Electric Sports Car Giant Test 2024 | Are EVs finally fun?

Cars Arena
18 followers
4 Video Views·Apr 13, 2026
We took six of 2024's best electric performance cars on road and track to find out which one is
best. When I first started doing this job we couldn't have done this test. One, there simply
wasn't enough fast electric cars to make it interesting and two, the measure for success
would have just come down to which has the most outrageous acceleration figure. It's only in the
last few years that the makers of fast electric cars have started to focus on the one thing
that we value above pretty much all else. Namely, which one puts the biggest smile on your face.
Right here, right now, that shouldn't be a problem. We've got track-focused Porsches,
jaw-dropping supercars, hyperactive mega hatches and even a Lotus SUV. Together,
they deliver over 6,000 brake horsepower, cost almost £4 million and create possibly
our most outrageous group test yet. Now a lot of what you see will be done on road because,
let's face it, that's where these cars are going to spend most of their time. But fear not,
we're also taking almost every car onto the legendary Nürburgring GP track to make sure
we get the best and most thorough verdict possible. This is Car Magazine and this is our
first ever electric sports car giant test. Let the games begin. We're going to start with the Tesla
Model S Plaid because, as electric performance cars go, this isn't just the OG, it's also got
to be the benchmark. Without Elon Musk and his crazy yet oh-so-often brilliantly brave ideas,
this type of car simply wouldn't be where it is today. The Model S may be over 12 years old and
it may look decidedly ordinary in today's company, but underestimate it at your peril. Tesla has had
a lot of time to get it right and it shifts these in incredible numbers for a reason.
Newsflash, Tesla Model S Plaid is quick. You didn't need me to tell you that and honestly,
I'm not going to dwell on it too much because there's not a single car in this test that
doesn't take your head off every time you put your foot down. But I think it would be remiss
of me not to point out just how good Tesla's powertrain is. It's not just the sheer speed of
it, it's the way that it gains the speed. The throttle response is damn near perfect,
doesn't matter what mode you're in, it's really smooth, it's crisp, there's no interruptions in
it and yeah, the speed, it's up there with McLarens and Ferraris and whatever supercar you
want really, it's astonishing. For sheer shock and awe, there's few cars that can do what the
Model S Plaid does. The fact that its interior is decked out like a high-tech dental surgery
only adds to the element of surprise when it takes off like a rocket and sends upwards of
1,000 brake horsepower coursing through the tarmac. You know, I think there's a lot going
for this Tesla, for Tesla in general, the performance, the innovation, the charging
network which is just leagues above anyone else's but driving this on road and on track,
it reminds me of some of the reasons why we've had issues getting on with EV performance cars.
For example, the steering, it's quick enough, it's direct enough, it's precise enough but
I've just got no feel, I've got no real idea how much grip the front wheels have got and actually,
I reckon they've got a lot of grip. In fact, when you do start to send it in and you've got a track
where you can do that sort of thing, you can tell that this car hangs on really well indeed but
with varying conditions on the road and just not quite knowing what the surface is like,
you don't get enough information by a long way.
When it came to driving the Tesla on the Nürburgring, it faced the same issue as all
of the other cars, namely the weather was pretty terrible. Off-camera however, we did get a chance
to track the cars in the dry and for the Tesla in particular, the extra space allowed me to find
the car's limits at which point there was more of a sense of what was going on through the steering.
Unfortunately, the car we had on test was not the track package version yet it still
gave the impression it could set a mighty lap time if the weather was improved.
I think this Model S Plaid has been a great place to start with this test. It's a brilliant
benchmark, it's shown for years how capable and effective performance electric vehicles can be
but now, years on, I think we're looking to move the game forward and I think there's cars out
there that can do it, that can be more fun, be more exciting and more engaging. That's what we're
for on this test and that is what I hope some of the other cars can do. So with the Tesla setting
a benchmark of where we've come from, I hopped into one of the newest cars on this test,
namely the Porsche Taycan Turbo GT to see how much progress has been made.
Of course, we know plenty about Stuttgart's first ever EV but this is the first time it's been given
a track-focused treatment. The GT signifies Porsche's most serious attempt yet at wrestling
EV production car lap records off Tesla with fastest laps of both Laguna Seca and the Nürburgring.
