in 1072, Malcolm agreed to get rid of
the Anglo-Saxons he was sheltering, apart from his wife of course, and give up his eldest son Duncan
to the King of England as a hostage. Despite this, he still invaded Northumbria in 1079,
though in the end the peace treaty was renewed between Malcolm and King William's son Robert
Curthoes, and as Richard Oram says, though quote, often presented as a defeat for Malcolm,
this settlement marked the high watermark of his power, for, as Robert's hasty building of a castle
at what became Newcastle upon Tyne revealed, Malcolm had successfully pushed his frontier
far to the south. Relations with the new William II were at first good, and Duncan was released
and sent back to Scotland, but it was still the English who would lead to his father's death.
In November 1093, after falling out with King William, Malcolm engaged in a battle with the
English at Northumbria alongside his eldest son by Margaret, named Edward. Both were killed,
and the King's body was initially left lying on the battlefield, though he was later buried at
Tynmouth Prairie, then moved to Dunfermline to lie next to Margaret, who died just days after her
husband and son, then ultimately they both ended up in Madrid of all places, thanks to the efforts
of Philip II of Spain. So much for Margaret's eldest son inheriting the Scottish throne.
Instead, fate favoured Ingeborg's firstborn boy after all, but not quite yet for there was now
a twist in the tale. Instead of one of Malcolm's sons inheriting the crown next,
it went to his brother, King Donald III, known as Donald the Fair, born in or before 1040 and
inaugurated at Scone in early 1094. Some accounts say he seized the throne by laying siege to
Edinburgh Castle and expelling his nephews from the realm, but honestly we know very little of
what really happened. Likewise, we know little about his life before he suddenly became king
in his mid-fifties, except that much of it was spent in Ireland where he had fled to escape
Macbeth. Just months after his accession though, Malcolm and Ingeborg's son, Duncan, born before
1072 and the man who'd spent much of his youth as a hostage in England, invaded with an English
and Norman army at his back and took the throne as Duncan II in May 1094. He was dead in November,
murdered by Melpadere, ruler of Mernes at Mondins near Stonehaven, and supposedly buried on Iona.
Donald III was back in power, and this time he stayed until 1097, at which point he was captured
alongside his nephew Edmund, a son of Malcolm and Margaret who had sided with his uncle against his
siblings in a power move. The pair had been caught by Edmund's younger brother and another of Donald's
nephews, Edgar, who had his brother chained up and ultimately sent to live out his days in a monastery
and his uncle blinded. Donald was supposedly killed in 1107, but we really don't know what
happened to him, though he ended up buried at Dunkeld, then Iona. And so we come to King Edgar,
fourth son of Malcolm and Margaret, and most likely born in the late 1070s. He had gained his
throne with the help of the English and was very much a vassal of Henry I, who took Edgar's sister
Edith, also known as Matilda, as a wife in 1100, probably without Edgar having much say in the
matter. He was described by Elred of Rouveux as sweet and lovable, employing no tyranny,
no harshness, no greed against his people, but ruling his subjects with the greatest charity
and benevolence. His reign was largely peaceful and he died, unmarried and childless, in January
1107. He was buried at Dunfermline and the throne went to his younger brother, Alexander.
King Alexander I was born in the 1070s and was another vassal king of Henry I. He even married
that king's illegitimate daughter, Sibylla, a woman considered immodest by contemporary
chronicler William of Malmesbury and not very pleasing on the eye either. It was clearly a
political union orchestrated by King Henry and the couple had no children. Alexander was also
forced by Henry to allow his, Alexander's, younger brother David to control much of southern Scotland.
He was deeply religious and continued a series of religious reforms instigated by his mother,
Saint Margaret. He died at Stirling in 1124 and was buried in Dunfermline Abbey.
The throne now passed to the aforementioned David, ninth son of Malcolm III and I'd like you to just
let that sink in for a moment because it's not often that a ninth surviving son gets the crown.
