IMF就金融穩定報告舉行記者會

新唐人精選新聞
6244粉絲
27 次觀看·2026年4月14日
美東4月14日上午,國際貨幣基金組織(IMF)將就2026年4月《全球金融穩定報告》舉行記者會。新唐人、大紀元進行網絡直播(即時翻譯字幕)。
Good morning everyone and thank you very much for joining us here today.
I'm Mira Lewis from the Communications Department.
And today I'm joined here by Tobias Adrian.
He is the Financial Counselor and the Director of the Monetary Capital Markets Department.
Also with us today, I have Thanos and Jason, Deputy Director and Assistant Director from the Monetary Capital Markets Department.
I think by now I expect everybody should have had the JFSR accessible.
You can access it on the website.
And you can also please join us by Webex if you can't be here personally.
So before we start and take your questions, I'll turn the floor over to Tobias for a few remarks.
And then we'll come to you for questions. Thank you.
Tobias.
Thanks so much Mira and good morning everybody.
Financial markets are being challenged by the war in the Middle East.
The financial system has been resilient so far.
This Global Financial Stability Report highlights that channels of financial vulnerabilities could amplify turmoil under some circumstances.
The conflict has alternated between escalation and de-escalation generating bouts of volatility.
But not the kind of sustained drawdowns that we have seen in previous times of liquidity stress.
We also haven't seen the margin calls and forced leveraging that has occurred a number of times in recent years.
So markets have been functioning in an orderly manner.
Central banks have been supporting markets in a number of countries through liquidity facilities.
And of course there have also been structural improvements in markets for example through central clearing.
We also see the benefits of resilient banks which remain more capitalized and liquid.
And so the banking system is not a worry at this point in this particular juncture.
Now having said all that the resilience is not assured in all states of the world.
And let me go into some of the vulnerabilities.
Elevated public debt and private debt, rollover risk as well as the bank sovereign nexus continue to make bond markets fragile at least in some countries.
And we particularly focus on the presence of leveraged investors in these markets.
So as governments have issued more debt a lot of non-banks have stepped in.
And we look in great detail in this global financial stability report at those issues.
Other risks that we are looking at include private credit as well as technology related investments.
And we particularly focus on leverage and interconnectedness in these areas.
Of course we also spend quite a bit of time on emerging markets.
There are additional risks in emerging markets.
Quite a bit of the non-bank flows.
Have dominated emerging market financing.
And they can be subject to shifts in global risk appetite.
Now one of the main themes of this report is the limited policy space in many countries.
When we think back over the past five or six years.
Oftentimes governments have come in to support financial stability.
With the policy space.
But the policy space has been drawn down in many countries.
So against this backdrop it is very important for countries to safeguard financial stability.
By monitoring closely how vulnerabilities are evolving.
Taking macro-intellectual actions where necessary.
Having strong oversight of the banks and the non-banks.
And of course being operationally ready to inject liquidity.
The task for policy makers is not in and of itself to predict shocks.
It is very hard to know what shocks are going to come down.
But rather to ensure that vulnerabilities are contained and understood.
And that actions can be taken if there are any instabilities that arise.
Finally let me underline that artificial intelligence represents both opportunities and risks.
And one of the risks that we are highlighting is the cyber security risk in this area.
So that needs to be managed carefully.
And the appropriate policy steps need to be taken there as well.
Thank you. Thank you Tobias.
And so now we will open the floor up to questions.
Please you can also join via Webex.
And also submit your questions online.
So perhaps we can start with like a global question.
The lady in the front over here.
Thank you so much. My name is Rui.
I am with 21st Century in Guangdong, China.
So my question is that with ongoing geopolitical risks affecting energy markets.
How does the IMF assess the renewed inflation shock
fading back into global financial stability system.
And also how do current geopolitical risks
and you just mentioned rising fiscal pressures
as well as volatile market cash flows
all interact together in shaping global financial stability.
Thank you.
Tobias.
So the first order impact of the higher oil price
that have resulted from the war in the Middle East
is that inflation expectations have increased.
And that is fairly broad across countries globally.
Now we can look at markets data
to look at what the implied path for inflation is.
