We ve Been Dressing Wrong For Cycling All This Time

BICYBLE SHOW
111 followers
I have been riding bikes for a very long time, and whilst I'm always learning new things
like chain waxing, or why I should now eat three times as many carbohydrates per hour
as I used to, and the increasing importance of Zone 2, and also Zones 4, 5, 6, and probably
3 as well now I think about it, the fact is it's rare that something new takes me by surprise.
Last year, something did.
And something made me question whether or not I've been getting dressed for cycling
all wrong.
Yes, getting dressed.
Not that it is in fact weird to go commando under cycling shorts, or that pockets in cycling
jerseys should go at the front, but that I've been wearing too many clothes.
Yes, put simply, have I been overdressing and getting too hot in winter?
I am going to find out, doing a little experiment on myself, as well as diving into peer-reviewed
scientific research.
Will what I find out lead me to genuinely rethink what I wear and how I approach cold
weather riding?
It's important to note here that I don't feel like I've been wearing too many clothes.
I haven't been feeling too hot.
In fact, sometimes my hands and feet have been getting bloody cold, but as we'll see
in a moment, those two factors are linked.
Nevertheless, though, you may well be wondering where on earth my epiphany has come from.
Well, it's because I was wearing a core temperature sensor.
Typically, they're used for heat training, which as you probably know, basically turbocharges
your fitness in both hot conditions and cold.
If you're interested in that, we'll pop a link in the description to a previous video
we've made.
However, that's not actually what I was doing.
I was not heat training.
I was simply riding to work with the core sensor still attached to my Haro Monster strap.
What I found was that in spite of it being mid-winter, about minus two, my core temperature
when I was riding was elevated to the point where it was actually detrimental to my performance,
let alone the fact that I was just a sweaty mess when I arrived.
When I look around at what other cyclists are wearing, it's clear that there are a lot
of different strategies for how to approach winter.
Here in the UK, there are always some brave souls in shorts, no matter what the conditions.
Then head south to Spain and riders will dress for the Arctic when the temperature drops
below 20 degrees centigrade.
Then over in Canada, I'm told that unless you actually dress for the Arctic, you'll
probably die.
What is right?
It's fair to say that it is very complicated, keeping your extremities warm whilst not boiling
your core.
It's time for our experiment.
I'm going to wear what I usually wear, what I've been wearing for the last 30 odd years,
in fact, for the control.
Then I'm going to dress how I see a lot of cyclists dressing, which is to keep my core
warm but wearing shorts.
Then I'm going to reverse it.
I'm going to keep my legs and arms much warmer, but then have less on my core, which I've
never done before, but it could be the answer.
I'm going to measure data using a power meter to keep my effort consistent, and then I'll
be wearing two core temperature sensors.
One in the usual place on my heart rate monitor strap, and then one on my quadricep, my thigh.
I'm ready.
Control run.
This is what I would choose to wear on a day like today, where it's overcast, five degrees,
a little bit humid, cold wind, but compared to Canada, absolutely fine.
I've got a windproof gilet on.
I've got a long-sleeve thermal top, and then I've got a thin long-sleeve base layer, normal
pair of tights.
I'm going to have windproof gloves, and I've got windproof overshoes.
Then, yes, that's basically me.
Also, just off-camera, come and join.
Hello.
I've got someone to keep me company.
Alex, you look like you're wearing exactly the same as me.
Long-sleeve base layer, thermal long-sleeves, windproof gilet, or vest as some people call
it, winter gloves, bib tights, and bondage overshoes.
We are literally exactly the same apart from your jazzy overshoes.
They kind of match your helmet.
Okay.
Right.
Now, it's important to note that Core have said that we should expect our core body temperatures
to rise when we're riding up to about 38 degrees, and then it should stabilize from there.
Okay?
Sounds nice because I'm actually freezing right now.
I'm a little bit chilly.
Come on.
Let's go.
Core have also said that we want to look at both my core temperature and my skin temperature.
Research has shown that if your core temperature rises too far, you lose performance.
Research has also shown that if it drops, surprise, surprise, you also lose performance
and really dramatically.
One degree sees a drop of up to 70% in a simple time-to-exhaustion experiment, but participants
dropped 65% even if it was just half a degree lower.
Now, that makes a lot of sense, and most of us would only ever get that cold in exceedingly
rare circumstances, thankfully, but what was also super interesting about that study was
that researchers repeated it, but this time, they kept the participants' core temperatures
the same, but just lowered their skin temperature instead, and in that one, the time to exhaustion
still decreased by 30% this time.
Now, in terms of reasons why, obviously, your skin temperature isn't completely separate
to your core temperature, and you can imagine that the muscles closest to the skin would
also therefore get a bit colder, and that would negatively affect your performance,
but there's another factor as well, and that is that we know that psychologically, if people
feel cold, then that also then has a negative effect on their performance, and that might
well just be hands and feet, but it still changes the way it feels when you ride.
We need to keep warm.