Born in about 1084, David I was apparently the one who pushed for the blinding of his
uncle Donald back in the 1090s when he himself would still have only been a teenager, so this
was not a kind and forgiving guy and maybe that's why he lasted so long. He had spent much of his
life in England where his sister Edith slash Matilda was queen remember and was well treated
by his brother-in-law Henry I, who allowed him to marry Matilda de Senelis, dowager countess of
Northampton Huntington and a member of the extended English royal family in 1113. Their son Henry was
born in circa 1115 but would ultimately predecease his father in 1152. Queen Matilda of Scotland had
long since died in 1130. David was very religious and highly anglified after his years in England
and his disdain for the inauguration ritual at Scone which had no church involvement was so
severe that he had to be talked into going through with it. Other notable events in his 29-year reign
included attempts up until the mid 1130s by Alexander's illegitimate son to take the crown
until this man named Malcolm was finally captured. David also responded to these threats by solidifying
his hold over ever more of Scotland through the use of castle building and loyal retainers. He also
periodically supported the ultimately doomed cause of his niece Empress Matilda when she tried to
the English throne after her father Henry I's death in 1135, though he also negotiated
advantageous peace deals with her cousin and rival King Stephen when it suited him. When it seemed
like Matilda was about to be crowned in 1141 however, David travelled south to join her at
her coronation, only for the whole plan to fall apart at the last minute, forcing them to flee.
See my video on Matilda, who is the basis for the character of Queen Rhaenyra Targaryen in
In Scotland itself, things were fairly peaceful from 1138 onwards and David was able to expand
the machinery of royal government and household with the creation of new offices based on the
English model. The economy, church and the law also developed further in his reign,
and he was the first monarch to introduce a home-made Scottish Cornage into his country,
so that the kingdom was in many ways a far better place when he died at Carlisle in 1153
than when this most unlikely of kings had ascended to the throne.
The next monarch was David's eldest grandson Malcolm IV, born in 1141 and so just 12 years
old in 1153, the first of many underage monarchs of Scotland as we'll see. Despite his youth,
there was no formal regency, though real power seems to have lain, at least initially,
with a group of powerful nobles around the king. There were rebellions against the rule of this
child monarch from the children of Alexander I's illegitimate son, the man imprisoned in 1134,
but these came to naught, and perhaps a more serious problem was the pressure from the new
English king, Henry II, who sought lands and homage from Scotland and its king,
which Malcolm had to give. Adding insult to injury was the fact that Henry wouldn't knight
the boy, which was an ardent wish of the young monarch. Malcolm's position as a mere vassal king
was further hammered home when Henry summoned him to do military service in 1159 in France.
Malcolm and his younger brother William willingly went, and he was finally knighted,
but his nobles were furious at the way he had prostrated himself to the king of England and
risked Scotland's independence along the way, and they tried and failed to capture him upon his
return in 1160. The practice of paying homage to Henry continued, and Malcolm even gave his
brother David over as a hostage to England in 1163. Suffering repeated bouts of illness from 1161
onwards, which have since been associated with a disease called Patchett's disease, he died unmarried
in December 1165 and was buried in Dunfermline. The throne now went to his younger brother,
William I of Scotland. He was born in around 1143 and would become Scotland's longest reigning
monarch ever while the kingdom was still separate from the rest of Britain. Having been stripped of
his earldom of Northumberland when he was a teenager in order to satisfy the demands of
Henry II, William was obsessed with getting it back, to the point that he tried to get the king
of France to help him do so in 1168. This enraged Henry and did serious damage to Anglo-Scottish
relations. Still, things had improved enough for William to attend the English court in 1170
and form a friendship with King Henry's son of the same name. When King Henry and his boy fell out,
William decided to try to help the younger man, still hoping to get back his English earldom.