In order to do this, it's got up to 68bhp more than a regular Turbo S thanks to a push-to-pass
attack mode plus overall kerb weight is down 145kg. 70kg of this is down to the no-cost option
VISAC package. This removes the rear seats, both surround sound system, one of the charging ports
and more, while also adding additional aero to deliver up to 220kg of downforce.
Aside from the Formula E car, this is without doubt Porsche's sharpest EV yet.
But it still weighs about 2.2 tonnes with the VISAC pack and although this isn't the heaviest car
on this test, it's definitely the heaviest car to ever be offered with the VISAC pack.
And thus, does it suffer from the same problem as the Tesla or can it move the game on somehow?
Well, suffice to say it's still breathtakingly capable but there's far more communication
between the car's limits and the driver. The steering, for example, is the finest on test
and while not at 911 levels, it feels nicer and more precise than any Panamera. Front-end grip
is prodigious and the agility makes you question whether the car is somehow anticipating your
movements. The way this thing goes through corners, a large part of it is down to the Porsche Active
Ride with GT-specific tuning so you've got all four dampers individually keeping the car level
through longitudinal and lateral forces. It can even lean the car into corners and then when you
couple that with the Porsche torque vectoring and the rear wheel steering, the way this thing is so
clean and precise through corners, oh man, it's breathtaking. I think that is where it really
stands out, it's the direction changes and the way it just darts around but it doesn't do it
in an intimidating way, at least not at road speeds. It's not quite perfect though. The brake
pedal is totally at odds with the feel from the steering. You'll go to apply them and not only
find plenty of travel but also an inconsistency that really shouldn't be there. Also, there's a
noticeable jolt when switching ratios with the unusual two-speed transmission that, while not
the end of the world, does again feel in contrast to the rest of the car which is very polished.
Overall though, it's a small price to pay. I mean, by rights, this car, this much weight,
this much power in these slippery, greasy conditions with these tyres, it shouldn't work
but somehow, somehow it does. It really, really works. Clearly, the Porsche's tyres were a
disadvantage on the wet track yet in the dry, the flatness, poise and levels of traction really stood out.
Considering this is the first electric Porsche GT, the levels it can deliver relative to the
petrol cars is far closer than you'd ever expect. So, the Porsche Taycan Turbo GT has already taken
the EV performance bar up a notch but in a market where a new name seemingly appears every day,
that often means nothing. So, right on cue, let me introduce you to the Pininfarina Batista.
Actually, you've probably heard the name before. Pininfarina is one of, if not the biggest name
in the history of car design. Founded in 1930 by Batista Farina, they've been instrumental in
designing some of the greatest looking cars of all time. The Alfa Romeo Giulietta Spyder,
the Ferrari 250 GT, the Dino, the Daytona, the F50, even the Hyundai Levita. Pininfarina has
styled them all and now it's had a go at making its own car. And here it is. It's 2.7 million pounds
worth of utterly damn gorgeous. A polished carbon body shell draped over a Rimac Nivera, it somehow
manages to avoid the clutches of vulgarity and instead blows you away with its delicate beauty.
I was doing so well not to get swayed by the power and torque figures of these cars. But I'm
sorry, when you've got 1,874 brake horsepower and 1,700 pounds worth of torque, that grabs your attention.
Step back from this world of unfathomable power, however, and the Batista's ability to cruise
around at low speeds is commendable. The four motors and two transmissions work together
smoothly and serenely. And while this 2C car weighs over two tons, if you dial up through
the drive modes, Karma, Pura, Energica and Furioso, you have a chassis that is infused
with pure torque vectoring and as such, it can pull off some breathtaking feats.
What I really like in this car is the steering because it treads a really,
really fine balance between being too light so that you get a sense of disconnect and you don't
get good feel, but it's light enough so that it makes the whole car feel lighter and more agile.
And it's just treading that balance brilliantly. And they say that a good steering setup can just
transform a car. And I definitely think that's the case with this because you've got that initial
speed just off centre. But then when you turn more into a corner, that's when you feel the outside
wheel digging in and it feels so positive. The steering itself is really precise. It's accurate
and it just lets you enjoy it even when you're not actually going that quick. That's the big
thing with this is that you don't just have that incredible power to let you enjoy it. There's also
the steering and how it feels, which is unusual with a car that weighs this much. Regardless of
whether it's petrol or electric, a car's ability to remain enjoyable even when you're not anywhere
close to its vast limits is perhaps one of the greatest tricks it can pull off. And it has to
be said that the various drive modes such as Karma with 617 brake horsepower really help with this.