The challenge with dressing for cold-weather cycling, and by that, I mean five degrees
in wet down to minus whatever Canadians ride in, is that we want to keep our core temperature
constant, but yet maintain skin temperatures.
No, Sherlock, I hear you say, but the difficulty though is to do that and not overheat, because
as we heard, performance can drop.
Plus, it's very easy to layer up and then get really sweaty, which is unpleasant, but
can also then end up leaving you colder when you have to stop or you end up riding down
a mountain.
Okay, a little update for you.
It's quite blustery out, isn't it?
Just a little bit windy.
Both of us started out feeling a little bit chilly, maybe because of my faffing around
changing pure tides.
What's your core temperature reading now, Alex?
Okay, I'm currently at 37.6 degrees.
It's just cleaned up to the 0.6.
Okay, fine.
I'm exactly the same.
Not only are we close buddies, we're temperature buddies as well.
I assume when I started out on this ride at 37.0.
Yes, so yes.
We're following along with what Cor said would happen, but neither of us are burning up yet.
I've definitely got a sweat on, I think.
We've always described it as a nice temperature right now.
Yes, we've got 30 minutes of riding on the clock.
Run number one completed.
This is what we would normally wear.
Core temperature, mine got up to 38.
I got to 37.9.
Did you?
I think I got to 38.
You're a bit cooler than me.
Yes, I am very cool.
But also not as hot.
Okay, but then interestingly, so my thigh sensor, let's drag that one up.
Core temperature was the same, got to 38.
Interestingly, my skin temperature decreased over the course of the ride.
It was down at 28.
No, 26 was the lowest.
Yes?
Yes.
Oh, fair.
My core and skin temperature has obviously just cooled down as we've
done the last little bit of ride, but my skin temperature peaked relatively early
and then it's gradually tailed off.
Maybe that's to do with the speed and the headwind we were riding into.
Either that or the sweat because both of us said,
oh, we feel really nice and comfortable after 30 minutes of riding, but now
I've sweated through my base layer and actually it's chilly.
As soon as the wind comes, I'm like, oh.
Which is exactly what I've been trying to avoid, right?
Is getting a real head of steam up, sweating, and then getting cold.
Yes, because not only does your kit keep the cold out,
when you're sweating, it can't get rid of that.
Then it's like, well, that's stuck there.
Exactly.
Right, run number two.
You fancy putting some shorts on, mate?
Yes.
Yes, that would be nice.
Shorts and a warm top.
Yes.
Brilliant.
That was good.
Here we go then.
Run number two.
Super thick thermal windproof jacket with a thick base layer on and then shorts.
Those are nice shiny shoes, aren't they?
They are.
For the moment.
I think the risk with this one is that our cores are going to get really warm,
but then our legs should get cold, which would mean that would decrease performance.
Then worse than that, I think we're going to feel cold with cold feet,
but yet we're still going to be overheating at the same time.
It's like our bodies won't know what's going on.
Potentially.
Am I hot? Am I cold? I don't know.
They will know what's going on.
They'll know that we're being idiots because we're wearing shorts.
Anyway, let's see.
All right.
While I'm out riding, I thought that with the power of editing,
I would also take the opportunity to dive a little more into some science.
The research that I quoted earlier was done on cyclists in an indoor test.
Now, I'm not going to lie.
I would not have wanted to volunteer for this one,
not only because of the use of rectal thermometers,
but nevertheless, the results are pretty valuable.
Thank you to those brave cyclists.
However, not much else has been done on cyclists,
but there is plenty of research into cross-country skiers
for whom cold weather performance is literally a day-to-day challenge.
Now, one of the most interesting papers for us
used five core sensors per athlete to monitor skin temperature
on various parts of the body as well as their core temperature.
They tested the skiers in two different outfits,
one warmer one and one cooler one.
The researchers found that the skin and therefore,
by proxy, muscle temperature, remember,
dropped everywhere but most significantly on the thighs
to the point where it was actually reducing their performance.
Hands, too, were reported as getting uncomfortably cold.
However, skiers felt that overall, they were warmer.
Now, strangely, clothing choice made no statistical difference to the results.
The conclusion of the paper, one of them,
was that clothing design for these skiers should potentially change,
targeting the extremities rather than the core
and that there needed to be a way of losing heat from the skier's torso,
which sounds a little bit like what's coming next.
That was unpleasant, wasn't it?
Well, it was nice riding along chatting to you,
but in terms of body temperature regulation,
I feel very confused and conflicted because cold, incredibly hot.
Yes, I feel cold.
My core temperature is a little bit lower than the previous one,
but not by much.
I'm like 37.9 as opposed to 38.
What's super interesting as well is actually the skin temperature on my quad
is the same as on the previous one, so that hasn't changed.
Even though my feet are bloody freezing.
Yes, mine are icy cold.
Yes, actually, my quad hasn't changed,
but because I feel cold,
that also is going to have a negative effect on my performance.
I think because I've sweated so much in this top underneath here,
I'm now actually freezing cold because it's immediately cooled down and I've stopped,
but when we were riding, my legs were really cold.
