Geometry, Measur And Astronomy In Ancient Britain - Dr Euan MacKie - Megalithomania Interview

Artifact Archives
9 followers
3 Video Views·Apr 14, 2026
Hey Megalithomaniacs, welcome to the Megalithomania podcast. Today we've got a very interesting
interview with Dr. Ewan Mackay. He was an archaeologist, he was the curator of the
Hunterian Museum in Glasgow and he spoke at the 2013 Megalithomania conference in Glastonbury.
He died in 2020 but his legacy is profound. He was one of the archaeologists and academics who
really supported the work of Alexander Thom and his research on archaeoastronomy and ancient
metrology. This culminated in the book called The Megalith Builders which was published in 1977
and he worked with Alexander Thom towards the end of his life and in this interview which we recorded
during the conference we get into some of the details about why Alexander Thom's work was
generally overlooked by academia and how Ewan Mackay kind of pushed it into the forefront
where it kind of remains today. I think it's an important aspect of this work that Ewan Mackay
was one of the only academics who really supported the work of Alexander Thom so it's a real pleasure
to have a chance to sit down and talk with him. I really do hope you enjoy this interview.
So Dr Ewan Mackay maybe you could just introduce yourself and a bit about your work.
I am trained as an archaeologist. I was at St John's College Cambridge at the end of the 1950s
so I had a very orthodox training specialising in the later prehistory of Europe.
It wasn't really until I came to Glasgow University to be an assistant curator at the
Hunterian Museum in 1960 that I really heard about Alexander Thom and his work
and that was introduced to me about three years later by Professor Archie Roy who died recently
unfortunately who had been surveying some stone circles on Arran and wanted me to assist with
publication to make sure he hadn't made any archaeological blunders and so on.
He told me about Professor Thom and his work but it really wasn't until
Thom's first book appeared in 1967 and the row that provoked in the archaeological profession
that I became seriously interested in all this and eventually decided I want to
try and do something to persuade myself either it was all nonsense or it was something in it.
I think the evidence that Professor Thom has given us makes it overwhelmingly probable
that astronomy could have been practised and it seems to me that it's up to us as archaeologists
to make an all-out effort to investigate as many sites as we can whether in fact the
man did do this, did do the things that Professor Thom has shown could be done.
You mentioned Alexander Thom as part of your kind of inspiration for getting into these subjects
but what do you think the reason was that the ancients actually built these monuments?
Do you think it was a primary purpose or many purposes?
The reason our Neolithic ancestors built stone circles and standing stones and henge monuments
is of course much argued over by not only by archaeologists but by other interested people as
well. My own view taking into account what I now think about Thom's work is that they were the
edifices, the instruments if you like, and the ceremonial centres of a priesthood,
a Neolithic professional priesthood who existed in the third millennium and part of the second
millennium BC. This is not a popular view in archaeology but I think most people would
accept that they were ritual sites of some kind and that it's so important that a gigantic effort
was made by many communities to heave the stones up and into position and bring them to the site
so whatever view you take about the exact function,
the work involved seems to have been absolutely central to the societies of the time.
Why do you think that nowadays and in the past these sites have such powerful effect on people?
The reason they have such strong feelings is not entirely clear to me.
I think from my own experience when you see a standing stone on a bit of Scottish moorland
it does somehow seem to be speaking to you or at least challenging you to explain it.
Why did this monster block get dragged there and heaved up, rammed into its socket? Was it
just random? Was it a signpost for a footpath or bridle path or was there something more to it?
They are very dramatic structures the circles and the stones and of course the slightly earlier
chamber tombs and so on. Also perhaps the fact that there's not much else from that time which
you can look at except an Orkney makes them seem that more important and requiring our understanding.
I would go for the atmosphere. The lonely places, the dramatic stones,
you know I think that really can't fail to have an effect on you.
Do you think that when they built the monuments they were building them to last many thousands
of years and almost as though they were leaving a message for future generations.
Do you have any ideas about that? I'm not at all sure what the long-term
motivation of these people was. If we take it as a reasonable idea for example that the standing
stones usually marked some kind of calendar line or astronomical alignment, I would imagine that
the only alternative they had to ramming in a wooden post was an upright stone. Whether they
thought well this will be here for another 5,000 years, possibly. I think that's rather unlikely
but they knew the posts only had a life of 20 years or more so they thought at least if they
thought in terms of the few generations of their colleagues they would want to have something
massive there. They seem to have had the power and authority to recruit the labour to do it which in
itself is very interesting. It does seem they went to a lot of trouble to build these sites
when you look at some of the size of the megaliths and just the sheer amount of earth moved
and just dragging stones from many many miles away often sometimes a very long way. Why do
you think they really went to that much effort to move stones and how do you think they probably
did that? The reason for moving stones to their chosen sites it's hard for us to grasp now unless
we adopt one of the explanatory theories like the astronomical motivation or something like that.