This ultimately resulted in his capture and imprisonment in Normandy in 1174, which was
a serious humiliation for both king and country, as was the treaty he had to agree to, complete
with loss of lands, provision of hostages and confirmation of Scotland's subordinate status to
England in order to secure his freedom. The English king also chose William's wife for him,
Ermengarde de Beaumont, who he wed in England in 1186, though it was 1198 before their son,
Alexander, was born. There were constant domestic threats to the king's power, as other men who felt
they were better suited to the job tried to take it from him. They all failed though, and William
proved effective at strengthening royal power within Scotland, even if he was in other ways a
lapdog of the English king. The humiliating treaty which had secured his freedom in 1174 was annulled
in 1189 for 10,000 marks however, thanks to the wishes of the new king of England, Richard the
Lionheart, who needed the money to go off crusading, and William was finally legally free as well as
physically. William's refusal to initially acknowledge the accession of Richard's younger
brother John in 1199, this is bad Prince John of Robin Hood fame, meant that they had a difficult
relationship from the get-go, and it never became good. John ended up extracting a humiliating
climb-down from King William in 1209, which included the payment of 15,000 marks and the
provision of two of his daughters as hostages to the English to be married off as John saw fit.
William was by now ageing and in poor health, and on the 4th of December 1214, he finally gave up the
ghost at Stirling. King Alexander II, born in 1198, was 16 years old when he became king of Scotland.
Despite his youth, he was smart and ruthless, and as King John's position in England disintegrated,
he was forced to sign Magna Carta in 1215, Alexander took advantage by seizing lands and
This didn't last long though, as when John died in late 1216, the Pope ended up excommunicating
the Scottish king and placing his realm under spiritual interdict until Alexander swore fealty
to the new English king, Henry III. Relations with Henry were nevertheless not bad for many years,
and Alexander married the English king's sister, Princess Joanna, in 1221, though they had no
children and Joanna died during a trip back to England in 1238. Alexander didn't even bother
having her body brought back to Scotland for burial. He remarried to the French Marie de Courcy in 1239,
and their son, named after his father, was born in 1241. One notable sign of Alexander's vicious
personality was his brutal suppression of uprisings against him in the Highlands,
which included having the last member of the troublesome McWilliam family
killed, an infant girl whose brains were dashed out according to Oram. He eventually died in 1249
as he fought to bring what are now the Scottish Isles, but which were then in Norwegian hands,
under his control. The rumour was that Saint Columba, protector of the Isles, had finished him
off. The crown passed to his young son by Marie, Alexander III, then eight years old, and on the
26th December 1251, still only ten years old, he was married off to Henry III's daughter, Margaret,
at York. Their daughter, also called Margaret, would eventually be born in 1261, then their son
Alexander in 1264, and another son named David in 1273. It is a later account of his inauguration
at Scone in 1249, by the way, which provides the earliest evidence we have for the use of the
famous Stone of Scone, aka the Stone of Destiny, being in use for that ceremony.
Alexander III went through several regents as the Scottish Barons fought for power over the
young king and the country, and was even kidnapped by one faction in October 1257.
He came through it all though, and took personal control in 1260. The remainder of his reign was
marked by fights with the Norwegians over control of what are now the Scottish Isles,
excluding Orkney and Shetland, with Scottish control already by then in place, confirmed by
the Treaty of Perth in 1266. Queen Margaret died in 1275, Prince David in 1280, and Princess
Margaret was married off to King Eric of Norway in 1281, though he was seven years her junior,
but then she too died giving birth to her daughter, another Margaret, in 1283. The king's heir,
Prince Alexander, died too in 1284. The Scottish succession now hung on the life of the little
Princess Margaret of Norway, the king's only legitimate grandchild. He did remarry in 1285
to Jolande of Drew, and apparently a ghost appeared at the wedding feast, I kid you not,
and the marriage therefore seemed doomed. As he was riding home to her at Kinghorn in Fife in
1286, in the pitch black and deteriorating weather, he became separated from his companions
and it appears that his horse stumbled and threw him, breaking his neck. His body was found the
next day. The result of this unexpected death was chaos for Scotland. The new monarch was
Alexander's infant granddaughter, Margaret, known to history as the Maid of Norway, but hers is a
tragic story. Her mother had died at or around her birth, her father was only turning 15 at that
time, and little Margaret was under the control of the Norwegian magnates. As the nominal Queen
of Scotland in her own right at the age of three, she was never crowned or inaugurated, which was
very important at this time, so you can argue amongst yourselves as to whether you think she
deserved the title of Queen, she was a desirable heiress, and her great-uncle Edward I of England
wanted her to marry his son-in-air and thus unite the crowns of the northern and southern kingdoms.