I also like how low you're sitting. This is the lowest driving position of all the cars here.
So it instantly feels more special. It instantly feels more like a supercar. And again,
I don't think I've driven an EV with a driving position quite like this. Granted, I haven't
driven every one, but I still think this is pretty rare in just how much of a proper supercar view
out you actually get. For insurance reasons, Pininfarina's vehicle tester drove the Batista
on the Nürburgring, yet I still got an opportunity to drive it on track in the dry the day before.
As you'd expect, the speed is like nothing else, and you'd swear the Speedo was in kilometers with
the rate at which it gathers numbers. But also, it was surprisingly approachable,
and the steering gave you great confidence going into corners. On exit, the torque vectoring allows
you to be greedy with the throttle, but you still need to have a lot of respect for how the power
and the weight can get you into trouble very quickly indeed. What it definitely proves,
is that an EV with huge mass can still handle. So, does that mean you can have an enjoyable
performance EV SUV? Welcome to the future of Lotus cars. Welcome to the Eletre R SUV.
Some of you may be repulsed by the sight of a 2.5 tonne Lotus, others will be intrigued,
and many will be feeling a mixture of both. Whatever you want to say about this car though,
it's certainly not short of talking points. And perhaps the most alarming one,
is that with 905 brake horsepower, this top spec Eletre R is the least powerful car
we've tested so far on this test. It's not often you get so readily outgunned with 900 plus ponies,
but then, these are unusual times. Now, as you'd no doubt expect,
the Eletre R is brimming with tech to make it handle. So, you've got twin chamber air suspension,
you've got active ride height control, active rear wheel steering, active anti-roll and
torque vectoring through braking. And it definitely needs all that because something
this tall and this heavy probably isn't going to handle that well without it, I reckon.
Ironically, this is pretty much the opposite to previous Lotus cars that many of us know
were absolutely sublime without any form of driver aid assistance or fancy technology
keeping the car on the road. Like I said, these are unusual times.
Now, what we found with this car that's quite interesting is that in the dry,
it's largely as you'd expect. Very effective, not a huge amount of fun, very well tied down,
fantastic body control, but yeah, not really getting your juices going.
But now, in the wet, things have changed a little bit. In sport mode,
you've really got to manage the back because the amount of power that's going through is
obviously more than enough to spin the rear wheels up. But it's not doing it in a terrifying
because this is an extremely tall, heavy SUV kind of way. It's doing it in a playful, engaging kind
of style. I'm honestly quite surprised, to be honest with you. I really wasn't expecting this
from this car. And as I said, the body is incredibly well tied down. There's virtually
zero roll. And that's no mean feat when the steering is as quick and direct as this is,
but it doesn't feel too much. It's really nicely judged. Also interesting is the brake pedal has
got better feel than the Porsches. I mean, it's not saying much because it really isn't that good
in the Taycan, but it does mean that when you're stopping this into a corner, you can feel what's
going on. And that's pretty crucial when this thing weighs as much as it does. I keep going
on about that, but it is in the back of your mind, even when it handles like it does. It's
always wanting to move around. But just step away from the dynamics for a minute,
because while they're impressive, I think what's arguably even better is the cabin of this car.
This is the nicest interior I've sat in in a while. It's really high quality. The materials
feel great. The design is new. It's interesting. There's lots of lovely details around. Not a fan
of the digital mirrors still, but as digital mirrors go, they're pretty good. But this is
such a lovely place to sit. And it goes without saying that the cabin is such a big improvement
over what we've seen before from Lotus. It's like going from the Conference League South
all the way to the sharp end of the Premier League. It's properly nice. Honestly, the cabin
is fantastic. And besides the infuriating warning chimes and sounds constantly interrupting my
pieces to camera. Speed limit alarm off. Always off. Right. I enjoyed everything about sitting
behind the wheel of the Lotus. However, one thing did occur to me. You know, I think the weird thing
and almost sad thing about this car is that it's, I think, suffering because of the Lotus name,
because people have seen it. It's a big, heavy SUV. And they've gone, well, that's not a proper
Lotus. And OK, it's not a Lotus that we've seen before. But equally, if this was a brand new
manufacturer that we'd never heard of before, I think it would be received a lot better because
there's no real reason why you'd pan this thing unless you were comparing it to the Lotuses that
we've seen before. And in that case, well, as a performance car, it's always going to lose.