And you know so far what we are seeing
is that the expected inflation impact
is somewhat contained in time.
So that inflation expectations remain well anchored
further out into the future
say 3, 4, 5 years into the future.
The expectations of inflation are coming back down.
So it is a temporary bout of inflation
that is priced into markets.
And you know that then generates
the kind of policy advice that we are giving
which is that for central banks
the option value of weighting
in many cases is high
so that you want to see how lasting the conflict is
how persistent the energy shock may be.
So you know some central banks may start tightening early
others may wait
in order to have more resolution of uncertainty.
Thank you.
Thank you, Tobias.
Anybody else?
Yes, the gentleman over there.
Thank you.
Rudy Sudhir with Horizon News, Lagos, Nigeria.
Just two quick questions on the policy space
for emerging markets.
Nigeria, for instance, has a budget benchmark
oil benchmark of $64.
We are at $97 now.
The ability to act based on higher benchmark
is that offset by possible demand destruction?
And on AI, the data centers require a lot of energy
and we've seen a number of hyperscalers raise money.
I think Amazon raised about $54 billion
in a bond issuance back in March.
Does the war and the energy requirements
of data centers, does that kind of upend
the ability to raise debts to build them out?
Thank you.
So before we take further questions,
are there any other questions on AI?
Yes, the lady over there
and the gentleman back there.
Thank you.
Thanks for taking the question.
Just when you talk about the cybersecurity issues
related to AI,
are you talking about the issues
around what we've seen this week
around, like, my thoughts on Anthropic
and do you have any advice for institutions
as they try to manage that,
particularly around the topic of the need
for global cooperation around that?
Thank you.
There's one more question on AI back there.
Sure.
Thanks a lot.
Matthew Lee, InterCity Press.
Actually, I was going to ask
about Anthropic as well
because obviously it's in the news.
So to go beyond what my colleague asked,
this dispute between the Department of War
and as a supply chain risk in Anthropic,
you have, I guess, overall,
I wanted to know what guidance
can the IMF give to government agencies
in terms of dealing?
Is it just this sort of, you know,
voluntary compliance of an Anthropic
or what can be done to stop some of these models
before they cause havoc in the markets?
Thanks a lot.
Thank you.
So perhaps we can start with the AI
and then switch to the emerging markets.
Yeah, absolutely.
So let me start with AI.
So the first AI question
was really about the energy consumption
of artificial intelligence data centers.
And, you know, of course,
it depends on the location
of the data centers, right?
So in some locations,
you have a fairly elastic supply of energy.
In other locations,
you have a more inelastic supply.
And we have certainly heard
anecdotally that data centers
do have an impact on energy prices
in the region where they are located.
You know, to what extent
the oil price shock
is going to feed into
the financial position of hyperscalers
I think it's something
that remains to be seen.
I don't think we have a clear reading
for the moment on this question.
Now let me turn to cybersecurity.
And let me start by pointing out
that at the IMF,
we have supported agencies
in our member countries
for over 8 years now
on cybersecurity questions.
So basically what we are doing
is to help regulators
and central banks around the world
to put into place
regulatory frameworks
relative to cybersecurity issues
in the financial sector.
And, you know, we have seen
quite a lot of demand
for this kind of support
to our membership.
You know, cybersecurity
is certainly a rising risk.
And it is extremely important
for global financial stability
to make sure
that any cybersecurity threats
are addressed very quickly.
Now with a specific sort of question
about the intersection
between artificial intelligence
and cybersecurity,
of course, you know,
artificial intelligence
is a very powerful tool
that can be used for good and for bad.
And I think the developments last week
were really focused around
making sure that
artificial intelligence
is used to protect
the integrity of financial institutions
and other corporations
and governments around the world.
So our advice is, you know,
to really stay at the frontier
of all of these threats
and to be extremely proactive
in terms of the policy frameworks
relative to cybersecurity
but also relative
to the operational readiness
to act when necessary.
Now, finally, there was a question
about oil price
and, you know, policy space
specifically with respect to Nigeria.
But I think there's a broader
question here as well.
And I would start
and then perhaps turn to my colleagues
to also complement me.