There are real shades here of some early plans for another infant female monarch, Mary Queen of
Scots, 250 years later. A council was put in place to rule Scotland on Margaret's behalf,
and it was arranged in 1290 that she was to travel to her kingdom, where various interested
parties were angling to get her married off into their families. Sadly, little Margaret,
then aged seven, died on the trip, apparently on the Isle of Orkney. Her body was taken back
to Norway and buried. It was the end of the House of Canmore. Enter the houses of Belial and Bruce,
and an incredibly turbulent time for Scotland. John I of the House of Belial was born in 1249,
probably in England, where his paternal family was from, think of Belial College Oxford,
which was founded by his father. His mother was Scottish, and through her he was the great-grandson
of William I's brother, Earl David of Huntingdon, through David's eldest daughter.
This made him the next heir to the throne after little Margaret of Norway died,
but he had rivals, the Bruces, who were descended from Earl David's second daughter,
again, serious similarities to the English Wars of the Roses here.
The Scots looked to Edward I of England to mediate a solution for them,
and he exploited the situation by making all the various claimants who weren't him
declare that he was overlord of Scotland. A legal hearing to decide on the next king
dragged on from 1291 to 1292, during which Scotland was stuck in an interregnum.
Finally, Edward decided in favour of Belial, whose reign is dated from November 1292 onwards.
As with so many Scottish monarchs, it didn't last long,
and it also resulted in abject humiliation for the king and his realm.
Having refused to bend to the English king's demands for fealty in military service,
and tried to make a French alliance instead, Scotland was invaded by the English in 1296.
John ended up surrendering to Edward and being forced to abdicate, and he, his son,
and the famous Stone of Scone, upon which all Scottish monarchs were inaugurated,
were taken back to London. The stone was not returned until 1996, and you can hear its
incredible story of survival in my video all about it, which I'll link below for you.
John was locked up in the Tower of London until 1299,
then eventually allowed to live in exile in France, where he died in around 1313.
His reputation was ruined, and he is known to history as Tomb Tabard, meaning Empty Surcoat.
His fall caused another interregnum, this time lasting from 1296 until 1306,
during which Scotland was ruled by a council on behalf of Edward I of England.
We now come to Robert the Bruce, one of Scotland's most famous kings.
Born in 1274, he had family connections to Ireland as well as Scotland,
and spent considerable portions of his life in England too.
His first wife was Isabel, daughter of the Earl of Marr, whom he married in 1296,
and with whom he had a daughter called Marjorie. Isabel was dead by 1297 though.
His sister was also the wife of Eric II of Norway.
When John Belial fell and Robert saw his country was going to be
run as an occupied Plantagenet province, to quote Oram,
rather than given to him as a vassal king, he decided to try to take the crown.
However, despite years of pursuing this goal, by the turn of the 14th century,
he had still not attained it, and ended up on the run much of the time from Edward I,
his occasional ally, with whom he was on good enough terms again by 1302
to be allowed to marry Elizabeth de Bourgh, daughter of the Earl of Ulster,
and obtain promises that King Edward would support his claims to be King of Scotland.
This was an uneasy alliance with Edward though, and Robert evidently realised at some point
that he would never be king at this rate unless he forced his English neighbour's hand.
Still, his actual route to the throne was very messy.
He murdered another prominent Scottish magnate, John Comyn of Badnach,
in the Church of the Greyfriars in Dumfries on the 10th of February 1306,
and the only way to avoid justice from either King Edward or Comyn's supporters
was to declare himself king. He was duly inaugurated on the 25th of March at Scone.