My upper body was feeling like it was overheating.
It's so hard to explain.
It just feels weird because I've got so used to trying to
regulate my temperature and dress correctly.
Yes, well, it's going to be even weirder on run number three.
You're bowing out at this point, aren't you?
Because you haven't brought random stuff like I have.
I wasn't down for the weird bit.
All right, things are going to get weird, mate.
This is totally bonkers.
Never in my life have I dressed like this,
but the theory is sound based on that research and my own creativity, shall we say.
What I've got is I've got arm warmers and a thermal top,
and then I haven't got a vest.
Under there is just bare skin.
The idea being that I'm going to keep my extremities warm,
but hopefully, I'm not going to get super sweaty
because my core is going to have a little bit more airflow,
but then my legs, I've got windproof tights and then these outrageous overshoes,
so my legs also should be nice and toasty.
The question is, will I stay warm and will it actually feel any better?
Before I tell you how my reverse dressing is going,
one thing that has occurred to me is how much individual factors
might affect what you should wear.
I've thought about it from my perspective,
and that my body composition has changed over the years.
Not massively, but when I was a professional cyclist,
I had basically no body fat around my midriff.
Now, I'm a 42-year-old who still fancies himself as a bit of a bike rider,
but actually only does six hours a week.
I've got a little bit more, should I say.
To actually make sense then, given that I've got more natural insulation,
I should need to wear less, to wear fewer clothes.
Perhaps it's not that I've been getting it wrong for 30 years,
it's that I've been getting it wrong for the last four years.
That's definitely something.
Therefore, it also got me thinking that what works for me
may not work for anyone else.
It's certainly going to depend on what power you ride at,
the more power you put out, the more heat you'll be producing.
Nevertheless, I definitely think there are some take-homes
for everyone following this little experiment.
Well, I need a debrief, but I think that's going to surprise you, genuinely.
A few days have passed now since my tests,
in part so I could actually double-check my findings, do a bit more riding,
because frankly, I am struggling.
I am genuinely struggling to get my head around things,
because the final test, that one where I was dressed like a total idiot,
it was really, really good, both in the way it felt
and backed up by the data I got from the core sensors.
I actually checked with one of the boffins at core, Brian.
Thanks, Brian.
He said that the data looked solid.
In essence, what I found was that those first two tests,
you can see from the core data that my legs became colder than optimal,
particularly with the shorts.
Then I was really at a level where I was losing performance.
My skin temperature dropped to 26.7, which is not far above that study,
which showed a 30% reduction in time to exhaustion.
However, my core temperature was elevated to 38 degrees,
and as a result, my torso felt sweaty and uncomfortable.
On the final run though, dressed like an idiot, remember,
the skin temperature on my legs was much higher at 30 degrees,
so my muscles were able to work optimally.
That was backed up by how it felt.
My legs just felt good, basically, like I could press on the pedals
and dance up climbs, whatever I needed to do.
While my core temperature was still as high as before at 38 degrees,
I felt way more comfortable.
Having no base layer on meant that air could just circulate around my torso.
There was literally no sweaty, clammy feeling.
Then when I stopped, because of the fact that I wasn't wet with sweat,
I stayed warmer even though I was wearing less clothing.
You can see that backed up in the data as well.
My skin temperature on my torso was lower when I was riding,
which explains why I was so much more comfortable.
Yes, I have since repeated this and I have felt exactly the same.
My brain is screaming that it doesn't work,
but when I'm out on the bike, I feel toasty warm
and then also breezy fresh at the same time.
I have learned something from all of this.
I need to keep my legs and my arms warmer when I ride
and that while I've long suspected that windproof layers on my torso
make me feel uncomfortable, now I've got some data to back it up.
Not only that, I need to go one step further and actively wear less.
Now, if this was a piece of scientific research in a peer-reviewed journal,
there would be a section at the end called limitations,
of which there are plenty.
This is just one person riding at one intensity in one weather condition,
six degrees overcast, windy, and high humidity since you're asking.
It may well not translate to you, your weather conditions,
Canadians, and the type of riding that you do.
However, I suspect that it might because you see now thanks to new tech,
sensors like the core ones,
we're paying more attention to our body temperature when riding.
Typically, it's been about cooling our bodies in warmer climbs,
but why not colder ones too where the challenges are different?
Keeping extremities warm while not overheating.
Let me know what you think about all of this.
Have I struck upon something or am I completely losing the plot?
Although, before you say that I've gone bananas, I think you have to try it.
Because 10 years ago, if I told you that the Tour de France
would be one on 30-millimeter wide tires ridden at 60 PSI,
you would also have said that I was bananas.
I'm having trouble convincing even my colleagues here at GCN.
Conor's done that thing where he's raised his eyebrows and gone like,
but believe you me, give it a try.
Let me know in the comment section down below.
Anyway, like I say, I'm really, really looking forward to reading your thoughts on this one.
Please do get involved and give the video a thumbs up if you've enjoyed it,
or you've at least appreciated the fact that I've tried with something new.