You know, basically, you know,
some countries are benefiting
from higher oil prices
if they're net exporters of oil.
But even when you benefit
because you're a net exporter,
you still have an impact
on the cost of oil.
So you still have
an inflationary impact.
And so central banks
will be confronted
with the question
of what actions to take
relative to the rise in inflation.
Now, of course,
for energy-importing countries,
the challenge is even larger, right?
Because on the one hand,
you have the inflationary pressure,
but you may also see constraints
in terms of actually getting
energy supplies.
And in fact, we see that
about 80 countries around the world
have introduced some measures
to save on energy.
So it is very country-specific.
And generally, oil importers
have seen their spreads rise
relatively more than oil exporters.
So let me just complement
by saying that
there's obviously vulnerable groups,
population in emerging markets
that are being...
that are suffering from
the increase in energy prices
and perhaps food prices later.
As a whole, emerging markets,
it is, in our view,
too early to think about, you know,
the adverse demand effects necessarily
and whether this is going to offset
the higher prices.
And therefore,
Tobias's message about monetary policy,
waiting and seeing
and maintaining the option value
is a rather important one.
I will just end by saying
that overall emerging market,
at least from financial markets' perspective,
has been, you know, fairly resilient
through this period so far.
And much of that has to do
with credible policies,
including monetary policy.
And therefore,
it is important for central banks
to act decisively
when they actually start to see
the impact on inflation
and inflation expectations
from this particular period.
Thank you.
And also just staying on emerging markets,
we got another question online
that's talking from Fatma Ibrahim.
She asks,
How does the IMF assess
Egypt's resilience
against potential sudden outflows
from non-bank financial institutions?
Yeah, that's a great question.
And, you know, in the case of Egypt,
we have seen, you know,
an adjustment in the exchange rate
relative to the shock.
And that is exactly aligned
with our macroeconomic advice
for countries such as Egypt
and other emerging markets.
Basically, you know, exchange rates
can be a very helpful shock absorber
in times of situations such as these
where all prices have risen suddenly.
Now, of course,
for the domestic economy,
you also have the impact on inflation
in terms of energy prices,
but also in terms of food prices.
And, you know, we're not seeing
an immediate impact
on financial stability to date,
but it's, of course, something
that we are watching very closely.
And maybe if I can compliment,
in the Egyptian case,
there has been a great exchange rate flexibility,
tighter monetary policy
and better fiscal policy
that has all fed into
the more resilient background
heading into the war in the Middle East.
And that has helped contain
the impact on exchange rate
on other financial market asset prices
in the case of Egypt.
So I think we should take this
as a fairly positive lesson.
Going forward,
maintaining financial system stability
maintains pretty paramount.
And in particular, you know,
focusing on banking sector
and how it could support the real economy
after the war
as we head towards the next stage
of this conflict will be very important.
Thank you.
So before I come back,
I'll come to you,
but we just have somebody
who's been waiting patiently on Webex.
So it's Doha.
We'll go to you on Webex.
Hello, Maria. Good morning.
Good morning.
Good morning for you all, colleagues.
Thank you so much for taking my questions.
I have two questions.
One is on a regional level
and the second is a country-focused one.
On a regional level,
to what extent the ongoing war
in the Middle East
could affect the U.S.-denominated
bond issues in the region?
And my second question
is on Egypt.
To what extent Egypt
could sustain its financial stability
amid the ongoing conflict?
Thank you so much.
Thank you.
Anybody else on a similar issue?
No.
OK.
So we'll take this
and then go back to you.
Yeah.
Of course,
the Middle East is in the center
of the conflict.
And a number of countries
in the Middle East
have been impacted directly
by the war.
So, again,
it depends a lot
on whether you are
an energy importer,
an energy exporter,
whether you're directly impacted
by the war.
So we see quite a bit
of heterogeneity across countries.
You know,
one of the key questions
is how lasting
the damage is to infrastructure.
And, you know,
when we look at market pricing
across the Middle Eastern region,
we do certainly see
that inflation expectations are up.
You know,
stock markets are down
to some degree.
But we also see policymakers
take decisive action
in order to inject liquidity
into the financial system.