As with the other cars, we took the Lotus out for a few laps on the Nürburgring. And as you can see,
it required my full attention to keep on top of all the power and mass. In truth, though,
I had good fun and you can see what Lotus has tried to do. The chassis felt very sharp and
alert. And my only real feedback would be that it just needed to work more cohesively with the mass
it's carrying. Still, all round a very pleasant and surprising experience. And that brings us
neatly on to this. Welcome to the Hyundai IONIQ 5N. At £65,000, it is anything but cheap, yet it is
the least expensive car here. It's also the smallest and the only one representing the
good old-fashioned hot hatch category. Now, like the Lotus, the Hyundai IONIQ 5N is a fairly fluid
take on its genre. It's not a hot hatch in the same way that a Peugeot 205 GTI was, but then
it doesn't claim to be. What it does claim to do, though, is be fun by the bucket load.
On first impressions, I know this to be the case because at the end of last year, I flew for nearly
30 hours to go and drive the IONIQ 5N on its own patch and was very impressed. Like the Lotus and
many other cars on this test, it majors on experience enhancing technology. Now, it sounds
like that could be pretty naff, but you've actually got some really cool stuff here. So we've got
N active sound. We've got N pedal, which is where it's like an extreme one-pedal driving mode.
There's N torque distribution, so you can make it 100% front-wheel drive or 100% rear-wheel drive.
There's N drift optimizer with clutch kick. The clutch kick doesn't work that well because you
need to have your hands at 9 and 3, which obviously when you're drifting, you don't,
but it's still a nice idea. And also, one of my favourites is N e-shift. Now, you might have
noticed that I'm using the paddles here to not adjust the regen, but to change gear. It's not
really a gear, obviously, but the software has incorporated gears into itself. So I'm in fourth,
third, second. I've even got a rev counter that has a red line and a hard limiter. It's not a real
hard limiter, but it still feels like one and the torque curve is changed so that the higher you rev,
the more you run out of puff. And I've got to be honest, it works really,
really well. It definitely adds a layer of engagement that I never really thought you
could do with an EV. And when I turn this off and I have it in just the one continuous speed,
I actually feel a little bit sick because I'm sort of expecting that gear change to come in,
but it doesn't and it feels very unusual. It's like stepping onto an escalator that isn't
working. Your brain is expecting something that just doesn't materialize. All of these gadgets
offer something to the driving experience. I'm not entirely convinced by the sound effects and
the clutch kick, but you can see the intention. Leave all of this aside for one second, however,
and the question is, is there a proper hot hatch underneath? Well, to try and ensure this, Hyundai
made enhancements to the body and white structure, reinforced the motor and battery mountings,
beefed up the subframes and worked on the drive axles to prepare the IONIQ 5
RID's performance car transformation. The result is just so impressive. Ex-Ford
performance engineer Tyrone Johnson crafted the dynamics on this car and it definitely shows
because it really reminds me of the last gen Ford Focus RS. You've got really quite meaty steering
that isn't as precise or delicate as something like a Honda Civic Type R, but it feels nicely
connected to the road. It gives you a good sense of what's going on, even if the outright feel
that you get in, say, a lighter sports car, it's not at that level, but you've still got a nice
sensation of what the front wheels are doing and then what the rest of the car is doing.
It's really malleable and chuckable. That's the key thing with this, is that unlike a lot of
very heavy cars, it actually responds well to being thrown around a bit. It doesn't just
suddenly all come undone. It's obviously better in the dry than it is in the wet,
that's just a byproduct of the weight, but I mean, even now, I'm still having a good time
in this thing. You know, the gadgets and gizmos on this car, they won't be for everyone, I get
that. I'd definitely say have a go because I think they're really good fun for the most part and
definitely add something to the driving experience, but the thing is that if there wasn't
a good car dynamically underneath, they would feel really, really silly and the point is that there
is a really good car and I honestly think it's really telling that of all the cars on this test,
this is the one that's doing the most kilometres. It's the one that's running out of range the
quickest, it's because everyone wants to have a go in it, everyone wants to drive it. It's the only
car here that properly makes you get in and think, yes, I want to drive it like a bit of a hooligan,
I want to go quickly in it. It's just such a laugh. Out on track, the Hyundai inspired a ton
of confidence, even in the wet conditions. It's not a small or a light car, far from it, yet after
the other contenders, I felt like I could jump in and drive it hard straight away. What's more,
the NE Shift was a game changer on track as it gave a proper reference point in the corners.