I suspect that the stones were moved not because they could be moved but because rather there was
an organization that was there and had the power to recruit the labour and so on and that would
imply that there's something more than perhaps a simple village stony society in existence
at the time. In fact I think it was Richard Atkinson who way back in the 1950s first made
this point that the sheer amount of labour which was put into Avery, Stonehenge, Silbury Hill and
so on must have meant, that must mean that there was a powerful man or people, a powerful group
who could recruit the labour from hundreds of miles around to get the work done.
As to how it was done I think enough experimental archaeology has taken place to show
that most of what we see could have been done with fairly primitive techniques,
rollers of wood, earthen ramps, huge levers provided there were enough men to work them and
provide it and this is a very important provider that there were skilled people to supervise the
project. I don't think there's any problem about that in a stony society when you look at what
other kinds of stony society there are throughout the world and what they achieve without metal tools.
You mentioned maybe some of these sites they brought in helpers and workers from hundreds
of miles away therefore do you think the sites maybe from way down south in England even to
Scotland and even France, Brittany for instance, do you think there was a network of people and
they kind of worked by the same principles and same working with the same astronomy
with the same metrology or do you think it was more isolated? The kind of societies that
produced these monuments all over Britain and Ireland and the west coast of Atlantic Europe
are so similar, at least the results of their efforts are so similar, that it's difficult to
doubt that there was some kind of group or elite class which was doing it. I know a lot of archaeologists
don't agree with that and prefer to think of them as the products of a simple agricultural society
but I think that it's only about 50 years since this was generally accepted in the 50s and 60s
that there was a group of people from Spain and Portugal right up to Orkney and parts of
Scandinavia as well who did this kind of thing. So I think it's quite likely that the idea will
come round again because the evidence is so strong. Why otherwise should there be stone circles
of basically similar kind throughout the whole of the British Isles unless there was some kind
of organisation which produced them and needed them? I think there is a very real danger that
we may underestimate what our prehistoric ancestors were capable of simply because
we perhaps subconsciously tend to assume that the evidence we have is the only evidence.
Do you think, as Alexander Tom I believe thought, was that there was a standard unit of measure
and they were working with the megalithic yard and do you think they were using these
kind of measurement systems throughout the British Isles and even in Europe,
but you know the ancient mythology kind of thing? Yes, Alexander Tom's work covered several
different aspects, one of which is the geometry of the stone circles and the other was whether
the circle builders laid out the circles using a unit of length and the third one of course was the
astronomy, the construction of long accurate alignments to pinpoint the passage of the sun
and moon as important parts of their cycles. As far as the metrology goes, I certainly thought
when I first read megalithic science in Britain that he had made out a very good case for there
being a standard unit of length. He called it the megalithic yard, just under 33 inches,
to lay out the exact circles which I think no one can doubt were what most of the stone circles were
set out as. A lot of people have spent a lot of time and effort in trying to
disprove this. Not being a mathematician, I'm not altogether sure whether I could argue
plausibly against that. All I can say is that the parallel work which I have tried to do
on an Iron Age building in Scotland known as Brock's has produced, through the same kind of
exact surveys of their interior wall faces, has produced evidence first of all they are exactly
circular, and secondly that a minority are elliptical in shape, and there seems to be some
evidence for the use of a unit of length by the Brock builders. So this is a parallel investigation
if you like, which I don't think would have produced such clear evidence of the kind of
work that Tom believed in, unless it was true. Again this is something that my colleagues in
Iron Age studies find rather difficult to accept, and it's not fully published yet,
but there's a lot of practical evidence connected in the field and I think it's going to be quite
hard to doubt it once it's all laid out. So yes, I think that there was something more than just
random pacing involved in laying out these ancient sites. I think the people concerned had
a system, they had a basic knowledge of geometry, and they had some kind of use of length. I'm not
sure whether the Megalithic Yard is the right one. With all this in mind, with the metrology,
the geometry, and the astronomy, which was decoded really by Alexander Tom,
why do you think academia has such a problem except in that our distant ancestors way back
then were that sophisticated? Yes, British archaeology has had great difficulty in coming
to terms with Tom's ideas. There was a point in the late 60s and the early 1970s when I thought
there might be a sea change occurring in our attitude to the kind of information he was
offering us. For example, Colin Renfrew, in his book Before Civilization, put forward an entirely
new radical scenario about European prehistory which maintained that it did not owe everything
to the civilizations of the Near East, which we had taken for granted before that. But there was
a lot of indigenous innovation going on in Europe in the Stone Age. One of the things he particularly
referred to was Tom's work in identifying a prehistoric calendar, for example, from all these
astronomical alignments. That book appeared in 1973. Then I wrote one, Science and Society in
Prehistoric Britain in 1977, which followed up that idea and tried to explain how well-known
archaeological sites could in fact have been the training colleges and residences of the
kind of priesthood that Colin Renfrew was proposing.