We've seen that
in a number of Middle Eastern countries
in order to basically support
financial system functioning.
You know,
in terms of immediate threats,
as I said earlier,
the key question
is the length
or the duration
and the magnitude
of oil price developments
and the war
in the Middle East
going forward.
And, you know,
it's too early to say
where we are going to end up
in this respect.
Well, the question
about dollar bond issuance
of the region,
I'll just make
a general observation
in line with what Tobias said.
I think the various support
rolled out in the banking sector
has helped investor sentiment.
EM spreads in general
has widened by a modest amount,
30 to 40 basis points.
And importantly,
it does not seem like
that countries are being locked out
of issuing dollar bonds.
So this is all
a very positive backdrop.
Now, of course,
the conflict may turn
in various ways
that would, you know,
make this outcome different.
But I think this also reflects
the fact that, you know,
many countries have
fairly sound fundamentals,
at least in the Middle East,
you know, coming into this conflict.
And I believe I answered
the Egypt question before.
Thank you.
So we go to the gentleman
over here in the front.
Thank you very much.
Hugo Dixon, Reuters.
I have a question about Russia.
There has been an increase
in bad loans
in the Russian banking system
that are connected with the war
and government-directed war loans.
So my question is
how serious do you assess
the vulnerability
in the Russian banking system?
And also coming on
to this question of policy space,
how much policy space
do you think that
the Russian government
has to respond to such vulnerabilities
and has the increase
in the oil price
actually increased
its policy space
to respond to any vulnerabilities
if they should emerge?
Thank you.
Yes.
So, you know, we have not...
We do not have a granular assessment
of the banking system
in Russia at this point.
There will be regional press briefing
on Europe
where you can ask
more specific country questions.
So, I don't know.
Do you want to say something on Russia?
Maybe just very quickly on policy room.
Fiscal policy room
has diminished in Russia.
And we are cognizant
of the fact that, you know,
non-performing loans
in the banking sector is risen.
That said, from the...
As Tobias said, you know,
we need to do
a more granular assessment
on this topic
and maybe our regional colleagues
can answer your question better.
But from our understanding,
right now the non-performing loan
remains at a fairly moderate level.
And so perhaps
there are certain banks
that, you know, would
paint a different picture.
But overall,
this is what we see right now.
Yeah, again,
if you have any very specific
regional questions,
we have regional briefings
coming up
and happy to
guide your questions there.
We'll take the lady over there
and then the lady here.
So, the two ladies up front.
All right, good morning.
I'm Nancy Najee from AIT Nigeria.
I would like to ask
a question on Africa
in terms of how
the ongoing war will readjust
perhaps foreign portfolio
influence into the country.
Let me also stick this in Nigeria.
Nigeria just concluded
a banking recapitalization.
I'm sure you know that.
What do you think
or what's also the guidance
in terms of how vulnerable
Nigerian economy is
in terms of foreign capital
and if the bank recapitalization now
would help?
Thank you.
Are there any other questions
on Africa emerging markets?
There's another question there
and here.
Good morning.
My name is Babacar from Senegal.
As you can notice
in our country
we are facing
a real challenge
when it comes to debt stabilizing
and our debt and ratio
of debt GDP is up to
118 to 132 percent.
That's huge.
So, what's the IMF
is doing right now
to help our government
to try to mitigate
the challenges
that the Senegal government
are facing?
Thank you.
Again, it is
very country-specific questions.
We do have regional briefings
coming up,
but if it's a general
banking,
Africa,
right here in the front.
Good morning.
Balesa from CNBC Africa.
I'm based in South Africa
in Johannesburg.
What policy trade-offs
are emerging markets
facing right now
between supporting growth
and maintaining
financial stability
especially given
we are in a higher
for longer interest rate
environment?
Thank you.
Any other questions
on emerging markets?
The lady up there,
front.
Thank you.
Karishma from
Business Today,
India Today Group.
I'll get you
to the APAC region.
You've already spoken
about the impact
on emerging markets
and the fact that
oil prices have already
been elevated,
dollar is strengthening.
Which Asia-Pacific economies
do you think
are the most vulnerable
to balance of payments
or refinancing stress
if the conditions worsen?