The English king came after him immediately, and Robert ended up fleeing into the Highlands
while his female relations were sent to the supposed safety of Kildromie Castle,
where they were captured by the English and some of them locked in iron cages,
though not Queen Elizabeth despite what the movie Outlaw King starring Chris Pine and Florence Pugh
shows. Robert staged an epic comeback however, and managed to repeatedly defeat his Scottish
and English enemies over the course of the next few years, and was even able to call a parliament
in 1309. In 1314 he defeated the English forces at Bannockburn, recovered his queen and daughter,
and sealed his place in Scottish history as one of their favourite kings. He's less popular where
I'm from for having invaded the north of Ireland and declared his brother the High King of the
Island in 1316. As well as two daughters, he and Elizabeth had twin boys in 1324, of whom one,
named David, survived, and the queen died in 1327. With England in turmoil after Isabella of France
deposed her husband Edward III, Robert seized the opportunity to attack, and eventually forced
peace in 1328, which included recognition of Scottish sovereignty, English assistance in
lifting his excommunication by the Pope, and marriage of his heir to Edward's sister Princess
Joan. The king's health was now failing, it looks as though he had leprosy, and he died in 1329.
The crown now passed to the orphaned five-year-old David II. He is notable as the first king crowned
in a papally recognised religious service in 1331, but he faced a rival in the shape of Edward
Balliol, son of John, who was born in around 1283, lived much of his life in various states of
imprisonment or exile, but came to Scotland in 1332 and had himself crowned at Scone.
Although the Scots got rid of him, he returned with an English army and won the throne in 1333,
becoming Edward III's vassal king. The child king, David meanwhile, went into exile in France in 1334,
along with his little wife Joan and his sisters. Back home, his supporters recovered much of his
lands, but took a great deal for themselves as well. David was back aged 17 in 1341,
and spent the next few years building up his power base, but he was defeated,
injured and captured during an invasion of England in 1346 and sent to the Tower of London.
It was 1357 before he was released and allowed back to Scotland,
by which point Edward Balliol had been ousted and died in 1364. He was separated from his
childless queen, who remained in England and died in 1362. He remarried to his mistress,
Margaret Logie in 1363, but they had no children and the marriage broke down within five years.
Attempts to have it annulled so he could remarry did not come to fruition before his own death
of natural causes at Edinburgh Castle in 1371. We now come to, I think, the most famous Scottish
royal house of them all, and the one which will take us to the end of the video, the Stuarts.
David II's successor was his half-nephew, Robert II, born in about 1316 to Robert the Bruce's
daughter, Princess Marjorie, and her husband, Walter, 6th High Steward, with a D, not a T,
of Scotland. Married firstly to Elizabeth Muir, who had died in 1355, he had four sons,
plus daughters by her, and more children by his second wife, Euphemia, Dowager Countess of Moray,
whom he married that same year. He married these children into the great Scottish houses,
and the sons also proved adept at seizing plenty of land for themselves,
seemingly strengthening his position even more. However, serious problems arose when his boys got
too big for their boots and couldn't be reined in, and in 1384, his eldest, John Earl of Carrick,
effectively deposed him and took over as lieutenant. A disastrous campaign against
the English later, and Carrick was kicked out in 1388 in favour of his brother, Robert Earl of Fife.
King Robert, now just a puppet king to his son, died in 1390, his queen having pre-deceased him
a couple of years earlier. Robert III was born around 1336 or 1337 under the name John,
and was Robert II and Elizabeth Muir's eldest son. He was the Earl of Carrick I mentioned a minute
ago in fact, who forcibly took, then lost, the position of his father's lieutenant.
He married David II's niece by marriage, Annabella Drummond, in about 1367. Despite the embarrassing
loss of the lieutenancy to his younger brother, the Earl of Fife, John ascended to the throne
anyway in 1390 and changed his name to Robert to match his deceased father's, and also confusingly,
that of his brother, the aforementioned Lord Fife. Notable events in his reign included the decision
to make his son and heir the Duke of Rothesay, after the Stuart's ancestral home, which is still
the title the heir to the throne holds in Scotland to this day. This son then sought to usurp the
father's power, just as the king had once done to his own father, by becoming the monarch's
lieutenant and using his parent almost as a puppet. This really didn't work out. Prince David,
Duke of Rothesay, was eventually arrested by his paternal uncle, the former Earl of Fife,
now the Duke of Albany, in 1401, soon after Queen Annabella's death, and starved to death
in Falkland Palace in March 1402. King Robert had agreed to the arrest and raised no public
objection to his son's death, saying it was divine providence. His heir was now his second son,
James, but he was captured by the English in March 1406, and his father died just days later.