After that, there was a bit of a reaction against it, and the reaction gathered pace in the 80s
after Clive Ruggles began his program of research. The aim of which seems to have been to show that
Tom's ideas were exaggerated, particularly the notion that there were accurate alignments.
Ruggles thought he had disproved quite decisively. I think the archaeological profession
was really rather pleased that this had come about, because it then didn't have to undergo
this fundamental rethink about Neolithic society.
As to why there is this conservatism and conservativism in archaeology, partly it's
because of a natural reticence about accepting a dramatic new theory suddenly. People want to
test it and assess it over many years. But I think also another major part of the problem is that the
evidence which Tom used is extremely difficult for a layman to understand in detail. You have
to be familiar with elements of astronomy, simple mathematics, and so on. The fact is that these
things are not taught in archaeology courses in Britain, so it's quite difficult for colleagues to
be familiar with the evidence and what it means. Whatever the result, I'm afraid the
current situation is that Tom is not talked about, and people like myself who occasionally raise the
subject are regarded as on the fringe and a bit balmy, to be honest.
Yes, I can imagine that we get suggestions that megalithomania is a bit balmy, to be honest.
We mentioned the astronomy, the metrology, the geometry. Do you believe that the people who
built these sites, these stone circles and dolmens and megaliths, were they surveying,
and were they marking out a kind of mapping system or a survey over Great Britain?
The amount of surveying and skilled surveying and measuring that these
Neolithic peoples did, again, is a controversial subject. My own views on all this have to be
controlled by what I've actually done myself as a researcher in fieldwork and so on.
I personally think it's very important that, particularly when you're following an unorthodox
line, you have to try and justify it by the experimental method, by making a prediction
from the new evidence and seeing if it can be tested by fieldwork.
So the amount of successful testing I've been able to do is confined to specific
astronomical alignments and geometry and measuring, to some extent. I have not personally
done anything concerning possible miles-long surveying, though I know people have argued,
even Tom argued himself, that there was some evidence for the placing of stone circles,
for example, at units of megalithic yards. But I've never done anything to check that myself,
so I wouldn't really want to comment on that. But in theory, I suppose it is perfectly reasonable,
considering that these structures are so widely distributed over the British Isles.
How you would demonstrate it as a fact, I'm not quite so sure.
What do you make of the whole idea about lays, about these straight line alignments
going vast distances that Alfred Watkins came up with in the 1920s?
Lay lines, well, that is a subject which you only have to mention it to an archaeologist and
you're immediately classed as beyond the fringe, you know. So again, I haven't done any work on
this myself and from what I've heard today, for example, it does seem as though certain types of
sites do form straight lines, at least judging by the names of the sites.
To archaeologists, though, lay lines have a bit of a reputation of including too many sites of
different ages, to be plausible. I think it's one of these things you would have to do a really
rigorous investigation, choose only sites of a certain type, like standing stones or stone circles,
which could be said to be more or less contemporary, and then survey them accurately
to see if there was any trace of this. I'm not sure whether that's really been done yet,
so I'd reserve judgement on that.
Okay, and there's been like recent research, an example is around Stonehenge, where there's a,
I can't remember the name of the site, but there's a site being dug there relatively recently,
which has pushed the date back a lot further than even 5,000 years older than the traditional
dating of Stonehenge. So some people are now suggesting that that may be contemporary with
like this site they found in Turkey, Göbekli Tepe, which is like 10,000 BC onwards,
possibly some of the earlier sites in Brittany, which stretch back a few,
couple of thousand years older than Stonehenge. Do you think in a general sense that some sites
may be older than what is traditionally said to be?
The date of these sites is a very important problem, of course, a very important subject.
There is an argument that some sites are much older than we have thought. All I can say to that
is that there's now a whole string of radiocarbon dates for Stonehenge, for example, which have been
slotted into the various phases of the development of the site. They were all described in an article
in Antiquity by Mike Parker Pearson a couple of years ago, and there's certainly no suggestion
from those dates as a whole that the site is older than about 3,000 BC. As far as I know,
neighbouring sites of Neolithic type, like Durrington Walls, Woodhenge, and so on,
their available radiocarbon dates firmly slot them into the Neolithic period too.