Thank you.
We'll take this round.
Thanks so much.
Let me start
with some of the questions
and then also
ask Jason to compliment me.
So starting with
the capital flow question
to Sub-Saharan Africa.
When we are looking
at capital flows
since the beginning
of the war in the Middle East
and compare that
to previous episodes
of conflict,
we do see
a sort of outsized reaction
in terms of capital flows,
but at the same time,
for example,
it's roughly twice as large
as what we have seen
during the Ukraine war
or the first several months
of the Ukraine war.
But when we look
at the price action,
the price action
remains fairly contained, right?
So yes,
there is a large reaction
on quantities of capital flows,
but the price reaction
to date is fairly contained.
And that really reflects
a broader healthy risk appetite
in global markets, right?
So as I mentioned earlier,
we've seen an ebb and flow
in terms of risk appetite,
but overall,
I would characterize
the risk appetite
as being fairly healthy.
Concerning bank recapitalizations,
of course,
it's in times of stress
where the value of bank capital
really comes to the fore, right?
So what we are aiming at
for global financial stability
is a bank sector
that is capitalized
against adverse shocks.
So yes,
bank recapitalizations
are very welcome
and are paying off
particularly under times of stress.
Concerning debt to GDP
and what the IMF is doing,
so in sub-Saharan Africa,
we have many countries
with programs.
So we're working actively
with governments
to address debt situations.
And across different countries,
this takes different shapes and forms,
but debt sustainability
and the fiscal position
is certainly very foundational
in our programs.
Turning to the question
from South Africa
on policy trade-offs,
so I think South Africa
faces similar trade-offs
as other emerging markets.
Basically,
you have this adverse supply shock
where inflation expectations
are driven up.
Inflation realizations
are already higher
because oil prices are higher,
energy prices are higher,
but at the same time,
real activity is driven down.
And so central banks
have to carefully evaluate
to what extent
the lower real activity
might dampen inflation over time
to what extent
the impact on inflation
is temporary or more permanent
and of course
what inflation expectations
are doing.
Turning to the question
from Asia
and the APEC countries
in particular,
we see vulnerability,
of course,
particularly in countries
that are dependent
on oil imports
and on food imports as well.
So really,
it's the most vulnerable countries
are the ones
that tend to be
lower-income countries.
So,
you know,
there are some in Asia as well.
And,
you know,
it's the most vulnerable countries
that tend to be hit the hardest
with this kind of shock.
And within those countries,
you know,
macro policies
for stability are important,
but it's also first order
to protect the most vulnerable
among the population
that are hit
by the higher food
and energy prices.
Maybe just to quickly
complement on two aspects.
One is debt and capital flows,
and the second is,
you know,
the picture in Asia Pacific.
On capital flows,
as Tobias mentioned,
I think the medium-term issue
is more reliance on debt
than FDI and equity.
If you look at the
across emerging markets,
those emerging markets
with better fiscal positions
generally have more access
to international markets
and lower debt spreads.
So this counsels us
to continue to make improvement
on that front
in order to guard against
sudden capital outflows
and over-reliance on debt.
Secondly,
on Asia Pacific,
I think it's fair to say
that financial markets
in Asia Pacific
is generally very deep.
And so,
so far during this episode,
we have not seen
really acute stress
in any of the financial market segments.
There have been pronounced
exchange rate movements,
but those appear to be managed
in an orderly fashion.
Thank you.
Thank you, Jason.
The gentleman over there.
And the third...
Thank you.
Alex Brown from the Daily Mail.
Your report highlights again
the expansion of shadow banking,
credit outside the banking system,
private credit.
We've seen a number of fractures
in those markets in recent days.
Blue Owl has been mentioned.
People have talked about cockroaches.
We've seen a number of the big banks
gate exit from their funds.
Do you fear that we could be
on the verge of something
similar to 2008
when there's a cascade
of money moving around
and causing failures
in the financial system?
And could the Middle East War
perhaps be the kind of shock or trigger
which could make that much worse?
Thank you.
Any other questions on private credit?
Private credit?
Hi, Paul Lake from AFP.
Just wondering if you see it
as a contained risk
or if you see it spilling out
into a broader risk as private credit?