James I, born in 1394, was just 11 years old when he became king, and spent the first chunk of his
reign as a prisoner of the English, while his realm was managed by his uncle Albany,
the guy who killed James' big brother, and then, after Albany's death in 1420, by his son,
James' cousin, Murdoch. The Scots wouldn't take any orders from him given his compromised position,
not to mention his age, and this unsatisfactory state of affairs would continue for 18 years,
until James was finally ransomed, released and returned to Scotland in 1424, complete with an
English wife, Joan Beaufort, niece of the Duke of Exeter. They would have one surviving son,
named after his father. His return was not a happy family reunion. He had Murdoch and several
other Albany family members executed in order to secure his own power base, and soon alienated his
people by his lavish spending and the taxes that this, along with the need to raise money to pay
for his ransom, required. He secured grand marriages for his daughters into major European
royal houses, and tried, with limited success, to broaden his authority in the Scottish highlands
and islands. A botched attack on the English-held castle of Roxburgh in 1436 deepened his unpopularity,
and eventually it was one of the factors which led to him being assassinated on the 21st of February
1437 at the Dominican convent at Perth. Having heard the would-be killers coming to get him,
James tried to flee for his life in a sewer tunnel which had unfortunately for him been
recently blocked up at the far end to prevent the loss of balls from his tennis courts,
and so his assailants found him pinned down in what was literally for him a dead-end situation.
They stabbed him to death, so ending a technically quite long but fairly dismal reign.
James II was born in 1430, the survivor of a set of twins, and came to the throne after his
father's murder, aged just six. The Scots really did have a shocking number of underage monarchs.
His mother, Queen Joan, was wounded in the attack which killed her husband, but escaped and was able
to rally support for herself and her child, ensuring that the conspirators who killed James I
were executed. A lieutenant-general, a bit like a regent, was named in the form of James II's
cousin, Archibald, 5th Earl of Douglas. He was the closest adult male relative little James had
in Scotland, but he died of plague in 1439, the same year Queen Joan was temporarily locked up
for remarrying without permission. She would die in 1445. Three major families, the Creightons,
the Livingstons and the Douglases, duked it out for power in Scotland for years afterwards,
with the latter two eventually becoming the most dominant. The King, who was known as Fieryface
because of a red birthmark on his left cheek, made a spectacular marriage in 1441 to the very well
connected Mary of Gelders, daughter of the Duke of Gelders and niece of Philip, Duke of Burgundy.
The Livingstons' lands were forfeited in favour of the Douglases and the Queen in early 1450,
then Douglas' lands were seized the following year, and James ended up personally murdering
the 8th Earl of Douglas at Stirling Castle in 1452, despite having promised the man safe conduct.
He and his Queen welcomed their son, another James, that same year.
James II went on to dismantle the Douglases' powerbase over the next few years and take their
lands. He died on the 3rd of August 1460, aged 29, when a cannon he was standing next to during
the siege of Roxburgh Castle broke apart and hit him with shrapnel. James III, born in 1452,
was 8 when he became King, and was at first protected by his clever and powerful mother,
Queen Mary, who took over the siege of Roxburgh when her husband died and took the castle in
less than a week. She died in 1463, however, when he was still a boy, and James Kennedy,
Bishop of St Andrews, took over the minority government. He then died in 1465, and Sir
Alexander Boyd of Drumcoil seized control of the King. James married the King of Denmark's daughter,
Margaret, in 1468 and began his personal rule, wiping out the by now hated Boyd family and
having Alexander executed. The King's lofty but expensive and impractical ambitions to extend
his power into mainland Europe, plus his taxation policies, willingness to sell pardons for serious
crimes and his unapproachable nature – he barely left Edinburgh, thus allowing law and order to
break down even further elsewhere in Scotland thanks to his lack of oversight – served to
make him increasingly unpopular. He was hated within his own family too, and his poor treatment