Now, there are older sites, of course. We normally describe them as of the Mesolithic age,
the hunter-gatherer period. I can't recall myself anything that's shocked the archaeological
profession and made them rethink all this, but I may be wrong about that. But I think what you
have to remember is it's not just a single date, but a whole suite of dates for individual sites
that really are needed to tell us how old they are, and so far I don't think there's been any
major hiccup in the standardised radiocarbon chronology for the Neolithic period.
Is there anything else you'd like to add? Is there anything I may have missed that
would be of interest to any megalithomaniacs listening?
My own work in this field has tried to focus on making predictions from
Professor Tom's theories and trying to test them by archaeological fieldwork, so I'd quite
like to mention one example, which is the Standing Stone at Kintraw in Argyllshire.
This first came to my attention when Tom's second book was published, I think in the early 70s,
it was called Megalithic Lunar Observatories, and he described a Standing Stone at Kintraw in that,
pointing out that there was a magnificent long alignment to the southwest from the stone which
took your eye to a couple of conspicuous mountains on the Arlington Dura, and the mid-winter sunset
went down just in the notch between these two peaks, something like 28 miles away.
So it's a long alignment, but sufficiently long that the
mid-winter's day, the shortest day of the year, would be known exactly.
The problem was that when you stand beside the stone at Kintraw, you can't actually see the
notch on Dura because of an intervening ridge, tree-covered ridge, so there was a bit of a
problem there, and Tom recognised it. Either he had to make some special pleading that they
had a sight a little higher up where they could see over the obstruction,
or of course this was a devastating disproof of his long alignment theory. He found on a hillside
about 200 yards northeast of the stone a couple of boulders which he thought would be the place
where they stood, and actually could get a clear view of Dura and the mid-winter sunset.
So when I read all this, I thought, well, if that's the case, then maybe there's an
artificial platform there for the observers, and I will go and excavate it and find out whether
there is or not. So it was the first time I had a chance to test this theory with a
practical prediction and go and dig, and we found a platform.
Unfortunately, it didn't have any artefacts or any charcoal for C14 dating, but a soil scientist
came from the University of Aberdeen and did some intricate tests and established, I think,
beyond doubt that the rubble platform at Kintraw, which was revetted by two massive boulders to
keep it in place, was in fact artificial. And there's also another little standing stone a
bit higher up the slope, which reinforces the idea that the three items are connected.
The little standing stone higher on the slope, the platform and notch, boulder notch on the
hill slope, and the standing stone in the field below, they're all lined up on Dura
and on the midwinter sunset. So I think this is a pretty fairly decisive confirmation of
Tom's basic ideas, and I think it was the result of this that really made me persist
in looking for more evidence for or against his ideas, and on the whole they have been for.
But I'm sure colleagues might say, well, I'm a bit biased about that, but of course I don't agree.
But it still remains controversial, I'm afraid, and I haven't got to the point yet of being able
to say I've convinced my colleagues that there's something in all this. It's not too late though,
I hope to do so soon. Do you feel that the work of Alexander Tomlmore,
colleges and universities, a bit more emphasis on the way he was researching rather than, say,
Clyde Ruggles, or do you think the way it's going now, where they've kind of simplified it,
it's going to just continue as it is? I think the archaeology course in Britain ought at least to
include an element of surveying. The surveying skills which are required to assess standing
stones and stone circle alignments and the plans for stone circles. So at least people,
the new generation of archaeologists, would be aware of the kind of information that can be
collected from and assess it. At the moment there is, as far as I know, no such course except
in Clyde Ruggles' own old department in Leicester, where students have been taught for a number of
years how to do this. I think on the whole though that this kind of evidence is so controversial
that we're not going to make any progress in the profession of archaeology
unless Clyde Ruggles' ideas of very rough alignments are accepted, or unless entirely
independent archaeological evidence comes up that there was a priesthood in existence
in that time. I think we may be coming to the point when the latter condition is becoming
real. There are some remarkable discoveries, particularly in the island of Orkney,
which are beginning to suggest that there's no doubt at all there were temples there and a
priesthood, exactly as Tom's evidence were predicting.
Okay, great. Would you mind just, we ask, you don't have to do this, but we ask everyone just
to look in the camera and just say Megalithomania. Okay, Megalithomania.
Thanks for watching Megalithomaniacs. I hope you enjoyed our interview with Dr Ewan Mackay.
He is a real legend in my opinion, and you can actually see his lecture from the conference
in the link below. It's a very, very cool lecture, by the way, so it's well worth watching. A really
good archive of his research and his work and his relationship with Alexander Tom. And remember,
if you're watching on a podcast platform, please click the five star button, and it really helps
support us and gives us a good rating. Obviously, if you're watching on YouTube, please like,
share, and subscribe, and click the bell icon to get notifications of more of these interviews.
Thanks again, Megalithomaniacs, and we'll see you next time.