Question on private credit?
Hi, Sabina Escobar with Barron's.
I was just also wondering
to piggyback on this.
Are there any markets
that you see especially at risk
with private credit?
And the report also mentions
that in themselves,
if defaults were to get higher
in response to the Middle East conflict,
that wouldn't be a real problematic sign.
But what would make you
start worrying more
about private credit risk
and which markets are more at risk?
And also just on private credit,
we got some more questions online.
One is do you see
any systemic risk from private credit?
Is the wealth effect
a potential issue
for the global economy here
now that stocks
have stopped moving higher?
This is from Greg Robb, Market Watch.
Another one is it appears
that U.S. insurers
are particularly exposed
to the risks of private debt
and leverage in business
development companies.
To what extent could this
constitute a contagion
or systemic risk
for other asset classes?
Yeah.
So let me start by pointing out
that we have quite a bit of analysis
of private credit
in the Global Financial
Stability Report.
So I think it's very worth
taking a look at that.
So let me make three points.
So the first one is
about the broader credit cycle.
So one question is
if we did see a deterioration
globally in the credit cycle
that would impact private credit
but also the loan books
of banks and others.
How much of a hit
would private credit take?
So in the GFSR,
in the Global Financial
Stability Report,
we're looking at scenarios
of a deterioration
of private credit.
And we're doing
a fairly extensive analysis
that is also described
in one of the appendices.
And that really shows
that, of course,
default rates would rise
just as they would rise
in other credit classes as well.
But we think
that the magnitude
is somewhat manageable.
So default rates
at the moment are perhaps
between 2% to 3%.
Under adverse scenarios,
they would go to 4%, 5%, or 6%.
But that is probably digestible
in and of itself.
I think the second question
is really about redemptions
in private credit.
So we have seen
a number of funds
that have received
redemption requests.
And so, you know,
the total direct lending universe
of private credit
is about $2 trillion globally.
We think about 50%
or $300 billion of that
is in semi-liquid structures,
so where investors can redeem.
But, of course,
the funds do have gates,
so they can basically gate
those redemptions.
We have seen that
in a number of vehicles.
So this is something
that is containing
the systemic risk in this area.
But, you know,
if more of this sector
were to become redeemable,
that would certainly impact
the broader assessment.
But to date,
we think that the systemic risk
is certainly contained
in this sector.
And finally,
there is the question
about other financial institutions
being exposed to private credit.
So our insurance companies,
pension funds globally
exposed to private credit.
There's certainly, you know,
some ownership,
but we also think
in the aggregate
that's fairly manageable to date.
I will add one point
that there is no doubt
that in recent years,
private credit has supported
overall credit growth
has supported the economy.
So although the focus now
is on risks in the sector,
looking forward,
it is important
to also monitor the flows
so that the sector will continue
supporting the economy.
Thank you.
Thank you very much.
So the lady over here.
Thank you.
I have some key points.
You mentioned that
the price shock is short term.
On the other hand,
the World Economic Outlook says
that if facilities end now
in the Gulf states,
they will need two years to recover.
So I would like to clarify
whether the IMF thinks
this shock is a long term
or a short term.
And in the light of this,
the European Central Bank
has held the key rates
and the Fed is currently
that they don't know.
So the question is
whether the central banks
are OK to hold the raising
of the key rates this time
or will it be too late
because there is a risk
that it might be the repeat
of the post-COVID reaction
when they have raised
the key rates too late
and then it costs us much more.
Thank you.
Any other questions
on central banks?
Any other questions
on central banks
and monetary policy?
No.
So we'll take that real quick
and then we have a person
waiting on Webex.
Yeah, absolutely.
So the way that
the World Economic Outlook
is treating the oil price shock
is really to look at
the three scenarios.
So a reference scenario
and an adverse
and a severe one.
And basically
in the reference scenario
what you described
is what's happening
is basically the inflationary impact
is a temporary impact, right?
In the adverse scenario
the inflationary impact
is larger and more persistent
and then in the severe scenario
there could also be
a financial condition tightening, right?
So there may be an impact
not only directly on inflation
but also an outsized impact
potentially on real activity.