of his wife, siblings and children, including forfeitures, forced marriages and fishy deaths,
led the survivors to rebel against him. One brother, Alexander, Duke of Albany,
invaded with an English army and the future Richard III in 1482, while three half-uncles
captured the King at Lauder to try to become lieutenant generals of Scotland, a bit like a
regency council. Although the King escaped and regained power, Albany continued to be a thorn
in his side until the Duke's death in 1485. Queen Margaret died in 1486, and her son, James, Duke
of Rothesay, had such a poor relationship with his father that it was an army acting in his name
which killed the King on 11 June 1488 at the Battle of Sauchieburn. James IV was born in 1473
and was 15 years old and orphaned when he became King. He was kept in a minority government until
1495, even though he was 22 years old by then. That minority government was overseen by a royal
council made up of the strongest magnates and was therefore more representative and less fractured
than other councils had been in the past. It is from James's reign that the Scottish Crown Jewels,
otherwise known as the Scottish Regalia or the Honours of Scotland, date, and they still survive
today and are considerably older than almost all of the English Crown Jewels are. They've also had
a wild history to get them from James to us, which you can hear all about in my video on them,
linked on screen and below. During his personal rule, James took care to travel through his country
and be seen, and as for foreign policy, he supported the pretender to the English throne,
Perkin Warbeck, in the 1490s, only eventually being brought into the Tudor fold in 1503
by being allowed to marry Henry VII's 13-year-old daughter, Margaret. It was the marriage which
would facilitate the eventual union of the two crowns a century later. Their only surviving son,
another James, was born in 1512. Despite the marriage, the Scottish and English continued to
have a problematic relationship, and in 1513, James attacked England while his brother-in-law,
Henry VIII, was away campaigning in France, which was a Scottish ally. An army sent by his sister-in-law,
the Queen Regent of England, Catherine of Aragon, thrashed his troops at the Battle of Flodden,
and James was killed. James V was yet another child king, who came to the throne aged 17 months.
His first regent was his mother, Queen Margaret, who lost the job when she remarried to the Earl
of Angus, who was a member of the Douglas family. Next, the government was ruled by the Duke of
Albany, who was the cousin of James IV, then his stepfather, James V's stepfather, despite
the fact that Queen Margaret had come to hate her second husband, as had her son. The pair
eventually divorced, and Margaret married for a third time to Henry Stuart Lord Methven.
James escaped from Edinburgh Castle, where Angus was holding him, at the age of 16 in 1528,
and began his personal rule. In 1536, he sailed to France to collect a bride in the shape of Mary of
Bourbon, but decided upon seeing her that he didn't like her, and instead wed Madeleine of France,
daughter of Francis I, on New Year's Day 1537 in Notre Dame in Paris. Unfortunately, the new
queen died in July of TB at the Palace of Holyrood back in Scotland. Not to be deterred from a French
union, James next wed the widowed Mary of Guise in 1538. After two short-lived sons, they had one
surviving child, a daughter called Mary, born on the 8th of December 1542. James never met her
though. By the time of her arrival, he was dying of cholera or dysentery at Falkland Palace, where
he expired when she was six days old. Mary, Queen of Scots, is, I think, the most famous Scottish
monarch of all. Raised for the first five years of her life in Scotland, and at first mooted as a
possible wife for Henry VIII's son, the future Edward VI, she was then taken to her mother's
leaving Mary of Guise behind, who managed to secure the regency for herself in 1554.
Mary, Queen of Scots, eventually married the French Dauphin in 1558, who soon after became
Francis II of France in 1559, before dying at the age of 16 in 1560. Unbeknownst to her Scottish
commissioners at the time of the marriage, Mary had signed a secret document saying that if she
died first, she left her entire kingdom to her French husband, hardly the mark of a good monarch.
As it was though, the now Dowager Queen of France, whose mother had died in 1560,
returned to her own realm to begin her personal rule as Queen of the Scots.