Overall, it was superb. Finally, we move on to our last car in this test, the BMW i5 M60.
Munich stopped short of calling this an all-electric M5, but since it's the same shape
and platform as the car that will eventually be the M5, it's not hard to draw the connection.
It also develops 593 brake horsepower, which even by M5 standards is impressive, but incredibly,
it also makes it the least powerful car on this test. However, as the Hyundai has shown,
less can sometimes be more, so is that the case with the BMW?
You know, there's something very telling about this car, and it's that when we did a straw poll
among the people on this test, which car we'd most like to drive home in, this was the winner,
and I can see why. It's just so, so nice to drive. It doesn't matter what setting you've
got the suspension in, it's smooth, soaks up the bumps brilliantly, it's really refined,
the tech works, everything makes sense, the seats are comfortable.
Oh, it's honestly so, so nice to drive around in.
As you can see, I was quite taken with the comfort of the i5, but then there's a full set
of very clever hardware to make sure this car can do both comfort and sporty.
So, you get the aforementioned adaptive dampers and rear axle steering as standard, plus,
as an option exclusive to the M60 and fitted here, the £4,000 M Adaptive Suspension Pro Pack
brings down the ride height by 5mm, gives a specific tune to the dampers, and adds active
anti-roll. I've even got a boost paddle on the left here. When I pull it, I get 10 seconds of
extra power and noise. Works very well. I think compared with the Tesla, this whole car feels
better resolved when you start to drive it in a more enthusiastic sense. The powertrain,
it feels like it fits in better because it's not dominating the whole package.
The steering isn't quite as sharp, but then it makes more sense in a car that's this size. It
feels like it's better suited to the chassis. I also think the driving position is better.
BMW's very good at making sure you're sitting in such a way that makes you feel really nice
and involved with the car. The M3, for example, brilliant driving position. And I should point
out that these Continental EcoContact tyres, well, on a track or on a really hot, dry day,
no, they're not going to give you as much grip as some of the more serious tyres that are on
other cars in this test. But when the weather is like this, they're great. They make way more sense.
For me, this car works as long as you set your expectations away from a proper M division
performance car. Yes, it's got the M in the name, but otherwise it's far too soft, comfortable,
and docile for that. And there's no doubt plenty of headroom for BMW to turn things up a notch.
And that was reflective on track too. Granted, it was better in the wet than I expected. The
softer setup really seemed to help, but in the dry, I really didn't feel any incentive to keep
lapping it. Make no mistake, there were far more exciting cars on this test and no doubt BMW will
one day make a much more thrilling EV than this. So what did we learn after two days driving the
finest EVs that 2024 has to offer? Well, for starters, there's no lack of variety. Yes,
the powertrains of each of our six contenders feel like they have more in common than their
ICE equivalents, but the cars that are built around them are rich in colour and contrast.
But more importantly, it seems that the automotive engineers that for years have
wowed us with their petrol performance car offerings have clearly taken a giant step
towards delivering a proper EV performance car. That's not to say there isn't scope to improve.
None of these cars are under two tonnes or £60,000 for example, but the progress made
is both rapid and deeply encouraging. And as it turns out, the winner of this test
and our 2024 electric performance car of the year is not nearly the most expensive
or the most powerful. For while we were wowed and thrilled by the likes of the Batista and Turbo GT,
it's the hatchback from Hyundai that stole our hearts. For this isn't just a car that
delivers incredible balance, stability, agility, poise and pace, but one that absolutely
puts the biggest smile on your face. Because at the heart of any great performance car,
and regardless of what it runs on, there must be an overwhelming sense of fun that
courses through the chassis and sends you into your own world of automotive paradise.
And it's that that the Hyundai IONIQ 5N delivers more than anything else like it.