And so those three scenarios
broadly map into
central banking strategies.
So under the reference scenario
where you have a temporary
oil price shock
at that point
some central banks
may want to look through
that oil price shock
though it depends on
what countries you're looking at.
So for example
if you have an immediate impact
on inflation expectations
central banks may want to tighten
even if they think
that the oil price shock is temporary.
But in those countries
where inflation expectations
are well anchored
and you don't see
pass through into co-inflation
you may want to wait.
So the option value of waiting
would be large
in this reference scenario.
In the more adverse scenario
where the inflation shock
is more persistent
and is of larger magnitude
at that point
we would expect central banks
generally to hike
in order to fulfill
the inflation mandate.
And then in the more severe scenario
it sort of depends on
whether the real activity
is outweighing the inflation shock.
So it's going to become
very country specific
and very much dependent
on how much of a drag
the tightening of financial conditions
is going to be on aggregate demand
in addition to the adverse supply shock.
Now when you look at market pricing
and this is what I was referring to.
When you look at market pricing
markets are generally
pricing in a fairly
temporary shock for the moment.
You can imagine that markets
are sort of averaging
across those three scenarios
and our understanding
from market pricing
is that they put quite a bit of weight
on the reference scenario
at the moment.
Our own forecast
is really about those three scenarios
and we don't per se
give a probability weighting
at this point.
Just to say that
the key difference with 2002
is that back then
demand was very strong.
Now we're dealing with a supply shock.
So it's a different case.
Thank you.
OK, now we turn to Webex.
Anthony Rowley
from the South China Morning Post.
Yes, can you hear me?
Yes, we can.
Good, OK.
Well, my question
is of a more general nature
and that is
this frequent reference
to the resilience
of financial markets.
But I wonder
to what extent
has this resilience
become structural.
What I mean by that is
huge amounts of savings
are channeled
via pension funds
life insurance companies
and so on.
Especially with the growth
of ETF funds
into investment.
In other words
the markets are guaranteed
if you like
of huge cash flows
into the markets.
So does this mean
in effect
that the markets
are automatically replenished
by these inflows
and therefore
all you see
are draining away from
in times of crisis.
It's just simply not possible now
simply because of the weight of
if you like
the rivers flowing into the lake.
Thank you.
Thank you for the question.
Are there any other questions
on a similar vein?
No.
Yes.
And then we'll come
to the room.
And so we're running
out of time.
So we'll take this
and then come
group questions in the room.
Yeah.
So let me say
something quickly
and then turn to Thomas
as well.
You know
there's certainly
ample liquidity globally.
As I mentioned earlier
risk appetite is strong.
So we have seen
financial conditions
tightened to some degree.
But it's fairly contained
by historical standards.
And we haven't seen
the sort of very sharp
tightening at the moment.
You certainly do see
reallocation of capital.
But of course that is the role
that capital markets are playing.
I mean they are
an insurance mechanism.
So when adverse shocks
are hitting
market prices adjust
in order to rechannel capital
in the right corners
of the global economy.
What I would also say
the way that stock markets
have reacted to the recent shock
is fully consistent
with the energy price moves
and the rates market repricing.
So we don't see
any dislocation
from this point of view.
And also although
risk appetite has been strong
as Tobias pointed out.
Growth has been surprising
to the upside
and earnings have been strong.
Thank you.
Now we have just
3 minutes left.
So if you can be very quick
the gentleman there
and then.
I'll yield.
OK.
All right.
Go ahead.
We just have 3 minutes left.
Walter Herrera
the George Washington University.
Given Venezuela's
large oil reserves
but severe financial
and institutional constraints
do you see a potential recovery
in its energy sector
as a stabilizing force
for global energy markets
or as a source of financial risk?
Thank you.
And then we'll take
one last question.
My question is about
the interbank transfer system
which is like
a global public good
like maritime navigation
or whether that is
internet or civil aviation
which are all governed
by the UN conventions
and have more democratic governance
unlike the interbank transfer system
which is controlled
by just a few countries
and that is being held hostage
to the geopolitical interests.
So is that eroding
the trust of the countries
in that system
and will it lead to
one not only lack of trust
but also the fragmentation
of the system.