She was now a French-speaking Catholic in what had in her absence become a Protestant country
however, and the fact that her English was never as good as her French after her childhood
was, I would argue, a serious oversight on the part of those who raised her, along with her
generally poor political education. The problems her religious and cultural alienation from her
country caused were only exacerbated by her ill-advised marriage to her English half-cousin,
the wild and disreputable Henry Stuart Lord Darnley in 1565, with whom she had a son called
James in 1566, in a surprisingly tiny room in Edinburgh Castle. Darnley had by then assisted
in the murder of Mary's Italian favourite, David Rizzio, pretty much right in front of her in
Holyrood Palace when she was six months pregnant, and with the bloom very much off the rooves when
it came to her marriage, it is little wonder that she was suspected of involvement in Darnley's
murder in February 1567, especially when she married one of the alleged conspirators,
James Hepburn, Earl of Bothwell, just months later in May. Her reputation in ruins,
and abandoned by her husband, who she never saw again and who died in 1578,
she was forced to abdicate in favour of her one-year-old son in July 1567, and eventually
fled to England in 1568, seeking the protection and assistance of her cousin Elizabeth I.
Big mistake. Mary had been antagonising Elizabeth for years by insisting that she was the rightful
Queen of England because Elizabeth Tudor was illegitimate. Which, to be fair, she was,
but she held her crown through her father's will and an Act of Parliament, which left it to the
descendants of his sister Mary, not his sister Margaret, who Mary Queen of Scots was descended
from, in the event of Elizabeth dying without children. Elizabeth was in no mood to help a
French-raised Catholic Queen to retake her throne north of the border, and she instead had Mary
imprisoned for 19 years in a series of castles and houses. Eventually it emerged that Mary was
plotting to have Elizabeth killed and herself put on the English throne, so Elizabeth beat her to
the punch and had her executed at Fotheringhay Castle in 1587, though she later denied that
she had intended for the death warrant to be enacted. Mary was buried at Peterborough Cathedral
and later moved to Westminster Abbey by her son, who is the final monarch on our list.
James VI of Scotland had a miserable childhood after the abdication of his mother, whom he never
saw again after the age of one. Raised a Protestant, he was taught by a strict tutor called George
Buchanan, who often beat him and knew little in the way of stability or family life, running through
a series of regents, the first two of whom, his half-uncle and his grandfather, died violent
deaths, the third, the Earl of Moher, passed away of natural causes, and the fourth, the Earl of
Moreton, was overthrown in 1580 and executed. The fifth was the Duke of Lennox, but James was
kidnapped from his custody in 1582 by William Ruthven, Earl of Gowrie, and his supporters, from whom he
escaped in 1583. The king now operated increasingly independently. In 1589, he went to Norway to
collect his bride, the 14-year-old Anne of Denmark, who had been unable to travel to Scotland due to
storms. With her, he had seven children, though there have always been rumours that he was in
fact gay, and he certainly had a series of male favourites. He was also obsessed with witches,
believing that a storm that beset he and Anne on their way back to Scotland after their marriage
was a product of sorcery. He supported a series of despicable witch hunts in Scotland, called the
North Berwick Witch Trials in 1590, personally oversaw the torture of women accused of witchcraft,
and wrote a book about witches and witch-hunting entitled Demonology in 1597. In 1603, Elizabeth
I of England died, and despite not actually being the heir to her throne, according to the
aforementioned will of Henry VIII, James was the senior blood claimant through his great-grandmother
Margaret Tudor, and he acceded unopposed as James I, uniting the crowns of the northern
and southern kingdoms. Never again from that date to this would there be a monarch of an
independent Scotland. He moved to England with his family and stayed there until his death,
aborting assassination attempts such as the Gunpowder Plot to blow him up in Parliament in
and styling himself, when he was able to because there was some pushback against it,
as the King of Great Britain. His eldest son, Henry, died in 1612, leaving his second boy,
Charles, as his heir, and his wife, with whom he'd had a sometimes difficult relationship,
particularly with regards to how their children were raised, died in 1619. James himself passed
away in 1625 and was buried in Westminster Abbey with his great-great-grandparents,
Henry VII and Elizabeth of York. Phew, gang, well done if you made it through all of that.
If you did, leave the word superstar in the comments because that's what you are.
You can also let me know there which of the Scottish monarchs is your favourite and why.
If you want to learn about the English monarchs leading up to James I, see my video looking at
all of them from 1066 until 1603, and if you want to hear about what happened after his death,
see my video on the British monarchs from him until the present day.
Whatever you choose, please enjoy, and until next time, keep learning!