How much is that risk
to the global financial stability
and one very quick question
on unregulated cryptocurrency
which has become
which is becoming
a storehouse of corrupt
and criminal money
and is also becoming
a source of terror financing
is that also a huge risk
to your financial stability?
We have space
for one last question
I'm afraid.
Right there.
And then we're going
to have to wrap it up.
I'm sorry.
Quick question.
Do you think hedge funds
increasing involvement
in the government bond markets
is an issue?
On the one hand
they help with market functioning
On the other hand
we've seen what happens
when their bets go wrong.
Would you like to see
more central clearing
or haircuts?
Yes.
All right.
Thanks so much for these
very interesting questions.
So on Venezuela
I would again defer
to the regional press briefings.
We are not really prepared
to answer
very country-specific questions
unless they're directly related
to the global financial stability.
Now turning to the
global payment system.
So indeed
there are a number of ways
in which payments flow
across borders.
And I would distinguish here
between clearing and settlement.
Right.
So clearing systems
are oftentimes quite integrated.
But settlement systems
are quite dispersed
across the globe.
There are many initiatives
across the world
to innovate
on global payment systems.
Some of that
is using traditional
account-based payment systems.
Others are more
tokenized systems
that are emerging.
Many of which
are developed
either by private actors
such as banks
including correspondent banks
other global banks.
But also
Fintech payments providers.
And of course central banks
are also very actively involved
in terms of improving
across-border payment systems.
So I would say
at the moment
we do see
the messaging system
which is part of clearing.
It's the messaging.
There is a pretty
broadly used system.
But there are certainly
other systems as well
that are emerging.
And on settlement
we see quite a bit
of fragmentation.
But also a lot of innovation
in terms of having
faster and cheaper systems.
Now yes.
Now the integrity of payments
is absolutely key
from a policy perspective.
So this is what we call
anti-money laundering
and counter-terrorist
financing initiatives.
So all countries in the world
are very focused
on making sure
that global payments
are legal and compliant
And that includes of course
also the crypto world.
We have put out
a policy framework
for crypto assets.
Many countries
are being supported by us
by the World Bank
and by international
standard setting bodies
in terms of phasing in
regulatory and policy frameworks
for crypto assets.
And making sure
that they are compliant
and legal
is certainly very first order
for countries.
So I think
that's a very active
policy area.
Now finally
coming to the role
of hedge funds.
So as you know
global debt to GDP
has been trending up
around the world.
Many countries
have increased
their debt.
They have run
expansionary fiscal policies
in recent years
starting with
the global pandemic.
And really over the past
15 years
we have seen an outsized
role of non-banks
in terms of absorbing
the supply of
sovereign debt globally.
And so
that's a very
positive development
for governments
because they are buyers
for this debt.
But of course
there are some
fragilities in those markets.
So governments
in the UK
and the US
and many other countries
have been very focused
on enhancing
market structure.
So for example
by a central clearing
by introducing
new backstops
by the central banks
to make sure
that the government
bond markets
are resilient
to adverse shocks
and that they
are resilient
to this changing nature
of the marginal
vestor in the space.
Thank you.
Thank you, Tobias.
I'm afraid
we've run out of time.
But if you have
any follow-up questions
please feel free
to follow up with me.
We're happy to help you.
Again, thank you for coming.
All right.
Good morning.
Welcome to the IMF.
My name is Frank Busquet.
I am the Deputy Director
of the IMF Institute
for Capacity Development
overseeing
our global partnerships.
Welcome to the spring meeting.
Welcome to the IMF
Capacity Development Events.
As you know,
the IMF is providing
both technical assistance
and training.
And we start
today with a
peak into training
which is going to present
the newest
but also the most advanced
course in our curriculum,
the macroeconomic policy
communication course.
So my colleagues
from the Institute of Capacity
Development,
I will introduce them later on,
who developed the course
and are delivering it,
will actually show
how communication
has become
an important policy tool
and how our member countries
are looking for opportunities
to develop their skills
in this area,
which is very important.
We will also showcase
how we are designing
modern courses,
especially using
the blended format,
which is...
